Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate it when people say “my husband/partner/boyfriend doesn’t do the night feeds because he works”

614 replies

ForestFae · 10/06/2022 16:32

Every time I see or hear this phrase, I rage. Usually said by some poor sleep deprived new mum who’s looking after the baby/ies all day long. Why is looking after a baby not considered valuable work? Why are men getting away with using this rubbish excuse?

OP posts:
ForestFae · 11/06/2022 14:52

And no, I’m not saying everyone else grows up horribly, I’m simply saying having a stable home with a SAHP can be a protective factor.

OP posts:
Forgothowmuchlhatehomeschoolin · 11/06/2022 14:51

But this is how it was...l didn't have an alarm clock telling me to go to work like he did so it seemed right that l did the night feeds?

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 14:51

5128gap · 11/06/2022 14:47

So enlighten me, how is society benefitting from your choice to be a SAHP? Don't get me wrong, I respect your right to do it for the benefit of your family, and if i were your partner, i would value it a great deal. But you call me shortsighted for not recognising the wider societal benefit. So, explain to me, what is it?

Healthy children raised to be kind and polite members of society. My children get fresh home cooked meals almost daily, they’re raised to respect animals and nature, they’re polite to others. Kids in schools and nurseries can end up learning to be absolute little terrors to each other (look how many kids get bullied and how many partake and/or stand by silently and watch, for example), they learn to just be cogs in the machine of the system. By having a SAHP, especially if attach,emf parenting is practised, kids are likely to grow up confident and well adjusted.

OP posts:
loudsnoringcat · 11/06/2022 14:49

I'm not arguing that children of working mums do not grow up as adjusted. Of course I'm not saying that. I was responding to the pp who specifically said -

"There is no benefit to wider society if a person decides to devote themselves solely to the care of their children."

Well, I am a member of this "wider society." I know that my children are better off with me than anyone I could pay to do the same. My children are also a part of 'wider society'. What did they want? It not all about turning out 'adjusted adults'. A pre-schooler has no concept of this. They are also 'wider society'. Do they care about the wider economy, or do they care about being with their mum?

Again, I am not arguing that nurseries etc are harmful to development. Nor am I saying that all women should want to SAH. Many are not cut out for it anyway. What I am saying is - the fact that most families today have to have two incomes just to have a reasonable standard of living should not be used as an argument to devalue the role of a SAHP. There is 'societal value' and then there is 'economic value.' Societal values encompasses a lot more than economics.

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 14:49

MRex · 11/06/2022 14:44

I’ve worked in several jobs, many of which were professional and certainly challenging. I found that type of work relatively easy - not saying everyone does, but for me personally, it wasn’t difficult. Challenging in some respects but it wasn’t exactly difficult - there were processes to follow and I was trained in the processes, it was just a case of finding the appropriate process for the particular task in front of me. There are only so many options.
Jobs with specific process training are not the type of roles suggested by "challenging", they are junior roles. Great if they suit you, but you should be aware that some people have roles that require them to think in-depth and respond quickly.

Lol. You have no idea what job I did or didn’t do, but keep telling yourselves “oh well she had an easy job, thats why she found it easier! Not like my complicated one!”

OP posts:
MRex · 11/06/2022 14:48

we should instead be living in small communities focused in craftsmanship, harmony with nature, permaculture and family and community relations
If that's what you want then you do that, rather than commenting on how others live. Communes like you describe exist, so off you pop: diggersanddreamers.org.uk/noticeboards/places-needing-members/

5128gap · 11/06/2022 14:47

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 14:39

This is short sighted, capitalistic and wrong. There’s value to having SAHP - and many jobs don’t have a societal value either, especially stuff like middle management. A lot of jobs are made up for the sake of jobs. This is getting off topic, but modern society is just a neoliberal hellhole designed to exploit labour out of people - we should instead be living in small communities focused in craftsmanship, harmony with nature, permaculture and family and community relations. Instead everyone is divorced from nature, chasing materialism and the family and community support is gone (for most people). It’s a terrible societal structure.

So enlighten me, how is society benefitting from your choice to be a SAHP? Don't get me wrong, I respect your right to do it for the benefit of your family, and if i were your partner, i would value it a great deal. But you call me shortsighted for not recognising the wider societal benefit. So, explain to me, what is it?

MRex · 11/06/2022 14:44

I’ve worked in several jobs, many of which were professional and certainly challenging. I found that type of work relatively easy - not saying everyone does, but for me personally, it wasn’t difficult. Challenging in some respects but it wasn’t exactly difficult - there were processes to follow and I was trained in the processes, it was just a case of finding the appropriate process for the particular task in front of me. There are only so many options.
Jobs with specific process training are not the type of roles suggested by "challenging", they are junior roles. Great if they suit you, but you should be aware that some people have roles that require them to think in-depth and respond quickly.

missdemeanors · 11/06/2022 14:43

What's the value of a SAHP to wider society?

5128gap · 11/06/2022 14:43

loudsnoringcat · 11/06/2022 14:21

There is a 'societal benefit' to having a SAHP if you believe young children will generally benefit from spending the majority of their waking hours with a parent, who loves them and is instinctively tuned into them, rather than someone who is paid to do it. It may not be a capitalist benefit, but capitalists don't generally look at things from the perspective if those with the least voice in society - ie, children. Don't confuse 'societal benefit' with 'capitalist benefit.' Also, dint assume that everything in 'society' has a financial price attached to it .

Personally I'm not convinced of the especial benefit to society of that model of child rearing, no. What is the evidence to support that belief?
As a member of society, a SAHP raising their child has no positive impact on my life. A working parent driving my bus, treating my medical condition or advising me on my pension does.
If I were the OPs husband, I would value her work, as I did my own partners SAH work, but I'm genuinely not sure why wider society should be expected to.

Remaker · 11/06/2022 14:42

I think it’s reasonable to share the load but unreasonable for the parent who isn’t working to expect the parent who is working to share all the night wakings. When I was on mat leave I’d go to bed around 9, DH would stay up and do a late feed around 11pm, then he’d go to bed and I’d handle any wakings between 12-6. He’d look after the baby between around 6-8 and then go to work. So he’d get a solid block of sleep and I would have had a decent amount just more broken. But I was able to sloth around in my pjs all day and focus only on the baby if it was a difficult day whereas DH had to be looking presentable and able to string a sentence together.

Just let people make their own decisions- there’s not always a right and wrong way when raising kids.

TheKeatingFive · 11/06/2022 14:41

I think the OP has a point. A balance should be found.

I switch off a bit from the whole 'being a SAHP is so much harder' line. I certainly didn't find that myself. However that doesn't mean it's ok to be on your knees with tiredness doing it, because the other parent goes to work. Sleeping while the children sleep is obviously horseshit, very few are able to.

I know someone who crashed the car with two small children in it as a result of sleep deprivation. Thankfully they were ok, but it shows you what can happen.

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 14:39

5128gap · 11/06/2022 14:12

Of course society values paid work more highly than domestic work. Paid work benefits society as a whole, domestic work only the individual family unit. There is no benefit to wider society if a person decides to devote themselves solely to the care of their children.
Paid work often requires years of education and training, or a particular talent or skill set that people not in that work may need, but not have. Childcare and domestic duties are carried out by most of us at some point, with few being incapable of them.
As with any work, the more specialist skills required and the more people require that work, generally, the greater its value at a societal level. I can't see that changing. But given the work is only done for the benefit of the family unit, as long as its valued there, it shouldn't really matter.

This is short sighted, capitalistic and wrong. There’s value to having SAHP - and many jobs don’t have a societal value either, especially stuff like middle management. A lot of jobs are made up for the sake of jobs. This is getting off topic, but modern society is just a neoliberal hellhole designed to exploit labour out of people - we should instead be living in small communities focused in craftsmanship, harmony with nature, permaculture and family and community relations. Instead everyone is divorced from nature, chasing materialism and the family and community support is gone (for most people). It’s a terrible societal structure.

OP posts:
ForestFae · 11/06/2022 14:36

Anotherdayanotherdisappointment · 11/06/2022 14:17

But not doing night time wakings doesn't mean partners aren't pulling their weight. I agree with pp, you lack the emotional intelligence to see other people's perspectives.

My dh only stated sharing night times once I went back to work, other then the odd time it was a particularly awful night. He has always done the majority of the housework though, and now I am working full time, all I do is the morning school run and cook. He does everything else.

So I really don't need your pity thanks. If anything, I pity someone so unfulfilled they need to start a thread on social media about how much they hate something that they know nothing about and has zero impact on their life. And you're in denial if you believe your happy with your choices. Happy people don't start these type of judgmental posts either.

Lol. If it helps you sleep at night (Grin) to believe I’m unhappy, go ahead. I actually couldn’t be happier with my life, wouldn’t change a thing and I thank the universe every day that I’ve been lucky enough to live the life I wish. But tell yourself whatever you need.

OP posts:
Ohrwurm · 11/06/2022 14:35

I think you're being ridiculous to generalise this. Is mum struggling/needing help and the husband isn't helping because he's working? Yeah that's crap. But I bet, DS only wanted me at night (at 23 months, still does), and when DH tried to help, he would scream like we were torturing him, and everyone would be awake anyway. So I ended up doing all the nights and cosleeping and breastfeeding back to sleep. There are however other ways for them to help. In the early days, I was thirsty all the time so DH would have his phone on loud in the night and if I needed something and didn't want to wake the baby, DH would bring me water etc. He used to get up on the nights sometimes if he heard us awake just to keep us company.
If I just told someone yeah I do all the nights cause DH works, you'd think the same but you have no idea about our personal circumstances, how our baby is and how else DH supports me. So I think your being quite judgemental.

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 14:35

missdemeanors · 11/06/2022 14:23

@5128gap great post.

To expand on this point of what society values, it's also in the interests of wider society to have children brought up with good values, who'll grow up to be productive members of society. But that can be done (or not done!) by parents who WOH or who SAH. There is no intrinsic value of having a SAHP other than the benefit for that particular family unit.

And to make it clear, I'm not minimising being a SAHP - it's an entirely valid choice provided both parents are happy with it. But it does make you question how content with their choices people are when they complain about them....

I’m not complaining about my choices - my DH did the night.

OP posts:
missdemeanors · 11/06/2022 14:29

@loudsnoringcat - it's in the interests of children to grow into well adjusted positive members of society - and obviously that's a benefit to society as a whole too.

You simply cannot extrapolate from that fact that it's better to have a SAHP. It may be the right thing for family units on an individual basis but that's all you can say.

WOHP have been around a long while... many of todays adults were raised by WOHP, my own 3 adult children included. The fact is, raising children well is dependent on a huge range of factors, not simply whether a parent is with them all day.

missdemeanors · 11/06/2022 14:23

@5128gap great post.

To expand on this point of what society values, it's also in the interests of wider society to have children brought up with good values, who'll grow up to be productive members of society. But that can be done (or not done!) by parents who WOH or who SAH. There is no intrinsic value of having a SAHP other than the benefit for that particular family unit.

And to make it clear, I'm not minimising being a SAHP - it's an entirely valid choice provided both parents are happy with it. But it does make you question how content with their choices people are when they complain about them....

loudsnoringcat · 11/06/2022 14:21

There is a 'societal benefit' to having a SAHP if you believe young children will generally benefit from spending the majority of their waking hours with a parent, who loves them and is instinctively tuned into them, rather than someone who is paid to do it. It may not be a capitalist benefit, but capitalists don't generally look at things from the perspective if those with the least voice in society - ie, children. Don't confuse 'societal benefit' with 'capitalist benefit.' Also, dint assume that everything in 'society' has a financial price attached to it .

Anotherdayanotherdisappointment · 11/06/2022 14:17

But not doing night time wakings doesn't mean partners aren't pulling their weight. I agree with pp, you lack the emotional intelligence to see other people's perspectives.

My dh only stated sharing night times once I went back to work, other then the odd time it was a particularly awful night. He has always done the majority of the housework though, and now I am working full time, all I do is the morning school run and cook. He does everything else.

So I really don't need your pity thanks. If anything, I pity someone so unfulfilled they need to start a thread on social media about how much they hate something that they know nothing about and has zero impact on their life. And you're in denial if you believe your happy with your choices. Happy people don't start these type of judgmental posts either.

missdemeanors · 11/06/2022 14:16

but you can’t say that society values paid work and domestic work the same

And how do you propose 'society' would show the worth of domestic work? Surely you can't be proposing wages for being at home?!

Surely the value of being at home is shown by your partner agreeing to be the sole earner to finance that choice and because it's something you both believe in, and which (presumably!) the SAHP gets enjoyment from?

5128gap · 11/06/2022 14:12

Of course society values paid work more highly than domestic work. Paid work benefits society as a whole, domestic work only the individual family unit. There is no benefit to wider society if a person decides to devote themselves solely to the care of their children.
Paid work often requires years of education and training, or a particular talent or skill set that people not in that work may need, but not have. Childcare and domestic duties are carried out by most of us at some point, with few being incapable of them.
As with any work, the more specialist skills required and the more people require that work, generally, the greater its value at a societal level. I can't see that changing. But given the work is only done for the benefit of the family unit, as long as its valued there, it shouldn't really matter.

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 13:43

I think sleep is a basic wellbeing/health issue and I don't think whether you work or not makes you less entitled to it. Being a SAHM or on mat leave doesn't mean you should be a zombie while your DH gets a full 8 hours.

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

OP posts:
ForestFae · 11/06/2022 13:42

OverCCCs · 11/06/2022 13:32

Your last few posts have been enlightening, OP. It sounds like you never held a particularly intellectually challenging job or anything that required much beyond repetitive tasks, and you struggle to conceptualize “desk” roles that require more active engagement and a clear, sharp mind.

You also apparently struggle to comprehend that not everyone has the same approach to being a SAHM that you do (an approach which appears to lead to you being consistently burned out).

Essentially—and I say this as an observation, not to be mean—you come off as lacking in emotional intelligence in regards to social awareness, perspective taking, and empathy. I hope your children have the opportunity to see those important skills modeled from someone.

Perspective taking would make it clear why a SAHP would in many cases take night feedings, and, indeed, explain a major part of why maternity leave exists at all (ie to give the mother time to laze about during the day after a broken night’s sleep).

I’ve worked in several jobs, many of which were professional and certainly challenging. I found that type of work relatively easy - not saying everyone does, but for me personally, it wasn’t difficult. Challenging in some respects but it wasn’t exactly difficult - there were processes to follow and I was trained in the processes, it was just a case of finding the appropriate process for the particular task in front of me. There are only so many options.

I’m also not consistently burned out - I found it very challenging during the baby period, now they’re older it’s enjoyable. It’s still intense, of course it is, but I wouldn’t describe myself as being constantly burned out.

You’re incorrect about that - my empathy is with the women who have partners who don’t pull their weight. Yes some women may be happy with the arrangement as some have said here, and that’s fine, but you can’t say that society values paid work and domestic work the same and it’s always assumed domestic work is easy when it’s often just as challenging, if not more so, than paid work. That doesn’t make it less enjoyable, rewarding or worthwhile, however.

I’d argue its people who say “sleep in the day” that lack the ability to see perspectives because it’s a huge assumption that the baby sleeps well, that the SAHP doesn’t have other children, or commitments, or doctors appointments, caring responsibilities etc. God forbid they just don’t want to feel like a zombie for years?!

OP posts:
Classicblunder · 11/06/2022 13:39

I think sleep is a basic wellbeing/health issue and I don't think whether you work or not makes you less entitled to it. Being a SAHM or on mat leave doesn't mean you should be a zombie while your DH gets a full 8 hours.

FWIW, I find working easier and less demanding than looking after under 5s all day - but I recognise that people, children and jobs all differ. My job is intellectually challenging but I am quite senior so I can set my own schedule and no one is monitoring my every move. My kids are quite intense and absolutely do monitor my every move! I also can't "just take it easy" when I have both under 5s with me, they don't get that concept, it's more stressful to try than to keep them on the move.