Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to hate that MIL brings all her coffee stuff when she visits?

209 replies

classicnegroni · 10/06/2022 16:18

It drives me mad. DH and I are both quite into coffee so it’s not like we just have a jar of five year old instant coffee brought out for guests. We have a coffee grinder, espresso machine, French press and V60 dripper, as well as coffee beans from our local roasters and a bag of pre-ground. If I were a MNetter’s DH I’d probably be called a coffee wanker!! She is welcome to use any of it. But she always brings a load of stuff with her and clutters up the counter with it (I hate having clutter out on the counter, but there’s not room in the cupboard for this extra stuff and she’d just move it back to the counter anyway).

I’d understand bringing a bag of decaf, though we’d happily buy it for her, but most of what she brings is equipment we have anyway and caffeinated coffee, which we have plenty of also. It’s brought with an air of what we have isn’t good enough which is pissing me off too. I wouldn’t dream of doing this at my friends’ houses, even the one whose ancient jar of instant coffee was so solidified it would have taken a chisel to remove the coffee! I just drink the coffee they have or don’t drink coffee. So AIBU not to want to have my counters cluttered with someone else’s coffee crap or am I being too grumpy?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Gingernan · 12/06/2023 19:01

It's not rude, she just likes what she likes and it makes her feel comfortable.Shes an older adult , she knows what she wants , your worktops will survive , you will miss her when she's not around with her bit of harmless clutter.

helibirdcomp · 10/07/2022 20:29

Put a small fold up table in her bedroom, with a tray a nice mug and jug of water near a wall socket and tell her you got her a special table for all her coffee stuff. Move anything that migrates to the kitchen straight back with a helpful "I'll just put that back for you". You get a clear counter and she finds out her stuff isn't welcome in your kitchen!

Barney60 · 16/06/2022 15:19

Im a MIL. I take my own coffee but its in a tiny sachet which is in my handbag, i dont like their coffee.
It wouldnt bother me if someone visited that brought their own, its not like its staying there, presume she takes it all home again with her?

Fizbosshoes · 16/06/2022 07:28

I bet people wouldn't mind their own mum bringing a bottle of water or her own coffee. It's just mil who does it for nefarious reasons.

I would mind if my mum brought her own food and didn't eat anything that I had served (without prior warning!)

Eirini1984 · 16/06/2022 07:22

My MIL brings her own toilet paper when she visits because ours is 'too harsh'. I rest my case...

PAFMO · 13/06/2022 07:23

justfiveminutes · 13/06/2022 05:41

I bet people wouldn't mind their own mum bringing a bottle of water or her own coffee. It's just mil who does it for nefarious reasons.

Aye.
Your own mam could bring used toilet paper and leave it on your sofa and it wouldn't be a problem.
Your MIL however could bring you five hundred grand a diamond necklace and MNers would think she was a CF.

justfiveminutes · 13/06/2022 05:41

I bet people wouldn't mind their own mum bringing a bottle of water or her own coffee. It's just mil who does it for nefarious reasons.

PoppyinCologne · 12/06/2022 20:46

Just wanted to add ..when we visit the mother in law , I often bring my own rubber gloves, apron and sometimes sponge so I can help clean up the kitchen for her , she goes to such a big effort when we visit..i want to help her and I want to be prepared so I don't ruin my clothes and hands when helping out... not bothered if she's offended .. if anything I think she looks impressed that I'm serious to help her , and am organised..

..she brings her own decaf instant coffee when she visits and I'm not bothered. , some other things bug me, but not that

PoppyinCologne · 12/06/2022 20:34

She just wants to feel comfortable, creature of habit, let her do her thing, make some room for her coffee kit and be happy that she's happy.

Fizbosshoes · 12/06/2022 20:26

Being a terrible host is being so caught up in your desired aesthetic, or the perceived superiority of your choices (whether that is food, coffee machines, bedding or whatever) that you make your guests uncomfortable and unwelcome.

I didn't mind too much my IL bringing their own bedding, biscuits (we don't buy that sort) coffee (again don't have the same brand)
I did mind them turning up late (without letting me know) to a meal they've been invited to - they have no allergies and hadn't made any preferences in advance- and bringing service station pre-packed sandwiches and eating them at the table, and ignoring the food I'd taken time to prepare.
To me, it felt like they were saying my food wasn't good enough but maybe it was me being unwelcoming?

Nanny0gg · 12/06/2022 19:23

IncompleteSenten · 10/06/2022 17:18

If she's doing it to be an arse then make a big fuss of her oh mil you are sooo wonderful. You save me so much effort, it's really thoughtful of you.

I do generally take my own pillows with me. Not many people have feather ones anymore and comfortable sleep is very important!

iwishiwasafish · 12/06/2022 19:07

It’s amusing how this thread is full of people complaining that they are such good hosts and their MIL keeps ruining it (beautiful table settings spoiled by a bottle of water, the audacity of guests bringing food, or needing their own bedding to be comfortable).

Being a good host is allowing your guest whatever they need to feel comfortable.

Being a terrible host is being so caught up in your desired aesthetic, or the perceived superiority of your choices (whether that is food, coffee machines, bedding or whatever) that you make your guests uncomfortable and unwelcome.

Willowwelsh13 · 12/06/2022 16:02

That would annoy me too. My MIL used to bring a refilled plastic bottle of water with her when she came round for a meal. Really annoying when the Christmas table was dressed at its best and there’s a creased, sad looking plastic bottle displaying the remnants of an Evian label taking its place at the table - why!?. Lol!

DangerouslyBored · 12/06/2022 12:45

justfiveminutes · 12/06/2022 08:21

Probably thought they were being helpful and didn't want to turn up empty handed.

Well done on 'smiling sweetly' and enduring the horrendous insult.

Haha my thoughts entirely. What an odd thing to get annoyed about. I’d love it if my guests filled my fridge with lovely M&S food.

And ‘smile sweetly’ is such a cringey MN phrase.

Ortega888 · 12/06/2022 12:26

Embrace the chance to try something different. Put all your stuff away when she calls and use hers. If she knows it’s irritating you she may do it intentionally so try reverse psychology and ask her about coffee and coffee machines and view it differently and she may or may not stop coming but it’s worth a try. It’s not worth getting upset about or even go out and let her have time with her son. You have to find a way to stop feeling so stressed out about it.

Kassiopeia · 12/06/2022 11:02

I admit it would piss me off a little, my ex-MIL used to arrive with what I called a Red Cross Parcel, containing the foods she thought her son and our daughter 'should' be eating rather than the "foreign muck" I cooked. (I'm Italian)

I refused to inflict her tinned garbage on my child - tinned Irish Stew with an inch of lard at the top of the tin, that even the cat wouldn't eat, stodgy suet puddings and canned meatballs. She was actually really angry when I cooked with wine and herbs and even exploded at the dinner table saying "it were a nice piece of meat before it were messed about wiy". (She was a northerner)

Her idea of cooking was opening a tin of potatoes, tinned veg and that awful sliced meat in gravy that came in oval tins.

She died of a stroke.

ijwmtb · 12/06/2022 09:52

It might bother me slightly depending on the undertones (which only you know) but I'd probably put it out of my mind. Cluttering up surfaces for a little bit isn't the worst inconvenience of having a houseguest and actually in a way it's flattering when someone is comfortable enough to truly make themselves at home at your house. I might ask her about it in a polite way if you wanted - 'can we get any particular type of coffee in for you so you don't have to lug your equipment down?'.

even the one whose ancient jar of instant coffee was so solidified it would have taken a chisel to remove the coffee!

As an aside, I felt very seen by this part of the post😳Not to hijack but what would coffee experts suggest keeping in for guests as a non-coffee drinker. Needs to not be complicated (I'm not keen to buy any type of equipment) and keep well! But fancy instant coffee is fine... unless that is just beyond the pale?

camphire · 12/06/2022 09:49

I think I know how you feel. I'm no with my parents (for very serious reasons) and have been for about five years.

Before that when they visited they would do things like this. My mother would bring the contents of her fridge with her and put things like half a pack of flora (we don't eat it) and some old raspberries in our fridge.

They'd read the newspaper and have it spread out all across the sofa and leave it there. When I put it away I'd get told off. Our house isn't big enough for people to leave spread out newspapers everywhere, no one could sit down.

She'd also go through the contents of my fridge and take out anything that was approaching its end date and spread it across the counter which I guess was a passive aggressive 'reminder' that, say, the mushrooms needed using up.

Whoever said 'coloniser' is bang on in my case.

I suppose I'm wondering what the rest of your relationship with your MIL is like. If she's generally critical of you then the coffee thing would feel like a dig.

My parents have absolutely no boundaries or ability to see me as anything other than an object to be ordered around and criticised and so their behaviour in my home was really hard for me to tolerate.

If there's there is other stuff than the coffee I can see how the coffee would feel like a dig. People who haven't suffered these kind of dysfunctional relationships won't be able to see it as anything other than coffee though (lucky them).

SmiledWtherisingsun · 12/06/2022 09:39

Just ignore it.

MixedCouple · 12/06/2022 09:39

Agree in my Culture you never go empty handed usually home made dish or dessert or at times shop bought.

MixedCouple · 12/06/2022 09:37

Have you spoken to her and asked why? That be the first thing I did. And depending on her answer I would see how to proceed.
But YANBU

Tilia · 12/06/2022 08:22

I just wonder if she uses paper filters for particular reasons? The do make it very easy to dispose of the grounds (straight to the compost bin for us), and I have heard that there may be health benefits. Perhaps it would be worth asking her.

justfiveminutes · 12/06/2022 08:21

Spanielsarepainless · 12/06/2022 06:57

We had guests once, who brought the contents of M&S food hall with them. I smiled sweetly, stacked it in the fridge and fed them what I had been planning.

Probably thought they were being helpful and didn't want to turn up empty handed.

Well done on 'smiling sweetly' and enduring the horrendous insult.

justfiveminutes · 12/06/2022 08:14

Some of the replies from pp are nuts. She is visiting her son, drinks and eats everything else that is provided but, for whatever reason, prefers her own coffee

Sure, she doesn't have to go to the trouble because op is able to brew a good coffee, lots of us wouldn't bother, we'd just drink the inferior coffee for ease, but it is hardly rude or offensive to do so.

If you're sensitive enough to be upset or offended by your mum implying that she prefers her own coffee to yours, I don't know how you get through life.

She dumps it all on the counter for the duration of her visit? Oh no. But surely preferable to her putting it in a cupboard or rearranging things. It's your mum. What would she do if you turned up at her house with something to eat or drink? Find a place for it? Happily leave it on the counter? Or get offended and start an mn thread?

mangipops · 12/06/2022 08:13

Unless you feel she is deliberately trying to put you down she may feel she is helping in some way. Many older people will bring cake or something around to their friends - she may prefer instant coffee to perculated - and may very well be worried at using any of your equipment feeling it would be less work for you. Try accepting this little quirk if the counter is only cluttered for a short visit. If the visit is longer - allocate her a little space to put her 'bits and pieces'. The worst thing you can do is make it a war with your husband in the middle.