Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what's going wrong with our finances!?

482 replies

pondering12345 · 10/06/2022 22:18

In the process of moving to a joint account with DH, so using this opportunity to review our monthly finances:

Income
DH take home pay £2600
My take home pay (part time) £1075
Child benefit £145
Total income £3820

Expenses
DH car loan £270
My car loan £160
Mortgage £645
Water £60
Gas and electric £250
Home insurance £15
Broadband £25
Council tax £190
DH credit card £110 (we each use our own credit card for any purchases for ourselves and pay off the following month)
My credit card £100
My phone £35
DH phone £35
DH car tax £20
TV license £15
Zoo membership £20
Apple Music subscription £15
DH contact lenses £40
DH haircut £15
My haircut £20 (£60 every 3 months)
My nails £30
Window cleaner £15
DH petrol £100
My petrol £100
Food £450
Takeaways (one per week) £150
Kids hobbies & swimming £100
Date night £50
Disposable income £500
Total expenses £3535

This leaves less than £300 per month to put towards tonnes of other expenses - annual car insurance, gifts, Christmas, holidays, kids clothes, home and car maintenance etc.

Where are we going wrong here!? I don't feel like we live a particularly lavish lifestyle.

OP posts:
Oblomov22 · 11/06/2022 08:57

I can't see the problem either. Your takeaways, zoo, food seems a lot.
We spend a lot on food, less on takeaways, and don't have car payments because ours are bought outright, but generally I'm lost as to what the issue is.

RuthW · 11/06/2022 08:53

MolliciousIntent · 10/06/2022 22:20

£500 disposable income plus £300 for savings each month? And you're wondering where you're going wrong? That's a tonne of free money. I wish I had your problems.

Absolutely this. If I have £120 disposable income , I'm happy.

cakeorwine · 11/06/2022 08:52

£800 a month you have left - that's £500 disposable income plus £300 spare

That's nearly £10,000 a year
You're fine.

WonderingWanda · 11/06/2022 08:51

Car loans are such a money pit but I appreciate once you are tied in that it's hard to get out. £430 for cars a month is a lot more than half your mortgage. Most families I know have one 'good' family car and one cheap banger run around if they need a second car. If you got rid of the more expensive one and both had whatever the cheaper car is at £170 per month each you'd have an extra £100 per month at least. Or even better if you could find away to buy a car outright (take money from the mortgage, borrow from parents, bank loans better than car finance) you'd have £270 per month, you could save half of that to put toward the next new car which would be nearly £5k in 3 years and £130 extra cash per month.

Mobile phone contracts are expensive. Next time you renew think about purchasing a reconditioned phone and getting a cheap sim only contract. Mine costs £8.50 per month.

How often do you go to the zoo? I know zoo entry is pricey but ours is abou £50 for a family ticket so you'd need to go at least 5x a year to make it worth the £240 you pay. My kids would get bored of it that many times. National trust membership is only £133 for a family for a year and you can use it all over the UK plus pay for a zoo trip at some point and still be spending less.

We earn a bit more than you, bigger mortgage but no car loans and I think that makes the biggest difference.

Jmaho · 11/06/2022 08:51

I'm a bit torn on this. It's about balance
We don't care about cars so we buy them outright and spend about 4 grand on one and keep it for about 5 years. That said we definitely have the worst cars in our street, friendship groups and kids are probably embarrassed. But I hate spending out on things like that. Both of our cars are cheap to run and insurance is about £400 a year for both which we pay annually
We also don't spend much on ourselves so beauty and hair. We do spend a lot on food but mainly normal food shopping as we are a family of 6
It is nice to have nice things and spend money on family things
Lots of people scrimp and save and don't like splashing out at all and I find that a bit odd
We go abroad every year which we save for as that 2 weeks is important for us.
But if we spent like you did we wouldn't be able to
I have a family member who tuts and moans every time we go away and says "I wish we could afford to go abroad, alright for some" that sort of thing. But then they have at least 2 takeaways a week. Both have cars on finance. Spend loads in costa, both buy lunch at work every day. We don't so we can afford to go away and to save
I definitely think there are areas where you can cut back. If you could save £100 or more a month from your list, then with the £200 odd you have left you could put this into savings and start building up money
Then when you increase your hours (if that's the plan) then add that extra straight into the savings pot. Don't be tempted to put it into a bigger loan for a better car
Things were really tight when ours were really young with childcare etc but since then we have both had payrises and saved the extra while keeping our essential costs the same
The kids do clubs, we spend a lot of birthdays and Xmas and holidays but we don't spend loads on the little bits

coffeecupsandfairylights · 11/06/2022 08:49

There's a grey area between "basic necessities" and "lavish". I don't see cutting hair or maintaining nails as a luxury, or an odd takeaway.

Paying a professional £30 to do your nails is definitely a luxury, lol.

OP has more than the "odd takeaway" - she spends £150 a month on theM and goes out for multiple meals as well.

No idea about the cars, but my commute to work on public transport is more than OP's car expense.

But her listed car expenses don't include insurance, her car tax, her MOT, annual service or things like new tyres. She's spending almost £400 per month just on car finance and petrol - her DH is doing similar. That's a huge amount of money just "gone".

Yes, for many people a car is a necessity (I need mine) but I spend maybe £150 per month on fuel, £30 on insurance and maybe another £20-30 averaged out over the year on MOT etc. Thats half of what OP spends and most of that is fuel!

Yayayaya20 · 11/06/2022 08:48

It’s surely not that unusual to have a car or cars on finance? When I read threads like this and see how many people are agog at the thought of paying £300pm for a car it just doesn’t tie up with the reality of what I see around me. Which is a huge number of fairly obviously financed cars. Also someone said people only used to have one car - well probably less families had two working parents then. It would be physically impossible for both my DH and I to work without having a car each and would just make life so difficult in other ways too.

Also the nails etc. You just need to look around to see its perfectly normal to spend money month to month on things like that.

I do think that the OP has the priorities of her budget wrong and needs to work from essential to non essential but I do think that what she’s listing are pretty normal expenses. I think OP is probably wrong to expect to have masses left over still after all of that though.

As a caveat to the above there probably is a wider issue with how lots of people are spending their money but I just can’t pair what I read on this thread with reality.

BEAM123 · 11/06/2022 08:48

You can get cheaper phone contracts - I never pay more than £27 a month, if it will cost more I wait for a deal. I get either the previous model or the one before that. After 2 years repaying phone I spend 1-2 years on SIM only for £10 a month.

Water seems high, you should easily be able to get that down to £45

Gas and electric -again even with rising costs that seems very high unless you live somewhere very cold or badly insulated. I am paying £85 based on meter readings, and I work from home. My supplier thought I'd need to pay £130 but I don't.

Zoo membership is a lot, do you use it or do you regard it as a charity donation to help them keep running?

Contact lenses - I don't use contacts but it sounds a lot - are there cheaper ones online?

Your haircut is cheap so the nails might be a luxury but you aren't paying much for your hair.

Takeaways - that is incredibly extravagant. I maybe get one every 6-12 months and even then it's £20 or so. I don't think takeaways are affordable when you have kids.

Date night - I think that's important and you should keep it but you could look for lower cost things - eg go to the pub and play a card or board game, walks in park down by river, cinema and get tickets through Meercat discounts or something?

Apple music - is that a household subscription that everyone can use? If so that's not a bad price.

TheMoth · 11/06/2022 08:47

And petrol is getting tough. I do about 200 miles a week communing. Dh does about 150. That's a lot of petrol. I walk everywhere I can at weekends, but unfortunately kid activities aren't in walking distance.

TheLadyDIdGood · 11/06/2022 08:46

Cut down the luxury spends, increase paying off debt & mortgage over payment. Plus, add more to your savings because a bigger utility price hike is coming this autumn. Start saving for your pension because you're wasting £1k on luxuries.

TheMoth · 11/06/2022 08:44

We both work full time and bring home about 3500 between us.
Mortgage 800
Council tax 200
Childcare 400

No car loans/ credit card.
Haircuts similar. Own brows and nails.
Kids' activities etc
Stopped the zoo.
Rare takeaway.
Probably similar food bill each week.
I know we have too much telly- nf, Disney and amazon.
Amazon music, but I travel a fair distance to work and I run. Music is the backdrop to everything I do and before streaming, I would have been buying it.

We certainly don't have 300 a month left. Dh is doing overtime and I'm doing examining and tutoring to try and give us a cushion.

Have you taken into account friends and family tax? All those 10 quids here and there for bday presents etc.

Blackberrybunnet · 11/06/2022 08:42

Wow! You are doing great! Don't know what you're worried about. You have loads of treats (takeaways, nails, date night, kids hobbies), are paying off a car loan, £500 pocket money, and STILL have some left to save. What's the problem?

FlannelandPuce · 11/06/2022 08:41

I don't think that budget is a realistic reflection of what you need spend. There are a lot of categories missing like Christmas, birthdays, kids clothes + shoes, school uniform. I would go through past statements and find a more accurate view of what you spend.

You have no long term goals like holidays or savings. Try and plan these into your budget using some of the savings people are suggesting. You are frittering money away today at the compromise of your future.

BillyCongo · 11/06/2022 08:41

The contact lenses seem very expensive! I pay £13 pcm for mine through Specsavers.
Zoo membership £20 seems a bit of a luxury. Have you worked out your cost per visit? Is it really worth it?
Takeaways, £150 this could easily be cut down.if you choose to. It seems such a lot!
Nails £30 this should really be allocated as your personal spending and come from that budget. Could you get a gel kit to use at home and do your own instead?
The cars are a big chunk of your spending. I'd be re-examining how to cut cost there.
I would get rid of the credit cards, or only use them for protecting payments on purchases (not as additional money). If you cut down on expenses above you could allocated you and DH £100 pcm budget for personal spending. If you spend 1/3rd of yours on Nails?
How are you spending the £500 disposable income?
If you don't already (as wasn't on the list). I recommend that you get/budget for life and critical illness insurance especially as you have children and a mortgage. I'd also put money into pensions and savings wherever you can.

ApplesandBunions · 11/06/2022 08:40

Hereforthenthtime · 11/06/2022 08:29

This is an example of how the rise in energy bills and fuel is going to affect lots of people not just the poorer families, average earners who have fairly lavish lifestyles are not going to be able to keep this up so places like nail parlours, eateries, etc. will struggle. A lot of people with big discretionary spending will be average earners

Yes I think that's right. Some of the commonest suggestions for cutbacks here are what will almost certainly be local small businesses. It's not unreasonable advice either, but it's worrying taken across the whole economy when you think what a lot of people are going to have to do.

I hope to be able to keep supporting that kind of setup, as my household expects to continue having reasonable disposable income, but if costs go up more than income does people are going to have to spend less. There'll be no choice.

Calmdown14 · 11/06/2022 08:39

I would go over to the Money Saving Expert forums and do a proper budget.

There's a lot missing from yours that might not be monthly spending but should be included. Car repairs, house maintenance (boiler check for example), holidays etc.

Allocating it monthly will help you get a better understanding.

You are fortunate in that you have a lot of incidental spending so have areas to cut back if required

forinborin · 11/06/2022 08:38

OP goes out for multiple meals every week, has two cars, has take away once a week, some how spends around £150 a week on 'disposable income', kids go swimming, have zoo membership, a window cleaner, gets her hair cut more often than most, nails done every few weeks, still has a fair few hundred left over spare... And she works part time.
There's a grey area between "basic necessities" and "lavish". I don't see cutting hair or maintaining nails as a luxury, or an odd takeaway. No idea about the cars, but my commute to work on public transport is more than OP's car expense. Probably also extravagant, could have walked for 4 hours.

onelittlefrog · 11/06/2022 08:36

I don't understand why the £220 credit card money and £500 'Disposable income' aren't being added to your remaining £300 a month?

In reality you've got over £1000 a month there that you are doing 'whatever' with. Look at that and cut back.

You are also spending ridiculous amounts on cars.

ApplesandBunions · 11/06/2022 08:36

Mirrorball2022 · 11/06/2022 08:28

Have you never been on a shopping thread? Plenty of people on here spend way more than that weekly!

Yeah, that was one of the more easily understandable parts. £450 a month is about £110 per week, for four people. The takeaway is probably one meal a week, date night looks to be once a month, perhaps they have another meal or two out most weeks. Let's say perhaps 17 meals per week per person for that budget? Certainly there are people who do it for less, but it's hardly last of the big spenders.

LethargeMarg · 11/06/2022 08:33

The car payments to me are a lot of money. We have very similar outgoing and salaries to you and would really struggle to afford big car loans so buy fairly old cars every few years so our car loans combined are £150. We put £400 a month into savings but that gets dipped into a lot as like you we still struggle financially and never seem well off even though our mortgage is small and on paper our money looks good. We each have about £400 a month for 'spending' after all kids activities, bloody private braces, childcare on top of things you've said (no credit cards either) but we quickly run out of money - we are terrible for spending a lot on treats at the start of the month and being skint last ten days of the month

Lockheart · 11/06/2022 08:31

forinborin · 11/06/2022 08:03

OP, I will go against the public opinion here and say that yes, you don't live a particularly lavish lifestyle. You didn't include holidays or dentistry/medical care, for example.
Competitive poverty on mn is a fascinating thing, everything that is not living on bread and water and walking to your 100 hours/week job is extravagant. It is ok to have nails done and hair cut, and to enjoy an odd takeaway.
You both are just not high earners, and that is ok.
I assume the reason for part time work is children at school? Would you be better off paying for childcare and working full time.

Of course it's OK to have nails done and to get takeaways, but if you're trying to save then it's an unnecessary expense which can easily be stopped, like the zoo membership etc.

There's nothing wrong with spending your money on luxuries if that's what you want and you're happy. Spend your whole salary on designer shoes and hair extensions if it pleases you. But if you want to save and you're worried about money then you're probably going to need to cut down on non-essential outgoings.

Hereforthenthtime · 11/06/2022 08:29

This is an example of how the rise in energy bills and fuel is going to affect lots of people not just the poorer families, average earners who have fairly lavish lifestyles are not going to be able to keep this up so places like nail parlours, eateries, etc. will struggle. A lot of people with big discretionary spending will be average earners

BobLemon · 11/06/2022 08:29

If you cut one car and tried to manage on one… and let’s assume it’s your car that has to go, because that’s how it works, let’s face it…

The added public transport costs, the extra fuel that gets used in the remaining car (it doesn’t just cease…) and the PITA that would be managing with one… I’d pay an extra £200/month just to avoid it being a PITA.

sashagabadon · 11/06/2022 08:28

You spend a lot on card imo. Plus you are probably spending more than £200 combined on petrol? That’s about a tank and a half each month? Sounds too low to me assuming you drive nearly every day?

Mirrorball2022 · 11/06/2022 08:28

00100001 · 11/06/2022 07:23

How are you spending £450 a month on food AND £150 on takeaway AND extra meals out?

You're spending £450 on just groceries? So over £100 a week on 6 days of meals??

Have you never been on a shopping thread? Plenty of people on here spend way more than that weekly!