Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you be put off by a man who doesn't drive?

907 replies

ItDoesMyHeadIn · 11/06/2022 12:25

I was. Cancelled the date. I'm being too fussy apparently. To be fair my friend is married to a man who doesn't drive and he's amazing. Neither of my parents drive. The guy I was going to date could afford it, he just can't be arsed. He is happy to walk everywhere or use public transport. Up to him. But I would want to be with someone who can literally take the wheel sometimes. Like fuck do I want to be the one driving 8 hours up to Scotland for a holiday, or being the one to always collect the takeaway etc. I'm pretty traditional and sometimes I admit I would want my man to pick me up and take me out for dinner etc (fuck off crazy feminists, yes I can take myself out for dinner). I didn't actually realise how much of a deal breaker this was until it was put in front of me! Interested in opinions...

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
ReneBumsWombats · 15/06/2022 11:07

But is only applies if you live in a situation where there is driving to be done?

Being able to drive gives you the option of living in a situation where there is driving to be done. It doesn't compel you to do it, it just means you don't have to rule it out at any point.

It gives you more choices.

SocksAndTheCity · 15/06/2022 11:03

Maighnuad · 15/06/2022 10:45

If you are dating someone who doesn't drive it gets old quickly. I did this and you the expectation of driving everywhere and picking up dropping off is exhausting
@ItDoesMyHeadIn there was divorce not for that specific reason but it didn't help !

But is only applies if you live in a situation where there is driving to be done?

I don't drive and nor does my partner (although he does have a licence, which I found out accidentally when it came up briefly in conversation a few years ago) and it's never entered my head before or since because there is no situation we're ever in where it would be necessary for any 'ferrying around' or 'picking up and dropping off'.

Like a PP, I live two minutes from my nearest tube station, five minutes from three more and within ten minutes of more still plus four mainline stations. There is a bus stop practically across the road, a bank of Santander bikes on the corner and even escooters just over from them. I'm not suggesting that this applies to many people, but just that it is not a given that everybody has to travel by car at some point in their day/week/year or miss out on something. They don't.

ReneBumsWombats · 15/06/2022 10:56

We've got several posters talking about the skills they find, and I quote, "far more impressive" than driving. They're missing the point.

I don't think drivers generally consider ordinary everyday driving to be "impressive". Quite the opposite: for most of us, it's a pretty mundane thing that I think most adults can do. But it also opens up a lot of choices that you wouldn't otherwise have.

That's why it's hard to see why you wouldn't do it if you could. Precisely because it's very useful, and doesn't require an impressive amount of skill or talent.

Simonjt · 15/06/2022 10:55

ReneBumsWombats · 15/06/2022 10:45

Would he have learned to drive if it had advanced his chosen field the way moving countries and learning new languages did?

I get the impression that you find his being trilingual impressive, which it certainly is. But again, if you can do something that impressive for your children's benefit, it's hard to see why you wouldn't do something else that most people would find easier to do and would open up yet more options.

Not really, as where I’m from speaking more than one language is both common and normal, I’m trilingual and I’m fairly proficient in BSL. Lots
of places (including where I’m from) being at least bilingual is the norm, so it would take more than three languages to impress me, unless it was something really hard learned as an adult, like Finnish.

Driving wouldn’t open any options for him, it would just drain his bank account by £50 for every lesson, thats if he could find a local instructor with an adapted car, if not he would either have to find a specialist instructor, or buy, insure, tax and adapt a cheap car to learn in.

ReneBumsWombats · 15/06/2022 10:50

surely a valuable life skill is being able to still be independent without driving, than blindly relying on it?

Another either/or. So many of them.

I don't know anyone who is capable of driving who isn't also capable of using public transport and taxis.

Maverickess · 15/06/2022 10:47

I have thrown thousands at learning to drive, it didn't happen because I can't reach the level required, no amount of shouting from the rooftops about essential life skills is going to change the mind of the examiners who have decided that.
I can do things other people can't, I don't dismiss them as useless or incompetent because I posses a skill they don't.

I decided to not keep banging my head against a rather expensive brick wall and just get on with my life, to not keep on throwing money at it and getting the same result, when I could use that (limited) money to arrange my life and make choices that take into account my lack of driving by choosing to live somewhere with decent transport links and access to amenities, and just get on with it.
I'm not sure I'd value a relationship or friendship with someone who didn't value me being able to do that tbh, and only saw that I lacked something rather than I have other skills that are valuable.

I still couldn't be a rural vet if I had a driving license because I'm not clever enough.
I still couldn't live in a lovely little isolated village if I had a driving license because I can't afford to.
I can't attend the party at an obscure venue if I'm at work, even if I could drive there.
I'm as much if not more restricted by other areas of my life than the lack of driving license.
I live within those restrictions the same way I do with not driving.

Not having a driving license isn't the end of the world unless you're so narrow minded and blinkered that you can't possibly realise there's other ways to live your life other than relying on a car.
A license isn't forever and automatic, it comes with conditions attached that are sometimes beyond a person's control - surely a valuable life skill is being able to still be independent without driving, than blindly relying on it?

ReneBumsWombats · 15/06/2022 10:45

Simonjt · 15/06/2022 10:42

What I'm saying is that it's hard to see why you'd go as far as moving countries to gain opportunities for your kids, learn new languages etc, but you won't drive. Assuming it's possible for you to learn, of course, but I hope that's an obvious given.

My husband is trilingual, he has moved countries for better opportunites in his chosen field, he hasn’t learned to drive because he doesn’t need to.

Would he have learned to drive if it had advanced his chosen field the way moving countries and learning new languages did?

I get the impression that you find his being trilingual impressive, which it certainly is. But again, if you can do something that impressive for your children's benefit, it's hard to see why you wouldn't do something else that most people would find easier to do and would open up yet more options.

Maighnuad · 15/06/2022 10:45

If you are dating someone who doesn't drive it gets old quickly. I did this and you the expectation of driving everywhere and picking up dropping off is exhausting
@ItDoesMyHeadIn there was divorce not for that specific reason but it didn't help !

OrientalDaisy · 15/06/2022 10:44

Well, because is not an essential skill for me, my work and my lifestyle at the moment. I always aimed to live in a city with a decent transport, all the necessities around me and I love walking. Whenever I have some additional money, I choose to spend it on what to me and my children are more valuable things in life such as experiences, education and other languages/travel. Not a car. To me OP's posts almost claim that this guy is somehow limited as a person because he doesn't drive, her examples given that he wouldn't be able to pick her up for a date when she got her tan spray on and got her hair done (her words not mine) nor would he pick up a local take away. To me this is a more limiting mentality in general because ones ability to drive doesn't necessarily mean you are more open to the world or more prepared to drive kids to all kinds of activities. What am I even saying, not driving doesn't say anything about a person at all. Simply that he doesn't drive. It somehow says more about OP that she is so fixated about those things.

Simonjt · 15/06/2022 10:42

What I'm saying is that it's hard to see why you'd go as far as moving countries to gain opportunities for your kids, learn new languages etc, but you won't drive. Assuming it's possible for you to learn, of course, but I hope that's an obvious given.

My husband is trilingual, he has moved countries for better opportunites in his chosen field, he hasn’t learned to drive because he doesn’t need to.

ReneBumsWombats · 15/06/2022 10:28

OrientalDaisy · 15/06/2022 10:21

Its not hard at all to assume you might have to move a house to be closer or in a catchment area for a better secondary school/college for example? Or leave a rural area or even country to get a better job elsewhere so your kids can have more opportunities? I believe to be able to speak 3 languages, as an example, is far more impressive as a life skill, than to be able to drive or to have a car. Therefore I think this OP's post is unreasonable.

What I'm saying is that it's hard to see why you'd go as far as moving countries to gain opportunities for your kids, learn new languages etc, but you won't drive. Assuming it's possible for you to learn, of course, but I hope that's an obvious given.

There do seem to be a lot of people on the thread who think there are loads of either/or choices related to driving.

OrientalDaisy · 15/06/2022 10:21

ReneBumsWombats · 15/06/2022 08:59

You can move houses/cities/countries to give your kids more opportunities if needs be .

Assuming it's possible, it's hard to see why you'd be prepared to move countries for your kids but not to learn to drive.

Its not hard at all to assume you might have to move a house to be closer or in a catchment area for a better secondary school/college for example? Or leave a rural area or even country to get a better job elsewhere so your kids can have more opportunities? I believe to be able to speak 3 languages, as an example, is far more impressive as a life skill, than to be able to drive or to have a car. Therefore I think this OP's post is unreasonable.

ReneBumsWombats · 15/06/2022 10:11

SpinMeARiver · 15/06/2022 09:33

I would see it more as enabling them to live near decent jobs, where they wouldn't be forced to part with many hundreds of £££ a month just to run a car to get to work, as well as being close to amenities and services.

I mean, what's even the insurance on a car for 20-somethings these days?

But having a licence doesn't "force" them to do anything or close off any options. It just opens up other ones. If they can't afford or don't want to run a car, they still have the option to live close to work, services and amenities. If they don't drive, they don't have the option to live elsewhere.

Besides, hiring a car is always a possibility if it's not worth owning one. That's not much as a one off here and there. Lots of jobs require a licence but not a car. My career breakthrough job did. I drove the company car when necessary.

Freedom and liberation means having choices. If you drive, you have more choices.

Badbadbunny · 15/06/2022 10:00

Pyewhacket · 15/06/2022 09:36

Shed loads of ppl in central London don't drive.

The majority of the population don't live in London!

SantiagoSky · 15/06/2022 09:54

I think there are two separate things here: being able to drive, and actually driving. I personally would agree with the former being a life skill. However in my opinion being reliant on cars is not a desirable situation. We as a family avoid car ownership and invest some of the money saved into alternative setups such living close to public transport, local school, deliveries, rail, sometimes car hire.

Pyewhacket · 15/06/2022 09:36

Shed loads of ppl in central London don't drive.

SpinMeARiver · 15/06/2022 09:33

ReneBumsWombats · 15/06/2022 08:59

You can move houses/cities/countries to give your kids more opportunities if needs be .

Assuming it's possible, it's hard to see why you'd be prepared to move countries for your kids but not to learn to drive.

I would see it more as enabling them to live near decent jobs, where they wouldn't be forced to part with many hundreds of £££ a month just to run a car to get to work, as well as being close to amenities and services.

I mean, what's even the insurance on a car for 20-somethings these days?

randomsabreuse · 15/06/2022 09:29

Simonjt · 15/06/2022 07:07

I don't believe for a SECOND that anyone with children can give them a good, decent, full childhood right up to (and including) the university years WITHOUT A CAR. There's no way that every single activity or hobby or sport or pastime, that they are involved in (for the 13-14 years of school and college life,) is within 10 minutes walk or a short 10-15 minute jaunt on the bus

Really? My son does rugby, ballet and swimming, we walk to all of them, we could if we wanted save the 15 minute walk to rugby and get a 3 minute bus. We can see both the leisure centre and the dance school from our flat. Within half an hour of walking we have club wise available to us, martial arts, horse riding, climbing, bike polo, skate part, gymnastics, football, circus arts, boxing, modern dance, athletics, tennis, cricket, american football and lacross. There are probably more that I’m not aware of. Within a twenty minute walk we have four very good parks, three with very good play areas, museums, cinemas, bowling, skating, play farms.

Within a thirty minute walk we have soft play, a farm park that has other play things available, the postal museum, gokarting, lots of museums, sky garden.

Within a forty minute walk or a ten minute bus ride tower of london, the globe, tate modern, hms belfast, the shard, charles dickens museum, london fields lido, museum of childhood

Some people can live in London. I can't. I lived there for 2 years and was desperate to get out, too crowded, too many people, I just felt surrounded. The only bit I liked was the City Square Mile on a Sunday when there were basically no people - so there's no way I could happily live in London. DH's job literally doesn't exist in London so we're compatible there fortunately.

So many activities don't require transport to start but then become more involved - football starts with local then you get after school matches and tournaments early on a Sunday when public transport hasn't started yet. Or the kids get to a higher level and start being expected to travel to competitions which are generally at obscure (because cheap) sports halls in random suburbs. Yes you can get lifts with other parents but lack of reciprocation tends to breed resentment (unless of course the school/club does the transport).

I don't include London in places where not driving would be a problem, but anyone wedded to London would not be someone I could be in a long term relationship with because I didn't like London as a place to live.

onthefencesitter · 15/06/2022 09:28

ReneBumsWombats · 15/06/2022 08:59

You can move houses/cities/countries to give your kids more opportunities if needs be .

Assuming it's possible, it's hard to see why you'd be prepared to move countries for your kids but not to learn to drive.

That's why when I hear the junior minister of transport talk about how private cars are outdated, I kinda get where she is coming from. I grew up in a rich country where it certainly wasn't available to the masses. My dad's car cost the equivalent of £200k, certificate inclusive and also additional taxes! Why should we assume car ownership is always available to the masses ? Like buying a house with garde in zone 3 London (or even certain parts of the home counties), it may just not be available to the masses anyway

onthefencesitter · 15/06/2022 09:25

ReneBumsWombats · 15/06/2022 08:59

You can move houses/cities/countries to give your kids more opportunities if needs be .

Assuming it's possible, it's hard to see why you'd be prepared to move countries for your kids but not to learn to drive.

If it became really hard to live in London without a car, I would consider moving back to Singapore where the certificate to own a car can be the equivalent of £70k. It would never be necessary to own a car there, the government has promised that 90% of the population would live within 0.5 miles of a metro station...

juice92 · 15/06/2022 09:23

I can drive but I'm really not a fan and I live somewhere with rubbish public transport, my Husband loves to drive. If I was single and met someone who didn't drive it would put me off. Not because I feel like it is a 'basic life skill' but because it would be impractical. If I lived in a city or somewhere with decent public transport it would be different

Vikinga · 15/06/2022 09:16

It wouldn't occur to me to judge someone on whether they drive or don't drive. I know plenty of women who don't drive and their husbands don't seem to mind.

It wouldn't bother me to be the main/only driver.

If in the future it becomes really necessary, he could always learn.

ReneBumsWombats · 15/06/2022 08:59

You can move houses/cities/countries to give your kids more opportunities if needs be .

Assuming it's possible, it's hard to see why you'd be prepared to move countries for your kids but not to learn to drive.

onthefencesitter · 15/06/2022 08:12

OrientalDaisy · 15/06/2022 07:55

How is that limiting a child's opportunities ? You can move houses/cities/countries to give your kids more opportunities if needs be . Parental diving licence or the lack of it is not what limits kids opportunities in life.

Economic hubs don't tend to be where there is bad public transport. In this day and age, where a solo FTB has to have a 70k deposit (circa 2022) and this is the whole of the uk, not just London, I might even argue that not living within commuting distance of an economic hub would severely limit your kids' opportunities; it may be the difference between them spending 50% of their salary on rent/ owning thier home if you don't have 70k to gift to them. DH and I saved 70k by living in London with his mum who had the foresight to buy and live in London (and she never had a car in her life). But it would v v unreasonable to start a thread saying people who move to the countryside and have no deposit to gift to their children are limiting their kids' opportunities.

But this would be the true divide in this country- those with secure housing and those without. Not those with cars and those without. You can't exactly get a job if you don't have a roof over your head,there are many jobs in many areas of the country which don't require a car; and in London, it is impossible to drive to the City anyway.

OrientalDaisy · 15/06/2022 07:55

Windbeneathmybingowings · 15/06/2022 00:42

There's no way that every single activity or hobby or sport or pastime, that they are involved in (for the 13-14 years of school and college life,) is within 10 minutes walk or a short 10-15 minute jaunt on the bus.

This though. I know so many disagree because it’s uncomfortable, but it’s limiting your childrens opportunities though choice.

How is that limiting a child's opportunities ? You can move houses/cities/countries to give your kids more opportunities if needs be . Parental diving licence or the lack of it is not what limits kids opportunities in life.

Swipe left for the next trending thread