Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is MIL

96 replies

Blonde35 · 10/06/2022 01:32

My OH and I have been together for over 2 years. I live here in the UK, he lives in the US.

We see each other every couple of months and speak every night. However it’s now reached the point where we want to live together (or at least in the same country!) and have a future together.

He has no children. He rents, he has a good job but it’s not a career to him (he likes it but will happily leave it). He has a big family who are close, but he visits his mum maybe once a month or so.

I have 2 children, own my home outright and have a career that I love. No family.

OH wants to move here and I agree.

MIL told me not to tell him but if he moves here it will “break her”. He has told her he is moving and has tried to discuss plans, she says “all I heard is he’s moving and I can’t listen to anymore”.

I think MIL is being ridiculous. I can understand she wants her son to stay in the same country, but her attitude towards it is childish and also offensive. She asked my 12yo if she wants to move. 12yo too polite to say anything so says she’s not sure. MIL says to her “I think it’s best if you all move here”. I found this manipulative.

we have worked out the sums and moving to the US is unaffordable. I don’t want to pay for healthcare or move my kids to another country. I would have to retrain to do my job there (2 years at uni and thousands of dollars to get a job I already do here!!!).

MIL says I should sell my house, give my cats up for rehoming and move over before school restarts end August. She wants me to be home help for her husband (he is unwell from cancer, remission but ongoing symptoms). She says we can live with her until we find a place but my cats can’t. (I’ve had my cats for 16 years! No way am I giving them up, she says I should just get another cat when I move out of hers)

I think MIL is selfish and unreasonable.

i don’t want to move and think OH should move here. He wants to move here.

AIBU?

OP posts:
JustJoinedRightNow · 14/06/2022 22:17

Yep this has definitely been posted before and got a lot of replies.

WishILivedInThrushGreen · 14/06/2022 22:17

Even the two Blondes cats are the same age!

NoSquirrels · 14/06/2022 22:46

You’re not moving to the US.

Now it’s up to your fella to decide if he’s moving to the U.K.

So nothing for you and his mum to discuss. Tell her that. Stop acting like she’s a decision maker with power or a say in this. It’s all up to your bloke.

SmartCarDriver · 14/06/2022 22:58

WishILivedInThrushGreen · 14/06/2022 22:17

Even the two Blondes cats are the same age!

Amazing coincidence as OP had never posted about this before.....

Hmm 🤔

Blonde35 · 14/06/2022 23:31

Never posted before, but I can see the similarities after skimming the other thread.

Just a side note, my best friend is also blonde with a 16 year old cat, so we aren't a rare breed lol (although she also has dogs and a UK boyfriend)

He isn't "just a man I've been talking to online", I don't know why mumsnet is so anti LDR, if I lived in Scotland and he lived in wales would our relationship be any different? One of my best friends has been married over a decade to a man who works away for months at a time and always has. Is their relationship fake too?

He was able to fly here during the travel ban, as we didn't ban visitors all he required was covid tests. He flew over a few times but i didn't fly over until Dec 21, I flew again in February. He flew March and may.

It isn't sustainable as he has to take unpaid leave to fly (he only has 10 days annual leave) and he also has to help pay for my tickets as I can’t afford it, I have the annual leave but not the money.

Anyway thank you for the advice, I have stopped engaging with her.

OP posts:
SmartCarDriver · 14/06/2022 23:33

Blonde35 · 14/06/2022 23:31

Never posted before, but I can see the similarities after skimming the other thread.

Just a side note, my best friend is also blonde with a 16 year old cat, so we aren't a rare breed lol (although she also has dogs and a UK boyfriend)

He isn't "just a man I've been talking to online", I don't know why mumsnet is so anti LDR, if I lived in Scotland and he lived in wales would our relationship be any different? One of my best friends has been married over a decade to a man who works away for months at a time and always has. Is their relationship fake too?

He was able to fly here during the travel ban, as we didn't ban visitors all he required was covid tests. He flew over a few times but i didn't fly over until Dec 21, I flew again in February. He flew March and may.

It isn't sustainable as he has to take unpaid leave to fly (he only has 10 days annual leave) and he also has to help pay for my tickets as I can’t afford it, I have the annual leave but not the money.

Anyway thank you for the advice, I have stopped engaging with her.

Dora's your friend also have an American boyfriend and over bearing future MIL?

IFeelItInMyFingersIFeelItInMy · 14/06/2022 23:48

What is your age bracket OP and that of your future MIL? I find the whole dynamic reads like something a young couple is going through (along with an overbearing MIL), but the way you are conveying the scenario and the way your MIL is acting, it feels like you are all a bit more mature.

KettrickenSmiled · 15/06/2022 00:52

if I lived in Scotland and he lived in wales would our relationship be any different?
Errr ... yeah? 'cos it's not a long international flight away, & you could see each other every weekend?

He flew over a few times but i didn't fly over until Dec 21, I flew again in February. He flew March and may.
So you've actually met half a dozen times, but you are in lurrrrve, you are going to move him in with your DC, & marry him to get him a visa?

Anycrispsleft · 15/06/2022 06:55

Why are people pointing out that the relationship is not a mature one as if that was going to be a killer argument against the OP's plans? She met someone nice, if they want to take their relationship to the next level, to do that one of them has to move, and it might not work out that's true, so who should move, the woman with house and a daughter in school and a job she loves or the bloke who is renting his flat and doesn't mind changing jobs?

girlmom21 · 15/06/2022 06:56

Anycrispsleft · 15/06/2022 06:55

Why are people pointing out that the relationship is not a mature one as if that was going to be a killer argument against the OP's plans? She met someone nice, if they want to take their relationship to the next level, to do that one of them has to move, and it might not work out that's true, so who should move, the woman with house and a daughter in school and a job she loves or the bloke who is renting his flat and doesn't mind changing jobs?

She has children and wants to move a man in she's met a dozen times. That's why.

KettrickenSmiled · 15/06/2022 07:40

so who should move, the woman with house and a daughter in school and a job she loves or the bloke who is renting his flat and doesn't mind changing jobs?

It's not a question of location @Anycrispsleft
The bloke could live in the States, New Zealand or on the moon.
OP has met him a handful of times, & based on that, she is going to install him into her home with her DC.

It's so irresponsible & desperate that I mainly think this whole thread is a tease.

Blonde35 · 15/06/2022 09:48

I am 35, he is 34. MIL is late 50s.

After not speaking to her for all of 2 days, she sent a message "this will be my last attempt" last night. This morning I woke up and she'd d made a Facebook status (yes status) simply saying "ignoring me will get you so far, no comments necessary". I find this ridiculously immature.

So yes this year so far we have seen each other 4 times, he is coming end of June so that's 5 months out of 6. Last year we saw each other less, probably every couple of months. We do speak constantly but appreciate this isn't the same as living together of course.

I've seen him more this year than my friend has seen her husband who works away... everyone keeps ignoring this. She met him when he was doing the same job so their entire marriage (over 10 years) she has seen him less than half the year but apparently her marriage is ok and mine wouldn't be?? And yes they lived together within a year or so and yes have children... just happens that she lives in the uk and he works abroad.

In order to maintain the relationship one of us has to move. Given that I have so much to lose and children in school, I feel it should be him and he agrees. The stumbling block is MIL who last week told me if I got pregnant she is "admittedly a controlling granny and you wouldn't be able to do anything right" and tells me her other grandchildren love her more than their own mum, this alarms me! She won't accept OH moving over and is constantly interfering and trying to put stumbling blocks in the way. I don't want to ruin his relationship with his mum. I also don't want the drama of if we get married her refusing to attend or causing issues etc.

She is very controlling - when I visited last time she told me I was staying, that we could get married that week and then I could stay permanently. I said er no.. and left of course. She said she is sick of the back and forth about who is moving so she made the decision! After that I told OH to stop telling her everything. He tells her all of our problems and I find it too much.. he needs to cut the apron strings. It's one thing wanting advice, it's another telling her everything about our relationship then moaning when she interferes.

OP posts:
KettrickenSmiled · 15/06/2022 09:59

Christ on a bike give it a rest OP.
YOU are the one manufacturing all this pointless melodrama.
If you just stopped communicating with her & blocked her, there would be no problem at all.

also don't want the drama of if we get married her refusing to attend
See what I mean?
Why would her NOT being there cause drama?
You must just love the thought of it all kicking off, because you seem unable to let it go.

You are a grown up. You can marry this man if you want. You can cut the comms with his mother if you want. What's she going to do about it? - you live 3000+ miles away.

Good luck installing a brand new man they didn't ask for into your kids' home.

WhenDovesFly · 15/06/2022 10:35

The other poster is also 35 with two kids, one of them 12. Just what are the chances eh? You should contact strawhatblonde OP, because she's going through exactly the same thing as you.

By the way, can you let me know what job you do that gives you 15-16 weeks holiday per year? I'd like a job like that too.

HELLITHURT · 15/06/2022 10:42

Blonde35 · 15/06/2022 09:48

I am 35, he is 34. MIL is late 50s.

After not speaking to her for all of 2 days, she sent a message "this will be my last attempt" last night. This morning I woke up and she'd d made a Facebook status (yes status) simply saying "ignoring me will get you so far, no comments necessary". I find this ridiculously immature.

So yes this year so far we have seen each other 4 times, he is coming end of June so that's 5 months out of 6. Last year we saw each other less, probably every couple of months. We do speak constantly but appreciate this isn't the same as living together of course.

I've seen him more this year than my friend has seen her husband who works away... everyone keeps ignoring this. She met him when he was doing the same job so their entire marriage (over 10 years) she has seen him less than half the year but apparently her marriage is ok and mine wouldn't be?? And yes they lived together within a year or so and yes have children... just happens that she lives in the uk and he works abroad.

In order to maintain the relationship one of us has to move. Given that I have so much to lose and children in school, I feel it should be him and he agrees. The stumbling block is MIL who last week told me if I got pregnant she is "admittedly a controlling granny and you wouldn't be able to do anything right" and tells me her other grandchildren love her more than their own mum, this alarms me! She won't accept OH moving over and is constantly interfering and trying to put stumbling blocks in the way. I don't want to ruin his relationship with his mum. I also don't want the drama of if we get married her refusing to attend or causing issues etc.

She is very controlling - when I visited last time she told me I was staying, that we could get married that week and then I could stay permanently. I said er no.. and left of course. She said she is sick of the back and forth about who is moving so she made the decision! After that I told OH to stop telling her everything. He tells her all of our problems and I find it too much.. he needs to cut the apron strings. It's one thing wanting advice, it's another telling her everything about our relationship then moaning when she interferes.

Where are your children when you are visiting so much?

Blonde35 · 15/06/2022 12:53

I don't like drama at all, I've been very laid back with her and look how she acts when I don't speak to her for a couple of days! It would be drama if she's not at the wedding because that's her son, she will never let him forget it and he wants his mum there. I doubt she'd refuse to come but she will definitely want to control it all.

All I get is attacked on this thread so I'm not going to waste my time.
Heaven forbid somebody meets a man who doesn't live in their country....!

OP posts:
Shinyandnew1 · 15/06/2022 13:01

The stumbling block is MIL who last week told me if I got pregnant she is "admittedly a controlling granny and you wouldn't be able to do anything right"

You speak to this woman-your boyfriend’s mum-more than I speak to my mother in law of 25 years! How are you communicating- do you ring her? Does she ring you?!

luckylavender · 15/06/2022 13:09

Blonde35 · 10/06/2022 01:32

My OH and I have been together for over 2 years. I live here in the UK, he lives in the US.

We see each other every couple of months and speak every night. However it’s now reached the point where we want to live together (or at least in the same country!) and have a future together.

He has no children. He rents, he has a good job but it’s not a career to him (he likes it but will happily leave it). He has a big family who are close, but he visits his mum maybe once a month or so.

I have 2 children, own my home outright and have a career that I love. No family.

OH wants to move here and I agree.

MIL told me not to tell him but if he moves here it will “break her”. He has told her he is moving and has tried to discuss plans, she says “all I heard is he’s moving and I can’t listen to anymore”.

I think MIL is being ridiculous. I can understand she wants her son to stay in the same country, but her attitude towards it is childish and also offensive. She asked my 12yo if she wants to move. 12yo too polite to say anything so says she’s not sure. MIL says to her “I think it’s best if you all move here”. I found this manipulative.

we have worked out the sums and moving to the US is unaffordable. I don’t want to pay for healthcare or move my kids to another country. I would have to retrain to do my job there (2 years at uni and thousands of dollars to get a job I already do here!!!).

MIL says I should sell my house, give my cats up for rehoming and move over before school restarts end August. She wants me to be home help for her husband (he is unwell from cancer, remission but ongoing symptoms). She says we can live with her until we find a place but my cats can’t. (I’ve had my cats for 16 years! No way am I giving them up, she says I should just get another cat when I move out of hers)

I think MIL is selfish and unreasonable.

i don’t want to move and think OH should move here. He wants to move here.

AIBU?

If you've been together for 2 years, you cannot have seen each other every couple of months. That doesn't stack up.

Sapphirensteel · 15/06/2022 13:49

MIL has had her life, lived the choices she made, she doesn’t get to make other adults choices for them.
30 /40 years ago, before FaceTime, Zoom, Skype et al I can understand that moving to another country meant you didn’t see the other person or even speak much ( my cousin emigrated to Oz in the 60s, his parents called him at Christmas and on his birthday. They had to book a call with BT and it cost a bomb) But she can see him most days, talk to him etc… She’s being very selfish.
Stick to your decision.

KettrickenSmiled · 15/06/2022 15:59

Heaven forbid somebody meets a man who doesn't live in their country....!

Nobody cares where he lives or where you met him.
Many are just gobsmacked that you plan to install a man you've met - what? 6 - 12 times? - into your DC's home.

But sure, make it all about his mother, & the amount of pointless drama you insist you are unable to disengage from.

NumberTheory · 15/06/2022 17:12

You’re giving your MiL far too much headspace. It’s for your DP to decide if he wants to move or not. You and DP have discussed and come to a decision. For what it’s worth unless you had little choice, I think you would be a bloody idiot and a poor parent to uproot your kids and move country for your partner if you haven’t even lived with the man yet. If your DP ends up not wanting to move that will be a shame, but it wouldn’t change the fact you have a couple of other people to prioritise over his or your feelings and certainly over MiL’s.

It’s understandable that your MiL doesn’t want him to move. But she doesn’t get that sort of control and it’s out of order for her to pretend she’s very supportive of your DP’s choices but secretly be trying to manipulate you and your children into changing the decision that’s been made. Tell her you won’t second guess your DP and she needs to speak to her son if she wants him to know. Don’t start your marriage out on a shaky foundation by letting her think she can get to him and manipulate him through you.

It’s fine to be chatty and involved with your in-laws, but when they try and make you do what they want instead of what you want you need to be able compartmentalise a bit and put their emotions and desires in perspective, prioritising your emotions and desires. It’s your life you’re leading here.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page