Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate it when people say “my husband/partner/boyfriend doesn’t do the night feeds because he works”

614 replies

ForestFae · 10/06/2022 16:32

Every time I see or hear this phrase, I rage. Usually said by some poor sleep deprived new mum who’s looking after the baby/ies all day long. Why is looking after a baby not considered valuable work? Why are men getting away with using this rubbish excuse?

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 11/06/2022 00:15

It's weird because babies don't all miraculously sleep all night by the time the mum returns to work so many people manage to go to work after a broken night.

So.what happens then?

Yes exactly I was going to say this!

I was very broken by having to do all of the night feeds with mine.

saraclara · 10/06/2022 23:58

ForestFae · 10/06/2022 23:17

Erm no, it’s about men assuming they don’t have to do an equal share of the unsavoury side of parenting, like night wakings.

Who's saying that it's men assuming they don't have to do it?

My DH used to get up to bring our baby to me to be BF in the night, because my carpal tunnel syndrome meant it was hard for me to get her out of the cot. But as soon as I could do it, I told him to stay in bed. For the reasons that several of us have mentioned and which you haven't responded to.
His work meant that he was accountable to many people. He simply couldn't take ten minutes down time if he got a wave of tiredness.
My SAHM job meant that I could switch my brain off, and simply not do things I planned if I was too tired. It made sense to me that he should get the sleep. Especially as I didn't have to get up at 6:30 am. More often than not, the more broken the night, the longer the baby would sleep. So I could often stay in bed until 9 and he'd already been at work for an hour and a half.

As I've said before, being a SAHM is hard work. But it's disingenuous to claim that it's harder than getting up early to get to work on time, where you're constantly 'on' and being monitored and accountable to others. Being a SAHM was the only time when I was my own boss, and that was the best bit.

Cameleongirl · 10/06/2022 23:58

Haven’t RTFT. I have a different take as I found it easier to handle the night feeds and changes by myself. I even suggested that DH sleep in the spare room for the first few weeks so he didn’t try to help! Even when he slept in our room again, I liked to take the baby downstairs and do everything there- I saw some truly rubbish TV while bfing at 3a.m.!

He was quite willing to help out, but I really enjoyed that night time alone with my babies, tbh, it was special. I remember it clearly, even though the babies are teenagers now. 😂

Topgub · 10/06/2022 23:49

@ForestFae

Nope.

I just think you're spending too long doing the dishes. You're doing what I do in more time. The dishes are still clean. and I've done the hoovering. And you've just done the dishes

There's no difference to what you're doing. It's not better. As you keep saying. Just different. But my way is double the work

I dont have a chip , no reason to or think I'm hard done to.

I enjoy my work and wouldnt not work even if you paid me.

I also don't 'outsource'

My kids have 2 parents and a GM. No need to outsource

Thinkbiglittleone · 10/06/2022 23:49

I don't really get the rage as if it works for their family, why not.

I BF our DS and it didn't make any sense for DH to get up as well.

alphons · 10/06/2022 23:45

There will be no difference in outcome

This I agree with. None of this matters to the child in the long run. In fact, once the child is fed, clothed, loved, kept safe, emotionally nurtured somewhat and educated, very little of what we do makes much of an impact in the long run. Our children will be who they will be. They’ll leave us behind and get on with their lives, as they should (and as I venture all of us are).

These things matter to the parents. It’s not about the kids. It’s about the longevity of a partnership, the quality of the relationship, careers, outcomes for the parents.

ForestFae · 10/06/2022 23:38

Topgub · 10/06/2022 23:36

@ForestFae

I am. Doing 2 things is harder than doing 1 thing. Doing the dishes and the hoovering is more work than just doing the dishes.

I'm not insulted. Why would I be? I dont think your way is better. I think mine is

🤷‍♀️

But in that analogy, you’d only be doing half the dishes since you spent the other half of your time hoovering. You cannot have more hours in the day. There are only 24. It you spend x amount of them working, that’s time you’re not spending with your kids - which is okay, as I’ve said repeatedly - but don’t argue it’s the same amount of work with your kids, it’s just not.

You clearly have a chip on your shoulder. You think you’re more hard done by because you work, even though while working you outsource the part of the role that SAHMs do all the time.

OP posts:
Topgub · 10/06/2022 23:36

@ForestFae

I am. Doing 2 things is harder than doing 1 thing. Doing the dishes and the hoovering is more work than just doing the dishes.

I'm not insulted. Why would I be? I dont think your way is better. I think mine is

🤷‍♀️

ForestFae · 10/06/2022 23:35

Blossomtoes · 10/06/2022 23:34

I’m sure you value the way you bring up your kids. I value the way I bring up mine. We have the freedom to do so.

And yet you start a thread criticising other people’s parenting decisions.

I’m criticising the fact many men seem to think their job is superior to the job women do of raising their children, and how many men seem to have kids without thinking they should actually do anything. The bar for men is low.

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 10/06/2022 23:34

I’m sure you value the way you bring up your kids. I value the way I bring up mine. We have the freedom to do so.

And yet you start a thread criticising other people’s parenting decisions.

ForestFae · 10/06/2022 23:33

no one is asking these blokes to stay up all night. Nor asking them to do it every night. It is about them getting up in night a couple of times, maybe 2- 3 times per week to spread the pain for both parents. Who the hell would want to live with a chronically sleep deprived wife anyway? Not a recipe for a harmonious and stress free home life.

exactly!

OP posts:
ForestFae · 10/06/2022 23:32

Topgub · 10/06/2022 23:29

@ForestFae

I'm not upset. I dont think you're doing anything I'm not.

Its you who seems upset that I'm doing more work than you are.

Your way might be different but it's not better.

There will be no difference in outcome.

On the being away from you front, I find it a bit sad that you dont envision your kids being away from you on a regular basis until they are adult.

My kids go on camps and sleep overs. They have a great time. Its so good for them to spend time with their peers away from their parents

You’re not. You have the same amount of time as I do. You’re splitting in between two things, I’m spending it on one thing. You don’t however, have more hours than I do.

Everyone chooses what they personally think is better for their own family. That’s not an insult to people who choose a different way.

Thats nice for your kids. I personally don’t let my kids stay at homes of people who aren’t family. Neither is right or wrong, it’s a personal choice.

OP posts:
EmilyBolton · 10/06/2022 23:31

Blossomtoes · 10/06/2022 16:45

Of course they are. Any job that requires high levels of concentration and/or alertness need sleep. Do you want your pension fund managed by someone who’s half asleep? Or your prescription filled by someone who can’t concentrate? Or to drive your children to school with other drivers half asleep behind the wheel?

Shit, wait till you see what menopause does to you…trying to make senior level decisions on around 4 hours sleep combined with day time brain fog 🤦‍♀️ Or all those pale stale male pension fund managers with sleep apnea who only use their CPAP for requisite min 6 hours ( in other words only get 6 hours of proper sleep) , or people who are just plain insomniacs, or travelling with jet lag and strange hotel beds

by your rules the country would grind to a halt pretty quickly or employment would be restricted to 25-40 year old childless, healthy people who can sleep anywhere.

once you get to menopause I suspect most women don’t get more than 5 hours on a good night of unbroken sleep in one hit…for me I can be awake for 2-3 hours in middle of night. As men and women get older we all find we wake to take a wee…

ah, the naïve joys of youth when you’d go to bed and sleep 8 hours - they are a short lived luxury for most.

Im quite surprised how many days I could go on 4 hours sleep per night between travelling abroad, menopause, jetlag - I’d go 3 nights in a row very effectively , after a 4th night I’d know it and have to consciously stay active, and then usually would crash that night anyway. It only became very difficult after a 5th crap night which was rare. what I could not cope with was 3-4 hours sleep EVERY night, recovering from c-section, trying to breast feed a baby who would take an hour to feed, sleep maybe 2 hours, then want feeding again, and with PND…nope…that’s not anything short of torture.

so reckon a father doing maybe one shift or 2 a week on night duty is not going to cause most men a complete breakdown in ability to function. If they go to bed with baby they’ll still get 6-8 hours sleep anyway- broken, but still sleep. A lot of those men probably have done that a few years before when they were single lads out on the town.

no one is asking these blokes to stay up all night. Nor asking them to do it every night. It is about them getting up in night a couple of times, maybe 2- 3 times per week to spread the pain for both parents. Who the hell would want to live with a chronically sleep deprived wife anyway? Not a recipe for a harmonious and stress free home life.

Topgub · 10/06/2022 23:29

@ForestFae

I'm not upset. I dont think you're doing anything I'm not.

Its you who seems upset that I'm doing more work than you are.

Your way might be different but it's not better.

There will be no difference in outcome.

On the being away from you front, I find it a bit sad that you dont envision your kids being away from you on a regular basis until they are adult.

My kids go on camps and sleep overs. They have a great time. Its so good for them to spend time with their peers away from their parents

ForestFae · 10/06/2022 23:17

TheHateIsNotGood · 10/06/2022 23:15

YABU for assuming there is even someone else around to share any 'baby duties' - lots and lots of people do it all on their own, although the majority have some help, from their DP or someone else.

Rage on about nothing my dear, it's not men that get away with this crap - it's more about women who're gaining ground atop the scrapheap not assisting those below them, possibly because their own 'footing' is on thin ground.

It's not by braying about your own 'wonderfulness' that assists the lot of Women.

Erm no, it’s about men assuming they don’t have to do an equal share of the unsavoury side of parenting, like night wakings.

OP posts:
TheHateIsNotGood · 10/06/2022 23:15

YABU for assuming there is even someone else around to share any 'baby duties' - lots and lots of people do it all on their own, although the majority have some help, from their DP or someone else.

Rage on about nothing my dear, it's not men that get away with this crap - it's more about women who're gaining ground atop the scrapheap not assisting those below them, possibly because their own 'footing' is on thin ground.

It's not by braying about your own 'wonderfulness' that assists the lot of Women.

Porcupineintherough · 10/06/2022 23:09

Sadly dh remained unable to breastfeed the whole time we had babies so night wakings were all mine. They didn't need settling (the boob did that) and I didn't do nappies at night (unless dirty, once in a blue moon) so he had little to offer. He did get to get up with them at 5.30am though because that's when the started the day.

Having been both a SAHM and a full time working mum with babies I found it about 1,000x easier to be knackered and looking after kids, than knackered and at work. At work I had to think and concentrate, sticking pepper pig on or going to the park didn't cut it.

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/06/2022 23:03

It's a reason why I'll probably bottle feed from the get go. I want it to be as equal as possible from the start and refuse to do all of the night feeds as well as the fact I'll have a short maternity leave and don't fancy expressing but we'll see.

Fedupsotired · 10/06/2022 22:55

ClinicallyProven · 10/06/2022 16:42

So you'd love it if your bus driver/doctor/gas man/child's teacher was sleep deprived because his child's mother insisted her role at home was just as important as his?

Of course her role is important, but you can doze in front of the tv etc when you're at home with a baby.

DH took his turn at weekends and he did the last feed at night so I could have an early night, but night feeds were mine during the week. Apart from the danger to his customers, working sleep deprived was a risk to his safety.

Exactly this. DH on a blue light run after no sleep whilst I'm on maternity leave. It's a no brainer 🙄. There are other ways to help!

ForestFae · 10/06/2022 22:52

Topgub · 10/06/2022 21:45

@ForestFae

What gives it value? Your way? What do you think you're achieving that wp aren't?

They might not be out 40 hours a week now but they soon will be.

Can't keep them at home for ever

This is getting ridiculous. You want me to write a whole manifesto justifying why I personally believe the way I raise my children is the best way for them, because you clearly feel upset by people choosing a different system to you.

when will they be out for 40 hours? When they’re at university maybe? Sure. Prior to that I highly doubt it.

OP posts:
Thebeastofsleep · 10/06/2022 22:18

Ledkr · 10/06/2022 16:41

It's weird because babies don't all miraculously sleep all night by the time the mum returns to work so many people manage to go to work after a broken night.
So.what happens then?

We then night weaned (breastfed) and took night wakings in turn.

saraclara · 10/06/2022 22:09

ForestFae · 10/06/2022 17:37

It’s not so much I care what individual couples do rather the insinuation that “women’s work”, looking after kids all day, is somehow inferior, less important or less valuable than men’s. Basically that women’s needs come second.

It's not inferior. But it is far more flexible than most paid work. You're your own boss. If you're not able to do what you planned to do because your knackered after a bad night, you just don't do it. It can wait. You won't have a boss breathing down your neck, you won't lose a contract or miss a sale, you'll not risk a deadline and piss off a colleague or a customer, you won't lose control of your class, you don't risk losing your job.

I've done both. Being a sahm was hard, but I was accountable to no-one and that makes a HUGE difference.

5128gap · 10/06/2022 21:58

anxiousmumagain · 10/06/2022 21:55

@5128gap

Ah ok, thanks for clarifying. I suppose I meant there are fewer hours left of the day if you're a working parent, so how do you achieve the same as a parent who is at home FT? But I see what you're saying - the way you achieve that is you have to be more efficient in the little time you have left, and leisure time gets dropped etc.

I haven't done both so can't compare - I've only ever been a FT working parent (apart from 1 year on maternity leave).

I suppose I was just relating to the OP's point about there being the same number of hours across the day regardless, for both SAHP and working parents. But I guess from what you're saying, it's not just the number of hours that matter necessarily, it's about the intensity of the work - ie. if you're having to cram a load of tasks into a shorter amount of time after work, it feels like harder work because you're trying to achieve the same output you would if you were at home FT, but you're doing that across fewer hours?? Which makes sense. I think. ? 🤣

Absolutely. You've summarised exactly what I was trying to say.

anxiousmumagain · 10/06/2022 21:55

@5128gap

Ah ok, thanks for clarifying. I suppose I meant there are fewer hours left of the day if you're a working parent, so how do you achieve the same as a parent who is at home FT? But I see what you're saying - the way you achieve that is you have to be more efficient in the little time you have left, and leisure time gets dropped etc.

I haven't done both so can't compare - I've only ever been a FT working parent (apart from 1 year on maternity leave).

I suppose I was just relating to the OP's point about there being the same number of hours across the day regardless, for both SAHP and working parents. But I guess from what you're saying, it's not just the number of hours that matter necessarily, it's about the intensity of the work - ie. if you're having to cram a load of tasks into a shorter amount of time after work, it feels like harder work because you're trying to achieve the same output you would if you were at home FT, but you're doing that across fewer hours?? Which makes sense. I think. ? 🤣

EllaDuggee · 10/06/2022 21:49

I agree with you OP. Yes if you are breastfeeding obviously it has to be the woman , and I did EBF my second. Occassionally I couldn't get her back to sleep though and then if I had been struggling for a while I would wake DH and ask him to help and he would. And you can't always sleep in the day, only if you've got one baby, if there's an older toddler and you don't manage to coordinate nàptimes you won't get the chance. My youngest would only sleep for 30 minutes so by the time I had got the toddler off the baby would be awake again 15 minutes later. I appreciate you can't get sacked for being tired at home but they do still need your attention anď input, and to go out and do activities ( if you have a toddler definitely) and if you're too knackered to do anything other than sit on the sofa with the TV on they won't get the best from you. Looking aftèr the children well is just as important as working, it's not one versus the other.
When I went back to work both times they were still waking at night and lo and behold I managed, it can be done! My job needs high levels of concentration, it's quite technical. And I expect being a SAHM is hard, I know I couldn't do it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread