Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the NHS had lost the plot over breastfeeding?

303 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 10/06/2022 08:56

www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-10892531/NHS-accused-putting-babies-harm-advice-trans-women-wanting-breastfeed.html

It feels like some kind of bizarre experiment - except it's babies who are being used for affirmation.

Am I being gaslit here?

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 10/06/2022 18:09

It seems ridiculous to bring up TW feelings as argument and then start banging on about how they don't matter

Yes I did bring it up. Because I have seen posters use this as an excuse why studies should not go ahead before.

I am comfortable if you are that they live with their disappointment if they are able to be reliably restricted from feeding any infant before, during and after the trial.

As long as they don’t do that, then as I said, I am all for robust data and studies that are properly reviewed and if after publishing they are disputed, that children are again prioritized and more trials are done without any child receiving the product of the trial.

BobbinHood · 10/06/2022 18:06

InChocolateWeTrust · 10/06/2022 17:46

I’m a sheep farmer and I have to ensure that our lambs get enough colostrum in the first hour of life. If they don’t, their health is invariably compromised, even to the point of death.

I always find it interesting that this is pretty standard/well known in farming, whether calves or lambs, the colostrum they get has massive health implications..... yet millions of women don't feed their baby any colostrum at all.

Most women do try to initiate breastfeeding, so most babies must be getting some colostrum.

However that’s kind of a moot point anyway since obviously babies do not die if they don’t get colostrum. I’m not a sheep and my baby is not a lamb. I didn’t know this fact about sheep, but it would have had no bearing on my decisions anyway. Since I’m not one.

ReneBumsWombats · 10/06/2022 18:05

professorostrich · 10/06/2022 17:33

I suppose my next question would be why asking for a definition of "comparable" in this context offended you so

It didn't offend me @ReneBumsWombats , but you could've spent a second googling what comparable means in terms of scientific research, instead of immediately assuming going on the agressive because you thought I was implying things about women & TW.

Why would I Google when I have a bona fide research scientist on hand to tell me everything I need to know? Why don't we all just Google and save you the trouble of casting your pearls?

In the interests of scientific advancement, I can tell you now that making accusations against someone's character because they asked you to clarify an important term most definitely comes across as going on the aggressive, and not being very objective. Professor.

In the meantime, I promise that I'm very, very interested in any robust study that shows no suggestion that natal females have a natural advantage when it comes to lactation.

Professor.

Hagiography · 10/06/2022 18:03

InChocolateWeTrust · 10/06/2022 17:46

I’m a sheep farmer and I have to ensure that our lambs get enough colostrum in the first hour of life. If they don’t, their health is invariably compromised, even to the point of death.

I always find it interesting that this is pretty standard/well known in farming, whether calves or lambs, the colostrum they get has massive health implications..... yet millions of women don't feed their baby any colostrum at all.

A very high percentage of women breastfeed in the early days. Can't recall exact figure, but I think it's over 80% even in the UK, that has some of the lowest breastfeeding rates in the world.

Clymene · 10/06/2022 18:03

Babies die without adequate nutrition. These people chose to forego giving their baby optimal nutrition in order to fulfil a want from the baby's father.

Their child belongs in care.

Hagiography · 10/06/2022 18:01

mbosnz · 10/06/2022 17:46

You may choose to centre a male’s needs in this example

Erm, no. This is about a male's wants, not their needs.

The infant is the one in this scenario that has 'needs'. They need to be fed, as optimally as possible, and that should be the primary consideration. They are the individual that should be centred.

Yes. That is what is important and must be kept front and centre.

Helleofabore · 10/06/2022 18:01

mbosnz

yes. You are quite correct. It is a ‘want’. It is not even comparative to a female’s needs because a pregnant female lactates as part of the infant and mother relationship. If a female is not lactating as they are expected, it may need to be addressed. That is part of the ‘needs’ for female health.

And many females have to live with the fact they then cannot successfully establish breastfeeding.

There are no ‘need’ for a male that has to be considered here. It is about wants. I stand corrected.

professorostrich · 10/06/2022 18:00

TastefulRainbowUnicorn · 10/06/2022 17:43

To be clear - I'm just answering the questions posed, as a research scientist.

🙄 research scientist, is it? Do they employ you at the business factory?

the study linked was presumably this one.

Not sure what you mean by that, but I'm assuming you're implying I'm an idiot or some such.

professorostrich · 10/06/2022 17:57

To be clear @Helleofabore - I did not mention hurt feelings or cruelty to transwomen, you did, as a faux concern against research.

In the next breath you get angry that feelings have been brought up.

This is the only reason it was referenced in my reply to you.

professorostrich · 10/06/2022 17:56

Helleofabore · 10/06/2022 17:43

You've just said again here you don't need to be considerate of their feeling, so just reinforcing my point, no?

No doubt. What of it?

Why should I consider a male’s feelings in this at this time? Why would you centre a male’s needs here?

Do you have an answer to what the benefits are in males breastfeeding infants in the first place knowing there is already some common sense logic issues.

Such as the inability for any male to tailor the feed to that child and replicate the interaction with the child and a mother breastfeeding her own infant ?

You may choose to centre a male’s needs in this example, but I choose not to. I have been quite clear in my statements as to why too.

Because you were the one who brought up transwomen's feelings in the first place? You used them as argument for research to not be done?

Is it ethical to induce lactation and then tell that male that they absolutely should not be feeding any infant? Isn't that cruel?

My reply:

I mean, you don't seem to be too considered with the feelings of transwomen, but sure.

There are plenty of trials & research studies that could be considered "cruel" because they raise hopes which may be dashed. All studies go through an ethics board & stringent checks to make sure harms to participants are minimised and not unacceptable. A study won't be approved if it is deemed unethical.

It seems ridiculous to bring up TW feelings as argument and then start banging on about how they don't matter.

mbosnz · 10/06/2022 17:46

You may choose to centre a male’s needs in this example

Erm, no. This is about a male's wants, not their needs.

The infant is the one in this scenario that has 'needs'. They need to be fed, as optimally as possible, and that should be the primary consideration. They are the individual that should be centred.

InChocolateWeTrust · 10/06/2022 17:46

I’m a sheep farmer and I have to ensure that our lambs get enough colostrum in the first hour of life. If they don’t, their health is invariably compromised, even to the point of death.

I always find it interesting that this is pretty standard/well known in farming, whether calves or lambs, the colostrum they get has massive health implications..... yet millions of women don't feed their baby any colostrum at all.

Helleofabore · 10/06/2022 17:43

You've just said again here you don't need to be considerate of their feeling, so just reinforcing my point, no?

No doubt. What of it?

Why should I consider a male’s feelings in this at this time? Why would you centre a male’s needs here?

Do you have an answer to what the benefits are in males breastfeeding infants in the first place knowing there is already some common sense logic issues.

Such as the inability for any male to tailor the feed to that child and replicate the interaction with the child and a mother breastfeeding her own infant ?

You may choose to centre a male’s needs in this example, but I choose not to. I have been quite clear in my statements as to why too.

TastefulRainbowUnicorn · 10/06/2022 17:43

To be clear - I'm just answering the questions posed, as a research scientist.

🙄 research scientist, is it? Do they employ you at the business factory?

the study linked was presumably this one.

professorostrich · 10/06/2022 17:39

WorriedWoking · 10/06/2022 17:38

Has anyone got a link to the studies, because I’m sure there must be plenty of them, that detail the quality of the colostrum made by transwomen? I’m a sheep farmer and I have to ensure that our lambs get enough colostrum in the first hour of life. If they don’t, their health is invariably compromised, even to the point of death. I’m looking forward to reading the studies so please don’t hold back with the ‘proof’!

As far as I'm aware there are only very low quality case studies (i.e., n=1), and none with a control group.

WorriedWoking · 10/06/2022 17:38

Has anyone got a link to the studies, because I’m sure there must be plenty of them, that detail the quality of the colostrum made by transwomen? I’m a sheep farmer and I have to ensure that our lambs get enough colostrum in the first hour of life. If they don’t, their health is invariably compromised, even to the point of death. I’m looking forward to reading the studies so please don’t hold back with the ‘proof’!

mbosnz · 10/06/2022 17:37

Well, surely, any parent should be most invested in the best interests of their child, what is optimal for their child - particularly in terms of nutrition, which is one of the most fundamental building blocks for an individual's entire life?

A child shouldn't be a political statement, or a vanity piece.

Helleofabore · 10/06/2022 17:37

If you found that milk from TW was unsafe, you want to be sure that it couldn't potentially explained by other things (i.e., confounding or bias), so that it could be used to inform policy- for example legisaltion against TW donating milk or whatever.

I am all for robust data.

As long as no male fed an infant or donated the milk until that research was done, peer reviewed and even repeated if necessary. Not even on the sly.

professorostrich · 10/06/2022 17:36

LemonSwan · 10/06/2022 17:35

But surely then you would have to know the full composition of breast milk which they don’t know.

I think you are massively simplifying this. Breast milk isn’t just volume, calories, hormones and a bit of water.

Perhaps you could measure whether it’s a safe comparative to formula.

But until we fully understand breast milk in all its rich varying complexity (changing as babe grows, changing through time of day, reacting to babes illness etc.) then I don’t think it’s possible to even attempt to compare whether it’s the same.

I was agreeing with you @LemonSwan

Definitively proving safety (like with many other things) would be be near impossible.

professorostrich · 10/06/2022 17:35

Helleofabore · 10/06/2022 17:33

I mean, you don't seem to be too considered with the feelings of transwomen, but sure.

Why should I be ‘considered’ of a male’s feelings about treatments to enable them to feed an infant when no one has yet explained the benefit to the child of a male being able to do so?

And yes, every potential compound should be tested for in the secretions from a male, not just nutritional value, amount, consistency etc. I am sure there will be able to be already a long list of substances tested for that female breastmilk is tested for. Including sex hormones and their artificial versions too.

Nothing should be assumed to be at similar level to female breastmilk.

I made that comment because one of your arguments against scientific research was concern that it was "cruel" to transwomen, which seemed at odds with the rest of your posts.

You've just said again here you don't need to be considerate of their feeling, so just reinforcing my point, no?

LemonSwan · 10/06/2022 17:35

professorostrich · 10/06/2022 17:09

Correct.

I suggested outcomes like volume, nutritional content and hormone levels, but that doesn't mean there couldn't be something harmful that no-one has considered.

Sort of like the coronavirus vaccines and the CVST complication.

But surely then you would have to know the full composition of breast milk which they don’t know.

I think you are massively simplifying this. Breast milk isn’t just volume, calories, hormones and a bit of water.

Perhaps you could measure whether it’s a safe comparative to formula.

But until we fully understand breast milk in all its rich varying complexity (changing as babe grows, changing through time of day, reacting to babes illness etc.) then I don’t think it’s possible to even attempt to compare whether it’s the same.

Helleofabore · 10/06/2022 17:33

I mean, you don't seem to be too considered with the feelings of transwomen, but sure.

Why should I be ‘considered’ of a male’s feelings about treatments to enable them to feed an infant when no one has yet explained the benefit to the child of a male being able to do so?

And yes, every potential compound should be tested for in the secretions from a male, not just nutritional value, amount, consistency etc. I am sure there will be able to be already a long list of substances tested for that female breastmilk is tested for. Including sex hormones and their artificial versions too.

Nothing should be assumed to be at similar level to female breastmilk.

professorostrich · 10/06/2022 17:33

I suppose my next question would be why asking for a definition of "comparable" in this context offended you so

It didn't offend me @ReneBumsWombats , but you could've spent a second googling what comparable means in terms of scientific research, instead of immediately assuming going on the agressive because you thought I was implying things about women & TW.

professorostrich · 10/06/2022 17:30

ReneBumsWombats · 10/06/2022 17:25

Thank you, Professor. Was that so hard?

I suppose my next question would be why asking for a definition of "comparable" in this context offended you so and drew baseless accusations against my character, but let's not go there. I don't want to know how we'd devise a clinical study to answer that one.

I'd be very interested in a study that found that, say, a white woman produced more and better milk than an Asian transwoman, and that the difference was down to their ethnicities. Let me know if there is one.

I'd be very interested in a study that found that, say, a white woman produced more and better milk than an Asian transwoman, and that the difference was down to their ethnicities. Let me know if there is one.

Again you seem uncessarily combative on this - SES, ethnicity, weight and I'm sure many other things will be confounders. I'm not definitively stating anything about what demographic groups produce "better milk".

You want scientific evidence to be robust so that criticisms can't be used to invalidate it.

If you found that milk from TW was unsafe, you want to be sure that it couldn't potentially explained by other things (i.e., confounding or bias), so that it could be used to inform policy- for example legisaltion against TW donating milk or whatever.

ReneBumsWombats · 10/06/2022 17:25

professorostrich · 10/06/2022 17:08

Ok - another example @ReneBumsWombats

Say you recruited from a sample of teen mothers where rates of poverty were relatively high, and were comparing them against a group of wealthy white TW.

You would be introducing bias by doing this - the milk outcomes (volume, nutritional content etc) from the women group might be look worse or comparable to that of the TW group becasue of factors like malnutrition.

This could get published and be used as an argument for TW breastfeeding, when in reality it was due to shite study design.

Thank you, Professor. Was that so hard?

I suppose my next question would be why asking for a definition of "comparable" in this context offended you so and drew baseless accusations against my character, but let's not go there. I don't want to know how we'd devise a clinical study to answer that one.

I'd be very interested in a study that found that, say, a white woman produced more and better milk than an Asian transwoman, and that the difference was down to their ethnicities. Let me know if there is one.