Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you be put off by a man who doesn't drive?

907 replies

ItDoesMyHeadIn · 11/06/2022 12:25

I was. Cancelled the date. I'm being too fussy apparently. To be fair my friend is married to a man who doesn't drive and he's amazing. Neither of my parents drive. The guy I was going to date could afford it, he just can't be arsed. He is happy to walk everywhere or use public transport. Up to him. But I would want to be with someone who can literally take the wheel sometimes. Like fuck do I want to be the one driving 8 hours up to Scotland for a holiday, or being the one to always collect the takeaway etc. I'm pretty traditional and sometimes I admit I would want my man to pick me up and take me out for dinner etc (fuck off crazy feminists, yes I can take myself out for dinner). I didn't actually realise how much of a deal breaker this was until it was put in front of me! Interested in opinions...

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
BobbinHood · 14/06/2022 23:36

I dare say the advantage of not having a parent with clear anger management issues will help outweigh the massive disadvantage I’m putting my DD at by living in an area which means we walk, cycle and take public transport. I know which childhood I’d prefer. (She’ll also grow up knowing what’s an appropriate number of exclamation marks to use per sentence, but that’s secondary.)

PaddingtonBearStareAgain · 14/06/2022 23:31

I don't believe for a SECOND that anyone with children can give them a good, decent, full childhood right up to (and including) the university years WITHOUT A CAR

Absolute crap.

BobbinHood · 14/06/2022 23:31

PurpleButterflyWings · 14/06/2022 23:03

BAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAAA !!! Deluded and clueless doesn't even begin to cover it. A season ticket for the train for someone who lives in Birmingham and works in London is over £6000 a year!

www.nationalrail.co.uk/times_fares/Season-Calculator.aspx

And let's not even MENTION the strikes, the railway line and train station maintenance works, and train delays and cancellations blah blah blah... Yeah getting a train is sooooooooooooo much better! PMSL!

That’s hardly an average commute to compare against the average cost of running a car. Why don’t you go the whole hog -

A SEASON TICKET from JOHN O’GROATS to LANDS END would be £46723377334.99!!!! So DELUDED it boils my PISS!!!!

Driving from London to Birmingham and back every day would cost £13,920 in fuel alone (assuming petrol engine with average mpg, petrol at £1.80 per litre), before taking into account tax and other costs of owning and using a vehicle.

It also takes longer. Average train time from Euston to Birmingham New Street is 1 hr 22 minutes. The same journey by car would take approximately an hour more (assuming no traffic). So that’s 2 hours more per day, 10 per week, 460 per year assuming this employee gets 30 days leave. There would have to be 19 days of strike action every year to outweigh that.

But this is nonsense anyway, because nobody in their right mind commutes from London to Birmingham so it’s a truly bizarre example to come up with.

GoldenOmber · 14/06/2022 23:21

I don't believe for a SECOND that anyone with children can give them a good, decent, full childhood right up to (and including) the university years WITHOUT A CAR.

I know, right? Those of us with disabilities shouldn’t even be allowed to have kids. Perhaps you could start some sort of campaign to have them removed from our care?

(Are you sure you’re entirely safe behind a wheel yourself, btw? You do seem so very, very angry about everything.)

PurpleButterflyWings · 14/06/2022 23:14

@Frazzledmummy123

as opposed to living in such a way that if suddenly the car went off the road or God forbid, something happened that you couldn't drive, you would be isolated and wee Billy would have to miss his clubs, etc. How independent eh! 🙄 . A set of wheels doesn't dictate if my kids attend their clubs and events..

Such a dumb, narrow-minded post. My kids primary school was 10 minutes walk away, and their secondary school was a 20 minute walk away. But many of their extra curricular activities; dance and drama and music, and singing lessons, various sports, (MMA, swimming, fencing, basketball etc,) and venues that their theatre club had their shows in, were all over the place, all over the town, and sometimes in another town.

I don't believe for a SECOND that anyone with children can give them a good, decent, full childhood right up to (and including) the university years WITHOUT A CAR. There's no way that every single activity or hobby or sport or pastime, that they are involved in (for the 13-14 years of school and college life,) is within 10 minutes walk or a short 10-15 minute jaunt on the bus.

I can only surmise that your child(ren) have very limited lives with very few things going on in them. That must be the case, because regarding what a pp said, the only children I ever knew who had parents without a car, had very dull and mundane existences, did fuck-all outside of school, and went on to do very little with their lives, because of the lack of opportunities when they were children, because the parents could rarely get to them anything, because they couldn't drive.

When my DC went to college, it was 10-12 minute drive or AN HOUR AND A HALF on the bus. I was able to take them AND fetch them back as I worked part time flexible hours, and so I did. Why the fuck would I make them get public transport and waste 3 hours of their day EVERY WEEKDAY, when it's 25 minutes by car? Because it's character building? Because they will then know how to use the bus??? Confused

LMFAO, do me a favour. No fucking WAY would anyone with a scrap of common sense NOT drive the kids when it's only 25 minutes round trip, to save them 3 hours on the bus!

And the very idea that if children are driven about (more than they get public transport,) means they won't know how to use public transport, is pathetic and farcical. Several posters here are just chatting shit and coming out with utter nonsense to try and prove themselves 'right.' (They're not right btw!) What's more, as a pp said, we did all used to go to places by public transport sometimes, often to cities, for concerts, and day trips, (where it was easier and faster by train or bus...) Quite often it is not faster by public transport though , as I and @Windbeneathmybingowings and some others have stated.

As I said, I would drive my kids about a lot (and so would DH,) and SHOCKER, they knew how to use the buses and trains on their own when they were 15/16 and started going out a lot on their own or with mates. They can even go on holiday abroad now and use a plane all by themselves, and even BOOK the trips too. I know right! And after being driven around quite a bit through childhood too! SHOCKER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Shock

And LOL at you saying 'oooooh people without a car are just so STUCK when said car breaks downs!!!' As if public transport is SO reliable!!! The trains in the UK are some of the most unreliable in the world. And who wants to wait for buses that go once an hour, get you there too late, or too early, and where you get soaked in the rain waiting for them? When you could be in a lovely warm car, and there in much less time?

PurpleButterflyWings · 14/06/2022 23:03

DdraigGoch · 14/06/2022 14:39

In case you missed this ... public transport is hugely expensive

Owning and running a car isn't exactly free. The average cost of motoring is £3.5k/year. An annual season ticket on the train for the average commuting distance would cost less than that, by bus it would only be around £600/700.

BAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAAA !!! Deluded and clueless doesn't even begin to cover it. A season ticket for the train for someone who lives in Birmingham and works in London is over £6000 a year!

www.nationalrail.co.uk/times_fares/Season-Calculator.aspx

And let's not even MENTION the strikes, the railway line and train station maintenance works, and train delays and cancellations blah blah blah... Yeah getting a train is sooooooooooooo much better! PMSL!

Sparklingbrook · 14/06/2022 22:20

DdraigGoch · 14/06/2022 21:32

But presumably beards are "just not for you". You don't say that "bearded men are not real men", "only prostitutes have beards", "you can't be a fully-functioning member of society with a beard", "people with beards just expect others to run around after them" or any of the other offensive things that have been said about non-drivers.

I have been married since forever. If I ever had to do a dating wish list though-

Must drive.
No beards.

And lots of other requirements TBF.

TruthHertz · 14/06/2022 21:50

Dewix · 13/06/2022 19:20

Litmus test;
Flip the genders and re-address.

Would it be unreasonable for a man to dismiss you as lazy if you don't drive*?

Can replace "drive" with anything.

This doesn't really work for me as a comparison tbh because I don't really view the sexes as the same. I like men that are 'manly' in terms of being able to chop wood or do things like DIY. Also driving a car well.

Not that we can't do these things ourselves (I certainly can) but ruggedness is just not something generally seen as being sexy in a woman. Perhaps old fashioned and a bit sexist but nonetheless true.

DdraigGoch · 14/06/2022 21:32

Sparklingbrook · 14/06/2022 18:09

Solid relationships are built on many things. Being able to drive or not can be one of those things, you can rule out relationships with people on whatever you want surely, we're all different?
I mean I'm not a fan of beards...

But presumably beards are "just not for you". You don't say that "bearded men are not real men", "only prostitutes have beards", "you can't be a fully-functioning member of society with a beard", "people with beards just expect others to run around after them" or any of the other offensive things that have been said about non-drivers.

Wishihadanalgorithm · 14/06/2022 19:32

I have dated men who wouldn’t drive and TBH it did put me off them. I didn’t want to be doing all the ferrying around and so each man (there were 3) lasted only a few dates each. If I was with someone for a long while and they suddenly became unable to drive then that would be different but for an initial few dates, nope not for me I am afraid.

dumpydecember · 14/06/2022 19:21

Frazzledmummy

'The fact that he stopped driving when they split up suggests that he was only doing it to please her. If someone doesn't want to drive, they shouldn't be told by anyone else they have to, driving isn't for everyone. It doesn't make the pp a terrible person, but she can't tell someone what to do. However, if he stopped out of spite, then of course that is totally different and I take what I said back'

He stopped driving the kids to activities, etc in the same way he didn't attend any parent-teacher meetings; refused to have them stop over; made no effort to do things with them once he no longer lived with them. So, I wouldn't say he stopped out of spite. Just basic selfishness, to be honest.

As for me forcing him in the first instance ... erm, well if my refusal to do all the ferrying about was somehow 'forceful', then fine (though it's a somewhat skewed interpretation). The reality was that he presented as understanding it would be unfair for one parent to do that and happily learnt. He was his own person, with a mind and a voice. Not once did he verbalise he didn't want to learn to drive. How did you think I 'forced' him, out of interest?

OrientalDaisy · 14/06/2022 19:14

Sparklingbrook · 14/06/2022 18:51

The trick is to rule people out but not announce why then you can't be judged for it. Wink

Fair enough but I don't think any decent respectful man would quite frankly settle for what OP got to offer if for her this is a deal breaker. I definitely wouldn't want my sons when they grow up to be judged by such ridiculous things as driving/owning a car by a girl.

Sparklingbrook · 14/06/2022 18:51

The trick is to rule people out but not announce why then you can't be judged for it. Wink

OrientalDaisy · 14/06/2022 18:30

Sparklingbrook · 14/06/2022 18:09

Solid relationships are built on many things. Being able to drive or not can be one of those things, you can rule out relationships with people on whatever you want surely, we're all different?
I mean I'm not a fan of beards...

So you assume if the OP's date turned up in a very old badly maintained car but he did drive it she would have been completely smitten? She clearly didn't like the guy for many other qualities and him not driving wasn't one of them. Of course you can rule out relationship with anyone you want. You can still be called a shallow person for doing so.

Sparklingbrook · 14/06/2022 18:09

OrientalDaisy · 14/06/2022 18:01

I think solid relationships should be based on something much deeper. I think the guy had a lucky escape there to be really honest.

Solid relationships are built on many things. Being able to drive or not can be one of those things, you can rule out relationships with people on whatever you want surely, we're all different?
I mean I'm not a fan of beards...

OrientalDaisy · 14/06/2022 18:09

PurpleButterflyWings · 13/06/2022 11:13

Exactly this. ^ The amount of ignorance and sheer narrow-mindedness of some non-drivers on here, is mind boggling. As I say, you can tell which posters on here have children and relatives who need care, from those who don't!!!

And as for 'I live in the city, I can walk everywhere, or just hop on a bus and be at my job/destination in 15 minutes!!! Bloody bully for you. Meanwhile, it's quite different, in the REAL world, for many MANY other people...................... Hmm

The thread is not really about that is it though. OP described that her priorities were to be picked up from her house for a date and to pick up a take away for her. Posters started coming up with scenarios where she would be driving 4 children around with no help from the guy or where she would need an urgent medical help whilst being in a rural area. 🙈

tigger1001 · 14/06/2022 18:01

ReneBumsWombats · 14/06/2022 16:36

My OH would argue he rarely asks me ‘for a lift’ but all of the household driving falls to me.

And that's the issue. It isn't just about driving him around, it's about doing ALL the household driving, with kids in the mix. It's a big issue for a lot of people and it's not hard to see why. It would be an issue for me. And I expect it would be an issue for my husband.

Why doesn't your partner drive?

My partner doesn't drive. But even if he did the majority of the running around after the kids would still fall to me.

I need my car for work. He doesn't but he also doesn't work locally (they have a works van for the squad) so I pick the kids up after clubs etc as i can do that on my way home from work.

We couldn't afford (and have no need) to run two cars and as I need the car for work that means getting the kids from their clubs is down to me regardless of his driving status.

If he goes into town at the weekend and I don't need to go, he gets the bus. My eldest also gets the bus to training (but it's easier for me to collect him when he's finished due to timings).

OrientalDaisy · 14/06/2022 18:01

I think solid relationships should be based on something much deeper. I think the guy had a lucky escape there to be really honest.

BobbinHood · 14/06/2022 17:56

Getting the train is absolutely not a big deal for us. It’s efficient and quick and enjoyable. Waiting hours on a road side in the rain for a bus to make some kind of moral point that it’s definitely better than driving because I wouldn’t want lazy children who cant stand to walk anywhere, would I, is kind of cruel really. I could drive them and stay happy.

I’m not making a moral point. I just wanted a life that didn’t involve having to drive, with all the expense and hassle a running a second car would entail. I have one. DH drives to work, because his job isn’t in a location he can feasibly get to by public transport. But he doesn’t use the car to do drop offs or activities. This is in no way child cruelty. 🙄

OrientalDaisy · 14/06/2022 17:10

Not driving being a major factor is just ridiculous to me sorry. You want a relationship so someone can drive to pick you up and collect a take away? This sounds and seems somehow narrow minded.
Neither my DH nor I drive. At this stage of our lives we don't really even want to anymore. Then again we lived together in Tokyo, Hong Kong and Stockholm and travelled the world together. We take public transport, walk or when needed use taxis. We see it as our contribution to the environment at this point. I guess there were some bigger things for me to look out for . Driving was never one of them

GoldenOmber · 14/06/2022 17:02

It's a big issue for a lot of people and it's not hard to see why.

I can see why it is a big issue for people who want lives that involve a lot of driving, and want that driving to be shared.

I don’t think it is fair, though, to assume as many on this thread do that everyone has/wants a life which involves a lot of driving, and the only difference is whether they’re doing it themselves or not.

Its interesting that so many people have said: oh, don’t get involved with someone like that, you’d have to be driving him about everywhere and doing all the school runs. But not: oh don’t get involved with someone like that, because he will obviously want to live somewhere else walkable or with good public transport and you’d have to move. Because it is just assumed that of course a non-driving man who had never learned must want a woman to do all ‘the driving’ for him.

ReneBumsWombats · 14/06/2022 16:36

My OH would argue he rarely asks me ‘for a lift’ but all of the household driving falls to me.

And that's the issue. It isn't just about driving him around, it's about doing ALL the household driving, with kids in the mix. It's a big issue for a lot of people and it's not hard to see why. It would be an issue for me. And I expect it would be an issue for my husband.

Why doesn't your partner drive?

2muchtimeonline · 14/06/2022 15:33

SisterAgatha · 13/06/2022 07:47

My DH didn’t drive. I didn’t mind so much at the start and then when I had the kids and couldn’t get to hospital etc it was a bit of an annoyance but ok.

Then i became disabled. He still couldn’t drive and we had three children by then. To say we were royally fucked, our children lead a vastly worse life compared to before (ie 2 hour bus journeys, walking several miles daily, leaving for school at 6.30am) and my MH was ruined is an understatement. For that reason I wish I had reconsidered my choices. I love him, obviously, but I hate him and will never forgive him for leaving all that to me when he had no health issue stopping him.

As someone with a non driving OH (no physical reason) this is my fear. We manage fine now and he does housework while I’m bringing kids to hobbies so we are technically both looking after the family but what if something big or small happened to me? Our lives would be drastically altered. We do use public transport, walk and cycle , and the kids are well used to that but there are certain things we need a car for and I would hate to be without it. When I was pregnant I dreaded the thought of labouring in a taxi . In the end a friend drove me but I did resent having to rely on someone else for something so intimate (I was trying to stay at home as long as possible so fully in labour by the time we left). What if I need hospital treatment? I would hate to have chemo and wait for a taxi afterwards. Yes it’s worse case scenario but people do get sick. My OH would argue he rarely asks me ‘for a lift’ but all of the household driving falls to me. It is an issue in the marriage, definitely

PussGirl · 14/06/2022 15:11

I'd be put off having a non-driver as a partner. I like to share the load & although I enjoy driving, I also enjoy being driven.

DP doesn't have a car ATM as he doesn't need one where he lives, but he drives mine when it suits both of us.

iBrows · 14/06/2022 15:05

If you drive you have a choice. It doesn’t exclude you from walking or taking public transport.

If it was genuinely just as convenient to take public transport I wouldn’t drive anywhere, but it isn’t anywhere near as convenient. I like to dictate what time my journey will be at, the temperature in my car, no annoying passengers sitting next to me with screaming babies. It feels a lot safer getting into my car rather than walking at night or even getting to a taxi (depressing as that may be).

I would question the reason a man didn’t want to make his life more comfortable if he had the money to do so.