Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect people to be able to control their children on planes?

519 replies

Ace56 · 10/06/2022 17:08

I recently returned from a long haul trip with connecting flights, so was on 5 planes altogether.

On 4 of these flights I was around children who’s parents just seemed to pussyfoot around them and seemed unable to control them.

Flight 1 - mum and 2 kids in the row in front of me. Dad across the aisle, plonks himself down on his laptop for the entire flight. Little boy (around 2-3) EXTREMELY loud, continuous shrieking, disrupting his sister. They had brought nothing for him to do - no iPad/colouring/books, so no wonder he was bored. Just shrieked constantly to get mum’s attention. Dad did absolutely nothing to help, didn’t offer to take him. Neither took him for a walk down the aisle or anything - he literally was in his seat the entire flight, absolutely bored shitless and disturbing everyone around him.

Flight 2 - girl of about 3 sitting behind me, next to mum. Dad across the aisle. Was fine during the flight but kept switching between mum and dad, and taking it in turns to sit on their lap watching her iPad. When it came to landing, she still wanted to switch every few mins. Air hostess politely told them a few times that she needs to be seated now for landing. Parents meekly tried to make her sit still with one of them but eventually gave up, so for the actual landing she ended up in the aisle (very dangerous) with mum holding onto her T-shirt. Air hostesses were seated at this point so couldn’t do anything/didn’t notice.

Flight 3 - boy of about 5 in front of me, standing up in his seat, leaning back into the seat, generally jumping around. Mum apologised but made no real attempt to stop him.

Flight 4 - large extended family sitting in various places around the plane. Children allowed to shout at each other across rows and over people’s heads, not told to stop once.

AIBU to despair at parenting these days if this is the norm? Have other people come across situations like this or was I just very unlucky?!

OP posts:
rainbowmilk · 15/06/2022 21:31

Josie77784 · 15/06/2022 21:01

@rainbowmilk
Are you showing true concern for someone or are you trying to make someone look crazy? Do I seem okay? Do I seem frustrated? Would you be?

I mean, it’s a bit weird to be lectured on adult tolerance and understanding from someone who keeps SHOUTING about child services and legal action and the general torment faced by parents in society.

Josie77784 · 15/06/2022 21:01

rainbowmilk · 15/06/2022 19:58

@Josie77784 Are you alright?

@rainbowmilk
Are you showing true concern for someone or are you trying to make someone look crazy? Do I seem okay? Do I seem frustrated? Would you be?

Josie77784 · 15/06/2022 20:16

@balalake see my reply to you at the end of the comments. Please never suggest taking legal actions against parents unless you'd like that done to you for your mistakes or weaknesses. This is pretty extreme.

Josie77784 · 15/06/2022 20:10

KosherDill · 12/06/2022 12:41

This!

Literally the opposite of what this person is saying. That so many people think some guy flying alone being "subjected" to children, is somehow reasonable is scary and what is wrong with the entire English speaking world. No understanding of children or parenting whatsoever. This guy probably blames his parents for his problems too. Shame on this individualiatic society who hates parents and children and comes from parents and children... It is WAY more difficult to be the parents in these situations and if this guy doesn't see it and HAS children, either they were easy children, he was lucky or he never was in a plane with his children. I have 4 children and 3 are easy, 1 is almost impossible and it is literally never my choice to have the children in public at all. Have been accused of abuse when I've tried to control his tantrums and threatened to be turned over to child services for doing so. On one hand you have the older generation telling us we're too easy on our children and another set of people telling us we're abusive. Not possible. You people need to get some lives. Get some headphones. Get some BALLS and if a CHILD is kicking your seat have the decency to ask their parents respectfully to please have the child not do it or ask them yourselves as you're ADULTS who apparently know basically everything about the world and are able to judge everyone so please make the right decisions, be more prepared for THE REAL WORLD that would COMPLETELY cease to exist without parents and children. How about be the wise person you're pretending to be and offer some help to the parent or child or suck it up and deal with life or stop flying because most adults don't actually HAVE to fly.

rainbowmilk · 15/06/2022 19:58

@Josie77784 Are you alright?

Josie77784 · 15/06/2022 19:56

Wow threatening to ban parents is pretty wild. I'd say they should try to help. Offer understanding. Threatening the people who are having the hardest time is pretty crazy. How can you even suggest that?

How about "Hey i know this is very difficult and probably been a really hard day being in the airport all day and now in a plane with small children. I want you to know that we will al stand by you if you have to hold your child down forcefully, screaming and crying and won't report you to child services for abuse because we all know you're going to be doing it for their safety and because it's a law. We promise under no circumstances will anyone in this plane be allowed to film you while you do that or attempt to threaten to have your children taken away if you attempt to discipline them in public or control them in a way you feel you need to. If someone does that we as an airline will BAN those passengers and will standby you against CHILD SERVICES as we support parents and want parents of small children to be able to fly safely and comfortably just like any other person. Especially because parents have such an incredibly difficult and important job raising our future."

Why wouldn't any of you all be suggesting that? Why are parents constantly having to be threatened with having their children taken or being banned from places?

Please open your eyes a little......

Josie77784 · 15/06/2022 19:23

Some flights don't have tv... And they aren't clear with videos. USB doesn't work for tablet then the parent is screwed. Especially if the last plane, same airline they had fun games and videos and this plane doesn't. They may have a plan. Then they don't.

Also I'd say the dad could be medicated and trying not to have a panic attack. Some dad's just suck though and are tired and can't be bothered. Not the mom's fault.

Also, are you all watching the parents or listening? How do you know what's going on in their seat? Many times I've been with an infant or a 2 year old and have other children and can't get up to get my child. They may have been seated apart as well when you have more than 1.

I'd say no excuse for an 8 year old kicking but if the parent isn't right there and doesn't know, someone will have to talk to the kid and explain.

Some parents do let their children run around but it's not usually the "entitled" parents it's usually uneducated people who think that's the best way. Entitled people are usually overly prepared and definitely get judged for that pretty harshly. Really hard to win as a parent. Either we're doing too much or too little no matter what and everyone thinks they should weigh in.

It's really important that we try to put ourselves in other people's shoes or get some headphones and be prepared yourself because the only reason you exist in the world is because of mother's and father's and children are a part of life. Can't think your way out of having to deal with young humans....

2005justone · 15/06/2022 17:42

👍

balalake · 14/06/2022 07:07

I think you were unlucky, especially with flight 1.

If you felt for one flight that there was dangerous behaviour, you should complain, and suggest to the airline they ban the parents concerned.

KosherDill · 14/06/2022 02:56

SilverGlitterBaubles · 13/06/2022 20:53

@KosherDill It is a bit much to expect parents of young children to stay at home permanently. In fact I think it may create more issues further down the line as how will kids ever learn unless they are exposed to certain situations. Perhaps it's not the best idea to take a wriggly toddler to a fancy restaurant for a lengthy lunch, sometimes even the most angelic child will unexpectedly have a meltdown that's just life (I'm still traumatised from DDs episode in a restaurant almost 20 years ago) Blush

Kids can learn at home if the family has proper seated meals rather than fast food shoved at a kid with a screen.

KosherDill · 14/06/2022 02:54

SilverGlitterBaubles · 13/06/2022 20:53

@KosherDill It is a bit much to expect parents of young children to stay at home permanently. In fact I think it may create more issues further down the line as how will kids ever learn unless they are exposed to certain situations. Perhaps it's not the best idea to take a wriggly toddler to a fancy restaurant for a lengthy lunch, sometimes even the most angelic child will unexpectedly have a meltdown that's just life (I'm still traumatised from DDs episode in a restaurant almost 20 years ago) Blush

Four or five years of local holidays and judicious choice of restaurants is, in consideration of others, not "a bit much."

Whatsonmymindgrapes · 13/06/2022 21:14

That would cheese me off.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 13/06/2022 20:53

@KosherDill It is a bit much to expect parents of young children to stay at home permanently. In fact I think it may create more issues further down the line as how will kids ever learn unless they are exposed to certain situations. Perhaps it's not the best idea to take a wriggly toddler to a fancy restaurant for a lengthy lunch, sometimes even the most angelic child will unexpectedly have a meltdown that's just life (I'm still traumatised from DDs episode in a restaurant almost 20 years ago) Blush

Natsku · 13/06/2022 16:04

Had a flight today, several children on board the small plane and all the others were good, one small baby crying during landing but that can't be helped, just the ear pain thing. My 4 year old did kick the chair in front a few times when he forgot himself and swung his legs (I took his shoes off though thanks to a tip from a pp, and of course stopped him each time) but no over-tired tantrums thank fuck, was exceedingly cheerful the whole time.
No lairy unpleasant men either, was quite the perfect flight!

Rosehugger · 13/06/2022 13:49

I'd rather lairy, unpleasant, rude men were confined to quarters until they can behave, than children. Have had far more issue with them over the years, especially in pubs.

Hardbackwriter · 13/06/2022 12:29

For the most part, unless relocating overseas, small kids needn't be on planes or in pubs or restaurants. Maybe parents need to suck it up and forego certain holidays or outings till the children are older, rather than expecting everyone else to suck it up.

What age is it that you think children will magically be well behaved in a situation that they've never been exposed to? Could you let all the rude adults that I see know, since they've presumably passed threshold?

I think parents should always try to control their children in public, and I certainly do. But it isn't with a 100% success rate, and that's part of learning and producing the next generation of adults. In a pub or restaurant then you can and should remove a disruptive child, but that's not an option on a plane!

ANameChangeling · 13/06/2022 12:26

Sometimes it can be the adult passengers rather than the children that are at fault though.

I travelled on a lot of long-haul flights prior to having children, so am aware that some can be be badly behaved (including having orange juice poured over my foot on one occasion by a tantruming child!) and have always been very strict with my mine and didn’t actually travel with them when they were very young.

On one flight, my two DS were arguing as we boarded and no doubt the other passengers were rightly hoping that they weren’t sitting near to us. However, I seated them either side of me, so that they couldn’t fight and they then spent the the whole 3-hour flight sitting quietly watching TV with headphones or reading, and not moving about. Despite this, the woman in front had obviously already decided that they were an issue and every time that my youngest spoke, would turn round to look at us and sigh loudly. He was speaking less than an adult probably would - e.g. asking how to change channels and what food option he wanted but I was made to feel really uncomfortable

CazCoo · 13/06/2022 12:10

Because you're only allowed to take your kids on holiday if they are perfectly behaved 🤦‍♀️ please.

KosherDill · 13/06/2022 11:04

SilverGlitterBaubles · 13/06/2022 08:30

I think a bit of understanding and consideration of others is needed and perhaps some parents don't teach this enough to kids letting them roam and disrupt wherever they go. At the same time some empathy is needed for those people who are in situations where their young child will not settle on a flight, in a restaurant or other places. We have all been there it's grim, it's embarrassing and no one wants to be in this situation.

But generally they are in the situation by choice.

For the most part, unless relocating overseas, small kids needn't be on planes or in pubs or restaurants. Maybe parents need to suck it up and forego certain holidays or outings till the children are older, rather than expecting everyone else to suck it up.

CulturePigeon · 13/06/2022 10:42

I think people should be able to control their children everywhere (barring those who have children with learning difficulties and other issues). Restaurants, pubs, shops, shows, cinema...basically whenever in public with them. It's called parenting, isn't it?

If they don't, the duty of care is passed to waiters, cinema ushers, shop staff, bus conductors, train guards (who ever sees those any more?)etc. They already have plenty to do, thanks. Because they often can't or won't tell loud or badly-behaved children where to get off, the onus falls on fellow passenger, cinema-goers or diners - making what should be a treat (and often an expensive one) into an ordeal.

What's gone wrong? Are people expecting to take children where realistically children shouldn't go? Are parents lazier now? Are families more entitled - just expecting the rest of us to put up with it because 'children will be children'? I don't know. Surely the common-sense rule would be 'we can only go there/do that if you behave (and define expectations - eg, sit in your seat, don't shout, learn some patience)? Children won't learn how to behave considerately to others unless boundaries are made clear. You might adore your children whatever they do, but if you want others to like them, you have to compromise on the 'let them do as they like' strategy, i would think.

MamaBerg · 13/06/2022 10:15

My kids are a pain. There's only so much we can do. We come armed with tablets pre-loaded with all their favourite cartoons, loads of snacks, colouring, games etc and they still kick off. The 3 year old is possibly SEN/ on the autism spectrum and just cannot be told what to do or to sit still. He's a runner. We use a CARES harness with him which helps loads. I suggest all parents of toddlers get one! The one flight we forgot it he was crawling under the seats and I couldn't get to him. Pissed loads of people off but I was trying my best!

mugglewump · 13/06/2022 09:56

You can't win with kids - one family accused of not doing enough to calm a child and keep him/her occupied (child sat screaming, not brought anything to calm him down, dad on laptop), others accused of doing too much to try to keep their child calm (passing between parents to stop child kicking off). There is a huge range of personalities among kids (I'm a supply teacher, I see thousands) and not all kids are easy angels like perhaps yours are. People are not given much support in how to manage children's behaviour and everyone has to do what feels right for them. I also think we are not hearing the full story here - we never do when someone wants to complain. What I would like to know is, did those posting do anything to help? Perhaps offered the couple with nothing to engage the child a book or some paper and colouring pens to distract and support? Or ask the people with with the loud Peppa Pig if their child would like to turn it down or borrow headphones? It's very passive aggressive to just post a rant...

Sarah13xx · 13/06/2022 08:34

This is why I’m quitting teaching 🙈

SilverGlitterBaubles · 13/06/2022 08:30

I think a bit of understanding and consideration of others is needed and perhaps some parents don't teach this enough to kids letting them roam and disrupt wherever they go. At the same time some empathy is needed for those people who are in situations where their young child will not settle on a flight, in a restaurant or other places. We have all been there it's grim, it's embarrassing and no one wants to be in this situation.

BalloonsAndWhistles · 13/06/2022 08:24

YANBU. Just got back from holiday. The flight home was a dream, so quiet and the plane was half empty with mostly adults/older children. The flight out had a lot of younger kids/babies and one kid spent ages singing ‘Let it Go’ with Mum looking on adoringly and kind of looking at the rest of the passengers as though we should think she was amazing aka the next Adele. She wasn’t.