Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect people to be able to control their children on planes?

519 replies

Ace56 · 10/06/2022 17:08

I recently returned from a long haul trip with connecting flights, so was on 5 planes altogether.

On 4 of these flights I was around children who’s parents just seemed to pussyfoot around them and seemed unable to control them.

Flight 1 - mum and 2 kids in the row in front of me. Dad across the aisle, plonks himself down on his laptop for the entire flight. Little boy (around 2-3) EXTREMELY loud, continuous shrieking, disrupting his sister. They had brought nothing for him to do - no iPad/colouring/books, so no wonder he was bored. Just shrieked constantly to get mum’s attention. Dad did absolutely nothing to help, didn’t offer to take him. Neither took him for a walk down the aisle or anything - he literally was in his seat the entire flight, absolutely bored shitless and disturbing everyone around him.

Flight 2 - girl of about 3 sitting behind me, next to mum. Dad across the aisle. Was fine during the flight but kept switching between mum and dad, and taking it in turns to sit on their lap watching her iPad. When it came to landing, she still wanted to switch every few mins. Air hostess politely told them a few times that she needs to be seated now for landing. Parents meekly tried to make her sit still with one of them but eventually gave up, so for the actual landing she ended up in the aisle (very dangerous) with mum holding onto her T-shirt. Air hostesses were seated at this point so couldn’t do anything/didn’t notice.

Flight 3 - boy of about 5 in front of me, standing up in his seat, leaning back into the seat, generally jumping around. Mum apologised but made no real attempt to stop him.

Flight 4 - large extended family sitting in various places around the plane. Children allowed to shout at each other across rows and over people’s heads, not told to stop once.

AIBU to despair at parenting these days if this is the norm? Have other people come across situations like this or was I just very unlucky?!

OP posts:
UWhatNow · 05/08/2022 16:13

vivainsomnia · 05/08/2022 15:34

Have you ever tryed to get children to behave for the entire flight in an enclosed space?
Yep, a few times a year and yes, except for the very short occasional moment, they were very well behaved. Why? Because I was always engaged with them. We talked about every aspect of the experience. Because I arranged for them to be occupied throughout the journey. Because I told them before we went on that there would be punishment if they didn't behaved. Because I dealt with any concerning behaviour very early to be sure to de-escalate it before it became a tantrum.

Amazingly, most parents manage it. Those who are engaged rather than seating there with their music on, phone in their hand, nothing to entertain their kids and then act all helpless when their kids lose it.

In my book, that is bad parenting.

100% agree. I have 3 children and when they weee little I could take them anywhere - including on planes every year.

Good parenting = you at least attempt to manage it.
Poor parenting = saying there’s nothing I can do about my kid kicking off so sod everyone else on the plane.

vivainsomnia · 05/08/2022 15:34

Have you ever tryed to get children to behave for the entire flight in an enclosed space?
Yep, a few times a year and yes, except for the very short occasional moment, they were very well behaved. Why? Because I was always engaged with them. We talked about every aspect of the experience. Because I arranged for them to be occupied throughout the journey. Because I told them before we went on that there would be punishment if they didn't behaved. Because I dealt with any concerning behaviour very early to be sure to de-escalate it before it became a tantrum.

Amazingly, most parents manage it. Those who are engaged rather than seating there with their music on, phone in their hand, nothing to entertain their kids and then act all helpless when their kids lose it.

In my book, that is bad parenting.

vivainsomnia · 05/08/2022 15:26

Parents have different tolerances levels and assume that what they tolerate, everyone else should.

because of a tantrum their child is throwing or some other equally impossible situation to control such as bowel movements or even a child's volume
Impossible situations to control? That's the issue I have. I never expect kids to be able to monitor their own behaviour in public. It's a learning process, but Gosh do I get annoyed with parents who act helpless and are too lazy to do something about their kids behaviour.

If a kid has a poo, you get up and change them. If your kid is being loud, you distract them, give them an activity that keeps them quiet. You engage with them in talking and remind them to keep it at a normal sound level.

There is nothing worse than a kid having a tantrum and parents doing absolutely nothing about it? I just can't fathom why you wouldn't at least try everything to stop it, whichever way and instead find it acceptable to impose it to everyone else.

SherbertLemonDrop · 05/08/2022 14:47

I never smacked my son but I only had to give him 'the look' and he shut and behaved. He knew there would be consequences otherwise. Some kids just don't get consequences.

I8toys · 05/08/2022 14:38

YANBU. I'd find all ways to occupy them and use bribery. I'd also reiterate that they listen to the air stewards/stewardesses, follow instructions and don't dick about. I don't want to inflict my children on others minding their own business. And the safety aspect is concerning if they can't get the kid to sit down through take off and landing they shouldn't be getting on the plane.

Capri3 · 05/08/2022 14:15

MsTSwift · 04/08/2022 11:47

We stayed within 2 hours drive until school age. Different if you have family abroad I guess but otherwise why choose to do that to yourself?! Young kids don’t know where they. Load of pointless stress.

Same here. Far easier to take all that you need with you too.

The majority of under 3’s understandably don’t want to just sit still for hours. If you add on travelling to the airport, going through bag drop, security etc, they’re probably all thoroughly fed up by the time they’re sat on the plane.

GoodThinkingMax · 04/08/2022 21:39

MsTSwift · 04/08/2022 11:47

We stayed within 2 hours drive until school age. Different if you have family abroad I guess but otherwise why choose to do that to yourself?! Young kids don’t know where they. Load of pointless stress.

Common sense at last!!

If you feel you really have to fly with small children, then you need to be on it. Not throw your hands up and let your children cry. Most people are tolerant of upset children if it’s obvious their parents are trying to distract and care for them.

But I’ve flown too many times when parents ignore behaviour which has an impact on other passengers, or seem totally ineffective in doing anything about it.

PatientlyWaiting21 · 04/08/2022 20:22

That’s nothing compared to the adult travellers I’ve came across.

Funkykitty · 04/08/2022 20:08

Johnnysgirl · 04/08/2022 20:06

Did you read the op? Not a single one of those scenarios related to "upset" children. Stop arguing something you haven't even understood, it makes you look extremely dim.

I see its you that dosn’t understand. Go back and read your own comment.

gogohmm · 04/08/2022 20:07

@Funkykitty

My kids had clocked 50,000 air miles before 5. It's perfectly possible to keep them quiet, and this was in the days before iPads and smartphones! You need to be very prepared as a parent with lots of distractions plus accept your won't get to relax at all. We mostly flew long haul west coast of USA due to living overseas but plenty of domestic us flights too.

I'll be forever indebted to the lovely ladies who read stories or bounced one of mine on their knees ... I never asked but always had offers. BA cabin crew are lovely too, especially the head steward who brought me a first class meal when I travelled solo with my 7 week old as I needed the strength!

Funkykitty · 04/08/2022 20:07

ivfbabymomma1 · 04/08/2022 20:03

If the parents are trying all they can and are struggling then fair enough but if they are literally doing nothing to handle the situation then YANBU. (I have a 3 yr old seen as this is being asked)

I agree with this.

Johnnysgirl · 04/08/2022 20:06

Funkykitty · 04/08/2022 20:01

What a ridiculous comment. Clearly you have never had to try to control upset children in a plane. So yes you will have to put up or shut up.

Did you read the op? Not a single one of those scenarios related to "upset" children. Stop arguing something you haven't even understood, it makes you look extremely dim.

ivfbabymomma1 · 04/08/2022 20:03

If the parents are trying all they can and are struggling then fair enough but if they are literally doing nothing to handle the situation then YANBU. (I have a 3 yr old seen as this is being asked)

Funkykitty · 04/08/2022 20:01

Johnnysgirl · 04/08/2022 19:58

Unfortunitly people will just have to put up or shut up.
What a ridiculous, graceless thing to say Confused. Put up or shut up...
What does it even mean in this context?

Nobody should have sympathy for you not being able to control your kids, and nobody even half civilised would have the entitlement to think they deserved it.

What a ridiculous comment. Clearly you have never had to try to control upset children in a plane. So yes you will have to put up or shut up.

Johnnysgirl · 04/08/2022 19:58

Funkykitty · 04/08/2022 18:27

Have you ever tryed to get children to behave for the entire flight in an enclosed space? Have to ever know children to stay quiet for a couple of hours flight the entire time? As annoying as it is for passangers there should be some sympathy for parents, as unfortunitly children will not stay quiet every time we want them to. Unfortunitly people will just have to put up or shut up.

Unfortunitly people will just have to put up or shut up.
What a ridiculous, graceless thing to say Confused. Put up or shut up...
What does it even mean in this context?

Nobody should have sympathy for you not being able to control your kids, and nobody even half civilised would have the entitlement to think they deserved it.

KosherDill · 04/08/2022 19:52

MsTSwift · 04/08/2022 11:47

We stayed within 2 hours drive until school age. Different if you have family abroad I guess but otherwise why choose to do that to yourself?! Young kids don’t know where they. Load of pointless stress.

This!

MeenzAmRhoi · 04/08/2022 18:59

Read the title and expected to say Yabu but reading your examples, that's dreadful. Shocked by 2nd flight, health and safety should trump everything. Yanbu!

Funkykitty · 04/08/2022 18:27

UWhatNow · 04/08/2022 10:51

No one is saying that. But everybody suffers being around out of control screaming kids on a flight. It’s just horrible and stressful for everybody. It’s just about at least trying to pacify little children out of consideration for others.

Or is ‘consideration for others’ not a thing any more?

Have you ever tryed to get children to behave for the entire flight in an enclosed space? Have to ever know children to stay quiet for a couple of hours flight the entire time? As annoying as it is for passangers there should be some sympathy for parents, as unfortunitly children will not stay quiet every time we want them to. Unfortunitly people will just have to put up or shut up.

MsTSwift · 04/08/2022 11:47

We stayed within 2 hours drive until school age. Different if you have family abroad I guess but otherwise why choose to do that to yourself?! Young kids don’t know where they. Load of pointless stress.

UWhatNow · 04/08/2022 10:51

CazCoo · 13/06/2022 12:10

Because you're only allowed to take your kids on holiday if they are perfectly behaved 🤦‍♀️ please.

No one is saying that. But everybody suffers being around out of control screaming kids on a flight. It’s just horrible and stressful for everybody. It’s just about at least trying to pacify little children out of consideration for others.

Or is ‘consideration for others’ not a thing any more?

2bazookas · 04/08/2022 08:07

Yes, I have met similar situations (on planes, trains, buses, ferries,in restaurants).. Then I did something about it. Polite, calm, firm. It works.

You could have asked the stewards to intervene
You could have spoken direct to the parents
You could have spoken direct to the children.

Anon778833 · 04/08/2022 07:29

I completely agree with the OP. Unless of course a child has SN. Which does not sound like it was the case here.

I definitely agree that there are a lot of parents who think they can just get on a flight and not bother to actually parent their children. I remember one flight that I was on where some kids were hitting each other and their father looked pissed out of his skull and just kind of mumbled at them before going back to sleep.

Another family kept letting their toddler wander off on the plane. It’s just not on. I suppose I’m lucky with my children because they are very placid and would sit and play travel scrabble etc. But I provided them with things to do - it’s not hard.

DelilahBucket · 04/08/2022 07:26

YANBU how difficult is it to prepare for taking a small child on a plane fgs. A bag full of new toys, books, colouring, snacks, a tablet or mobile phone with some favourite programmes uploaded and a set of headphones. Any long journey DS had a tablet and headphones with short programmes and cartoons downloaded. It was the one time he was allowed to watch them all back to back - he loved it!! Not once had he ever tantrummed, screamed, kicked the back of someone's chair, jumped up and down (or even stood on a seat) or run around on a plane. He's been taught these aren't acceptable behaviours.
We also used to take sweets/lollies to help with the ear popping.

Sweety1428 · 04/08/2022 07:19

I had an experience on flight where the lady started shouting on top of her voice and questioning about parenting techniques as my kids were playing in the bus with a poll.I can co relate you with the same lady. She started saying everyone is irritated as your kids are playing and I politely said I don’t think so and 2 strangers around us confirmed that they are fine and the lady became quite. In my instance the kids were not screaming but were singing songs and playing with a pole.I think people like you need help with their anger management issues for trying to insult other people for thinking you are entitled to do so.You are causing more distress and nuisance in a public place with you tone and your screaming.This shows your in consideration for peoples feelings around you, and eventually humanity though you are an adult. It is not OK to try to intimidate other people around you when you yourself are doing the same things.FYI the children should be guarded from such people or they will pick up on the rude and disrespectful behaviour towards others.

Josie77784 · 15/06/2022 22:30

@rainbowmilk
You all (if you feel so offended) are the ones lecturing and not understanding the reality of being a parent today. If you find all of that, child services stuff a bit much then you would agree with me. That's the reality of parenting today. Those are real things that happen to moms every day doing normal things and having normal and very difficult situations happen to them simply because they have children and then are threatened and lectured by perfect strangers, doctors, other mother's etc. to be reported, banned, excluded etc. because of a tantrum their child is throwing or some other equally impossible situation to control such as bowel movements or even a child's volume. And in this specific case like another mother has pointed out, it's on an airplane where the mother(s) can't simply grab her child and disappear if everything she's done or knows to do will not help the situation. Many people are even suggesting not to ever travel while you have children that they can't control everything about them, is a very stupid suggestion as it's not possible and deserves a solid reaction. Most mother's travelling by plane are not on vacation and neither will their vacation feel like a vacation if they are, because she has small children. If you don't understand what I'm saying then you are not a mother or you have an incredibly amazing support team and incredible kids and that makes you lucky, not smart and definitely not better. So maybe have some humility and don't think you have the right to point the finger at people whom you don't know.

It's incredibly judgmental and idiotic, like I said previously, to continue as a culture to be so harsh towards parents instead of helpful and supportive. Yes it does become infuriating that you can't go out as a mother without everyone having their say about every move you make. Are you all also the people who don't understand when people completely freak out and hurt others after being mistreated repeatedly by people who think they're better? Do you try to make people feel crazy and then blame them for their reactions or are you trying to be a part of the good change in the world?