Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate it when people say “my husband/partner/boyfriend doesn’t do the night feeds because he works”

614 replies

ForestFae · 10/06/2022 16:32

Every time I see or hear this phrase, I rage. Usually said by some poor sleep deprived new mum who’s looking after the baby/ies all day long. Why is looking after a baby not considered valuable work? Why are men getting away with using this rubbish excuse?

OP posts:
PinkCheetah · 11/06/2022 11:46

My DH is an A&E reg. When he's working I do all the night time duties and my daughter is exclusively breastfed anyway. When not working he'll do the nappies at night. I'm not even going to pretend I have it harder. I'd rather be at home with my baby than managing a full A&E department so no I wouldn't dream of asking DH to do nights too.

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 11/06/2022 11:46

there isn't one universal life we all live that you can see how different people do it and compare. I did all the nights on dc one when I was off because he was a dream. On dc2 I was fucked because I was so exhausted and so was dh for different reasons and together we were destroyed but somehow had dc3 and we're both in much better places and shared the load. I think it's all about respect. I respect how hard dh works so am happy to do the first night feed. He respects how hard I work so he's happy to take over/do the second feed/do whatever I need. Similarly now dc3 is older and wakes less frequently he does the night feeds because his sleep is wrecked anyway. Like who else has the same situation as us that would like to compare our solutions? No one.

Anotherdayanotherdisappointment · 11/06/2022 11:44

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 11:37

I find it weird that people value each other’s sleep if someone works, but not if they’re caring for dc. It shows that they value the caring work less.

Because if you're at work you can't nap! You can't get up late (and if its been a bad night DC will tend to sleep longer). You can't just cancel plans and have a relaxing day. You have to be 'on' for the whole time. It's been said repeatedly! If your at home you have opportunity to take it easy. At work you can't.

It's not undervaluing, it's realistic. I'm a teacher, I'm fully aware of "women's jobs" being undervalued. But it's fully factual that I could easily cope on Mat leave/when I was a SAHP with less sleep. If I get several nights of poor sleep working, I struggle. And that's the same for most people, they struggle more at work with less sleep than they did as a SAHP.

anxiousmumagain · 11/06/2022 11:44

I can honestly see both sides of this. I do agree with the OP that staying home to look after children is most definitely not a walk in park and in that sense can - a lot of the time - feel like work. And I do strongly believe that everyone performs better when well rested - no matter the tasks that are filling their day; and that chronic sleep deprivation is going to affect most people's mental health eventually if not immediately.

But - I can see the flip-side to this, too. I've never been a SAHM, I've always worked FT and have 2 DC, but I have done a year on maternity leave so that's my only comparison. Whilst it does feel like hard slog at times looking after children at home (on mat leave there were some days DP would come from a 12 hour shift and I'd feel utterly drained and exhausted), you are still in many ways the architect of your own day. By and large you get to choose what you fill your day with. Yes there will be the usual every day tedious tasks such as washing, putting the dishwasher on, food shopping (working parents need to find time to get those done, too), but you can adjust and tweak most of your day to suit how you feel. Don't feel like going to the park? I'll change the plan and stay home and do arts and crafts instead with the kids (as a rough example). At work, I can't say to my boss "sorry I don't feel going to that meeting today, can I just do x and y at my desk instead?"
You're only accountable to yourself as a SAHM and you have a lot of flexibility within your day.

I think that's the main difference. And the fact that you can't get sacked and lose your income if you mess up.

So yeah ... I see both sides. I agree with OP that SAHM need their sleep just as much as anyone does - I do strongly believe that mental health and cognitive functioning is impacted negatively in most people (whether they realise it or not) on lack of sleep. That's risky whether in charge of children or in charge of machinery or patients at work. On the other hand I take the point that the flexibility within your day and not being accountable to a "boss", or feeling the pressure to do well to keep bringing the income home, probably make being a SAHM less pressured in many ways.

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 11:42

LaMarschallin · 11/06/2022 11:37

Well, they can because a friend of mine is a surgeon and they managed to care for a baby perfectly well.
Not at the same time as doing full time surgery though; that wouldn't be practical, would it?

Certainly, on the whole, the broken nights caused by on call rotas for training surgeons last a lot longer than night feeds for a baby.

I think a valid point is how long night feeds last for - with my dc, two of them didn’t start to sleep through until nearly 4, and it’s not guaranteed they will sleep through. Night wakings for years is a different ballgame to night wakings for 6-12 months. DC1, while not a good sleeper, didn’t do this so I was really surprised when 2 and 3 did it.

OP posts:
LaMarschallin · 11/06/2022 11:37

5128gap · 11/06/2022 11:14

Yet somehow they can't manage to care for a baby? It can't be both ways.

Well, they can because a friend of mine is a surgeon and they managed to care for a baby perfectly well.
Not at the same time as doing full time surgery though; that wouldn't be practical, would it?

Certainly, on the whole, the broken nights caused by on call rotas for training surgeons last a lot longer than night feeds for a baby.

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 11:37

Anotherdayanotherdisappointment · 11/06/2022 11:36

But why should they if the other parent is at home the next day?

Most people have said once back at work they split night wakings 50:50 but when 1 parent is at home, why shouldn't they do it? (As long as weekends it's split and other child related jobs are split)

I find it weird that people value each other’s sleep if someone works, but not if they’re caring for dc. It shows that they value the caring work less.

OP posts:
ForestFae · 11/06/2022 11:36

C8H10N4O2 · 11/06/2022 11:35

But you would be safe to look after a baby?

Looking after a baby needs care and attention and a mistake due to being sleep deprived can lead to harm.

Both partners need to sleep to be effective, not just the highly paid partner.

This is what I think, and surely harm to dc is worse than a mistake at most desk jobs

OP posts:
Anotherdayanotherdisappointment · 11/06/2022 11:36

AquaticSewingMachine · 11/06/2022 11:03

As has been pointed out on here, surgeons do shifts including nights for years, and still manage to cut people open on limited and broken sleep, so like fuck can someone not manage a desk job while waking in the night.

I went back to work at 8 months each time and my babies continued to wake in the night until 18mo. I ebf so I did do all the feeds, but DH did all non-feed getting up.

But why should they if the other parent is at home the next day?

Most people have said once back at work they split night wakings 50:50 but when 1 parent is at home, why shouldn't they do it? (As long as weekends it's split and other child related jobs are split)

C8H10N4O2 · 11/06/2022 11:35

Simonjt · 10/06/2022 16:46

We both have office jobs, this requires high levels of maths and data handling. You can’t do that for eight hours if you’re tired. Thats why the worker here doesn’t do the night wakings.

But you would be safe to look after a baby?

Looking after a baby needs care and attention and a mistake due to being sleep deprived can lead to harm.

Both partners need to sleep to be effective, not just the highly paid partner.

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 11:33

LaMarschallin · 11/06/2022 11:26

I’d argue it’s more intense

You've said that a lot and I understand that the feelings one has for one's children are incredibly intense, but what's intense about the regular day to day cleaning, feeding, nurturing etc?
Do you feel at a high pitch of emotion all day? Are you actively rearing your children minute by minute?

If you were working on a supermarket checkout, say, you couldn't just suddenly say you needed a break because things were a bit overwhelming and go and do something else.
If you're looking after your children, you can. You might cut an outing short or make something a bit more simple for the evening meal but no one would criticise or sack you.
Looking after children can be bloody boring, frustrating, sometimes difficult and there's no immediate end to it, but that's like all jobs.
And the benefit is that you're not doing it because of demanding customers or pupils (and their parents) or patients or an obnoxious boss... you're doing it for people you love. Who, when they stop being a pain, won't cut off your income because you've had an off day.

It’s the implication that he doesn’t do them because he works and therefore the mother doesn’t,

Well, I see that as he works at one job and the SAHM works at another.
But why does it still upset you now? If your husband's not saying the arrangement doesn't work for him then crack on and don't worry about what other people are doing.
If you're convinced you're doing the right thing, don't feel guilty. But also appreciate others might feel differently.

Because there’s no let up. You can’t just take a minute to go and clear your head - if I did that in the early days, the room would be trashed (no exaggeration - my kids could unscrew furniture and had to be supervised constantly. They climb too. One of my dc has the nickname Spider-Man because she can climb up pretty much anything) Also, it depends what you do with the kids. I spend most of my time actively doing things with them. I don’t sit around watching TV, we are out and about and every minute is a lesson. It never stops. Now, I enjoy this, but it’s an intense job. My own dad worked a high paid, high powered job for 40+ years. He has a lot to do with my kids now he’s retired and he’s said multiple times that he thinks it’s harder to look after them all day than it is to do his former job, and he was a career oriented man who was always on business trips in various countries, would work late, get up at 4am to travel etc.

Its not about my arrangement, it’s about society not valuing motherhood, particularly western society.

OP posts:
LaMarschallin · 11/06/2022 11:26

I’d argue it’s more intense

You've said that a lot and I understand that the feelings one has for one's children are incredibly intense, but what's intense about the regular day to day cleaning, feeding, nurturing etc?
Do you feel at a high pitch of emotion all day? Are you actively rearing your children minute by minute?

If you were working on a supermarket checkout, say, you couldn't just suddenly say you needed a break because things were a bit overwhelming and go and do something else.
If you're looking after your children, you can. You might cut an outing short or make something a bit more simple for the evening meal but no one would criticise or sack you.
Looking after children can be bloody boring, frustrating, sometimes difficult and there's no immediate end to it, but that's like all jobs.
And the benefit is that you're not doing it because of demanding customers or pupils (and their parents) or patients or an obnoxious boss... you're doing it for people you love. Who, when they stop being a pain, won't cut off your income because you've had an off day.

It’s the implication that he doesn’t do them because he works and therefore the mother doesn’t,

Well, I see that as he works at one job and the SAHM works at another.
But why does it still upset you now? If your husband's not saying the arrangement doesn't work for him then crack on and don't worry about what other people are doing.
If you're convinced you're doing the right thing, don't feel guilty. But also appreciate others might feel differently.

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 11:23

5128gap · 11/06/2022 11:20

Well as a working parent, how about if you stop undervaluing my work with your assumptions about office jobs, and I won't undervalue yours? It wouldn't never have occurred to me to think SAHP didn't work. Its you who have introduced the idea that a working parent has it easier. You're confident and happy in your choices and world views, so why not just leave other women alone and stop 'fuming' at theirs?

It wasn’t me that initially said that, I was responding to a poster who repeatedly demanded I justify my choices while insisting she does “more” than me because she works outside the home. It’s not undervaluing a desk job to say that 2 or so nights a week of broken sleep wouldn’t be impossible.

OP posts:
5128gap · 11/06/2022 11:20

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 11:02

Exactly, both work just in different ways. I’m sick of the work mothers do being undervalued.

Well as a working parent, how about if you stop undervaluing my work with your assumptions about office jobs, and I won't undervalue yours? It wouldn't never have occurred to me to think SAHP didn't work. Its you who have introduced the idea that a working parent has it easier. You're confident and happy in your choices and world views, so why not just leave other women alone and stop 'fuming' at theirs?

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 11:15

5128gap · 11/06/2022 11:14

Yet somehow they can't manage to care for a baby? It can't be both ways.

It’s more that most adults can do either job, working or caring for a child, on limited sleep, but neither can do either job well with chronic sleep deprivation. That’s the problem.

OP posts:
5128gap · 11/06/2022 11:14

AquaticSewingMachine · 11/06/2022 11:03

As has been pointed out on here, surgeons do shifts including nights for years, and still manage to cut people open on limited and broken sleep, so like fuck can someone not manage a desk job while waking in the night.

I went back to work at 8 months each time and my babies continued to wake in the night until 18mo. I ebf so I did do all the feeds, but DH did all non-feed getting up.

Yet somehow they can't manage to care for a baby? It can't be both ways.

itsgettingweird · 11/06/2022 11:06

Well I breastfed ds and DP worked.

Whilst DP worked and ds and I were at home I could catch a nap when he did.

We then both had some catch up of sleep (DP didn't get up but the crying would wake him obviously!) when we needed it and could.

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 11:05

LaMarschallin · 11/06/2022 11:02

ForestFae it sounds like you had a very difficult time when your children were babies and I'm very sorry for that.
I was lucky enough to have two healthy children (albeit the first was extremely difficult and got me up three times a night until her sister was born 18 months later).
I still feel that looking after a healthy baby and toddler isn't more difficult than most jobs.
Surely it should mostly be pleasurable?

Why do you "rage" about mothers saying their partners don't do the night feeds because they're working?
Do you take it as an implied criticism of you? If your husband was happy doing the feeds, fine. And it sounds like you feel you have an extreme reaction to lack of sleep, so I presume you couldn't have done them. My SiL apparently had the same problem; my MiL used to explain that it was difficult for SiL: "She gets emotionally upset, not like you who can cope".

I suppose if you've taken on home education, that's a job in itself. But it's a choice. I still don't see why it's harder than anything else.

It is pleasurable, I’d argue it’s more intense but more rewarding. I get annoyed by it because I think it undervalues what mothers do. It’s the implication that he doesn’t do them because he works and therefore the mother doesn’t, when staying home and caring for children is very much work, albeit a different kind.

OP posts:
AquaticSewingMachine · 11/06/2022 11:03

As has been pointed out on here, surgeons do shifts including nights for years, and still manage to cut people open on limited and broken sleep, so like fuck can someone not manage a desk job while waking in the night.

I went back to work at 8 months each time and my babies continued to wake in the night until 18mo. I ebf so I did do all the feeds, but DH did all non-feed getting up.

LaMarschallin · 11/06/2022 11:02

ForestFae it sounds like you had a very difficult time when your children were babies and I'm very sorry for that.
I was lucky enough to have two healthy children (albeit the first was extremely difficult and got me up three times a night until her sister was born 18 months later).
I still feel that looking after a healthy baby and toddler isn't more difficult than most jobs.
Surely it should mostly be pleasurable?

Why do you "rage" about mothers saying their partners don't do the night feeds because they're working?
Do you take it as an implied criticism of you? If your husband was happy doing the feeds, fine. And it sounds like you feel you have an extreme reaction to lack of sleep, so I presume you couldn't have done them. My SiL apparently had the same problem; my MiL used to explain that it was difficult for SiL: "She gets emotionally upset, not like you who can cope".

I suppose if you've taken on home education, that's a job in itself. But it's a choice. I still don't see why it's harder than anything else.

ForestFae · 11/06/2022 11:02

stillherenow · 11/06/2022 11:00

My dd only slept in 20 min naps. I had a row with bil when he said this. It's way more exhausting being at home with a baby than going to work. I've ever done any job as exhausting as looking after a a baby. Both work in the day one at work one with baby so night feeds are split equally.

Exactly, both work just in different ways. I’m sick of the work mothers do being undervalued.

OP posts:
ForestFae · 11/06/2022 11:01

nalabae · 11/06/2022 10:57

That’s what maternity for, if you don’t need to leave your home you can look after the baby.
Women have been doing this for years, strong women.

Maternity leave is not for constant sleep deprivation.

OP posts:
stillherenow · 11/06/2022 11:00

My dd only slept in 20 min naps. I had a row with bil when he said this. It's way more exhausting being at home with a baby than going to work. I've ever done any job as exhausting as looking after a a baby. Both work in the day one at work one with baby so night feeds are split equally.

nalabae · 11/06/2022 10:57

That’s what maternity for, if you don’t need to leave your home you can look after the baby.
Women have been doing this for years, strong women.

sunglassesonthetable · 11/06/2022 10:27

Worked for us. It was a practical choice. I was on maternity. And I breast fed. 🤷‍♀️

Can't really get worked up about it.