Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you be put off by a man who doesn't drive?

907 replies

ItDoesMyHeadIn · 11/06/2022 12:25

I was. Cancelled the date. I'm being too fussy apparently. To be fair my friend is married to a man who doesn't drive and he's amazing. Neither of my parents drive. The guy I was going to date could afford it, he just can't be arsed. He is happy to walk everywhere or use public transport. Up to him. But I would want to be with someone who can literally take the wheel sometimes. Like fuck do I want to be the one driving 8 hours up to Scotland for a holiday, or being the one to always collect the takeaway etc. I'm pretty traditional and sometimes I admit I would want my man to pick me up and take me out for dinner etc (fuck off crazy feminists, yes I can take myself out for dinner). I didn't actually realise how much of a deal breaker this was until it was put in front of me! Interested in opinions...

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
BeltnBraces · 14/06/2022 14:54

No, as long as he has a good driver🤓.

dottypotter · 14/06/2022 14:52

Not at all.
As long as he was kind, caring, and we got on well what does it matter about driving.

DdraigGoch · 14/06/2022 14:39

In case you missed this ... public transport is hugely expensive

Owning and running a car isn't exactly free. The average cost of motoring is £3.5k/year. An annual season ticket on the train for the average commuting distance would cost less than that, by bus it would only be around £600/700.

Frazzledmummy123 · 14/06/2022 14:33

@Windbeneathmybingowings yeah, you'd need your husband to drive whereas I wouldn't have to tell my husband he needed to drive. Then if my husband doesn't want to drive, then isn't it selfish to force him? I don't need any fall back as I don't rely on a lump of metal that could break down any time to get us around.

I also don't judge others... I'll leave that right there 🙂

Windbeneathmybingowings · 14/06/2022 14:02

Oh well if also sitting on the bus with said child doesn’t mean being ferried why would I pick all those buses and time spent waiting, over 10 mins in a cars. And child B may wish me to sit on the bus in the opposite direction for their friend. A driver could do both journeys in half the time.

Getting the train is absolutely not a big deal for us. It’s efficient and quick and enjoyable. Waiting hours on a road side in the rain for a bus to make some kind of moral point that it’s definitely better than driving because I wouldn’t want lazy children who cant stand to walk anywhere, would I, is kind of cruel really. I could drive them and stay happy.

@Frazzledmummy123 You’ve proved your own point really. If something happened, I’d have a husband to drive. The second adult is the back up. One driver means less contingency, no fall back and poor billy doing candle making instead of what he really wants to do because it’s closer and more convenient for the adult.

Newmumatlast · 14/06/2022 13:59

HellFireClub · 11/06/2022 12:29

fuck off crazy feminists

🤔Charming

Yeah tbh this would be a deal breaker for me lol

Scurryfunge12 · 14/06/2022 13:57

Another way to make people with medical conditions feel shit about themselves. I know you’ve said medical conditions are a different matter, but honestly, if the problem is that you don’t want to be giving lifts, then medical condition or not, it’s going to be off putting to you, and seemingly swathes of other posters here. There are loads of lovely people who don’t drive for many reasons. A real shame.

randomsabreuse · 14/06/2022 13:55

Most people don't actually choose their school and "choose" where to live in relation to their budget and what's available.

I'd prefer to live somewhere that the is next to my children's clubs but it's not even close to in budget ... There's other areas that would be close and affordable but you have to be really lucky with timing to buy one of the houses there. That's with a decent budget and buying. If you're renting there's even less choice and moving becomes more frequent. It's a bit rubbish for kids to lose their hobbies just because the landlord wants to sell or get more money...

Frazzledmummy123 · 14/06/2022 13:46

@Windbeneathmybingowings as opposed to living in such a way that if suddenly the car went off the road or God forbid, something happened that you couldn't drive, you would be isolated and wee Billy would have to miss his clubs, etc. How independent eh! 🙄 . A set of wheels doesn't dictate if my kids attend their clubs and events..

BobbinHood · 14/06/2022 13:40

You accompany them on the bus. “Being ferried” suggests you’re driving them about, so they never have to walk more than 10 paces in case those little legs get tired. You might tell them that, I wouldn’t have to because getting the bus (metro, walking, cycling, scooting) isn’t a big deal. No sad times needed.

Yes, and I’m not the only person not in those circumstances, as this thread has revealed, so it’s almost like different circumstances means it’s inaccurate bollocks to class people as “selfish” and “incompetent” for choosing not to drive.

Windbeneathmybingowings · 14/06/2022 13:36

I generally don’t let my 6 year old get the bus unaccompanied so what other option do I have other than ferry them about? Tell them no, you can’t go because it’s my choice not to drive. Sad times.

We don’t even live far from anything at all except their school. I could be in Stratford faster than I could be at their school. I am not the only person in these circumstances as this thread has revealed.

BobbinHood · 14/06/2022 13:31

Windbeneathmybingowings · 14/06/2022 13:26

it doesn't necessarily cause any problems or stress - to the adult.

The child may be thinking ah I really wanted to go to play with my friend but he lives too far. Get over it, Daddy didn’t want to drive today so no problem.

Maybe they’re thinking they wish they didn’t live so far away from everything that they have to be driven?

BobbinHood · 14/06/2022 13:30

@Windbeneathmybingowings again, no one is walking 2 hours and 2 hours back. Clearly your specific circumstances are such that you’ve created a life for you and your children that requires a car. I’ve created a life for me and mine that doesn’t. My DC misses out on nothing by virtue of me not driving. My DH does drive, as it happens, but doesn’t drive her to any activities because she doesn’t need to be ferried about. How is any of this selfish? If you don’t choose to live a 2 hour walk from their school and activities then your child isn’t limited, because there’s a way to get to all of them by using their legs or two wheels. And they won’t grow up relying on us for lifts earlier which I know from teenage experience gives a great deal more freedom.

Windbeneathmybingowings · 14/06/2022 13:26

it doesn't necessarily cause any problems or stress - to the adult.

The child may be thinking ah I really wanted to go to play with my friend but he lives too far. Get over it, Daddy didn’t want to drive today so no problem.

Windbeneathmybingowings · 14/06/2022 13:23

@BobbinHood waking hours. Obviously. And a 2 hour trip to school and a 2 hour trip back would be 4 hours. Or walk down the A10.

@Frazzledmummy123 you insinuated the poster was coercive and that if the roles were reversed we would be up in arms. When in fact asking someone to do their share is not at all coercive.

A lot of non drivers do live with great transport links. Great. But if they do not; then learning to drive is the very least they can do if they do not want to burden their spouse with the majority of the care.

and choose after school activities, clubs, etc that are accessible without needing a car, and there is it. Sorry Billy, you can’t go to football/swimming or any other activity you enjoy and have picked yourself, daddy doesn’t want to drive you there. Your only options are whatever is closest. That’s selfish and limiting your child’s opportunities though choice.

Frazzledmummy123 · 14/06/2022 12:55

@Windbeneathmybingowings where did I say the previous poster was a terrible person? Unless you are correct that her ex stopped driving out of spite, she said she told him he needed to start driving. The fact that he stopped driving when they split up suggests that he was only doing it to please her. If someone doesn't want to drive, they shouldn't be told by anyone else they have to, driving isn't for everyone. It doesn't make the pp a terrible person, but she can't tell someone what to do. However, if he stopped out of spite, then of course that is totally different and I take what I said back.

You seem to have backtracked a lot from your earlier post both in your response to someone else and myself. Your earlier reply, in first paragraph in particular, basically generalised all non drivers to be selfish. Now you are drip feeding that your circumstances (school location, etc) means you have to drive as is unwalkable and requires a lot of travel for which a car is needed. I didn't say people should put their kids through that amount of walking and travel by public transport if it is impossibly so. Obviously people adapt their arrangements to suit their situation.

Non-drivers make sure they are beside transport links and choose after school activities, clubs, etc that are accessible without needing a car, and it doesn't necessarily cause any problems or stress. People who live in certain places do need a car, but don't have a right to dictate if others drive or not, or judge non-drivers as being selfish.

BobbinHood · 14/06/2022 12:52

There are only so many hours in a day, if you spend 1/3 of them standing in a queue for a bus, connections, little legs tired from walking, it’s a complete waste of a childhood. After school activities that are a mile away from each other have to be missed because the bus takes an hour, for example.

Who is spending 8 hours a day waiting for the bus? Little legs get tired from walking when they’re little legs that never walk anywhere except for to and from mummy and daddy’s cars. After school activities that are a mile away from each other can also be walked or scooted or cycled.

Windbeneathmybingowings · 14/06/2022 12:16

I agree @GoldenOmber . It was the anger that struck me with that particular poster as to how terrible a person that mother must be to expect equal input from the father in getting the children around.

Likewise, I feel sorry for people who bring up their kids to be ferried about anywhere, never having been on a bus or train, and have never walked anywhere in their lives. Having to walk anywhere is seen by snobs like yourself as 'a waste of childhood' or 'trekking across the country' (dramatic much!).

@Frazzledmummy123 its not either or. Its possible to travel on public transport and still be a car owner. I live in Hertfordshire, I can be in London in 20 minutes on the fast train and in fact have already been in to London this morning for work and am back home already. We visit London almost every week as we have fabulous links and my eldest is only 13 and can find his own way on the tube. However my childrens school is an unwalkable distance, a bus is every hour and the next connection is often missed making it an almost impossible trek to do what takes 10 mins in a car. Would I be unreasonable to make my children spend hours every night waiting for those connections or walking down a dual carriageway, when I could drive in 1/10th or the time. Yes. That would be selfish and a waste of their childhoods, making them tired and grumpy purely because the adult didn’t feel like it.

Frazzledmummy123 · 14/06/2022 11:35

Windbeneathmybingowings · 14/06/2022 10:41

@Frazzledmummy123 thats a really awful thing to say, that man has decided out of spite to make his ex wife ferry his children around. Thats a terrible example to set children. A non drive through choice is is basically limiting their childrens opportunities because they don’t feel like driving. That’s selfish.

There are only so many hours in a day, if you spend 1/3 of them standing in a queue for a bus, connections, little legs tired from walking, it’s a complete waste of a childhood. After school activities that are a mile away from each other have to be missed because the bus takes an hour, for example.

I feel sorry for children who are forced to trek across the county purely because their parents couldn’t be bothered.

If it was done out of spite by him, then yeah she has a point. However, how do we know it was done out of spite? She basically demanded he drove, and then they split, so we don't know that he didn't choose to stop driving because he wasn't instructed to by his then wife. As I said earlier, if it was a man demanding his wife drove, opinions would be very different.

Likewise, I feel sorry for people who bring up their kids to be ferried about anywhere, never having been on a bus or train, and have never walked anywhere in their lives. Having to walk anywhere is seen by snobs like yourself as 'a waste of childhood' or 'trekking across the country' (dramatic much!).

Children I know whose parents don't drive tend to be very independent, resourceful and have plenty of options for going places. They also tend to be down to earth not look down at other people.... (I am referring to the judgey drivers here, not drivers in general).

GoldenOmber · 14/06/2022 11:29

Windbeneathmybingowings · 14/06/2022 10:41

@Frazzledmummy123 thats a really awful thing to say, that man has decided out of spite to make his ex wife ferry his children around. Thats a terrible example to set children. A non drive through choice is is basically limiting their childrens opportunities because they don’t feel like driving. That’s selfish.

There are only so many hours in a day, if you spend 1/3 of them standing in a queue for a bus, connections, little legs tired from walking, it’s a complete waste of a childhood. After school activities that are a mile away from each other have to be missed because the bus takes an hour, for example.

I feel sorry for children who are forced to trek across the county purely because their parents couldn’t be bothered.

Surely it’s possible to accept that that particular man is being a selfish arse - by choosing to have and raise children somewhere that a car is required, and then suddenly refusing to drive them - without also deciding that every non-driver with kids is inflicting the same cruelty on their children, no matter where they live?

I wouldn’t want my kids to grow up only being able to get to places by being driven, myself. I’d be concerned they would turn into the kind of adults who can’t get their arse from A to B unless it’s sat in a car seat.

KarmaStar · 14/06/2022 11:25

Better for the planet surely?one less car on the road.
I'd say it's a positive thing and the opposite of lazy.
Everyone has different views on driving,he has his own,you don't know him well enough to comment really.
But it is your life,your choice too.

Windbeneathmybingowings · 14/06/2022 10:41

@Frazzledmummy123 thats a really awful thing to say, that man has decided out of spite to make his ex wife ferry his children around. Thats a terrible example to set children. A non drive through choice is is basically limiting their childrens opportunities because they don’t feel like driving. That’s selfish.

There are only so many hours in a day, if you spend 1/3 of them standing in a queue for a bus, connections, little legs tired from walking, it’s a complete waste of a childhood. After school activities that are a mile away from each other have to be missed because the bus takes an hour, for example.

I feel sorry for children who are forced to trek across the county purely because their parents couldn’t be bothered.

dumpydecember · 14/06/2022 10:29

Frazzledmummy123

'So basically you forced him to do something he didn't want to do, and when you split he stopped doing it to please you?'

I didn't force him to do anything. He saw the fairness of shouldering the ferrying of the kids when we were married. Didn't when we were not.

In case you missed this ... public transport is hugely expensive, often doesn't run effectively when you live outside major cities and doesn't necessarily match activities and clubs' times.

lolarosea12 · 14/06/2022 10:10

Really puts me off... along with not being able to cook and living at home still 😬so I dont think you are that fussy OP!

Frazzledmummy123 · 14/06/2022 10:08

dumpydecember · 14/06/2022 09:26

My ex didn't drive when I first got with him. I told him he needed to, especially as we were planning a family. Fair enough, he did. We divorced 5 years ago. Kids remained at home with me. He instantly surrendered his licence and refused to drive them anywhere meaning he played little oart in ferrying to and fro from clubs/after school activities/ university open days/ to and from uni 6 times a year

So basically you forced him to do something he didn't want to do, and when you split he stopped doing it to please you? If this situation was the other way around on MN, there would be an outcry.

Why do the kids HAVE to go everywhere in a car? Could your ex not take them on public transport. If the kids are old enough to go to uni, can't they use a bus or train?

Swipe left for the next trending thread