Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is MIL

96 replies

Blonde35 · 10/06/2022 01:32

My OH and I have been together for over 2 years. I live here in the UK, he lives in the US.

We see each other every couple of months and speak every night. However it’s now reached the point where we want to live together (or at least in the same country!) and have a future together.

He has no children. He rents, he has a good job but it’s not a career to him (he likes it but will happily leave it). He has a big family who are close, but he visits his mum maybe once a month or so.

I have 2 children, own my home outright and have a career that I love. No family.

OH wants to move here and I agree.

MIL told me not to tell him but if he moves here it will “break her”. He has told her he is moving and has tried to discuss plans, she says “all I heard is he’s moving and I can’t listen to anymore”.

I think MIL is being ridiculous. I can understand she wants her son to stay in the same country, but her attitude towards it is childish and also offensive. She asked my 12yo if she wants to move. 12yo too polite to say anything so says she’s not sure. MIL says to her “I think it’s best if you all move here”. I found this manipulative.

we have worked out the sums and moving to the US is unaffordable. I don’t want to pay for healthcare or move my kids to another country. I would have to retrain to do my job there (2 years at uni and thousands of dollars to get a job I already do here!!!).

MIL says I should sell my house, give my cats up for rehoming and move over before school restarts end August. She wants me to be home help for her husband (he is unwell from cancer, remission but ongoing symptoms). She says we can live with her until we find a place but my cats can’t. (I’ve had my cats for 16 years! No way am I giving them up, she says I should just get another cat when I move out of hers)

I think MIL is selfish and unreasonable.

i don’t want to move and think OH should move here. He wants to move here.

AIBU?

OP posts:
JellyBellyNelly · 10/06/2022 10:41

There’s just something about this thread that’s off. I’m not sure what though.

NoSquirrels · 10/06/2022 10:36

I cannot see what the problem is?

You want to stay.
He wants to come.
His mother is controlling, wants you to be a nurse so she doesn’t have to, and there’s literally no benefit in any of it for you.

Why is it even an issue?

Blonde35 · 10/06/2022 10:33

dont know him? Glorified pen pal?

goodness. So in your opinion how does anyone ever have a relationship with someone who doesn’t live in the UK then?

my friend has been married 12 years and the entire time her husband has worked away for 4 months at a time. Does that mean her marriage isn’t valid?

came on here for support and get ridiculed and belittled… not worth it.

OP posts:
Ragwort · 10/06/2022 10:32

This is almost exactly word for word the same situation that was posted recently... I can't believe that's a coincidence? Hmm.

Just back off, you barely know this man, what example are you setting your DC if you are even considering living with (let alone having a child with) a glorified pen-pal. Shock.

If you must persist in this 'relationship' then just don't engage with his mother, you don't need to talk to her.

Blonde35 · 10/06/2022 10:31

Yes. I earn enough to sponsor him. I own my house outright so accommodation criteria is met. My kids are British citizens so aren’t subject to the income requirement. He also has enough savings to pay for his flights and the time it takes to get a spouse visa which enables him to work, plus the costs of the visa. He has about 25k saved and is still saving.

OP posts:
CharSiu · 10/06/2022 10:25

I have two friends that married men from America and Canada, both ended in divorce. Without detail one had a child from her previous marriage who as a young adult has extreme anxiety.

Not focussing on the drama, the he said she said of it all which runs through your post in the first instance. Do you as a couple meet the financial requirements for him to even be able to get a spousal visa?

Blonde35 · 10/06/2022 10:18

Also just to jump in again sorry still reading replies.

understand his mum wants him to stay there, of course she does. I don’t like her flippant attitude with me, telling me to give up everything and move when I have so much more to lose than he does. She might as well say “I don’t care what you have to lose, just get here so he stays” because that’s what she really means.

his mum wants me to move in to her house and be the nurse to her husband. I dont want to do this (I’m also not a physical health nurse! She seems to forget that). She says she’s not ready to be a carer and now he’s getting older she is thinking about his future needs.

OH doesn’t care about his job, whereas I love my career. He has no ties to the US outside of his family. He rents. I own my home without a mortgage and have 2 kids in school, plus pets and friends. OH doesnt really have any friends, he has only one whom he sees twice a year. He is really keen to move, if anything it’s me telling him to think about his family.

it is going to be hard - I don’t earn good money and he knows this. But just because we live in different countries does that mean we can’t have a relationship? Why does it mean our relationship isn’t real, just because I don’t see him every week? My best friends husband works away abroad for 4 months at a time, home for a bit and away for 4 again… does that mean she barely knows him? He’s done that since they met.

OP posts:
Blonde35 · 10/06/2022 10:10

Haven’t posted before so not sure where that’s come from.

its his stepdad not dad who had cancer, he is in remission and has been for some years, he isn’t likely to die soon as a pp suggested.

i can’t count the exact days but I spent just under 14 weeks there since the borders reopened. He was able to visit several times as our borders didn’t shut to visitors.

i get a lot of annual leave (15-16 weeks) but he does not, so he was having to take unpaid leave. That’s another reason why moving makes sense.

we are not strangers as pp suggests - international relationships do happen and do work, not easy and not often but they do. We have to make a lot of effort, we speak every night (usually for a couple of hours, catching up on how our days have been etc) and when we see each other we have to make the most of it. However I’ve had UK relationships where I haven’t seen my partner much more often due to work patterns!

OP posts:
AnneLovesGilbert · 10/06/2022 10:01

Didn’t you get enough advice on your many other threads? Why don’t you listen? Listen!

Blonde35 · 10/06/2022 09:58

Still reading the replies but just jumping in, we would be getting married so he would come on a fiancé then spouse visa here. I wouldn’t move over there so didn’t look into it, but last time I went there on holiday MIL told me to just stay and get married!

i don’t have family but I do have a huge support network of friends and their families. Family is who we choose I suppose.

my other concern is we would want a child in future. MIL has freely admitted she is “controlling and I wouldn’t be able to do anything right” but she would be really hands on too, so I’m torn about that

OP posts:
AWobABobBob · 10/06/2022 07:38

I'm sure this exact thread has been posted before...

ladydimitrescu · 10/06/2022 07:35

Every couple months, over 2 years, so around 12 times you've actually met this man, and now he's moving in with your kids? That's a bigger issue than his mum.

KellyJonesLeatherTrousers · 10/06/2022 07:33

She’s not your MIL. He’s barely even your boyfriend if you see each other once every 2 months.

Definitely don’t uproot your children across the world for this new relationship - I know you say it’s 2 years but you’ve not spent a lot of time together. See how he copes with moving over here, ideally in separate accommodation for 6 months to see if a) it’s a viable relationship b) he likes it here.

ladydimitrescu · 10/06/2022 07:33

How many times have you actually met? Or your kids?
She's not your MIL she's your boyfriends mum.
Personally think it's ridiculous to move him In when as far as i remember from your previous threads, you've met him a handful of times.

Howshouldibehave · 10/06/2022 07:32

You’ve been together for two years-the world was locked down for most of that! How many days have you spent together?!

I wouldn’t be giving up my job and moving across the world to be her husband’s career, no. Stop engaging with her about ur-that’s her issue.

Do you really know this man though?

girlmom21 · 10/06/2022 07:28

@Imsittinginthekitchensink I meant standing up to her about her manipulating his girlfriends children, not about her wanting him, completely understandably, to stay in his home country.

Everything you say is completely right.

TestingTestingWonTooFree · 10/06/2022 07:20

whateveryouwantmetosay · 10/06/2022 04:27

I'm just going to give you a practical response as an American married to a British person.

Your MIL has a point. Family is number 1. You have your kids (who can move) but no one else. Asking OH to leave his entire (big) family may sound like the best decision on paper but in reality, it's not. You need family close by. If you have they option, take it. Trust me.

Also, re: healthcare. You get what you pay for. I'll leave it at that.

They need family nearby so they can look after MIL’s partner? 🤔Family is great if it’s the right family. It sounds like OP has done ok without that support so far.

toomuchlaundry · 10/06/2022 07:18

Has it been easy to see each other in the last 2 years during the pandemic?

Belephant · 10/06/2022 07:15

@Copernico I must have read some dodgy info then - I thought the price I was reading for the Lido wing seemed too good to be true tbh🤣

thesunwillout · 10/06/2022 07:13

I've definitely read this before.

Imsittinginthekitchensink · 10/06/2022 07:11

girlmom21 · 10/06/2022 06:14

So you've actually met a grand total of 12 times and you're already letting his mother manipulate your children? If he's not prepared to stand up to her then why would you consider any of this?

I think more to the point, they've met a grand total of 12 times and she's insisting the man uproot himself, leave his home, job, country and family and move him in with her school age children.
And you took from all that that the man isn't standing up to his mother?

NoSquirrels · 10/06/2022 07:05

i don’t want to move and think OH should move here. He wants to move here.

There’s no problem then.

Copernico · 10/06/2022 07:02

Private healthcare definitely isn’t cheaper in the UK! Or rather, what is cheaper is limited. Private insurance here doesn’t cover pre-existing conditions, unlike in the US.

That said there’s a lot of variety in plans in the US. I had a baby in the US, had an EMCS and complications and my week long stay in a private room and all my care was about $200 (employeer-paid insurance).

Expecting my second baby in the UK and I’d much rather pay $200 than have the care I’ve had here. Unfortunately the Lindo wing is a bit pricier than that!

To the OP’s point it’s perfectly reasonable to want to stay in the UK for whatever reason she wants to.

Belephant · 10/06/2022 06:47

Billybagpuss · 10/06/2022 05:24

Also, re: healthcare. You get what you pay for. I'll leave it at that

No British person has ever been bankrupt through inability to pay healthcare bills.

I’ve had 2 kids one through caesarean and special care, I’ve had a major operation, my DH had cancer. How much did it cost me - nothing that’s how much. We are fit and healthy and yes the NHS has its problems but it’s bloody well there when it matters and if you can afford it and don’t want to wait, private is available here too.

Also, isn't even private healthcare cheaper in the UK? I don't know anything about US healthcare other than bits and bibs I've seen online, but from a cursory, uneducated glance online, it seems like places like the Lido wing charge less than an average US hospital. And in the U.K. if something goes wrong you can transfer straight to the NHS rather than have to pay for it.

But like I say, I don't know much about it so could be wrong.

OP, your MIL is being unreasonable for sure by bothering your children, but she's probably just upset and dealing with it badly. I'd just give her a little grace and see if she improves down the line?

Holly60 · 10/06/2022 06:47

If I was your MIL I would be ridiculously worried. He is thinking of moving to a new country to move in with someone he hasn't really spend a huge amount of time with, and her children. The reality of that is going to be HARD. He has no family or friends network to fall back on, no job etc.

What happens if you have another child but then split up? He is either stuck on his own in a strange country or he has to go back to the US without his child.

His dad is really ill- possibly going to die and he is either going to be moving soon after that or already living in another country.

I can see why she is so upset.

It wouldn't be easy the other way round either but this is why I'm not sure that people moving country to live with a partner is really such a good idea to be honest.