Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate it when people say “my husband/partner/boyfriend doesn’t do the night feeds because he works”

614 replies

ForestFae · 10/06/2022 16:32

Every time I see or hear this phrase, I rage. Usually said by some poor sleep deprived new mum who’s looking after the baby/ies all day long. Why is looking after a baby not considered valuable work? Why are men getting away with using this rubbish excuse?

OP posts:
OverCCCs · 11/06/2022 13:32

Your last few posts have been enlightening, OP. It sounds like you never held a particularly intellectually challenging job or anything that required much beyond repetitive tasks, and you struggle to conceptualize “desk” roles that require more active engagement and a clear, sharp mind.

You also apparently struggle to comprehend that not everyone has the same approach to being a SAHM that you do (an approach which appears to lead to you being consistently burned out).

Essentially—and I say this as an observation, not to be mean—you come off as lacking in emotional intelligence in regards to social awareness, perspective taking, and empathy. I hope your children have the opportunity to see those important skills modeled from someone.

Perspective taking would make it clear why a SAHP would in many cases take night feedings, and, indeed, explain a major part of why maternity leave exists at all (ie to give the mother time to laze about during the day after a broken night’s sleep).

MRex · 11/06/2022 13:14

Whoever isn't working can get up and then day nap with the baby, which is an option not open to the working one. If there are older children that make this impossible, then more sharing will be needed. I breastfed, so not much point DH getting up regardless unless I wanted him to fetch something; instead he would take the baby for me to have a lie-in, make dinner while I chilled out etc. You don't know everything about how tasks are split in someone else's relationship and if someone is unhappy with the effort their own partner makes then that's up to them to resolve, you can rage all you want but it's not clear why you'd bother.

RealBecca · 11/06/2022 12:55

Yanbu. There are very few instances where the couple cant work around it. He could finish his labour intensive man day, have dinner and go to bed at 7pm and sleep til 3am and do the rest of the night. Or one night on and one off.

loudsnoringcat · 11/06/2022 12:50

missdemeanors - Yes I also loved days with the kids when they were little. Having 4 at home was not easy, but still preferable (to me) to the alternative. At least if it's a horrible morning and they're a bit ill, you can just put the fire on and watch movies and play games or whatever. You're not having to drop them at at baby day centre at a given time and then rush through traffic into work and do a days work there.

missdemeanors · 11/06/2022 12:35

It certainly comes across as some SAHP being at pains to tell us how difficult and inflexible their days are.

I'm not denying that looking after small children can be demanding but it's sad that some people seem angry and frustrated with the choice they've made.

Personally I loved my non- work days with my little ones. Yes of course sometimes they argue, are stubborn etc and need constant supervision in some situations but it wasn't the ordeal some people seem to make it into

Sugarplumfairy65 · 11/06/2022 12:26

I did all the night feeds because firstly i breast fed, secondly my husband drove for a living and it was imperative that he didnt doze off behind the wheel of his articulated lorry doing 60mph on the motorway.
He did pull his weight in other areas though

anxiousmumagain · 11/06/2022 12:25

I definitely had more flexibility in the office than at home.

That's interesting (genuinely - I've never been a SAHP as I say but have been on mat leave for a year which is the closest I have been to it).

My days were easily 10 times more flexible when on mat leave compared to a day at work. My boss isn't a tyrant, he's actually lovely and generally supportive. But he still expects me to be accountable to him about my day and where I am and when, and why, etc, which is fair enough as that's what they pay me for! I'm accountable to no one at home and I call the shots, so I suppose that's what I meant.

But I take the point that some kids can be non stop and intense! My little one has just started toddling so I probably have that to come ... 🤣

12Thorns · 11/06/2022 12:24

ClinicallyProven · 10/06/2022 16:44

How many babies are still "feeding" in the night at 12mo?

Weird entitled assumption. Most mums can’t afford 12 months maternity leave, or even 6 months

LaMarschallin · 11/06/2022 12:22

If they’re interacting with each other, I’m planning what to do next or setting up the next activity while also supervising because my DC get carried away very easily and will take things too far. It’s not like I don’t let them do things, they’re very independent more so than kids their own age as they’re raised climbing trees, doing chores, and spending most of the time outside, but everything we do involves some level of thought

Fair enough. I suspect that's the case for most people when looking after children but, for me anyway, it happened more automatically without consciously feeling I was planning what to do next or setting up activities. Everything everyone does requires some level of thought.

I hope, despite the hard work, you're enjoying bringing up your children and that they end up appreciating every minute that you put into it.

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 11/06/2022 12:20

I definitely had more flexibility in the office than at home. I find my kids don't understand the concept of please stop talking to me and leave me alone. In work if I wasn't feeling great I could a)call in sick and b)reschedule my day so that i was working on a report or doing research or site visits which required less thinking. My kids are 10 times more intense than any boss I've ever had, with the exception of one who was such an arsehole that I actually had zero respect for him or drive to motivate myself so it all levelled out.

Which is why comparison is a complete waste of time.

anxiousmumagain · 11/06/2022 12:15

@ForestFae

I'm not sure if you've already acknowledged this so apologies if I've missed it.

Surely you take the point in relation to the greater degree of flexibility you have over your day as a SAHP? I'm assuming the lessons you plan for your children are decided upon by you and you only? And that you design them and decide when they will happen? And if you want or need to change the schedule for the day, that's easily done in most cases? You don't have a boss checking that you're doing what it says in your diary or timetable, for example? No pressure of deadlines looming?

I'm not saying that to undervalue what you do, it sounds very hard work from how you put it across on here. But surely you see that you - as the boss - can change and flex to suit yourself and your needs (and those of your family) that day? Paid jobs don't work like that, and hence there is an added layer of pressure for working parents in terms of accountability, inflexibility, deadlines, and so on.

Removing that pressure in itself I would argue removes a layer of intensity from being at home with the children, surely?

loudsnoringcat · 11/06/2022 12:15

Hi OP. I admit I have not RTFT, but I've read your comments. I just wanted to give my perspective as someone who was a SAHM to 4 DC (and still am) and they are now 19, 17, 15 and 12.

As I remember, I did do all the nights. I think it started because I was bf so there was no point in DH getting up. Then a pattern just emerged from there.

I'll be honest, it never really occurred to me to get DH up. With the first baby, I would say I was ok and I adapted to sleeping in two / three hour stints, night and day. No I wasn't at my sharpest, but it was enough. I only had a baby to focus on and had lots of other friends in the same situation so that became the norm. I didn't have to deal with actual adults and work deadlines, so I just accepted that feeling a bit zombified was part and parcel of it.

Where it does get more tiring is with the second, third and fourth babies as you have to get them up and out for school etc and you can't just follow the pace of one baby. That's when it gets more tiring. But also, I think you get used to broken sleep by that point. What I always did, was whenever I did have any downtime, I made the most of it.

Having said all this, I never had kids with chronic sleep problems or anything like that. When one of them was ill, DH would inevitably get involved.

Even with teens, I still don't sleep past 6 because I physically can't. I'm 48 now and maybe in peri-menopause and I think this I'm often waking up at 4am these days. Su sorry to say, it isn't just babies that affect sleep patterns!

I think it really depends on individual couples. Everyone is different and some people manage in less sleep than others. My DH had an extremely intense job and was also often overseas so I never relied on him in that way. But had he just worked a regular 9-5 in an admin job or something, I think I would have had different expectations.

There are no hard and fast rules basically. Ok, I was a bit zombified for a few years (well, maybe a decade!) but at least I never had to worry about money or deal with difficult people at work. Nor did I have work deadlines imposed in me. Nor did I have to 'look professional' or live my days to anyone else's schedule apart from my own and the kids.

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 12:14

missdemeanors · 11/06/2022 12:12

You can rant all you like about western society, feeling undervalued etc but what actually matters at an individual level is the partner you choose to have children with and the way you carve things out between you. Some people genuinely don't wish to combine paid work with parenting and that's a valid choice if your partner agrees with that, and in these cases it's likely that the SAHP will do the vast bulk of child and domestic related chores. Other people choose different set ups and want a more equal balance of earning/child/domestic responsibilities.

FWIW i was determined that I wanted a more equal balance when I partnered up, and we both always worked and shared things like night wakings - apart from when I was bf as I certainly wasn't going to wake dh up when he didn't need to be awake.

All this was years ago - my kids are adults now. Before paternity leave, transferable parental leave, year-long maternity leave... it was possible to strike a decent balance then and the legislation is in place to make this more straightforward now.

It's a shame that you seem unhappy and angry with your choices.

I’m not remotely unhappy with my choices.

OP posts:
missdemeanors · 11/06/2022 12:12

You can rant all you like about western society, feeling undervalued etc but what actually matters at an individual level is the partner you choose to have children with and the way you carve things out between you. Some people genuinely don't wish to combine paid work with parenting and that's a valid choice if your partner agrees with that, and in these cases it's likely that the SAHP will do the vast bulk of child and domestic related chores. Other people choose different set ups and want a more equal balance of earning/child/domestic responsibilities.

FWIW i was determined that I wanted a more equal balance when I partnered up, and we both always worked and shared things like night wakings - apart from when I was bf as I certainly wasn't going to wake dh up when he didn't need to be awake.

All this was years ago - my kids are adults now. Before paternity leave, transferable parental leave, year-long maternity leave... it was possible to strike a decent balance then and the legislation is in place to make this more straightforward now.

It's a shame that you seem unhappy and angry with your choices.

tigger1001 · 11/06/2022 12:12

There just isn't a right or wrong answer to this. It's family specific and what works for one family might not work for another.

It's important to work out what's best for the individuals involved. Most will come to a natural arrangement that suits their specific circumstances. No point criticising others for doing it differently to you.

I did the majority of the night time wakings when mine were babies as I breast fed each for 2 years. No point us both being up and when they were babies generally that's why they were awake - to be fed. Eldest was a dream and slept through from about 7 weeks old. Youngest was a different story and hated sleep until he was about 3. He still has nightmares now, although not often thankfully and he comes through to us but that means we are all awake. I struggle far more now with lack of sleep than I did when I was younger.

Partypoooooper · 11/06/2022 12:10

I breastfed my daughter so he wouldn't have been able to feed anyway, she barely slept for 18 months, we left the bedroom so my partner could get a full night's sleep.

He is a farmer operating heavy machinery, it would put his life or anyone else on the farm or road at risk if he was over tired.

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 12:04

LaMarschallin · 11/06/2022 11:58

ForestFae I'm afraid I disagree with you but if you're convinced that what you do is more "intense" than other jobs because you spend all your time "actively doing things" with your children then carry on believing that.
I didn't "sit around watching TV" either, but I must confess that "every minute" wasn't "a lesson". Sometimes they'd actually manage to interact with each other without my intense attention.
And since mine are grown up and happy and successful, I've got proof that my method worked for mine.
As I'm sure yours will for you and for most people, regardless of intensity and whethet every minute is spent concentrating on them or not

I still don't understand why you "rage" on behalf of other women who, from the evidence of this thread, are managing their lives pretty well and don't particularly need your intervention.
If you feel you can't work outside the home and bring up your children, don't.
If you're genuinely worried about mothers who do, campaign for better rights for them.

My own dad worked a high paid, high powered job for 40+ years. He has a lot to do with my kids now he’s retired and he’s said multiple times that he thinks it’s harder to look after them all day than it is to do his former job

Yes, I'm not surprised he says that to you.
On the evidence of this thread, he'd have his ears chewed off if he suggested anything different Grin

If they’re interacting with each other, I’m planning what to do next or setting up the next activity while also supervising because my DC get carried away very easily and will take things too far. It’s not like I don’t let them do things, they’re very independent more so than kids their own age as they’re raised climbing trees, doing chores, and spending most of the time outside, but everything we do involves some level of thought.

Because society isn’t geared up to properly support families and everything often gets dumped on women without any actual support in place. For example, it was the norm to raise kids with multiple other family members, now it’s assumed that the mother (usually) has to do everything by herself, AND work in many cases, AND keep a tidy house, AND maintain a social life etc. Employers are inflexible when it comes to families, house prices are a mess…this is just one aspect of mothers work and family lives in general being undervalued. I could rant about how western society doesn’t support the family all day, but that’s a general overview of why I get annoyed by it. It’s less about individual families diving the labour and more about general trends.

Lol! He said it without any prompting from me, and without knowing my views on this. He was referencing that when I was little, he didn’t do very much hands on child rearing because of his career and he left most of it to my mum, and how he didn’t actually appreciate how full on it was until he retired and spent lots of time with his dgc

OP posts:
anxiousmumagain · 11/06/2022 12:01

I agree with you OP re sharing the load and night wakings - I've agreed with that from the start and in my subsequent posts. DP and I do just that as we both work in equally as intense jobs where mistakes could be extremely risky.

But - I can absolutely see the other side too, whereby the flexibility within your day and the lesser degree of accountability means that you can afford to drop the odd ball, or tweak the plan, and no one gets injured or loses their household income. That isn't true of some paid jobs, and that's the point people are making I think.

Unfortunately that's true of both mine and DP's jobs and our little one (14 months) still wakes repeatedly through the night. So we are essentially winging each day between us and hoping for a miracle. 😫

LaMarschallin · 11/06/2022 11:58

ForestFae I'm afraid I disagree with you but if you're convinced that what you do is more "intense" than other jobs because you spend all your time "actively doing things" with your children then carry on believing that.
I didn't "sit around watching TV" either, but I must confess that "every minute" wasn't "a lesson". Sometimes they'd actually manage to interact with each other without my intense attention.
And since mine are grown up and happy and successful, I've got proof that my method worked for mine.
As I'm sure yours will for you and for most people, regardless of intensity and whethet every minute is spent concentrating on them or not

I still don't understand why you "rage" on behalf of other women who, from the evidence of this thread, are managing their lives pretty well and don't particularly need your intervention.
If you feel you can't work outside the home and bring up your children, don't.
If you're genuinely worried about mothers who do, campaign for better rights for them.

My own dad worked a high paid, high powered job for 40+ years. He has a lot to do with my kids now he’s retired and he’s said multiple times that he thinks it’s harder to look after them all day than it is to do his former job

Yes, I'm not surprised he says that to you.
On the evidence of this thread, he'd have his ears chewed off if he suggested anything different Grin

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 11:58

Anotherdayanotherdisappointment · 11/06/2022 11:54

@ForestFae

Which just makes this thread even more rediculous. You, 1 person, had an easy job so you think everyone else has the same.

No. Lots of people find they actually need to decent sleep to be productive at work and find parenting easier. But you think your opinion is more valid then anyone else's and are judging them for it.

I’ve done several desk jobs. I don’t think MOST desk jobs are harder than looking after several children, I think they’re hard in different ways, but I don’t think they’re so significantly difficult that the partner doing one should get to shirk all the night feeds.

OP posts:
ForestFae · 11/06/2022 11:57

anxiousmumagain · 11/06/2022 11:52

I found working when tired easier than SAHPing when tired. I can just do my job on autopilot, I can’t do that with kids

Ahh I think that's maybe the key difference then OP. I most definitely cannot do my paid job on autopilot. It involves making decisions about often quite risky situations and responding to what I'm presented with at any given moment in a timely manner in order to keep others and myself safe. My own and others' safety and well-being literally depends on me being on the ball for the vast majority of my working day, with occasional less intense moments where I can take my foot of the pedal and do the "office job" (😁) part of typing up patient records etc. but even then I need to ensure what I'm typing is accurate!

It is somewhat job specific, but I don’t think a couple of nights of broken sleep would render most people unable to do their desk job. No one is saying the working partner should do it all, just share the load somewhat

OP posts:
Anotherdayanotherdisappointment · 11/06/2022 11:54

@ForestFae

Which just makes this thread even more rediculous. You, 1 person, had an easy job so you think everyone else has the same.

No. Lots of people find they actually need to decent sleep to be productive at work and find parenting easier. But you think your opinion is more valid then anyone else's and are judging them for it.

artisanbread · 11/06/2022 11:52

I can just do my job on autopilot, I can’t do that with kids

Very job specific! DH and I are teachers. When working part-time my days at home with the DC after a bad night were infinitely preferable to a day at work with 30 of other people's DC.

anxiousmumagain · 11/06/2022 11:52

I found working when tired easier than SAHPing when tired. I can just do my job on autopilot, I can’t do that with kids

Ahh I think that's maybe the key difference then OP. I most definitely cannot do my paid job on autopilot. It involves making decisions about often quite risky situations and responding to what I'm presented with at any given moment in a timely manner in order to keep others and myself safe. My own and others' safety and well-being literally depends on me being on the ball for the vast majority of my working day, with occasional less intense moments where I can take my foot of the pedal and do the "office job" (😁) part of typing up patient records etc. but even then I need to ensure what I'm typing is accurate!

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 11:47

Anotherdayanotherdisappointment · 11/06/2022 11:44

Because if you're at work you can't nap! You can't get up late (and if its been a bad night DC will tend to sleep longer). You can't just cancel plans and have a relaxing day. You have to be 'on' for the whole time. It's been said repeatedly! If your at home you have opportunity to take it easy. At work you can't.

It's not undervaluing, it's realistic. I'm a teacher, I'm fully aware of "women's jobs" being undervalued. But it's fully factual that I could easily cope on Mat leave/when I was a SAHP with less sleep. If I get several nights of poor sleep working, I struggle. And that's the same for most people, they struggle more at work with less sleep than they did as a SAHP.

That assumes you can nap at home and that broken quality sleep doesn’t affect you, which just isn’t true for many. I found working when tired easier than SAHPing when tired. I can just do my job on autopilot, I can’t do that with kids

OP posts: