Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Transactional parenting

30 replies

SpringSpringTime · 10/06/2022 20:22

I have the kind of 4 year old of whom people say ‘ooh…he’s got a lot of energy’ with varying levels of amazement/tension. He’s a total delight but also cannot be contained (or at least barely). However! He is a straightforward little soul who responds incredibly well to if-that-then-this logic and I realise it’s basically become the backbone of my parenting. My go-to is ‘if x continues then no telly in the morning’, or 1-2-3 (where 3=no telly in the morning). This seems like a fairly minor threat that he really responds to though consequences escalate if he ignores me and I always follow through! I do sometimes try to appeal to his empathy/better judgement but tbh it takes too bloody long if it works at all and in the meantime he might have set the house on fire. But I do wonder if this is going to have unintended consequences later on! Soooo….YABU=you are creating a monster or YANBU=please tell me you do this too

OP posts:
ChocolateHippo · 10/06/2022 21:00

They don't have a lot of empathy/better judgement at that age... you have to model to them how their actions make others feel and even then it takes a while for them to get it. I think having clear consequences for misbehaviour is fine, even if somewhat 'transactional', until your DS is mature enough to want to behave well for its own reward.

SalmonEile · 10/06/2022 20:46

What happens if he’s done something to warrant no Telly in the morning and then he does something else bad? Or is the threat enough to stop him

PunchyAnts · 10/06/2022 20:43

I think you are giving yourself a bit of a hard time. Sounds like there are boundaries in place and you are sticking with them which is the main thing. Best not to call them or think of them as threats.

Natural consequences are related to the behaviour you would like to stop and ideally immediate. Something like, "I can't let you hit that toy off the TV. If I see you doing that again, that toy is going away until tomorrow". It's good to teach the behaviour you do want to see alongside that by offering some suggestions of acceptable ways to play with the toy.

The thing about empathising with him is that it definitely appears like it's not "working". Saying "I can see you're upset about the toy going away" probably won't result in him instantly repenting of his misbehaviour. But it is a way of teaching him to regulate his behaviour and learn about his emotions.

SpringSpringTime · 10/06/2022 20:28

😬He tries to haggle back by uninviting me from his birthday party…I tell him I love him no matter what but he still has to brush his teeth!

To be fair he’s ok with other kids, he just doesn’t bloody listen to anything other than a half brick in a sock 😉

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 10/06/2022 20:24

Both.

Grin

Natural consequences are great. Quick, natural and they work. You still work on the empathy though.