Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the NHS had lost the plot over breastfeeding?

303 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 10/06/2022 08:56

www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-10892531/NHS-accused-putting-babies-harm-advice-trans-women-wanting-breastfeed.html

It feels like some kind of bizarre experiment - except it's babies who are being used for affirmation.

Am I being gaslit here?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Helleofabore · 12/06/2022 09:11

What an interesting reaction to this thread.

It seems that very few posters (was there any this time?) support males breastfeeding at this time, when there is no evidence at all about the composition of what is secreted.

Again, not one answer about how this would benefit an infant over donated breastmilk from a female expressing with an infant at a similar developmental stage or formula with it’s known properties.

But there are still posters out there who wish to police language other posters use, often while hypocritically using denigrating language themselves or to express their own negative and unsupported prejudices about MN users.

And I think we can all agree that NHS is failing too many females at this point who need more support for their feeding choices, be it breastfeeding or formula or mixed. When I think of the support I got from breastfeeding clinics in my area, (and they still are) I am very sad to think this is so much a post code lottery.

Hagiography · 11/06/2022 12:58

Bobbin, I'm really sorry to hear that. I wish you'd had better support.

WarriorN · 11/06/2022 12:31

As has already been laboured, why are we prioritising the needs of males to do something that has been demonstrated to be unsuccessful for the infant and so this only benefits the male?

Clymene · 11/06/2022 12:25

God I'm sorry @BobbinHood - that's horrendous

Helleofabore · 11/06/2022 12:19

BobbinHood · 11/06/2022 10:39

Because I’d had it drummed into me at an NHS antenatal breastfeeding class that it was “liquid gold” and life changing, and that I might struggle to bf because I had gestational diabetes and PCOS so it was really important to bring it with me in little syringes, because god forbid my baby might be given a perfectly adequate alternative like formula if it was required. So I spent ages crying over the fucking few millilitres of colostrum that was all I could get out.

Flowers

What an enormous amount of pressure you were put under.

floralarrangement · 11/06/2022 11:20

WarriorN · 11/06/2022 09:36

Why would we design a study to compare breast milk and male nipple secretions?

Who does it benefit?

No is a full sentence.

As has already been laboured, if it was found that hormones/domperidone were present in high quantities, or that the nutritional quality of the milk (or "nipple secretions" as you insist on calling it) was low, that would be valuable information.

It could be used to inform stronger guidance - i.e., transwomen should never attempt to breastfeed, transwomen should not be donating their milk.

Personally I think knowledge (from well conducted research), is power, and don't think research should ever be shut down because someone doesn't like the subject area. As has already been said, funding would likely come from charities, not taxpayers.

BobbinHood · 11/06/2022 10:39

Clymene · 11/06/2022 10:18

Why were you trying to 'harvest ' colostrum before you'd given birth @BobbinHood? Confused

Because I’d had it drummed into me at an NHS antenatal breastfeeding class that it was “liquid gold” and life changing, and that I might struggle to bf because I had gestational diabetes and PCOS so it was really important to bring it with me in little syringes, because god forbid my baby might be given a perfectly adequate alternative like formula if it was required. So I spent ages crying over the fucking few millilitres of colostrum that was all I could get out.

Clymene · 11/06/2022 10:18

Why were you trying to 'harvest ' colostrum before you'd given birth @BobbinHood? Confused

LunaLights · 11/06/2022 10:16

professorostrich · 10/06/2022 18:09

@ReneBumsWombats

I don't understand your posts

They're just dripping with sarcasm and laden with all sorts of implications

Obviously "natal women" "have an advantage" when it comes to producing milk (understatement of the year). No one needs to study that because it's obvious. TW can produce milk with lots of intevention, but there huge questions around amount, safety and nutritional content.

“No one needs to study that because it’s obvious”…..

There are currently a lot of things in this world that I would never have thought needed to be empirically/scientifically studied because they are “obvious”: the inability of human beings to change sex is the first one that comes to mind and yet, here we are!

WarriorN · 11/06/2022 09:36

Why would we design a study to compare breast milk and male nipple secretions?

Who does it benefit?

No is a full sentence.

BobbinHood · 11/06/2022 08:32

SW1amp · 11/06/2022 08:19

@BobbinHood
weird that you would expect a vet to provide that evidence, but ok

and death isn’t the only adverse outcome we should worry about

as the body of evidence around gut health grows, it’s becoming increasingly clear that those early days have a huge bearing on health in later life, and also the connection between gut health and a huge range of illnesses from autoimmune conditions to dementia

It’s weird that a vet was being mentioned at all in a conversation about babies. Don’t you realise that this is my point? And yes death is not the only negative outcome. But death is what the post I was responding to was going on about. All these ignorant mothers not breastfeeding their babies, when everyone knows lambs die if they don’t get colostrum. It’s hyperbole and irrelevant. Also there’s no strong evidence of difference in long term outcomes for babies receiving colostrum after birth vs being supplemented by formula. Which is something I wish I’d known before spending the last 2 weeks of my maternity leave before baby trying to harvest the fucking stuff.

SW1amp · 11/06/2022 08:19

@BobbinHood
weird that you would expect a vet to provide that evidence, but ok

and death isn’t the only adverse outcome we should worry about

as the body of evidence around gut health grows, it’s becoming increasingly clear that those early days have a huge bearing on health in later life, and also the connection between gut health and a huge range of illnesses from autoimmune conditions to dementia

BobbinHood · 11/06/2022 08:13

WorriedWoking · 10/06/2022 23:01

Ah ok, humans aren’t like other mammalian young. I’ll be sure to tell my vet. She’ll disagree, but you’re obviously cleverer than her 🤷🏻‍♀️

Will your vet be able to provide evidence that babies who are given formula rather than colostrum are dying in droves?

WorriedWoking · 10/06/2022 23:01

BobbinHood · 10/06/2022 18:06

Most women do try to initiate breastfeeding, so most babies must be getting some colostrum.

However that’s kind of a moot point anyway since obviously babies do not die if they don’t get colostrum. I’m not a sheep and my baby is not a lamb. I didn’t know this fact about sheep, but it would have had no bearing on my decisions anyway. Since I’m not one.

Ah ok, humans aren’t like other mammalian young. I’ll be sure to tell my vet. She’ll disagree, but you’re obviously cleverer than her 🤷🏻‍♀️

Helleofabore · 10/06/2022 19:06

professorostrich · 10/06/2022 17:57

To be clear @Helleofabore - I did not mention hurt feelings or cruelty to transwomen, you did, as a faux concern against research.

In the next breath you get angry that feelings have been brought up.

This is the only reason it was referenced in my reply to you.

I would also like you to point to the post where I ‘get angry’?

Plus where I have answered you aggressively whereas I did see a ‘ridiculous’ and that I am ‘banging on’ levied at me as well. As well as ‘faux concern’ several times. (And I think that it is cruel to allow a male to go through the process of this research. Just like I think it is cruel for the rhetoric about uterine implants at the moment. )

Helleofabore · 10/06/2022 18:39

Actually I am not ‘determined to have an argument’. However, I am trying to ascertain your motivations in your own ‘aggressive’ posting behaviour.

And yes, I consider it tone policing that you focused on one part of my post, that I have since explained, to call me out on. I do consider that tone policing. If you don’t, then we agree to disagree.

Maybe you could answer my other questions though?

Should I or should I not have to centre male’s wants and feelings above an infant’s in this issue?

And what is the benefit to the child in a male breastfeeding considering we know already that no male body will react to create especially tailored milk for that infant? Even if the quantity was enough, and there was absolutely no harm in the natural hormones, artificial hormones and other medication and body interactions to that substance produced?

What is the benefit to the child to do this when formula and donated breastmilk from lactating females producing milk for an infant at the same developmental stage?

ReneBumsWombats · 10/06/2022 18:38

AgathaAllAlong · 10/06/2022 18:31

@ReneBumsWombats I don't get what the professor ostrich has done to annoy you. I think she's just saying what such a study would look like. You would have to test: volume and nutritional value of the milk; how the babies were growing and developing; their later immunity; chemically analyse the samples. And you would have to do this against a control group of (natal) women of same income, background, habits, access to bf care, to make sure that other variables weren't skewing results. I don't think she meant to cast aspersions on your character.

Idk this stuff is a catch 22. Unethical to do the study as can't give babies potentially harmful substances for research, unethical to give it until it's been researched. Strong reason why no one should ever induce lactation in TW.

She mentioned studying "comparable" lactating women and transwomen.

I immediately thought: "How the heck can they be comparable for this purpose?"

So I asked.

I was told that I didn't understand (clearly, that's why I asked), that I was looking for an argument and that I "wanted" any difference to be down to their natal sexes. Then I got told I should have just Googled the answer.

And now, it seems the Professor actually does say that women lactate better than transwomen, so I don't know why it would be an issue if this is indeed what I "want".

But like I said...enough rational science for one evening.

AgathaAllAlong · 10/06/2022 18:31

@ReneBumsWombats I don't get what the professor ostrich has done to annoy you. I think she's just saying what such a study would look like. You would have to test: volume and nutritional value of the milk; how the babies were growing and developing; their later immunity; chemically analyse the samples. And you would have to do this against a control group of (natal) women of same income, background, habits, access to bf care, to make sure that other variables weren't skewing results. I don't think she meant to cast aspersions on your character.

Idk this stuff is a catch 22. Unethical to do the study as can't give babies potentially harmful substances for research, unethical to give it until it's been researched. Strong reason why no one should ever induce lactation in TW.

ReneBumsWombats · 10/06/2022 18:30

The first scientific question to answer now is why the fuck my paragraphs didn't work. I promise I had some.

I shall look for some comparable HTML.

ReneBumsWombats · 10/06/2022 18:29

The Professor has just said that it's so obvious that females are better at lactating that it requires no research to state it, and that there are currently many questions around the quality and quantity of any milk produced by a transwoman.And yet, when she thought I was implying exactly this by asking how a woman and transwoman might be considered "comparable" for a lactation study, she accused me of not understanding, being argumentative and - the best part - "want[ing] any differences in the milk to be explained by the fact it's from a transwoman than a woman, rather than because of their age or ethnicity etc".Even though she's just stated herself that that's actually a fact. Regardless of what she imagines I "want".I think that's enough rational, objective science for one evening. I'm going to go polish my crystals.

professorostrich · 10/06/2022 18:22

professorostrich · 10/06/2022 16:34

And to all those posters who are keen to have studies done.... how is this to be done ethically without males then feeding infants in the meantime? Or donating milk as at least two males have had the intention of doing that I have read about?

It would be very easy to design a study without involving infants- seems like you're creating problems @Helleofabore

Depends what specific research question you're trying to answer - but the most pressing seems to be "is the milk produced from TW comparable to that of women".

You would recruit a sample of TW & comparable lactating mothers. Follow the protocols referenced for TW. Volumes, nutritional content, presence of hormones etc can then be compared between the two groups.

Is it ethical to induce lactation and then tell that male that they absolutely should not be feeding any infant? Isn't that cruel?

I mean, you don't seem to be too considered with the feelings of transwomen, but sure.

There are plenty of trials & research studies that could be considered "cruel" because they raise hopes which may be dashed. All studies go through an ethics board & stringent checks to make sure harms to participants are minimised and not unacceptable. A study won't be approved if it is deemed unethical.

I've already said all of that @Helleofabore

You seem determined to have an argument

professorostrich · 10/06/2022 18:21

@Helleofabore

It's not "tone policing" to point out that you brought up faux concern for TW feelings as an argument against research. I pointed out this isn't an argument against research.

You then went on the aggressive about me bringing TW feelings into, when clearly I hadn't, I was just responding to your post.

Helleofabore · 10/06/2022 18:17

professorostrich · 10/06/2022 17:56

Because you were the one who brought up transwomen's feelings in the first place? You used them as argument for research to not be done?

Is it ethical to induce lactation and then tell that male that they absolutely should not be feeding any infant? Isn't that cruel?

My reply:

I mean, you don't seem to be too considered with the feelings of transwomen, but sure.

There are plenty of trials & research studies that could be considered "cruel" because they raise hopes which may be dashed. All studies go through an ethics board & stringent checks to make sure harms to participants are minimised and not unacceptable. A study won't be approved if it is deemed unethical.

It seems ridiculous to bring up TW feelings as argument and then start banging on about how they don't matter.

So like other posters, you are just tone policing then?

You and I agree that if robust research where those males are in no way feeding infants the substance that is under investigation, it should go and ahead?

And if any expert disputes the findings, more research should be done before this becomes any way available in the UK? (Because we can only make guidance relevant to this country).

And until that time, males should not be feeding infants from their breasts?

ReneBumsWombats · 10/06/2022 18:10

professorostrich · 10/06/2022 18:09

@ReneBumsWombats

I don't understand your posts

They're just dripping with sarcasm and laden with all sorts of implications

Obviously "natal women" "have an advantage" when it comes to producing milk (understatement of the year). No one needs to study that because it's obvious. TW can produce milk with lots of intevention, but there huge questions around amount, safety and nutritional content.

Oooh.

professorostrich · 10/06/2022 18:09

@ReneBumsWombats

I don't understand your posts

They're just dripping with sarcasm and laden with all sorts of implications

Obviously "natal women" "have an advantage" when it comes to producing milk (understatement of the year). No one needs to study that because it's obvious. TW can produce milk with lots of intevention, but there huge questions around amount, safety and nutritional content.