Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Childhood traits persist in adulthood

29 replies

Hannahpops4 · 10/06/2022 16:11

Inspired by another thread about a badly behaved toddler terrorising the OP’s child.

As a fifty year old, I’ve seen plenty of my friend’s kids, and kids in my extended family, grow up. I have an observation that has left me wondering if I’m being unreasonable.

I’ve noticed (purely anecdotal and from a relatively small sample!), that kids who excessively and repeatedly behave badly towards others - with nasty, spiteful, jealous, bullying behaviours, tend to remain nasty as adults.

I can think of two kids (now adults) who were particularly nasty to other kids throughout their childhood, even as toddlers. They are now arseholes. I’m not talking about naughty or boisterous kids, that’s different. I’m talking about really underhanded, sly, manipulative behaviour. Both kids were adept at lying and getting other kids into trouble, hitting other kids and generally being mean and selfish, deliberately causing trouble and enjoying the fallout.

I know all kids act up and none are perfect but most kids show kindness and compassion to others as well. Most of them learn how to interact with others and share, take turns etc.

Perhaps my perception of the two people I’m referring to is slightly skewed because of their behaviour as children, but I’ve spoken to others who think they’re arseholes as well. Both of them brought up well and their siblings are generally very nice.

I recognise all kids can be horrible at times (including my own!) but am I way off the mark with my observation?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OutwiththeOutCrowd · 11/06/2022 08:34

I think that parents, siblings, peers, teachers - and the immediate social landscape in general - can have a great deal of influence over whether certain childhood behaviours end up becoming ingrained habits for life.

Antisocial behaviour in childhood can be reinforced or enabled but can also be redirected by others, particularly a wise and vigilant parent.

ItWillBeOkHonestly · 11/06/2022 08:25

I once knew a man in his 30s who had a vicious temper. I saw it in action a couple of times where he'd lose the plot, kick walls, throw objects etc. I remember thinking at the time that it was like watching an adult have a toddler tantrum. A year or so later I met his parents in the family home and his mum was jokingly showing us some dents in the wall from when he'd been a kid. She was almost proud of it and said 'oh he had a terrible temper as a kid but we used to just laugh at him'.

And you could see right there that because he'd done it as a kid and no one had ever put any boundaries in place, he'd never grown out of it.

gillyff · 11/06/2022 08:11

While some others learn that they can get away with sneaky behaviour (and get others into trouble instead) so it becomes more ingrained in their behaviour. They might have learned differently if the people around them had treated them differently.

I agree that it's harder to spot but where to the dc learn about this behaviour? I think some must pick it up because that's what they see in their parents.

Amdone123 · 11/06/2022 08:11

I watch and read a lot of true crime, and I've found that the majority of perpetrators suffered gross abuse in their childhoods.
I often think that their parents should be in the dock with them.

gillyff · 11/06/2022 08:07

On all those murder programmes 95% of them have neighbours, extended family who say how lovely the murderer was as a kid & how there wasn't any signs!

unlimiteddilutingjuice · 11/06/2022 08:06

YANBU
Psychopathy runs in my family so this is some thing I've had to think about.

If you get a kid like that your best efforts as a Mum might lead to them being an asshole to their family and friends, but not a criminal. And that should be counted as a success.

There's a neurologist who studied the brains of psychopaths and discovered that his own brain scan looks the same. He credits his parents love for steering him away from serious wrongdoing. But his family were not surprised by the scan and said it "explains a lot" so I would guess he is horrible in smaller ways.

Corgi887 · 11/06/2022 07:59

I agree. My dad proudly tells stories about hurting other children and being quite horrible. Laughing about awkward children from his childhood. Thinks it normal childhood stuff. He is now n awful adult

chchchchch · 11/06/2022 07:56

YANBU.

My brother was prized dickhead as a child (always the smart arse, no respect and attention seeker) to the people around him, and he still is a wanker as an adult, just on a bigger scale as he screwed so many people over in his life, including our own parents and my other two brothers. NC now.

Amdone123 · 11/06/2022 07:54

Very thought provoking thread,op. I don't think YABU, and I don't think you're way off the mark.
I was a teacher for over 20 years and experienced many children who, god forgive me, were just plain vile.
It's very complex, though. Some of these children, as a pp said, experienced such neglect from rubbish parents, that it was probably a defence mechanism. So sad. Others weren't helped by parents who could neither see nor accept their children were on the wrong path, so basically ( not in all cases), a life of crime beckoned.

MsTSwift · 11/06/2022 07:52

Disagree that’s it’s all nurture. The example I gave the family were lovely - rather posh creative slightly hippy types very loving to their children but they tried to be firm too. Their eldest was not their fault. He was born like that.

Mally100 · 11/06/2022 07:49

5zeds · 10/06/2022 22:47

i think I was brought up believing in nurture over nature but my experience is that an awful lot of who you are is there from the beginning and born into you.

I agree. I think some are just born evil. Yes even children can be evil and become evil adults.

BrokenRice · 11/06/2022 07:47

AliceW89 · 10/06/2022 22:43

I don’t think kids aren’t born devious, malicious, spiteful, manipulative or any of these other negative traits listed. They are complex facets of a developed personality. I do however think that some kids are born with temperaments that predispose them to negative personalities in later life, depending on their life experience. There will be a lot of kids with the building blocks to be ‘unpleasant’ who turn out to be wonderful adults and vice versa.

This is what I mean by traits that the adults around them failed to recognise or failed to intervene over. The ‘naughty’ and ‘boisterous’ kids usually spend their childhoods being told off or facing consequences. While some others learn that they can get away with sneaky behaviour (and get others into trouble instead) so it becomes more ingrained in their behaviour. They might have learned differently if the people around them had treated them differently.

Needtogetoffmyphone · 11/06/2022 07:42

@5zeds
i agree

5zeds · 10/06/2022 22:47

i think I was brought up believing in nurture over nature but my experience is that an awful lot of who you are is there from the beginning and born into you.

AliceW89 · 10/06/2022 22:43

I don’t think kids aren’t born devious, malicious, spiteful, manipulative or any of these other negative traits listed. They are complex facets of a developed personality. I do however think that some kids are born with temperaments that predispose them to negative personalities in later life, depending on their life experience. There will be a lot of kids with the building blocks to be ‘unpleasant’ who turn out to be wonderful adults and vice versa.

Needtogetoffmyphone · 10/06/2022 22:38

It possibly depends on your perspective… my family have disowned me because they think I’m too difficult, I think they’re narcissistic. Who knows what the truth is?

But in my view, my sister was a bully as a child, and still is.

I do think that as we age, our personalities show through in our faces. Some people look selfish, others have a happy, open, demeanour.

Jellybean23 · 10/06/2022 22:37

I agree, people don't change their personality traits that much as they age. Also, as I told my daughter when she was young, she shouldn't assume all adults know better than her. Thick kids don't suddenly become intelligent or wise adults.

MsTSwift · 10/06/2022 22:30

I agree. Only one child I have come across was consistently cruel and mean to siblings. He was an awful teen (often made younger female teachers cry) last heard of being a drug dealer. His family (who were lovely and tried their best) emigrated and left him behind. His behaviour was in a different league to your average stroppy / mischievous kid.

Minimalme · 10/06/2022 22:23

I agree op.

I always find it weird how people think human beings change throughout their lifetime, whereas I find people remain relentlessly themselves.

My three kids were born nice people and I thank my lucky stars for that.

My Mum is horrible and I think she has been since day one.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 10/06/2022 22:13

I tend to agree, OP - for both good and bad traits. Barring extreme circumstances people remain the person that they always were.

Sunnytwobridges · 10/06/2022 22:06

I‘m thinking about the way my (STBX)H describes how he was as a child and how it relates to some of his most problematic behaviour as an adult. He talks of himself as having always been ‘underestimated’. He was small (still is) and extremely good at playing innocent. He tells stories of how he never got into trouble because the adults always blamed the other kids for things he did.

This sounds exactly like my ex and his childhood. He told me a lot of his childhood and how he would get out of trouble because he was small (and he still is small), every one protected him. His siblings and cousins would be the ones that got pulled up on whatever was going on. And he still acts the same way as an adult, never owned up to anything he did wrong. Placed the blame on others every chance he could get.

RedPlumbob · 10/06/2022 21:52

One of my sisters is exactly as you describe - she got away with shit I never would have, for unknown reasons.

As a result, I see her as barely functional adult. She is just an overgrown toddler. Everything has to be handed to her or done for her, she has a sense of entitlement as wide as the fucking equator and is an absolute horror of a human being.

It’s embarrassing.

DingleyDel · 10/06/2022 21:40

I’ve only ever know one really sly, nasty child. Even his own mother was very worried about him when he was very small. He now works for the Tory party so I guess you must be right Grin (he’s an adult now just to clarify).

PestoPasghetti · 10/06/2022 21:33

Well I suppose the adults who are nasty tossers had to come from somewhere, and it's highly unlikely they were sweetness and light as youngsters and then radically changed for the worse as they aged, so yep, nasty selfish difficult destructive aggressive adults would most likely have once had the same characteristics in childhood!

Hannahpops4 · 10/06/2022 21:10

SoggyPaper - your stbx sounds like he has a few dark traits there - the bit about him feeling as though he was underestimated is very telling! It suggests he thought he could outsmart the people around him.

But do you think that sinister behaviour can be corrected by parents? I wonder if it’s innate in some people. I wonder whether any attempts to correct it may make the child even more sneaky and better at hiding it. Can you mould a child into developing a conscience?

Maybe for some kids it can be a survival thing, or a defence mechanism - I mean for kids who’ve had a tough childhood, it might be their way of coping with neglect or abuse. Or it might just be that they never learnt empathy because they were never shown love.

But for some kids, I think it’s just in them from the outset.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread