Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you be put off by a man who doesn't drive?

907 replies

ItDoesMyHeadIn · 11/06/2022 12:25

I was. Cancelled the date. I'm being too fussy apparently. To be fair my friend is married to a man who doesn't drive and he's amazing. Neither of my parents drive. The guy I was going to date could afford it, he just can't be arsed. He is happy to walk everywhere or use public transport. Up to him. But I would want to be with someone who can literally take the wheel sometimes. Like fuck do I want to be the one driving 8 hours up to Scotland for a holiday, or being the one to always collect the takeaway etc. I'm pretty traditional and sometimes I admit I would want my man to pick me up and take me out for dinner etc (fuck off crazy feminists, yes I can take myself out for dinner). I didn't actually realise how much of a deal breaker this was until it was put in front of me! Interested in opinions...

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Badbadbunny · 13/06/2022 12:58

@Mol1628

I wouldn’t want a partner who couldn’t drive. I will also make sure my children learn to drive. They don’t have to own a car or want to drive but having the skill is important.

I agree. My DS had his first driving lesson on his 17th birthday and passed his test a few months later. He doesn't have his own car, he drives ours when he needs to drive anywhere. Still uses local buses between his Uni and his student flat (because there ARE good bus services along the main arterial route and he purposely rented a flat on the route so he could use the bus). Whether he buys a car when he graduates & gets a job depends entirely on where he works - if he gets a job in a city with good public transport, he has no intention of buying one, but otherwise he will. It's the flexibility and options that are important to him, as is the ability to rent a car when on holiday, or rent a van to help him move, etc.

Mol1628 · 13/06/2022 12:50

I wouldn’t want a partner who couldn’t drive. I will also make sure my children learn to drive. They don’t have to own a car or want to drive but having the skill is important.

Me and my husband both drive. We also use public transport and walk a lot.

I am friends with a couple and neither of them drive. I find it strange. They can’t even rent a car to go on holidays neither of them has ever even tried to learn , I’m sure they’d be capable. And money isn’t an issue for them. I just see how restricted their lives are and I wouldn’t ever want that. They are limited with jobs, where they can live, the schools their children can attend.. everything.

onthefencesitter · 13/06/2022 12:50

PurpleButterflyWings · 13/06/2022 12:28

@onthefencesitter

....which is why poorer motorists are pretty much screwed and so poorer people should really consider moving more centrally...!

This is actually off-the-charts batshit. I don't even know where to begin with this one! Confused I have not seen such an ignorant, ill-informed post on here in a LONG time.

Poor are you? Can't afford petrol, or to run a car? Just move into the city or town where you can walk to your job and your childrens school and the hospital, and all your relatives, (because of course, they will ALL be in the same place!) Confused What a lovely little bubble you live in. What's the weather like there?

Strike that. I don't believe you're being serious. I don't know a SOUL in real life who would make such batshit, ignorant, daft, farcical comments. You HAVE to be taking the piss.

No. not move to the town. My cleaner lives in zone 5 in harrow, so further out than me ( I live in zone 3). Her child gets free bus fares; in london that is the case. But she takes the tube to camden and then the bus to moorgate to save on commuting fares. She says her rent plus her commute from zone 5 cost much less than when she lived in kent even though her flat is smaller and her rent is more expensive. But at least she can do her job and afford the transport there. There are hospitals accessible by public transport in harrow. As for relatives, well there are trains and if it was a choice between living near relatives and being able to make a living, i think most people would choose the latter.

But yes I think its why crime rates are higher in the inner cities and in some non leafy outer suburbs of cities. Its because if you do the math, it is cheaper to live in such places so it attracts people from more deprived backgrounds. Its also why even expensive places like Islington (where Boris and the founder of mumsnet lived) also has a lot of poorer residents; the secretary in my office also lived there and she could walk to work! It also votes for Corbyn cos there are a lot of council residents there. There is a reason why they don't move out even though its pretty much a million pound neighbourhood- their rent is either housing association or covered by housing benefit; public transport is cheap(zone 2 to zone 1) or they can walk to many jobs or they can bike, they have access to aldi and lidl (which costs the same everywhere). Council tax is cheaper in London. Heating is cheaper (smaller homes). Most london catchment areas are really small (0.5 miles) so your kids' school would be walkable! i did the math before and it is cheaper even for me to live in London even as a home owner as my basic costs are very low esp without a car, all my money is able to go into overpaying my mortgage with an extra £1000 every month, which is a better use than spending it on fuel or car insurance as I can get it back when I sell my flat one day...For someone who is trying to make ends meet, I suppose it makes even more sense.

BobbinHood · 13/06/2022 12:47

In the last few posts - adults who can’t drive are incompetent. People who can’t drive aren’t real adults.

These attitudes are pathetic and so incredibly small minded. You should be grateful that there other people out there choosing not to pollute yours and your children’s lungs and using public transport so that there might be some semblance of a network there when you find yourself unable to drive any longer.

GroggyLegs · 13/06/2022 12:46

It would put me right off.
Dated someone who couldn't drive - ended up feeling like his Mum.

And I think most feminists would agree everyone should take their turn at doing the driving 🙄

BobbinHood · 13/06/2022 12:42

And this is unprecedented. The cost of motoring hasn't risen much in comparison with public transport fares in the last 2 decades because fuel prices hasn't risen much. This is going to change. We are in unchartered waters

No, it hasn’t risen much in comparison with public transport fares through deliberate government decisions influenced by the motoring lobby. Such as not applying fuel duty increases. The cost of fuel and high voltage power have the same impact on bus and local rail services as they do on cars.

Areas of low car ownership correlate with areas of deprivation. People in deprived areas are, on average, more reliant on public transport, walking and cycling than those in less deprived areas. This isn’t about rich people living 5 minutes from tube stations, this is about properly funding buses, properly funding cycling and walking infrastructure. But this isn’t what happens, because as a nation we prioritise the motorist and look down on those who can’t or won’t drive. While attitudes like those displayed in this thread continue, that’s never going to change.

Namechangedfeb22 · 13/06/2022 12:41

I’m a feminist. It’s a deal breaker for me. I don’t want to be the only driver in a partnership. It gets boring always being the adult. It’s not agout being chauffeured around it’s about sharing it out.
what if you needed to go to hospital asap ?? You getting in the bus

burnoutbabe · 13/06/2022 12:40

i mean i CAN drive. i passed my test when i was 18 or so. Not driven since. But i could take refresher lessons if i wanted to.

but i choose to live in big cities and places where i can commute to work. Its not something i have ever thought about in a partner?

Mrscmay17 · 13/06/2022 12:39

Deal breaker for me too !

Badbadbunny · 13/06/2022 12:38

PurpleButterflyWings · 13/06/2022 12:28

@onthefencesitter

....which is why poorer motorists are pretty much screwed and so poorer people should really consider moving more centrally...!

This is actually off-the-charts batshit. I don't even know where to begin with this one! Confused I have not seen such an ignorant, ill-informed post on here in a LONG time.

Poor are you? Can't afford petrol, or to run a car? Just move into the city or town where you can walk to your job and your childrens school and the hospital, and all your relatives, (because of course, they will ALL be in the same place!) Confused What a lovely little bubble you live in. What's the weather like there?

Strike that. I don't believe you're being serious. I don't know a SOUL in real life who would make such batshit, ignorant, daft, farcical comments. You HAVE to be taking the piss.

Yep I agree, had to read that comment a couple of times to make sure I was reading it properly and there weren't typos etc.
As you say, absolute batshit.

Empressofthemundane · 13/06/2022 12:30

Agree with you OP. Driving is something able bodied adults of sound minds should be able to do. It’s part of being a competent adult.

PurpleButterflyWings · 13/06/2022 12:28

@onthefencesitter

....which is why poorer motorists are pretty much screwed and so poorer people should really consider moving more centrally...!

This is actually off-the-charts batshit. I don't even know where to begin with this one! Confused I have not seen such an ignorant, ill-informed post on here in a LONG time.

Poor are you? Can't afford petrol, or to run a car? Just move into the city or town where you can walk to your job and your childrens school and the hospital, and all your relatives, (because of course, they will ALL be in the same place!) Confused What a lovely little bubble you live in. What's the weather like there?

Strike that. I don't believe you're being serious. I don't know a SOUL in real life who would make such batshit, ignorant, daft, farcical comments. You HAVE to be taking the piss.

onthefencesitter · 13/06/2022 12:10

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 13/06/2022 11:56

which is why poorer motorists are pretty much screwed and so poorer people should really consider moving more centrally...And as the GBP drops and the war in ukraine rages on, it does stand to reason that the cost of fuel would be sky high and there is nothing much we can do about that!

Increased urbanisation leads to reducing standards of living and higher levels of inequality. Just getting everyone to move into a city won't do anything to help, only aggressive and thorough wealth redistribution can hope to sort out the mess we are in but there's zero chance of that happening. Rumour has it Boris is planning to offer free fiddle lessons as his next big idea to "build back better"

I don't disagree with that, but people will not have much choice in this matter. I mean, would you rather live without a car in Manchester/London or in Shropshire? If you are an essential worker in London, you can get night buses or the tube. You might not earn much more than you do in Shropshire but in Shropshire, if you can't afford to run a car, you are stuck on UC. And that is not fun even if your housing costs are lower.

onthefencesitter · 13/06/2022 12:06

BobbinHood · 13/06/2022 12:01

How come the cost of motoring has not risen anywhere near as fast as the cost of public transport (outside London)? The MPs you’re talking about represent seats in leafy shires where everyone wants to drive their SUV 4 minutes down the road. The motoring lobby is unbelievably powerful in this country.

Well the people in wealthy leafy shire areas will be able to buy electric cars or to buy petrol. Also my colleagues who do live in leafy shires only use their cars on the weekend despite them loving their cars. They work in london and so they have to take the train and even when they WFH, they are not using the car.

And this is unprecedented. The cost of motoring hasn't risen much in comparison with public transport fares in the last 2 decades because fuel prices hasn't risen much. This is going to change. We are in unchartered waters

Frazzledmummy123 · 13/06/2022 12:03

FiveNineFive · 13/06/2022 11:17

Exactly this. ^ The amount of ignorance and sheer narrow-mindedness of some non-drivers on here, is mind boggling. As I say, you can tell which posters on here have children and relatives who need care, from those who don't!!!

I don't drive. Should I not have had a child?

Dangerous question on MN! I was told on another thread that I shouldnt have had a child because I rent.

BobbinHood · 13/06/2022 12:01

onthefencesitter · 13/06/2022 11:42

The big decisions in this country are made by people who live 2 minutes from a bus stop and 10 minutes from a tube station. Boris has always been able to cycle to work.

So if a tank of petrol reaches £200-300 (currently £100), it does not affect them. Yes they could afford the cost of petrol (whatever it is) but equally the 'poorer' people who they would interact with the most i.e. junior staff at downing street would also live near public transport networks. The people they do know who live in the countryside are likely to be the type with a Georgian pile or £2 million house in Beaconsfield. So they would have limited sympathy for anyone who cannot afford an electric car or who cannot afford £400 per tank of petrol because in our London centric world, anyone who is poor or middle income has no business owning a car if they can't afford it. It is a luxury on par with going out to eat at a restaurant in inner London. The government has no money to subsidize fuel.

which is why poorer motorists are pretty much screwed and so poorer people should really consider moving more centrally...And as the GBP drops and the war in ukraine rages on, it does stand to reason that the cost of fuel would be sky high and there is nothing much we can do about that!

How come the cost of motoring has not risen anywhere near as fast as the cost of public transport (outside London)? The MPs you’re talking about represent seats in leafy shires where everyone wants to drive their SUV 4 minutes down the road. The motoring lobby is unbelievably powerful in this country.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 13/06/2022 11:56

which is why poorer motorists are pretty much screwed and so poorer people should really consider moving more centrally...And as the GBP drops and the war in ukraine rages on, it does stand to reason that the cost of fuel would be sky high and there is nothing much we can do about that!

Increased urbanisation leads to reducing standards of living and higher levels of inequality. Just getting everyone to move into a city won't do anything to help, only aggressive and thorough wealth redistribution can hope to sort out the mess we are in but there's zero chance of that happening. Rumour has it Boris is planning to offer free fiddle lessons as his next big idea to "build back better"

onthefencesitter · 13/06/2022 11:42

PurpleButterflyWings · 13/06/2022 11:26

@Badbadbunny

You live in "your" real world where it sounds like YOU don't need a car. However, most people don't live with 10 mins from the tube and 2 mins from a bus stop. So THEIR real world (the majority of people) is completely different to yours, and lots of them DO need a car to do pretty basic/simple normal tasks that you take for granted can be done by public transport.

Thank you! FFS, I feel like I'm going mad reading this thread, with the amount of ignorant narrow minded bullshit on it from SOME non-drivers. 'Oh but I live 5 minutes walk from the bus stop and 10 minutes walk from the tube, therefore everyone should get rid of their car!!!' Utterly bizarre! There's no getting through to these people. Batshit!

The big decisions in this country are made by people who live 2 minutes from a bus stop and 10 minutes from a tube station. Boris has always been able to cycle to work.

So if a tank of petrol reaches £200-300 (currently £100), it does not affect them. Yes they could afford the cost of petrol (whatever it is) but equally the 'poorer' people who they would interact with the most i.e. junior staff at downing street would also live near public transport networks. The people they do know who live in the countryside are likely to be the type with a Georgian pile or £2 million house in Beaconsfield. So they would have limited sympathy for anyone who cannot afford an electric car or who cannot afford £400 per tank of petrol because in our London centric world, anyone who is poor or middle income has no business owning a car if they can't afford it. It is a luxury on par with going out to eat at a restaurant in inner London. The government has no money to subsidize fuel.

which is why poorer motorists are pretty much screwed and so poorer people should really consider moving more centrally...And as the GBP drops and the war in ukraine rages on, it does stand to reason that the cost of fuel would be sky high and there is nothing much we can do about that!

Mariposa80 · 13/06/2022 11:40

I wish people would consider how the sort of views and statements expressed here affect those who can't drive for medical reasons.

My husband can't drive due to epilepsy, his diagnosis as a teenager closed off a lot of avenues to him and it wasn't an easy time for him. A couple of decades on and he's mostly made peace with it. But people have come out with all sorts of shit in front of him and no matter of "oh we don't mean you" or him having to justify that he gets a 'pass' for medical reasons makes him feel better about it.

BobbinHood · 13/06/2022 11:28

Mwnci123 · 13/06/2022 11:22

@FrazzledMummy123 I agree wholeheartedly with your comment. I tend to use my car for journeys I could walk/ cycle/ use public transport for and am trying to reduce this, in large part inspired my non-driving husband who is absolutely not a CF and manages to get around remarkably well.

Hope it works well for you! My DH did the same when we got together (I’m the non-driver, he was far too reliant on the car) and he saved loads of money as a result as well as avoiding a lot of traffic jam/parking type stress.

PurpleButterflyWings · 13/06/2022 11:26

@Badbadbunny

You live in "your" real world where it sounds like YOU don't need a car. However, most people don't live with 10 mins from the tube and 2 mins from a bus stop. So THEIR real world (the majority of people) is completely different to yours, and lots of them DO need a car to do pretty basic/simple normal tasks that you take for granted can be done by public transport.

Thank you! FFS, I feel like I'm going mad reading this thread, with the amount of ignorant narrow minded bullshit on it from SOME non-drivers. 'Oh but I live 5 minutes walk from the bus stop and 10 minutes walk from the tube, therefore everyone should get rid of their car!!!' Utterly bizarre! There's no getting through to these people. Batshit!

BobbinHood · 13/06/2022 11:26

PurpleButterflyWings · 13/06/2022 11:13

Exactly this. ^ The amount of ignorance and sheer narrow-mindedness of some non-drivers on here, is mind boggling. As I say, you can tell which posters on here have children and relatives who need care, from those who don't!!!

And as for 'I live in the city, I can walk everywhere, or just hop on a bus and be at my job/destination in 15 minutes!!! Bloody bully for you. Meanwhile, it's quite different, in the REAL world, for many MANY other people...................... Hmm

Why is my life which involves full time work, a young child and ageing parents who need support, not the real world? It’s not in London, either, I’ve never lived there.

PurpleButterflyWings · 13/06/2022 11:23

@onthefencesitter

Do I not live in the real world cos i live a 10 minute walk from a tube station and a 2 minute walk from a bus stop? Tube trains come every 2 minutes!

Dear God. I give up! 😖

Badbadbunny · 13/06/2022 11:22

onthefencesitter · 13/06/2022 11:17

Do I not live in the real world cos i live a 10 minute walk from a tube station and a 2 minute walk from a bus stop? Tube trains come every 2 minutes!

You live in "your" real world where it sounds like YOU don't need a car.

However, most people don't live with 10 mins from the tube and 2 mins from a bus stop. So THEIR real world (the majority of people) is completely different to yours, and lots of them DO need a car to do pretty basic/simple normal tasks that you take for granted can be done by public transport.

Mwnci123 · 13/06/2022 11:22

@FrazzledMummy123 I agree wholeheartedly with your comment. I tend to use my car for journeys I could walk/ cycle/ use public transport for and am trying to reduce this, in large part inspired my non-driving husband who is absolutely not a CF and manages to get around remarkably well.