Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is MIL

96 replies

Blonde35 · 10/06/2022 01:32

My OH and I have been together for over 2 years. I live here in the UK, he lives in the US.

We see each other every couple of months and speak every night. However it’s now reached the point where we want to live together (or at least in the same country!) and have a future together.

He has no children. He rents, he has a good job but it’s not a career to him (he likes it but will happily leave it). He has a big family who are close, but he visits his mum maybe once a month or so.

I have 2 children, own my home outright and have a career that I love. No family.

OH wants to move here and I agree.

MIL told me not to tell him but if he moves here it will “break her”. He has told her he is moving and has tried to discuss plans, she says “all I heard is he’s moving and I can’t listen to anymore”.

I think MIL is being ridiculous. I can understand she wants her son to stay in the same country, but her attitude towards it is childish and also offensive. She asked my 12yo if she wants to move. 12yo too polite to say anything so says she’s not sure. MIL says to her “I think it’s best if you all move here”. I found this manipulative.

we have worked out the sums and moving to the US is unaffordable. I don’t want to pay for healthcare or move my kids to another country. I would have to retrain to do my job there (2 years at uni and thousands of dollars to get a job I already do here!!!).

MIL says I should sell my house, give my cats up for rehoming and move over before school restarts end August. She wants me to be home help for her husband (he is unwell from cancer, remission but ongoing symptoms). She says we can live with her until we find a place but my cats can’t. (I’ve had my cats for 16 years! No way am I giving them up, she says I should just get another cat when I move out of hers)

I think MIL is selfish and unreasonable.

i don’t want to move and think OH should move here. He wants to move here.

AIBU?

OP posts:
ILoveYoga · 10/06/2022 06:28

I’m an American married to a Brit and moved moved here with one child to be with him.

yes, MIL has a point BUT so do you. There are far more implications in this scenario than just MIL and her needs. Your career, livelihood, your children’s education and safety, healthcare and social needs are also important.

what you do need is leeway that your OH can have the freedom to go back to visit as and when needed without qualms. You’ll need to agree to meet the cost of the flights and home away when needed. On my way to have happy medium to fulfill his role as son and as husband/stepdad here.

my DH and I have been married close to 40 years, in addition to my Child (from previous relationship) moved here with, we had more children together. (My DH is fully a father to my child, now an adult). I did have times where I had to leave quickly due to family emergencies back in usa, I used to also spend set times annually to do my part in caring for elderly relation, had to leave short notice (and expense) for funerals too. But that is the price of living far away. However, it is also as similar as living on different coasts within the USA.

there are also two VERY BIG reasons I would NEVER want to live in USA again and as a mother, if I had children, no way ever

GUNS. Children have to live with active shooter drills. With all these s hook shootings or mass shootings out and about, no way

health care. No way. Their health care system is seriously failing. Unless you’re amazingly wealthy, a serious health issue can bankrupt you or the care you (your child) may need you can’t get if your insurance e don’t come dr it or co pay is astronomical. Far too many people I know have had to deal with this. No way would I ever move back.

12Thorns · 10/06/2022 06:21

I think MIL has a fair point. It would be fine if her son was moving away temporarily, or for a job, but moving to move on with a stranger and her children- it’s crazy

girlmom21 · 10/06/2022 06:14

So you've actually met a grand total of 12 times and you're already letting his mother manipulate your children? If he's not prepared to stand up to her then why would you consider any of this?

MistyRuins · 10/06/2022 05:56

I think MIL is being ridiculous. I can understand she wants her son to stay in the same country, but her attitude towards it is childish and also offensive

I think you attitude towards her is childish and offensive. Her husband has cancer, her son is planning to mine hundreds of miles away. Can't you see how those things out together will be difficult to deal with?

Yanbu to think him moving here is the better option.

Yabu to be so dismissive of how she feels. She is fully entitled to feel the way she does, and she clearly recognises that it is for her son to decide as she doesn't want him to know.

You sound completely unsympathetic and selfish.

Pinot4me · 10/06/2022 05:54

I am sure she is gutted that her son is leaving. Desperate people do desperate things. She is going about it the wrong way by involving your kids.

Mally100 · 10/06/2022 05:48

LaurieFairyCake · 10/06/2022 04:30

Stop talking to her, she's your boyfriends mum - she's literally nothing to you

He's a grown up, he can decide to move

This, what she says is irrelevant. Ignore her, any stop allowing your kids to speak to her. She's nobody to them and vice versa.

SmartCarDriver · 10/06/2022 05:43

Giraffesandbottoms · 10/06/2022 05:37

Ffs you always post. You’ve met him twice or something, and want to move him in with your children.

This

Giraffesandbottoms · 10/06/2022 05:37

Ffs you always post. You’ve met him twice or something, and want to move him in with your children.

IDreamOfTheMoors · 10/06/2022 05:31

She isn’t your mother-in-law if you aren’t married.
And now that the others mention it, I most certainly do remember you.

I remember the answers to your question being the same, too.

Billybagpuss · 10/06/2022 05:24

Also, re: healthcare. You get what you pay for. I'll leave it at that

No British person has ever been bankrupt through inability to pay healthcare bills.

I’ve had 2 kids one through caesarean and special care, I’ve had a major operation, my DH had cancer. How much did it cost me - nothing that’s how much. We are fit and healthy and yes the NHS has its problems but it’s bloody well there when it matters and if you can afford it and don’t want to wait, private is available here too.

Hollyhocksarenotmessy · 10/06/2022 05:23

This is all very hypothetical because from what you posted, neither of you have a chance in hell of getting a visa to move to each others country.

Have you even looked into that?

autienotnaughty · 10/06/2022 05:23

I would be nice and say oh he will miss you too and we will have lovely hols visiting you etc.Then drop it it your guys decision nothing to do with her.

WibblyWobblyJane · 10/06/2022 05:16

Of course she wants her son to stay close. But it’s his decision and not yours nor hers.

Mothership4two · 10/06/2022 05:15

It's between the two of you. I wouldn't be discussing it with her at all

LaurieFairyCake · 10/06/2022 04:30

Stop talking to her, she's your boyfriends mum - she's literally nothing to you

He's a grown up, he can decide to move

whateveryouwantmetosay · 10/06/2022 04:27

I'm just going to give you a practical response as an American married to a British person.

Your MIL has a point. Family is number 1. You have your kids (who can move) but no one else. Asking OH to leave his entire (big) family may sound like the best decision on paper but in reality, it's not. You need family close by. If you have they option, take it. Trust me.

Also, re: healthcare. You get what you pay for. I'll leave it at that.

Flederjo · 10/06/2022 03:56

deirdreshere · 10/06/2022 01:54

Haven't you posted this exact thing before? Pretty much word for word

Yep, I also think she's posted this whole thing before. I seem to remember a long thread.

Boxowine · 10/06/2022 01:58

Is she willing to cosign for an apartment for you?

deirdreshere · 10/06/2022 01:54

Haven't you posted this exact thing before? Pretty much word for word

Stompythedinosaur · 10/06/2022 01:48

I don't think I'd be discussing it with her any further tbh. Just say, "me and dp have chatted about it and agree he is moving here."

FlissyPaps · 10/06/2022 01:46

Your OH is a grown ass adult and he has the right to do whatever he wants with his life.

Of course his mother will miss him if he moves country. But that is something she should be telling him. Not you and your children.

Try and not take her words to heart.