Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect people to be able to control their children on planes?

519 replies

Ace56 · 10/06/2022 17:08

I recently returned from a long haul trip with connecting flights, so was on 5 planes altogether.

On 4 of these flights I was around children who’s parents just seemed to pussyfoot around them and seemed unable to control them.

Flight 1 - mum and 2 kids in the row in front of me. Dad across the aisle, plonks himself down on his laptop for the entire flight. Little boy (around 2-3) EXTREMELY loud, continuous shrieking, disrupting his sister. They had brought nothing for him to do - no iPad/colouring/books, so no wonder he was bored. Just shrieked constantly to get mum’s attention. Dad did absolutely nothing to help, didn’t offer to take him. Neither took him for a walk down the aisle or anything - he literally was in his seat the entire flight, absolutely bored shitless and disturbing everyone around him.

Flight 2 - girl of about 3 sitting behind me, next to mum. Dad across the aisle. Was fine during the flight but kept switching between mum and dad, and taking it in turns to sit on their lap watching her iPad. When it came to landing, she still wanted to switch every few mins. Air hostess politely told them a few times that she needs to be seated now for landing. Parents meekly tried to make her sit still with one of them but eventually gave up, so for the actual landing she ended up in the aisle (very dangerous) with mum holding onto her T-shirt. Air hostesses were seated at this point so couldn’t do anything/didn’t notice.

Flight 3 - boy of about 5 in front of me, standing up in his seat, leaning back into the seat, generally jumping around. Mum apologised but made no real attempt to stop him.

Flight 4 - large extended family sitting in various places around the plane. Children allowed to shout at each other across rows and over people’s heads, not told to stop once.

AIBU to despair at parenting these days if this is the norm? Have other people come across situations like this or was I just very unlucky?!

OP posts:
Bordesleyhills · 11/06/2022 19:02

Totally get both sides as I have a 3 year old. My mother was horrified that I had to bring him to a funeral but packed lots of stuff, sat by an exit and he was fantastic. We’ve all seen the parent struggles and most of us understand but I do agree when it starts to annoy others it unfair. Children do need to understand that they do occasionally just have to sit- I’m a mum who refuses the iPad in the car... he has to learn to cope with not being stimulated all the time. I personally am going to wait a bit longer for long haul flights till my children are older but that’s personal preference and the fact is my passports out but I do understand that some people have to travel long distances with kids and do it well.

Tigger1895 · 11/06/2022 19:02

I like to read on a flight so don’t forget those parents who allow children to watch a movie or play a loud game on an iPad at full volume. It’s not to much to ask that they wear headphones.

Doginthewindow · 11/06/2022 19:01

Hmm1234 · 11/06/2022 18:47

You must be childless to not understand how difficult children CAN find it travelling. Confined in the air restrained to an isle seat and you want them to do it quietly?! Crazyyy

Not quietly, just not disturbing others too much. Not crazy at all.

CoastalWave · 11/06/2022 18:52

Tbh this is why I won't take my kids on a plane. My son has ADHD and wouldn't cope at all if things didn't go exactly as they should do.

Why should I inflict his meltdowns on other people?

I would say, if you have the type of children who can't 'cope' - don't fly. Holiday in GB instead.

WimbyAce · 11/06/2022 18:52

First time we travelled with our daughter around 20 months I was so worried about how she was going to behave! We went extremely prepared with all manner of things to entertain her and shed loads of snacks even though the flight was relatively short and miraculously she was fine and people even thanked and praised us which was lovely. We built up the flight times each holiday and have been fortunate that had no problems.

Hmm1234 · 11/06/2022 18:47

You must be childless to not understand how difficult children CAN find it travelling. Confined in the air restrained to an isle seat and you want them to do it quietly?! Crazyyy

Tessabelle74 · 11/06/2022 18:42

I have 4 children from 5-14, YANBU. I hate other people's kids for the most part, mine know better than to mess around plus I take plenty to occupy them

MrsP9716 · 11/06/2022 18:41

So the first family you were annoyed at lack of involvement from dad and lack of technology to keep said child entertained then you were annoyed that what you are complaining didn’t happen on the first flight was happening on the second because it didn’t couple with your expectations? Pick a struggle lady.

Doginthewindow · 11/06/2022 18:38

CounsellorTroi · 10/06/2022 17:32

Flight 2 - girl of about 3 sitting behind me, next to mum. Dad across the aisle. Was fine during the flight but kept switching between mum and dad, and taking it in turns to sit on their lap watching her iPad. When it came to landing, she still wanted to switch every few mins. Air hostess politely told them a few times that she needs to be seated now for landing. Parents meekly tried to make her sit still with one of them but eventually gave up, so for the actual landing she ended up in the aisle (very dangerous) with mum holding onto her T-shirt. Air hostesses were seated at this point so couldn’t do anything/didn’t notice.

I’m sure that if anything had happened to her the parents would have sued the airline.

Had there been serious turbulence/air pocket that girl would basically have hit the roof of the plane and died. Possibly falling on another passenger who also could have died.
They should have been banned from flying again, idiot parents.

Tabitha005 · 11/06/2022 18:36

ZaraSizeMedium · 10/06/2022 17:24

YANBU.

I honestly would pay extra for child free flights if such a thing were possible. Grin

Same! I think airlines might be missing a trick with this one. And I'm also sure there are plenty of parents who'd love to stick their offspring on a kids-only flight whilst they take the adults-only flight!

JudgeJ · 11/06/2022 18:33

Crazylazydayz · 10/06/2022 17:54

YANBU I recall waiting to push back for take off and the cabin crew repeatedly picking up a toddler running up the aisle and re-strapping them on their parents lap. Literally seconds later the toddler was running up the aisle. The parent wasn’t in the least bit interested and just let the crew bring the child back.

There was still time to remove the lazy parents and their child, it's a pity that the airline dodn't do it, if only as a lesson to others.

Nik2019 · 11/06/2022 18:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Whereas you sound delightful…

Anyway, YABU OP. And you sound like you’re the entitled one, does the sound of children’s voices bother you that much, should they be seen and not heard?! I have a young child and as long as they’re not hurting anyone, or being rude etc., then I’ll try and get through the flight as best as I can and not take all the fun out of what should be an exciting experience.

Live and let live people!

vivainsomnia · 11/06/2022 18:31

All the kids misbehaving can't all be on the spectrum. I think there is a lot of excuses for letting kids misbehave and acting as if nothing can be done.

I've traveled alone with two kids under 4 and it is certainly about putting the efforts in. Starting with letting them know what to expect, communicating with them to explain what is happening, answering their questions, having a bottle or dummy for take off/landing (and explaining in advance it will be the only time they can have it), alternating time for snacks, watching something on the screen with headphones, reading, sticker books, colouring, nap, etc...

It takes a lot of involvement but so worth it to be told how well behaved the children have been.

If a parent is not able to manage a tantrum, because you certainly can't always prevent them, then the children are not ready to travel on a train or plane.

HotWashCycle · 11/06/2022 18:31

I endured a 9 hour flight once with a Mum, Dad and toddler in the row behind. The mother had the child on her lap and it kicked the back of my seat non-stop for most of the flight. Quite early on, I politely asked the mother if the child could stop as it was disturbing my chance of sleep. She could have handed the child to her partner or had the child at a different angle on her lap, but she did not and the child kicked my seat virtually the entire journey. I do not know what to make of people like this, it was so miserable that they did not care about anyone else..

xippo · 11/06/2022 18:25

we've travelled lots of times in business with the kids. loved seeing the dread on some people faces when we arrived with 2 small kids. They were always so well behaved, much easier with more room etc though.

TheHaka · 11/06/2022 18:19

Luckily I’ve only ever come across screaming babies on the Emirate night flights, but their parents will let them scream & the staff will pick them up & condole them. But I’m just glad they’re not mine, & I feel for the parents that try. I know take off & landing hurts their ears, it does mine so I hate to think what they go through. On my last flight there were about 5 toddlers who were as good as gold, apart from one who was a little shit. The parents got told by staff. One sweet kid was holding out her dummy to little shit to try & help.

SewingMum46 · 11/06/2022 18:17

YANBU. I used to travel from overseas to the UK with my 3 DC from when the eldest was six months. The last time was when they were aged 10, 8 & almost 3 and we had a 90 minute flight followed by 8 hr stopover, then 11 hours overnight flight - door to door the journey was a little over 24 hours. The whole process was reversed when we went home. I think I did it 8 times in total over 10 years, and on one occasion I was 34 weeks pregnant with a toddler. My husband came with us on one occasion only. The rest of the time it was me and the DC. We never, ever had a problem. They just behaved. But if they hadn’t, I would have done something about it - I’d have been mortified if they’d been disturbing other passengers.

Grrrrdarling · 11/06/2022 18:16

Ace56 · 10/06/2022 17:08

I recently returned from a long haul trip with connecting flights, so was on 5 planes altogether.

On 4 of these flights I was around children who’s parents just seemed to pussyfoot around them and seemed unable to control them.

Flight 1 - mum and 2 kids in the row in front of me. Dad across the aisle, plonks himself down on his laptop for the entire flight. Little boy (around 2-3) EXTREMELY loud, continuous shrieking, disrupting his sister. They had brought nothing for him to do - no iPad/colouring/books, so no wonder he was bored. Just shrieked constantly to get mum’s attention. Dad did absolutely nothing to help, didn’t offer to take him. Neither took him for a walk down the aisle or anything - he literally was in his seat the entire flight, absolutely bored shitless and disturbing everyone around him.

Flight 2 - girl of about 3 sitting behind me, next to mum. Dad across the aisle. Was fine during the flight but kept switching between mum and dad, and taking it in turns to sit on their lap watching her iPad. When it came to landing, she still wanted to switch every few mins. Air hostess politely told them a few times that she needs to be seated now for landing. Parents meekly tried to make her sit still with one of them but eventually gave up, so for the actual landing she ended up in the aisle (very dangerous) with mum holding onto her T-shirt. Air hostesses were seated at this point so couldn’t do anything/didn’t notice.

Flight 3 - boy of about 5 in front of me, standing up in his seat, leaning back into the seat, generally jumping around. Mum apologised but made no real attempt to stop him.

Flight 4 - large extended family sitting in various places around the plane. Children allowed to shout at each other across rows and over people’s heads, not told to stop once.

AIBU to despair at parenting these days if this is the norm? Have other people come across situations like this or was I just very unlucky?!

Sadly many don’t give a flying fudge about others feelings or experiences in enclosed spaces anymore. Many more are just rude. Unless these kids had special needs reasons for behaving as they do the staff should have had words! Yes there are situations where kids lose control, as kids they can’t always control their emotions, but that is where good parenting & preparing for the flight comes in. Surprised the flight crew didn’t offer the kids flight packs.
As for the parents who let their child into the aisle while the plane was landing they are the worst in this case & that is a serious safeguarding flag for me! Not being able to control your child in a ‘no choice but to stay seated because you could die otherwise’ situation is bad!!
My child would have been pinned in that seat for their own safety & I’d just apologise to everyone for the noise after we landed.

jumpupanddown · 11/06/2022 18:15

Lot of kids have things like adhd and autism etc and are very over stimulated by flying and much less manageable than usual as a result. In these situations the parent telling a child off for the benefit of what everyone judging you on the plane might think can often escalate a problem. You won’t know who these kids are by looking at them so best to keep an open mind. However hard it is for you for the short flight duration it can be a lot harder for the parent who is struggling and having people judging when you’re trying your best feels horrific. I’ve had lots of horrible comments from people on planes about my son who has a neurological disorder and it’s really upsetting. Now he’s older we can use focus medication and it calms the situation on a plane. Obviously people should bring entertainment for their kids and try their best though. Also many young kids won’t have much experience of flying because of the pandemic, so it probably exacerbates the problem.

RunningJumpingClimbingTrees · 11/06/2022 18:14

I have travelled a fair bit with my two and it’s definitely about making the effort. My wee boy can be a little monkey at times but has never been an issue on a plane. He is told why he can’t do things and it seems to be one of the times he is willing to actually listen. We always have plenty of colouring and iPads fully charged.

I agree with others who say it is about trying and not just letting them run amok. My son will talk to just about anyone and usually makes friends everywhere and he usually has a kind adult or older child chatting to him for a bit of the flight but we always make sure he has not outstayed his welcome and ensure we are involved in the chat to read the social cues that he can’t. My daughter likes to keep her head down and ignore everyone else so is no trouble(7 going on 17).

Fluffmum · 11/06/2022 18:14

yanbu. My pet peeve is playing on iPad without headphones. I’m not that interested in Peppa pig!

WhoKnowsProbsNotMe · 11/06/2022 18:12

YANBU I get kids will be kids have the odd tantrum not realise the volume is getting higher and higher 😂 however, it’s the parents job to remind them. I’ve been on a flight before and the child behind me kicked my seat the fulllllllll way (it wasn’t too long a flight so I CBA risking making a scene by saying something) but you would have thought me turning around and glaring at the parents would have prompted some response to remind the child someone is in the seat in front …..but nooooo and it wasn’t a slight foot tap so there’s no way they weren’t aware 🫠😤 x

BanquoGhostie · 11/06/2022 18:07

Even though I am suspect I left to vibration due to my deafness - I have 3 nieces and nephews on the Autistic Spectrum. If your son is having a meltdown or even when he isn’t - maybe let the fellow passengers be aware of that there is someone on the spectrum then allowances can be made. I know from my brother that he often ‘loses the will to live’ when trying to get his 2 boys to bed. My 12 yo niece was diagnosed as being on the spectrum this year.
if you inform fellow passengers then you will find them more accommodating. My beef is with parents who don’t bother looking after their DC on the flight.

Josie77784 · 11/06/2022 18:07

I think the parents would also opt for child free flights. That is so hard and some kids when you discipline them they FREAK out and scream their arses off so you have to balance what you're doing with how you know their reaction will be for THAT flight. What you as a passerby are seeing is not the totality of their parenting, it's the parenting that is required for that flight to do whatever they can do help balance the experience for other people.

(Side note: some parents have to fly, it's not a choice and they're scared to death themselves of flying and are medicated and trying not to have a panic attack and have the plane have to land mid-flight...)

My kids are all different and also a 2 or 3 year old is WAY harder to control than a 6 or 7 year old .. so it really depends on the child and their age, in conjunction. Not so much the parenting, unfortunately.

So in my opinion because I have been on many flights with my children and having been EXTREMELY prepared and definitely judged for everything like by 100 people in a tight plane for hours.... It's WAY more difficult for the parent than you so I'd just chill and stop judging. Way easier to be you buddy.

xmaswiththeinlaws · 11/06/2022 17:58

YANBU that would really wind me up too. We took our eldest on a plane at 6 weeks and again a year later. It was hard work carrying all the small child paraphernalia and their lack of understandingwhat is going on, but we managed. We didn't fly again until our youngest was old enough to follow instructions and a bit more independent. Yes, kids get irritable on planes, but parents should at least attempt to keep them entertained and under control. Getting on a long haul flight having made no plans for how to entertain them is just irresponsible. It should be as much a part of the trip preparation as sorting out passports, visas and vaccinations.