Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Challenging racism - did I do enough? AIBU to take it further?

82 replies

Cma1988 · 10/06/2022 00:40

Im mixed-race (black-white) (relevant to the story) and I’m currently away at a residential course.

This morning one lady on the course left suddenly, we don’t know the reason, I guess something personal, and this lady is black (again, only mentioning as it’s relevant.

This evening few of us were playing cards in the lounge this evening, and I don’t even know how it even came about in conversation as I was only half-listening at this point, but one guy, (who is white South African) made a comment about the basement (we are staying in an old manor type house) and then he said “maybe that’s where Jane went,, mind you she’ll have to smile so you could see her”. There was a awkward silence and then another lady who doesn’t have English as her first language asked him what he meant, and he then explained his “joke” saying you know, you can’t see black people in the dark, only their teeth and then laughed again. I was in total shock that he could say something so horrendously racist - and worse - in front of me - as if he was saying a completely normal comment.
I challenged him saying “that’s not funny and it’s actually really racist and I can’t believe you just said that. He then went in to defend himself and justify himself saying that it was a joke, that he grew up in South Africa where he had black friends and they made that joke all the time and apparently his black friends used to make the joke too and he just brushed it off and carried on shuffling the cards. I then told him again that I was very upset by his joke and that He had shown his true colours because if he had made that joke in front of me, what would he be saying behind my (or any other person of colours) back. He then gave a poor excuse for an apology, he said sorry, but backed his sorry with more defending himself and I left and went to bed.

I’m now stewing with anger in bed, thinking I didn’t challenge him enough and feeling really hurt by his casual racism. I’m wondering if I should just leave it now, or if I should take it up again tomorrow either with him or with the course leaders? We are here together until Saturday but we will be joining together again in a few weeks for part 2 of the course and I feel that maybe he should be formally spoken to? Or am I overreacting? I really want to make a formal complaint about him. AIBU?

OP posts:
RubricEnemy · 10/06/2022 05:09

Marvellousmadness · 10/06/2022 04:49

"It sounds like the guy is stupid rather than viciously racist."

Yeah i agree here. (And i am not white) he sounds stupid but i wouldnt waste my time on him. Its not gonna achieve anything.

If you wanted to do anything still, then educate him. Dont go making a formal complaint. He'll have learned nothing and you didnt achieve anything either.

Start a dialogue with him. Communicate. Educate.

It is not a black person's job to educate a racist out of their racism. He can educate his own damn self.

Making a complaint will have the very obvious benefit of driving home the point that his behaviour is unacceptable in the UK.

Well done, OP. You aren't his mummy or his teacher. If he can't take your words on board, escalate and let someone else do the 'educating.

WiddlinDiddlin · 10/06/2022 04:55

Yep, take it further.

My friend used to make that joke about herself, she is VERY dark even among her own family... but thats HERS to make about herself, her choice, not mine.

I would not dream, not even if my friend says its ok, because it crosses a line.

And as for 'he's from SA he doesn't understand'.. bollocks bollocks and thrice bollocks. He knows he could get away with it there, but he knows its wrong all the same.

SO yes, take it further because until people do, he will just learn to pick his audience more carefully, he will not learn that he is wrong and offensive.

Marvellousmadness · 10/06/2022 04:49

"It sounds like the guy is stupid rather than viciously racist."

Yeah i agree here. (And i am not white) he sounds stupid but i wouldnt waste my time on him. Its not gonna achieve anything.

If you wanted to do anything still, then educate him. Dont go making a formal complaint. He'll have learned nothing and you didnt achieve anything either.

Start a dialogue with him. Communicate. Educate.

LaurieFairyCake · 10/06/2022 04:34

Yes, you need to let your organisation know formally - he needs to have training on this to work here, what he said is a disciplinary offence (and would be viewed by my organisation as very serious, possibly fireable)

If you're in an old Manor House it's an organisation you work for (like a church?) rather than a uni course?

22N · 10/06/2022 04:18

Yes, take it further. Where I am there would probably be a process that involved a conversation between him and the organisation leader/s then, depending how that went, a sort of restorative justice session where you can tell him whatever you need/want to and he listens and responds to let you know what he’s doing to ensure he doesn’t cause the same hurt in future.

If management were not satisfied that he had grasped the enormity of his offensive behaviour they would not allow it to proceed to a conversation with you. He would be let go.

I’m so sorry this happened to you and well done for challenging him. I hope you take it further and that it’s handled professionally.

WanderingFruitWonderer · 10/06/2022 03:58

Oh OP, what a horrible, distressing experience for you. I think you did really well. Especially as you must have been in shock, and it's very difficult to know what to say or do in the moment. You did brilliantly.
He sounds very ignorant. I don't know how long he's been in the UK for? But if for any significant length of time, he should have figured out by now, that such 'jokes' are totally unacceptable here. I wonder if reporting him would get the message across to him? Then he'd know never to do it again.
I had an experience recently of someone using a terrible racist word in my presence 'as a joke'. I was shocked and felt actual repulsion. I told him he should never use the word, and that it was offensive. To be fair, he apologised, and I hope he got the message. But I too wondered after if I could have done or said more. It's just so difficult in the moment, when in shock.
For context, I'm not black or mixed race, and I felt very hurt (bigotry is insulting to my fellow humans) so I can only imagine how much more hurtful it must be for a person of colour.
I'm so sorry you had such an upsetting experience. Sending you love and solidarity OP. Hopefully one day we'll live in a world free of bigotry and ignorance. Take care Flowers

Nahnanananahna · 10/06/2022 03:52

I also agree with taking it further. I know a lot of white (Afrikaans) South Africans and the casual racism you're talking about is very common. He may not have been meaning to offend, and he may not have realized his comment was racist, but he absolutely should be educated to know that what goes in SA (hardly a country to model what is acceptable on!) does not go in the UK.

PurpleMarie · 10/06/2022 03:33

if It’s not funny, it’s not a joke.

Magenta82 · 10/06/2022 03:18

I would take it further, from your account of the conversation it sounds like he doesn't see a problem with what he said and would make the same "joke" again.

Bluedabadeeba · 10/06/2022 03:06

Take it further!!! Or else these professional casual racists will consider it acceptable... it is not. Not in South Africa, not in America, not in the UK.

I assume he hadn't literally got off the plane from SA that morning; I assume he had previously interacted with several non South Africans in his lifetime... and therefore is well aware of how offensive that comment is in the UK (Or anywhere for that matter). He needs to be put in his place!

Justcannot · 10/06/2022 03:06

Well done for challenging him. From your description it doesn't sound like he apologised because he accepted he'd done something wrong, but to try and make you leave him alone. Therefore a formal complaint is the next step both imo and in every organisations' policies I've worked with recently. He's been unacceptably racist and doesn't recognise that at all.

MrsTerryPratchett · 10/06/2022 02:59

It sounds like the guy is stupid rather than viciously racist.

And the brilliant thing about making a complaint is that he can get training.

Making a formal complaint is actually great. The more people who understand what is OK and what is not... the better. It's either an opportunity for growth or he won't.

FOTB · 10/06/2022 02:51

MangyInseam · 10/06/2022 02:29

I think you you need to decide what your endgame is - what sort of outcome are you looking for? What do you hope to achivein the larger picture.

He's very likely telling the truth that it would have been a normal thing to say in SA, including among black people. In my experience Africans are much more inclined to make comments or jokes that directly reference race in a way we wouldn't. So you might want to consider that it is pretty easy for any one of us to make a faux pas in a culture different from our own.

The last time I was properly racially abused in the UK, it was by a white South African who refused to accept what he said was offensive.

I took it further to scare the shit out of him. Only when he realised his behaviour was offensive and wouldn't be tolerated did I allow the complaint to be dropped.

It was less about me, and more about stopping him from acting that way towards other people in the future. Until I pushed ahead with a complaint, he thought it was just funny. It damn well wasn't. Me challenging him wasn't enough to make him change his ways. If it had been, I probably wouldn't have taken it further.

Like you, OP, my white South African told me it was acceptable to make such comments in Africa. I have no idea if that's true, but it's certainly not acceptable in this country.

OP - good on you. You reacted really well, and I think you should take it up with the course leaders tomorrow. Make clear you want him to realise his behaviour is unacceptable rather than necessarily kicking him off the course. If the course leaders talk to him, that might make him realise it's not just one - woman? - kicking up a stink; no one tolerates his crappy behaviour.

God. I hate casual racism. Hate it, hate it, hate it. Some people just don't realise how awful what it is they're saying. They need to learn.

Boxowine · 10/06/2022 02:34

Just out of curiosity, does your course have a "standards of conduct" policy? I've seen places provide a written policy and I've seen some instances where the class starts off by listing their class rules on a board.

MangyInseam · 10/06/2022 02:32

mout · 10/06/2022 02:14

Doesn’t sound like he realised he’d been unacceptably racist

If you accuse people of something their immediate reaction is almost always to push back. And outside of North America,Australia, and some of Europe, the idea that intent is unrelated to being racist is less accepted. I imagine he's well aware now people didn't find his joke funny.

MangyInseam · 10/06/2022 02:29

I think you you need to decide what your endgame is - what sort of outcome are you looking for? What do you hope to achivein the larger picture.

He's very likely telling the truth that it would have been a normal thing to say in SA, including among black people. In my experience Africans are much more inclined to make comments or jokes that directly reference race in a way we wouldn't. So you might want to consider that it is pretty easy for any one of us to make a faux pas in a culture different from our own.

mout · 10/06/2022 02:14

Ferrarilover · 10/06/2022 02:07

I am mixed race. I think the fact that he is south African is pertinent here. He doesn't see racism in the same way as we do in the UK. It's awful but it's widely accepted to be true.

Hopefully you have made him aware of how racist he was being and he might think twice before making offensive comments like this again.

You did well to challenge him but I wouldn't take it further, on the basis that unfortunately he is probably doesn't know any better, and you have made him think about his attitude.

Doesn’t sound like he realised he’d been unacceptably racist

Ferrarilover · 10/06/2022 02:07

I am mixed race. I think the fact that he is south African is pertinent here. He doesn't see racism in the same way as we do in the UK. It's awful but it's widely accepted to be true.

Hopefully you have made him aware of how racist he was being and he might think twice before making offensive comments like this again.

You did well to challenge him but I wouldn't take it further, on the basis that unfortunately he is probably doesn't know any better, and you have made him think about his attitude.

daretodenim · 10/06/2022 02:04

1000yellowdaisies · 10/06/2022 01:28

You challenged him. He apologied. Taking it further would be overkill. What would you be wanting to achieve from a more formal complaint? Him kicked off the course?
It sounds like the guy is stupid rather than viciously racist.

On what grounds should he not be thrown off the course? What level of racism is unacceptable to you? What level of defending racist comments - sorry, "jokes" - is unacceptable?

If the organisation doesn't throw him off, then it's implicitly saying that these racist comments are acceptable to it.

Mamathebest · 10/06/2022 02:02

@1000yellowdaisies

Are you serious? As a black person I wouldn’t want him anywhere near me. You were nicer then I would have been OP.

catandcoffee · 10/06/2022 02:01

1000yellowdaisies · 10/06/2022 01:28

You challenged him. He apologied. Taking it further would be overkill. What would you be wanting to achieve from a more formal complaint? Him kicked off the course?
It sounds like the guy is stupid rather than viciously racist.

You're talking crap.
He's a nasty piece of work and needs to be dealt with.

Maybe he can get away with that stuff in South Africa, but it's not acceptable here.

OP make an official complaint.

Boxowine · 10/06/2022 01:55

Wow. I'm sorry. That must have been really shocking for you. You have every right to be upset and you are experiencing a delayed reaction to a blatantly racist incident. I think that you have every right to make a formal complaint but I think that you should avoid interacting with him in any way.

rocksonrocks · 10/06/2022 01:32

@1000yellowdaisies remove yourself from this thread. Completely worthless input.

1000yellowdaisies · 10/06/2022 01:28

You challenged him. He apologied. Taking it further would be overkill. What would you be wanting to achieve from a more formal complaint? Him kicked off the course?
It sounds like the guy is stupid rather than viciously racist.

BreadInCaptivity · 10/06/2022 01:11

You were great to challenge him.

Next step is to make a formal complaint.

Nothing changes until people exercise their power to ensure equality by vocalising it.