Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL's response to miscarriage

67 replies

Bootsandcats12 · 10/06/2022 06:23

Hi all,

We discovered at the 12 week scan last week that our baby had no heartbeat and I've gone on to miscarry the pregnancy 😔I've found the whole process absolutely gut wrenching and the miscarriage itself was harrowing.

My in laws are visiting us weekly at the moment to very helpfully provide childcare for DC. I have a good relationship with them for the most part and would consider myself close with them generally.

We decided to email them to explain what was happening as the miscarriage unfolded, as I didn't want them to wonder what was going on and I couldn't face explaining what was happening in person. We'd really hesitated on telling them - partially because they're a bit closed off emotionally and also because when I miscarried previously (at 6 weeks) my MIL just brushed it off and it made me feel rubbish.

I thought I was prepared for the brush off again, and really lowered my expectations in terms of how they might respond but their indifference has just floored me. They arrived to look after DC on Tuesday and MIL didn't even ask how I was - no hug, nothing.

I'm so upset and angry with them that I really want to say something and to let them know (particularly MIL) how she's made me feel. DH can see where I'm coming from and is supportive but thinks there's no point bringing it up with them - he doubts they'll see or understand how they've made me feel and it'll just create tension.

I just feel so let down. My DM died when I was little so I sometimes think I unfairly expect my MIL to fill that void. But really, I just needed a motherly hug when I was going through the miscarriage and I'm not sure how I can get passed her being so cold.

WWYD?

YANBU - be honest and say something to MIL
YABU - lower your expectations and move on

Thanks for reading

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Sceptre86 · 11/06/2022 14:43

I'm sorry for your loss but I think yabu in expecting your mil to fill your mum's void or act in the way you want her too. People show love in different ways, she looked after your children whilst you went through it. I'd argue that is a type of love. Not the same as your experience but when I lost someone close to me my mil came and hugged me, held my hand whilst I cried. My mum bought me tissues, tea and stocked my freezer with meals so I didn't have to cook for a while.

My sil has had two late losses, we don't get along at all but I offered her a hug and she took it. I don't ever mention her miscarriages unless she raises the topic, not because I'm an unfeeling cow but we aren't close and I don't want to upset her further.

You haven't singled out your fil, you've already said that they are a bit emotionally stunted, you emailed them and actually don't sound very close. I don't think you could have expected much more from them tbh. I wouldn't email, next time you speak mention you want her emotional support and see how she responds.

MayMi · 11/06/2022 13:36

So sorry for your loss Flowers

I never really understand when people choose to do nothing after someone has hurt them/caused trouble. The tension has already been created so not saying anything only keeps the burden on you and they just get away with treating you badly.

Why not say something to MIL in a way that's doable for you emotionally right now.

Good luck with everything ❤️

Mustardmusings · 11/06/2022 11:35

By the way my mum said something like oh you can try again or plenty more fish in the sea when I miscarried which I really hated. She didn’t do it to be mean though, just didn’t know what to say.

Mustardmusings · 11/06/2022 11:33

I think it’s nice of them to come and look after your DC and she probably doesn’t know what to say? It’s not worth falling out over.

FWIW I hate people fussing around me and would prefer your MILs approach. Make sure your DH is around for plenty of hugs.

Sorry for your loss. X

littlepeas · 11/06/2022 11:28

Like any hard and horrible life experience people can feel at a loss as to what to do and say. When I miscarried I didn't even tell my mum, as I knew she would unintentionally say something awful while trying to be nice. The people we did tell all responded in ways that I found awkward/annoying, but they didn't do it maliciously, or even thoughtlessly really - they just felt like they needed to say/do something and probably based what they said and did on what they felt they would personally want in the same situation. People respond very differently in these situations. I find that I am able to talk about my miscarriage, but don't really want anything back from people - there is no way that those people can know that unless I tell them. I find it's best not to have expectations of people - look after yourself in any way that you can. Best wishes op.

Knittingnanny2 · 11/06/2022 11:18

I’m very sorry for your loss x
I’m a MIL/ step MIL/stepmum and I always try to pre empt how they would like me to react etc. I was very very aware of how much one of my stepdaughters wanted her late mum when she had miscarriages so I didn’t hug straightaway if you see what I mean. I expressed my sadness though and waited a while before hugging her. Maybe your MIL feels a bit like that?

Bootsandcats12 · 11/06/2022 11:08

Thanks everyone, I'm glad I haven't said anything to MIL as reading through the responses has made me view things in a different light. I think I've unfairly aimed my grief (for the mmc and loss of a mum to support me at this time) at my MIL and as a previous poster has pointed out I shouldn't rely on her for emotional support if she's not that way inclined. Although I have to take responsibility for not giving her the opportunity to respond how I may have wanted because of how we broke the news. At the time, we felt it better than blindsiding them with it in person but perhaps it seems to them like we don't want to address it.

It's interesting to see the different views on miscarriage, having been through it twice and struggled with fertility I just can't imagine not offering my DD or a future DIL a shoulder to lean on if they went through it. But that's just my reaction and not clearly everyone's.

Thank's @Badlifeday I completely agree.

OP posts:
drpet49 · 11/06/2022 09:55

Some people react to an early miscarriage as devastating, others don’t.

Knowing how incredibly common a first trimester miscarriage is - and I had several - I accepted them and moved on. After a couple of days I certainly didn’t expect other people to talk with me about it.

I don’t think she’s necessarily cold. There’s a reason people didn’t used to say anything until after 12 weeks - at least one in five won’t progress to that stage.

^Exactly this

becausetrampslikeus · 11/06/2022 09:51

Also worth remembering that years ago you were encouraged not to think you were. Pregnant until after the first 3 months - you view it differently

SlatsandFlaps · 11/06/2022 09:34

I think YABU why do you need a hug from them? If that's not how they choose to react then that's their choice. They may not feel as emotionally affected as you and that's ok.

With absolute respect, turning this into a bigger thing is not going to help you at all

Ragged · 11/06/2022 09:29

I can see them thinking that it's best not to start a conversation that is going to pointlessly upset you.

Whatever00 · 11/06/2022 09:26

I'm sorry for your loss.

I think you are unreasonable when it comes to your MIL. The older generation would find talking about miscarriage very taboo. It was something that wasn't discussed. Thankfully, things are changing now and people are discussing miscarriage and the physical and emotional impact.

OneFrenchEgg · 11/06/2022 09:17

I agree with @SpiderVersed , sad and disappointing but also private and I would feel you've backed that up by sending an email. Tbh I'd be completely lost as to the required response to an email about a miscarriage.

Babdoc · 11/06/2022 09:16

After I miscarried my first pregnancy, DH and I drove 250 miles to stay with MIL and PIL for Christmas. It was the first time I’d seen them since miscarrying.
Not only was there no mention of it, no sympathy or hug, they were sitting playing with the baby monitor they had bought for their daughter’s imminently expected baby, and seemed to think we would be happy to join in the conversation.
Some people are just emotionally illiterate, OP.

Nutellaspoon · 11/06/2022 09:11

When I had my MMC and other losses I didn't want to speak to anyone about it, I didn't tell anyone at work about my MMC and went in the next day. I'd have hated people to start lots of faux head tilting or worse, hugging. So I tend to treat other people in the same way, I've had colleagues who have had MMC and I've just ignored it, if they want to speak about it they will, until then, dredging it up every 2 mins won't help (in my opinion). Maybe your mil is the same.

Badlifeday · 11/06/2022 09:04

I wondered how long it would be until one of the "hierarchy of grief" posts showed up. Angry
this is not the thread for it.

SpiderVersed · 10/06/2022 10:49

bloodyplanes · 10/06/2022 10:25

I don't think its a generational thing because im in my 40's and my attitude towards it is " its sad and disappointing but its not a fully formed human its a bunch of cells, move on and focus on the future." I most certainly wouldn't want people bringing it up or hugging me. Different people deal with things differently, we can't force people to think and behave as we would.

This!

I’m surprised by people referring to an early miscarriage as “lost a child”.
No, we didn’t.
A pregnancy that might have resulted in a child but didn’t is NOTHING like the death of a child. It’s pretty disrespectful of bereaved parents to conflate the two.

Pragmatism isn’t being cold.

Dishwashersaurous · 10/06/2022 10:32

People are generally a bit shit at dealing with anything to do with grief and loss.

If people are not good at handling their own emotions then dealing with other people's emotions is impossible for them.

These people just ignore bad things and pretend they didn't happen as their default coping mechanism.

It's a horrendous situation and honestly unless people have been through it they just don't get it.

I hope that younhave friends who you can talk to and get support from. You need to accept that you won't get it from your in laws. That's who they are and no point trying to change them or getting frustrated with them.

bloodyplanes · 10/06/2022 10:25

I don't think its a generational thing because im in my 40's and my attitude towards it is " its sad and disappointing but its not a fully formed human its a bunch of cells, move on and focus on the future." I most certainly wouldn't want people bringing it up or hugging me. Different people deal with things differently, we can't force people to think and behave as we would.

10HailMarys · 10/06/2022 10:11

People also say "her generation" but at no point can I see the OP mention her age - she could be 45 to 85!

It's really only very recently that miscarriage has been something people have been encouraged to talk about openly. I'm in my mid-40s and only found out very recently that a lovely relative of mine, who is 15 years older than me, had several miscarriages in her 30s. The women in my family are all really warm and open and supportive about most things and will happily talk about really personal stuff, but the only person in the family who knew (other than her own mum) was my mum - and that was only because my mum is super close to her as she practically brought her up in her early years.

10HailMarys · 10/06/2022 10:02

First of all, I'm so sorry you've had to go through the experience of miscarriage. All my sympathies go out to you.

I can completely understand why you feel hurt by your in-laws lack of reaction. However, you do say that you generally have a good relationship with them and that you do feel you're fairly close, so it seems highly unlikely that they're being deliberately hurtful. From what you've said, it sounds to me like they just absolutely do not have a clue what to say or how to address it. Some people are very much like that, and just clam up in emotional situations, or think that the best way to deal with things is to brush them under the carpet, or are really uneasy in situations where they feel powerless to do anything, and simply don't know what else to do but pretend it's not happening. I also think that miscarriage itself is something that in your PILs' generation was quite a taboo subject, something that people kept secret and private and didn't talk about or acknowledge, so it might feel very alien to them to be open about it. I'm in my mid-40s and I know that even when I was a young child in the 80s, 'miscarriage' was one of those words that people would whisper mid-sentence because it was considered such a personal/private thing.

You also say in your post that your DH emailed them because you 'couldn't face telling them in person', so I think it's also possible that they genuinely felt that you wouldn't want to talk about it and that mentioning it would make you more upset. Plus, you acknowledge that they are quite emotionally closed-off in general - that doesn't mean they don't feel bad for you, but it does mean they have no idea how to show it.

I also think the fact that it's your MIL that you're most angry with is definitely very much connected with the loss of your own mum. I think perhaps a lot of your grief over your mum, and your recent miscarriages, is probably being diverted into anger at the moment, and I don't think it would help you or your relationship with your MIL if you confront her.

hoomaeyya · 10/06/2022 09:54

The sort of person who would prefer a reaction like that but understand that is rare!

Sorry for your loss, so horrible.

hoomaeyya · 10/06/2022 09:54

Do you think perhaps they weren't sure of what to say and they didn't want to bring it up and upset you?

I'm the sort of person who w

Feelingoktoday · 10/06/2022 09:00

I lost my mum when I was young. I’m a lot older than you. I learnt that no one else will be your mum. I thought I could get close to my ex mil and be like a daughter to her. I thought that too with aunts and friends mums. People are polite of course but they are not your mum. I’m sorry for your loss. Lean on your DH.

LizzieSiddal · 10/06/2022 08:57

The OP has said her MIL has told her she hasn’t had a miscarriage but I’ve said that to many people (I’m in my 50s) because I really do not want to talk about my 3 miscarriages to anyone apart from DH.