Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect people to be able to control their children on planes?

519 replies

Ace56 · 10/06/2022 17:08

I recently returned from a long haul trip with connecting flights, so was on 5 planes altogether.

On 4 of these flights I was around children who’s parents just seemed to pussyfoot around them and seemed unable to control them.

Flight 1 - mum and 2 kids in the row in front of me. Dad across the aisle, plonks himself down on his laptop for the entire flight. Little boy (around 2-3) EXTREMELY loud, continuous shrieking, disrupting his sister. They had brought nothing for him to do - no iPad/colouring/books, so no wonder he was bored. Just shrieked constantly to get mum’s attention. Dad did absolutely nothing to help, didn’t offer to take him. Neither took him for a walk down the aisle or anything - he literally was in his seat the entire flight, absolutely bored shitless and disturbing everyone around him.

Flight 2 - girl of about 3 sitting behind me, next to mum. Dad across the aisle. Was fine during the flight but kept switching between mum and dad, and taking it in turns to sit on their lap watching her iPad. When it came to landing, she still wanted to switch every few mins. Air hostess politely told them a few times that she needs to be seated now for landing. Parents meekly tried to make her sit still with one of them but eventually gave up, so for the actual landing she ended up in the aisle (very dangerous) with mum holding onto her T-shirt. Air hostesses were seated at this point so couldn’t do anything/didn’t notice.

Flight 3 - boy of about 5 in front of me, standing up in his seat, leaning back into the seat, generally jumping around. Mum apologised but made no real attempt to stop him.

Flight 4 - large extended family sitting in various places around the plane. Children allowed to shout at each other across rows and over people’s heads, not told to stop once.

AIBU to despair at parenting these days if this is the norm? Have other people come across situations like this or was I just very unlucky?!

OP posts:
Mandypocket · 11/06/2022 21:41

Sometimes controlling kids in that situtation can be hard, but I would at least expect the parents to try

Autumn61 · 11/06/2022 21:40

Erm , yea it fucking is !

JudgeRindersMinder · 11/06/2022 21:36

TeaWithFlorence · 10/06/2022 17:10

Do you have children?

You were one of the pathetic parents on OP’s flights aren’t you?

Mumzy2020 · 11/06/2022 21:30

Jott · 10/06/2022 17:19

I think I'd have been justified in saying "tough!" in that instance. I'd prefer to be judged for actually parenting and making my child follow a safety rule than be judged for not.

This definitely this!!
. My own mother judges me for parenting. It is what it is. Kids need to be taught right from wrong the earlier the better. They will scream and shout flip out but as soon as they realise nothing is changing they'll soon back down.

carchi · 11/06/2022 21:10

I believe that parents should try and understand that children get bored and in a confined space that's going to be difficult. Therefore bring distractions toys, food, games, computers with games films etc. Your children are your responsibility not other passengers or flight crew. My children and grandchildren are no angels but I always made sure that they understood the importance of behaving when on a flight. You are not being unreasonable to expect that type of parenting.

Insanelysilver · 11/06/2022 21:09

I used to be a teaching assistant in an after art school class.
At least half the children in the class of 5 and 6 year olds , had parents who were Russia or from Eastern Europe.
It was a real eye opener to me . I saw a noticeable difference in the behaviour of those children and very much in the expectations of the parents of the child’s work.
The parents of the Russian kids invariably ‘ reminded’ them to behave at the beginning of each class and in serious way. Their behaviour and concentration was way better than the English kids. Their work was usually so much of a better standard it was embarrassing when we displayed it. . If a child’s work was not as good as the parent expected , the child was sometimes told it wasn’t good by the parent. They didn’t pull the punches but their kids work was amazing and they were able to knuckle down and sit down and work for the entire class , where as many of the English kids were flicking paint at each other or painting their own tongues lol

ChocolateHippo · 11/06/2022 20:53

Rinatinabina · 11/06/2022 20:37

I am not looking forward to a long flight with 3yr old Dd we have coming up 🙈 apologies in advance to anyone sharing the plane with us. Am tempted to get her kiddy headphones and plug her into a screen for a bit. Other passengers are going to have to listen to me reading the frog prince and a bazillion times.

My DC is by no means an angel or even a particularly well-behaved child (despite my efforts). But the ipad comes out every time we travel, he is plugged in with earphones, snacks are passed every now and again and generally we (and everyone around us) hardly hears a whimper from him.

Being honest, the best children to travel next to are those who are plugged into a screen (with headphones). That generally keeps those who are around 3 or over occupied. I don't mind 'actively parented' children who are being read stories and played with either, but they do make more noise and cause more disturbance than those on screens. There is a time and place for screen time limits and imo it's not on flights 😁!

rainbowmilk · 11/06/2022 20:45

Would really like it if we could stop with the incessant narrative that it’s only childless people with their inherent lack of tolerance who find this annoying. There have been many parents on the thread who have said the same thing. Tolerance is not something that’s reserved to parents, and if anything I think it’s over-attributed, as many parents who preach tolerance are only talking about people having it for their kids, they don’t practice it themselves by having tolerance for those who can’t abide the noise and disruption, for example. That’s not being tolerant, it’s being self-centred.

Rinatinabina · 11/06/2022 20:37

I am not looking forward to a long flight with 3yr old Dd we have coming up 🙈 apologies in advance to anyone sharing the plane with us. Am tempted to get her kiddy headphones and plug her into a screen for a bit. Other passengers are going to have to listen to me reading the frog prince and a bazillion times.

qtpa2t · 11/06/2022 20:36

To add - my partner wasn't able to make it on the trip so I had to travel alone with her :D

Riannie · 11/06/2022 20:36

CurlyhairedAssassin · 11/06/2022 20:05

And everyone will have seen your efforts to deal with it and stop the bad behaviour, and appreciate that, even if he DOES have a meltdown as a result. People are for the most part kind and understanding, especially if parents explain that their child has ASD.

My son is tall for his age and very friendly most of the time. People assume he is older than he is and have told me he is, as well as telling me he is spoiled because he screams when told no. It is no one's business that my son has ASD and I am not telling a stranger just so they are sympathetic. I told him no or to stop and why. I tried to calm him down. That should be enough, but in my experience there is always someone who judges hard. Those people are the reason we don't travel as much as we could, and why I know people who don't go anywhere at all, even the local zoo, because they are tired of ignorant judgy people who say thing like 'children like that should not be allowed here.'

qtpa2t · 11/06/2022 20:36

I recently took the first ever plane trip with my
pandemic baby, she was 22 months old at the time. I was 30 weeks pregnant and stressed out so much about preparing for this flight. She had a bunch of colouring books, a magnetic toy thing, a water colouring book where you have water in the pen and draw to reveal the colours, a fidget cube, lots of snacks, iPad with a bunch of cartoons, her own headphones, etc. She was amazing the whole flight and all the distractions worked wonders! The ONLY time she was loud was at takeoff when I had to force her to sit in my lap strapped into the seatbelt. To be fair with my belly she was probably just uncomfortable, and overwhelmed at the first experience of a plane. YANBU.

MotherOfUnicorns4 · 11/06/2022 20:35

I was on a flight home a few weeks ago and the parents sat across from me couldn't get their toddler to sit down properly ready for takeoff. The flight attendant asked them three times to make sure their child was sat with seat belt on. The mother kept saying that she only wanted to look out of the window. Eventually they got her belted in while the toddler had a bit if a cry about it, but as soon as the flight attendant went to her own seat the mother unbelted the child and let her stand on her knee so she could see out of the window while the plane took off.

thesurrealist · 11/06/2022 20:35

Tbh, the worst behaviour I’ve witnessed on flights have all been perpetrated by full grown adults!

It's almost as if, when they were kids they weren't parented properly, isn't it 🙄🤔

Glenthebattleostrich · 11/06/2022 20:32

Flights to and from Florida, we paid for extra legroom seats but the plane was swapped and we ended up in the middle of the plane with ignorant arseholes using our space as a shortcut.

The 8 year old who every ten minutes wandered between his parents on either side of us was a pain in the arse. He was told fairly sharpish to stop. His dad tried to tell me he could do that and tried to stare me down. Unluckily for them I had raging PMT so was in no mood for fuckwits. Dad tried his luck with the cabin crew who agreed it was my space and not an aisle so he could walk around.

Then there was the family with mum, dad and 3 kids. Dad did fuck all and kept saying to mum well what do you want me to do? He didn't appreciate my response of I think I speak for everyone in the area when I say she wants you to actually parent your children. Mum thought it was funny though.

The toddlers behind us were delightful and very sweet and well behaved luckily!

A few years ago on a flight from the canaries dad had packed the nappy bag and forgot the wipes, snacks and calpol. Mum was so grateful with my 'mary poppins childminder bag'. Every time she looked for something he eas all oh should i not have put that in the hold? Oh sorry. And I'd just pass the required item back! They did buy me a drink and their little one was utterly gorgeous and delightful!

ArtVandalay · 11/06/2022 20:30

YANBU.

Feckless parents on flights who don't seem to be aware of anyone but themselves and their annoying kids drive me mad.

We always flew long haul with ours from when they were babies onwards, but we made every effort to keep them occupied and quiet.

JKRowlingDevilWoman · 11/06/2022 20:30

Ace56 · 11/06/2022 20:14

@JKRowlingDevilWoman Ah, the age old ‘I’ve never seen that so it doesn’t exist’ argument. Why would I be making this up? :D is everyone else on the thread talking about their similar experiences lying too?

I think it unlikely to be as bad as you've described. It's extremely unlucky to see it on 5 consecutive flights over the space of 24 hrs. Or have I misread your op? I'm not saying it doesn't happen. I have seen evidence of it. I'm saying that I think it's likely you are exaggerating. You still haven't qualified if you have children yourself. Perhaps you are lacking in tolerance as you are not a parent, and therefore exaggerating the behaviour of the children/parents.

Riannie · 11/06/2022 20:29

CurlyhairedAssassin · 11/06/2022 20:02

I think lots of people on this thread are forgetting that the children who struggle on planes because of their ASD turn into adults who struggle on planes because of their ASD. Those adults also deserve not to have their seat back kicked or have an ipad game blaring out next to them for 2 hours. ASD children do need to be taught how to deal with people saying no to them, and having to stick to non-negotiable rules about safety because, well, that's life and some things ARE non-negotiable. To just take the attitude "he has ASD therefore he should be allowed to do what he wants otherwise he has a meltdown" is wrong on an environment like a plane. Anyone who DOES take that attitude should perhaps think of waiting till their child is over before taking them on a plane, until the child has learned some strategies to deal with their intense frustration. Take an alternative type of holiday until then - one which suits your child's needs more.

I assure you as someone who has worked with ASD adults I do know this, and I think others do too. No one has said ASD is an excuse to let children do what they want, just that they can be harder to control/keep calm and quiet. An adult with ASD should understand that (although I have met a few who are so absorbed in their own ASD they don't care about others ASD, adult or child).

MrsDoubtfireForever · 11/06/2022 20:28

This one family had four kids. Mum was sat with another family rows away. The dad opened up a bag of laptop leads and headphones, doled them out. Didn’t notice when the youngest stood up as we were taking off and started wandering up aisle. All of us women were on our feet practically about to shriek when the mum, a few seats up, shouted orders at him from her seat. Luckily his older brother got him back in his seat and strapped him in. I don’t get it. I was there with my two but we make sure they’re supervised at the very least! Same family, bit later, kid nearly loses a finger on carousel.

Mfsf · 11/06/2022 20:22

Do you even have kids lol .
move traveled all over with my kids , some flights they are saints , others they won’t shut up .
none of what you described is considered children out of control IMO

Ace56 · 11/06/2022 20:21

MrsP9716 · 11/06/2022 18:41

So the first family you were annoyed at lack of involvement from dad and lack of technology to keep said child entertained then you were annoyed that what you are complaining didn’t happen on the first flight was happening on the second because it didn’t couple with your expectations? Pick a struggle lady.

Lol, what are you talking about? U ok hun? I wasn’t complaining about the technology being used in the second example or the dad’s involvement, it was the fact the kid was in the aisle for landing 😂

OP posts:
Ace56 · 11/06/2022 20:18

Nik2019 · 11/06/2022 18:32

Whereas you sound delightful…

Anyway, YABU OP. And you sound like you’re the entitled one, does the sound of children’s voices bother you that much, should they be seen and not heard?! I have a young child and as long as they’re not hurting anyone, or being rude etc., then I’ll try and get through the flight as best as I can and not take all the fun out of what should be an exciting experience.

Live and let live people!

@Nik2019 But by allowing your child to kick someone’s seat or shout loudly etc they ARE being rude, don’t you see that?

OP posts:
Ace56 · 11/06/2022 20:14

@JKRowlingDevilWoman Ah, the age old ‘I’ve never seen that so it doesn’t exist’ argument. Why would I be making this up? :D is everyone else on the thread talking about their similar experiences lying too?

OP posts:
Riannie · 11/06/2022 20:13

CoastalWave · 11/06/2022 18:52

Tbh this is why I won't take my kids on a plane. My son has ADHD and wouldn't cope at all if things didn't go exactly as they should do.

Why should I inflict his meltdowns on other people?

I would say, if you have the type of children who can't 'cope' - don't fly. Holiday in GB instead.

You are being ignorant and insensitive. My family lives in the USA, my husband and I live in GB. Why should I not take my son to visit his grandparents because he is ASD? Why should any child with a neurological challenge be denied the right to fly for someone else's peace of mind? Yes it is a struggle to keep my son seated and entertained, but telling him we can't visit is worse.

Happymum12345 · 11/06/2022 20:12

Every child is different. Well done to all of you who have perfectly well behaved children and who have done a great job at raising them so well. Big pat on the back to you.