Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not take the job?

85 replies

xmasaries · 11/06/2022 07:36

First thread!

I'm young (under 25) and have 2DC, one in school and one aged 2.

I've been offered a job with a surprisingly high salary for a starter and the company will support me to do a degree.

We've always struggled financially and this would put us in a much more comfortable position.

However, I am just feeling down that I'll be sacrificing so much time with the kids.
The hours will mean I'm out the house from 8am-6pm all week, will never do school drop-off or pick-up and my youngest will be in childcare 50hrs a week. The idea that I'll only have the rushed bit of time to get out the house and do bedtime with them is just getting me down.

In contrast, I have a job offer that is a lower salary but they're willing to accommodate whichever hours would suit me.

I just feel like I'd be in the wrong by turning down an offer that would financially benefit us but also feel like I'd be in the wrong by sacrificing so much time with my DC when they're still so young.

OP posts:
wheresmymojo · 12/06/2022 09:07

There's no right or wrong here.

It comes down to personal values - ultimately do you value family time more than financial stability?

Only you can answer that really (sorry, not much help).

Personally I would take the higher paying job with prospects but that's because I value career success, financial stability and personal growth very highly.

Someone that values time with their children when young higher than that isn't 'wrong' or 'right'. They just 'are' and that's okay.

Alliswells · 12/06/2022 09:06

Blackberrybunnet · 12/06/2022 07:08

You will never get the years with your kids back again. You can pick up your career any time.

Totally agree, it's a tough call OP but 50 hours childcare? That's such a long time for any child to be in childcare

Danascully2 · 12/06/2022 08:52

I would definitely check on the degree arrangements i.e. do you get paid time off or are you expected to do it in evenings/weekends on top of full time work? The latter is hard even without children. Could you negotiate working only for a year or two before starting the degree if you would normally start it straight away? Then you can settle into work and kids can get some of the nursery bugs etc out of the way and be a bit older. The kids will be fine whatever you do. I agree with everyone saying that women are disadvantaged by part time/lower prospects in the long run but burning oneself out in the short term trying to do everything isn't ideal either... I think it also depends whether you have a wider support network eg grandparents who could help out in school holidays. And whether salaries will be such that you can throw money at the logistics eg cleaner, gardener. Do what's right for you!

clippety clop · 12/06/2022 08:51

If it were me it would be lower paid job. I couldn't put money and a career before my children. That said it's a very personal decision. I always think back to what a friend said, realistically you've 16 summers with your children before they go their own way....stopped me in my tracks.

There'll always be jobs and the chance to study but there'll only ever be 16 summers.

EmilyBolton · 12/06/2022 08:48

Op, there is no right answer here as you can see it is pretty 50:50 and based on experiences of women responding. Whatever you do will be a compromise and you are going to have to weigh up those compromises.
what is it that the employers saw in you to offer the higher salary degree support job? Focus in on that….either those skills mean you could look for similar role but maybe with more flexible hours, or maybe you could take low aid role and study through OU in meantime under your own steam…..in other words don’t think of it as an “ either or” there maybe other ways to achieve the same end point involving less of a hard choice

whatever you do, you will regret some aspects of compromise you made…it doesn’t mean you made wrong decision, it just reflects that as working mums or SAHM and anything in between, there is no right or perfect way to do it and searching for that is a waste of effort.

Toomuch2019 · 12/06/2022 08:44

You have to do what's best for you and what you can do around the edges, eg if DH and family around it's much more workable.

Personally I'd take the job then negotiate on hours later-if you're doing a great job they will want to keep you.

These opportunities don't always come round again and they come less and less the older you get. It's absolutely not right at all (one of the big things we get wrong in the workplace) but in general I think people are far keener too support and develop older people as younger.

MobLife · 12/06/2022 08:43

Women get screwed over all the time financially and in the workplace.
I'd always advise functioning as if you have to rely on your wage only and ensure you're able to be totally independent.
This sounds like a brilliant opportunity especially as there's a degree in it for you! Take the higher paid job and when you get settled start some negotiations with them about flexible working arrangements.
What industry is the role in?

EmilyBolton · 12/06/2022 08:41

ItWillBeOkHonestly · 12/06/2022 08:10

As the saying goes, 'no one ever said on their death bed, 'I wish I'd worked more''. Life is short and no money in the world can compensate for lack of quality time.

Sure, the extra money will likely come in handy but then are you going to be too tired to even enjoy it? Would the new employer consider flexible working? If not, personally I'd go for the lower paid job and pursue something like this when the kids are a bit more independent. By the way, I'd say this to a man just as much as I'd say it to a woman.

that term is used for high paid career men who were wedded to their job 24/7.

women dying in hard ship with little personal pension and reliant on meagre state pensions probably do have concerns about how much they sacrificed to their family before securing their own future. Particularly if those children she sacrificed her personal security for are busy with their own lives and don’t see her that often or have no appreciation of what she did.
and I think before you state no money in the world can compensate for lack of quality time, you maybe want to walk in shoes of someone who currently can’t afford heating, food, petrol etc ….when you are worried about how the next bill will be paid it is hard to get into a head space of quality time.

Trite, naive, meaningless sayings.

im not saying she should take the higher wage job…but really are those your best argument?

tiredanddangerous · 12/06/2022 08:36

I would take the lower paid job. My eldest is 15 now and I feel like her childhood passed in the blink of an eye. You'll never get the time back.

Rainbowqueeen · 12/06/2022 08:33

I’d take the higher paid job. Ask if you can WFH a couple of days a week after the first couple of months.

Once you prove yourself there’s a really good chance that you will be able to go part time

MediocreHRPerson · 12/06/2022 08:31

Can your DH flex and do pick ups etc? I would take the higher paid job.

It is not just about the wage, which will probably be spent o childcare, it is about pension, future earning potential etc.

If you can grow your income now, there might be other opportunities later on to work flexibly at a good rate.

Kerberos · 12/06/2022 08:31

Is there any scope for your partner to decrease their hours?

Without knowing more about your setup it's impossible to say, but I've seen many stories on here and in real life of women who take a step back and massively regret it in later life when it's hard to get a role which pays more than minimum wage. Is there a compromise you can make between the two roles?

Think carefully about the long term as well as the short.

TitInATrance · 12/06/2022 08:25

I worked a job with those hours and did a degree when my children were at primary school. No regrets at all, and I hope it gave the DC a good example, both are now successful in their careers.

I think to take the lower-paid job would send a poor message to a DD, if you have one.

FlowerArranger · 12/06/2022 08:24

ScarlettSunset · 12/06/2022 07:40

For most people it's not so easy to just pick up your career again.

Lots of people, particularly women, end up sacrificing their careers which has a massive impact on them for the entire rest of their lives, long after the kids have grown up and moved on with their own lives.

THIS. Absolutely this.

I bet your husband wouldn't consider taking a lower paid job...

Women continue to disadvantage themselves careerwise, and many end up as single parents in middle age, struggling to make ends meet because they are stuck in low paying jobs without any prospect for career progression.

It's unfortunate that a woman's childraising years coincide with the crucial years for climbing the professional ladder, but I'd think hard before tossing away this opportunity.

DickVanDyke26 · 12/06/2022 08:19

Another one for the lower paid role definitely

CharChar91 · 12/06/2022 08:18

I was recently stuck in a low paying job whilst my children were young. I took a leap and a higher paid job back in my field on engineering. The hours were long and I had all kinds of guilty feelings but 6 months in when they were happy with my performance etc I negotiated a drop in hours which is very flexible, fits in with pre-school/nursery drop offs etc.

babyjellyfish · 12/06/2022 08:14

Take the better paid job.

Yes, your children are small for a really short time and you probably have 40 years of working life ahead of you.

This job could be a spring board for you to earn much more money and be far more comfortable for those 40 years. If you turn down this opportunity you might not get another equivalent one and your earning potential could be negatively affected for the next 4 decades as a result, long after your kids have grown bigger and more independent.

Your kids probably won't remember exactly how much time you were at home when they were 2. But they will appreciate things like you being able to afford holidays when they are 12 and driving lessons when they are 17.

PurassicJark · 12/06/2022 08:13

I would take the longer hours one. You need the money and providing financially for children is a big thing, they will want to do activities in the future and with the cost of living rising quickly (which likely won't come down for ages) could you afford to pay for that based on the lower paid job?

ItWillBeOkHonestly · 12/06/2022 08:10

As the saying goes, 'no one ever said on their death bed, 'I wish I'd worked more''. Life is short and no money in the world can compensate for lack of quality time.

Sure, the extra money will likely come in handy but then are you going to be too tired to even enjoy it? Would the new employer consider flexible working? If not, personally I'd go for the lower paid job and pursue something like this when the kids are a bit more independent. By the way, I'd say this to a man just as much as I'd say it to a woman.

Lucia574 · 12/06/2022 08:06

If you can sort the childcare, take the better paid job. Financial security gives children a huge advantage.

Eloradannin2nd · 12/06/2022 08:06

I'd go for the better paying job with better prospects. I was in a similar situation when my two were young. My DH was able to cut his hours so he was there for them. We have a much better life now and have been able to move to a fantastic location due to my job. My kids have so many more opportunities now.

roses2 · 12/06/2022 08:05

Take the higher paid job and ask for flexible working if possible. Eg 1-2 days per week from home and 7am - 3.30pm instead of 9am-5.30pm

Wonderwoman333 · 12/06/2022 08:03

I would not take the higher paid job. You would miss out on so much precious time with your dcs. 50 hours in childcare is way too much in my opinion.
I can't imagine never picking my kids up from school and only briefly seeing them in an evening before bedtime every week day.

Also think about school holidays, is there a generous annual leave package?

Andromachehadabadday · 12/06/2022 08:01

I would and did take the higher paid role. One of my kids is an adult and I don’t regret it at all.

but a lot depends on the circumstances you haven’t posted about. Like is there a partner? what hours does he/she do, how likely is it that he will take on responsibility etc

Is the relationship a happy and equal one? If not and it might end you need to think about that etc

lanthanum · 12/06/2022 08:00

What does "support to do a degree" actually mean? Would you be given study time? Would that be enough study time or would you also need to use up your evenings? Would they be paying the fees?

As someone else said, at your age it's unlikely that there won't be opportunities in the future. If the lower salary would be enough for current needs, I'd be inclined to go for that.