Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate it when people say “my husband/partner/boyfriend doesn’t do the night feeds because he works”

614 replies

ForestFae · 10/06/2022 16:32

Every time I see or hear this phrase, I rage. Usually said by some poor sleep deprived new mum who’s looking after the baby/ies all day long. Why is looking after a baby not considered valuable work? Why are men getting away with using this rubbish excuse?

OP posts:
Anotherdayanotherdisappointment · 11/06/2022 16:14

Being a SAHP has nothing to do with raising a child well. Plenty of useless SAHPs raising 'little terrors' as you put it. Plenty of amazing WOHPs raising polite, well rounded children.

Cameleongirl · 11/06/2022 15:59

@missdemeanors of course they do, that why this debate is getting boring. There isn’t a “right” answer.

missdemeanors · 11/06/2022 15:50

I think most people just get on an live their life in a way which suits their own family actually!

And of course it's not a simple binary choice where one course of action means happy family and another way would be disastrous.

I chose to keep working when I became a parent, as did my dh, but I've no doubt my kids would be just as happy and well adjusted as adults if Dh or I had been home too.

Cameleongirl · 11/06/2022 15:49

5128gap · 11/06/2022 15:33

Thats not quite the point though. The SAHP is contributing to society via their role as a volunteer. Its the volunteering that is the contribution not the parenting. If you don't subscribe to the view that having a SAHP is essential for raising well adjusted future citizens, which I don't, that still doesn't explain how the role of SAHP benefits society.

@5128gap The flexibility that the role provides, perhaps? That could be applied to other roles, of course, essentially anything that isn’t full-time and during regular business hours. I’ve lost interest in this debate, tbh, people should do what suits them.

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 15:48

LuckySantangelo35 · 11/06/2022 15:47

@ForestFae

you can’t nap at work.

Therefore YABU

HTH

Not everyone can nap at home. I couldn’t.

OP posts:
LuckySantangelo35 · 11/06/2022 15:47

@ForestFae

you can’t nap at work.

Therefore YABU

HTH

LuckySantangelo35 · 11/06/2022 15:46

@ForestFae

you can’t nap at work.

Therefore YABU

HTH

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 15:37

5128gap · 11/06/2022 15:33

Thats not quite the point though. The SAHP is contributing to society via their role as a volunteer. Its the volunteering that is the contribution not the parenting. If you don't subscribe to the view that having a SAHP is essential for raising well adjusted future citizens, which I don't, that still doesn't explain how the role of SAHP benefits society.

It’s one way to ensure kids are raised well. Is it the only way? No. I’d argue it’s one of the better ways, which is why I chose it, but people tend to bristle when you say you chose your choices because you think they’re the best option.

OP posts:
5128gap · 11/06/2022 15:33

Cameleongirl · 11/06/2022 15:10

@missdemeanors i know that working and retired people can also volunteer, I do some myself! But, SAHPs can ( and in my area, do) massively contribute to wider society this way too. A new park is being created near us, 18 acres of facilities for the general public. The land was was purchased by an environmental organization for several million and I know the people involved- hours and hours of meetings with the sellers, garnering support from politician, local organisations, and private donors, multiple grant applications, etc. The main instigator is a SAHM with a business background!

Thats not quite the point though. The SAHP is contributing to society via their role as a volunteer. Its the volunteering that is the contribution not the parenting. If you don't subscribe to the view that having a SAHP is essential for raising well adjusted future citizens, which I don't, that still doesn't explain how the role of SAHP benefits society.

loudsnoringcat · 11/06/2022 15:20

I think flexibility and the ability to make personal choice is the the most important indicator of 'societal benefit' because there is no benefit to a miserable society in which economics take precedence over all else and this is all people can comprehend. It's about quality of life and freedom to make choices that suit you and your family. This will mean different things for differnt people, obviously.

These days, we are all pulled in so many different directions and it's about finding the right balance. Everything we do has 'value.' Take children out of the equation. Supposing you are a carer for a disabled or elderly relative. Yes, you could hire someone else to do the care visits. Then it's a 'proper job' right - so it would have 'societal value' according to the argument above. But I bet it would be your visit that the disabled or elderly relative would value more. And these people are part of 'wider society.' They matter as much as anyone else. I bet they value their family member who visits more than any employer values that same individual in the workplace.

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 15:15

missdemeanors · 11/06/2022 15:12

You could equally say many parents would benefit from working but can't afford childcare...

And anyway, I thought it was being at home that left mums frazzled and exhausted, not working! Grin

Would they? Why? Having one person working and one to manage the domestic is, for most people, more efficient than having two people working and not having adequate time to devote to the domestic sphere. Society should be less about consumerism but people are unfortunately materialistic.

Being a SAHP is difficult when they’re newborns, but I think you’re getting the wrong end of the stick if you think I’m saying it leaves you frazzled and exhausted. It would if you never got any sleep - which is why nights shouldqnt be solely left to the SAHP

OP posts:
missdemeanors · 11/06/2022 15:12

You could equally say many parents would benefit from working but can't afford childcare...

And anyway, I thought it was being at home that left mums frazzled and exhausted, not working! Grin

Cameleongirl · 11/06/2022 15:12

Let’s agree that one size doesn’t fit all then and finish the debate. Phew! 🤣

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 15:11

missdemeanors · 11/06/2022 15:07

Yes, a SAHP is valuable to the family unit (if both parents agree!) I've agreed that point all along. It's being a GOOD a parent which has the wider societal value... thankfully that's not a one size fits all

Yes there isn’t a one size fits all, but I think a lot of families would benefit from being able to have one parent stay home. So many want to but can’t afford it, which I think is a shame. I don’t think kids benefit from parents being consistently exhausted and stressed from work.

OP posts:
Cameleongirl · 11/06/2022 15:10

@missdemeanors i know that working and retired people can also volunteer, I do some myself! But, SAHPs can ( and in my area, do) massively contribute to wider society this way too. A new park is being created near us, 18 acres of facilities for the general public. The land was was purchased by an environmental organization for several million and I know the people involved- hours and hours of meetings with the sellers, garnering support from politician, local organisations, and private donors, multiple grant applications, etc. The main instigator is a SAHM with a business background!

missdemeanors · 11/06/2022 15:07

Yes, a SAHP is valuable to the family unit (if both parents agree!) I've agreed that point all along. It's being a GOOD a parent which has the wider societal value... thankfully that's not a one size fits all

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 15:07

missdemeanors · 11/06/2022 15:04

@Cameleongirl tbh It sits uncomfortably with me that so many organisations rely on volunteers... but that's a whole other thread! But you certainly don't need to be a SAHP to do all those things you mention- in fact I and many of my working mum friends were stalwarts of the PTA! And of course many older retired or semi retired people do a lot of volunteering too

You don’t need to be, but being a SAHP usually gives you more flexibility with when you can do those roles.

OP posts:
missdemeanors · 11/06/2022 15:04

@Cameleongirl tbh It sits uncomfortably with me that so many organisations rely on volunteers... but that's a whole other thread! But you certainly don't need to be a SAHP to do all those things you mention- in fact I and many of my working mum friends were stalwarts of the PTA! And of course many older retired or semi retired people do a lot of volunteering too

PinkPiranha11 · 11/06/2022 15:03

I did all the night feeds because I was bf and there was literally nothing my DH could do. Plus he’d just started a business. I take the view there’s no point both of us being knackered. I was on Mat leave. There are many, many things I resent my DH for in terms of not pulling his weight, but that isn’t one of them.

JustFrustrated · 11/06/2022 15:01

bellamountain · 10/06/2022 16:35

It rages me too, only way it can feasibly be excused is if said husband is up at 5am and working on a building site / operating dangerous machinery every day. Office jobs are not a good enough reason.

That depends on the "office job"

You don't want a sleep deprived designer drawing the electrical schematics of a hospital.

Cause that's an office job FFS.

Not all office jobs are just sitting at a computer pressing a button with no outcome.

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 15:01

missdemeanors · 11/06/2022 14:58

Thanks for confirming my point @ForestFae, that it's about how children are raised - whether they are loved, stimulated, given healthy meals, taught good manners etc- which matters.

And the fact is, that can be done (or not) with one or both parents working. If in your own particular circumstances you felt that could only happen with you being home then that's fine. The rest of us aren't you.

Of course. People are free to make their own choices. That doesn’t mean the role of a SAHP isn’t valuable just because it can be outsourced. Many things can be outsourced, they’re still valuable.

OP posts:
DorritLittle · 11/06/2022 15:00

My DH never did any night feeds because his job involved overnight overtime (on call) and I breastfed so he couldn't anyway m. But he is very helpful in other ways. More helpful than I often am actually

Cameleongirl · 11/06/2022 15:00

missdemeanors · 11/06/2022 14:43

What's the value of a SAHP to wider society?

I’m not a SAHP but I know a handful and the main way they benefit can wider society is through volunteering on a major scale, because they have the time and flexibility.

The ones I know do a huge amount of fundraising for local schools and neighbourhoods. They use their professional backgrounds and flexibility to meet with people who can make a difference, e.g., local politicians and private individuals who could make substantial donations , to ask for their support for projects such as creating new sports facilities, restoring neglected buildings, etc. They write grant applications that take hours ( grant writing is part of my job so I know how long they can take😂). They’re also the people who volunteer at school and organize the fetes as they’ve got the time. They coach sports teams, they do meals on wheels deliveries, they volunteer at animal charities and work at charity shops. And the list goes on.

Tbh, I don’t know any SAHP who “only” look after their children. Perhaps it’s just the people I happen to know as I’m keen on community involvement so I meet likeminded people? Anyway, volunteering is the area where I personally believe SAHP’s really contribute to wider society. I’m sure there are others.

missdemeanors · 11/06/2022 14:58

Thanks for confirming my point @ForestFae, that it's about how children are raised - whether they are loved, stimulated, given healthy meals, taught good manners etc- which matters.

And the fact is, that can be done (or not) with one or both parents working. If in your own particular circumstances you felt that could only happen with you being home then that's fine. The rest of us aren't you.

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 14:53

loudsnoringcat · 11/06/2022 14:49

I'm not arguing that children of working mums do not grow up as adjusted. Of course I'm not saying that. I was responding to the pp who specifically said -

"There is no benefit to wider society if a person decides to devote themselves solely to the care of their children."

Well, I am a member of this "wider society." I know that my children are better off with me than anyone I could pay to do the same. My children are also a part of 'wider society'. What did they want? It not all about turning out 'adjusted adults'. A pre-schooler has no concept of this. They are also 'wider society'. Do they care about the wider economy, or do they care about being with their mum?

Again, I am not arguing that nurseries etc are harmful to development. Nor am I saying that all women should want to SAH. Many are not cut out for it anyway. What I am saying is - the fact that most families today have to have two incomes just to have a reasonable standard of living should not be used as an argument to devalue the role of a SAHP. There is 'societal value' and then there is 'economic value.' Societal values encompasses a lot more than economics.

You said this better than I did.

OP posts: