Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Challenging racism - did I do enough? AIBU to take it further?

82 replies

Cma1988 · 10/06/2022 00:40

Im mixed-race (black-white) (relevant to the story) and I’m currently away at a residential course.

This morning one lady on the course left suddenly, we don’t know the reason, I guess something personal, and this lady is black (again, only mentioning as it’s relevant.

This evening few of us were playing cards in the lounge this evening, and I don’t even know how it even came about in conversation as I was only half-listening at this point, but one guy, (who is white South African) made a comment about the basement (we are staying in an old manor type house) and then he said “maybe that’s where Jane went,, mind you she’ll have to smile so you could see her”. There was a awkward silence and then another lady who doesn’t have English as her first language asked him what he meant, and he then explained his “joke” saying you know, you can’t see black people in the dark, only their teeth and then laughed again. I was in total shock that he could say something so horrendously racist - and worse - in front of me - as if he was saying a completely normal comment.
I challenged him saying “that’s not funny and it’s actually really racist and I can’t believe you just said that. He then went in to defend himself and justify himself saying that it was a joke, that he grew up in South Africa where he had black friends and they made that joke all the time and apparently his black friends used to make the joke too and he just brushed it off and carried on shuffling the cards. I then told him again that I was very upset by his joke and that He had shown his true colours because if he had made that joke in front of me, what would he be saying behind my (or any other person of colours) back. He then gave a poor excuse for an apology, he said sorry, but backed his sorry with more defending himself and I left and went to bed.

I’m now stewing with anger in bed, thinking I didn’t challenge him enough and feeling really hurt by his casual racism. I’m wondering if I should just leave it now, or if I should take it up again tomorrow either with him or with the course leaders? We are here together until Saturday but we will be joining together again in a few weeks for part 2 of the course and I feel that maybe he should be formally spoken to? Or am I overreacting? I really want to make a formal complaint about him. AIBU?

OP posts:
Greensleeves · 10/06/2022 11:20

One of my acquaintances (not a friend - it's complicated) is a white South African, and I've noticed at social events of his that the tolerance level for casual racism is very different (all his friends are white SA as well). Things like "I don't agree with apartheid, BUT...." and "I'm not racist - I love white people, haha". I find it very difficult to stomach and do challenge it when I hear it. I think it's important to call it out every single time, even though it's uncomfortable to have to do it. I would definitely make a formal complaint about this guy if I were you, and I think you did really well to stand up to him in front of others.

Tonty · 10/06/2022 11:15

It sounds like the guy is stupid rather than viciously racist

All racists are stupid.

Moithered · 10/06/2022 11:09

1000yellowdaisies · 10/06/2022 01:28

You challenged him. He apologied. Taking it further would be overkill. What would you be wanting to achieve from a more formal complaint? Him kicked off the course?
It sounds like the guy is stupid rather than viciously racist.

and this, Ladies, is why racism continues. I do hope that you aren't passing this message on to your kids (if you have them)
OP - so what if he was south african, he cannot get away with such comments. Sadly, he probably doesn't see the issue precisely because of his heritage. His excuse was the same as 'i can use the n word because i have black friends who use it.
Report him please

Phlewf · 10/06/2022 10:01

I also struggle with the different culture/different generation argument. Yes you are a product of your culture but my grandfather would have been well over 100 if he was alive and grew up in rural piss poor Scotland and got the cane from his school teacher because he wouldn’t agree people from the empire were lesser. Now that was because his dad had seen some shit.
the man here has the benefits of formal education, international travel and freedom and choses to remain ignorant and racist.

22N · 10/06/2022 09:42

SurfBox · 10/06/2022 09:20

oh come on all the "he didn't realise it's racist" because he's South African.
Racist is racist and he knows it

Whilst I see where you are coming from, racism etc can be seen as more acceptable in some cultures even though they don't see it as such. I used to have alot of gay friends and many would openly make gay jokes, use gay slurs in jest etc.

Racism is never acceptable, that it is more rampant in some places than others does not make it ok.

AlternativePerspective · 10/06/2022 09:40

He absolutely needs to realise that the comments he makes in SA aren’t seen the same as here.

However he’s right that comments are seen differently over there. And the reality is that for people growing up in apartheid it is different. They never knew any better because it was how they grew up, and nobody didn’t live that way iyswim.

And there definitely are terminologies that are used in other countries which aren’t here etc. e.g. people who are mixed race are called coloured. It’s not offensive over there, it’s a term used by everyone, even those who are mixed race themselves, and no, they don’t just use it because they feel they have to, it’s an accepted term there. But we don’t use it here, and so when a South African refers to someone who is mixed race as coloured over here we assume he must be racist when actually he’s just using the terms he’s grown up with and which have always been used, iyswim. So we educate rather than condemn. It’s the only way to change mindsets.

SurfBox · 10/06/2022 09:20

oh come on all the "he didn't realise it's racist" because he's South African.
Racist is racist and he knows it

Whilst I see where you are coming from, racism etc can be seen as more acceptable in some cultures even though they don't see it as such. I used to have alot of gay friends and many would openly make gay jokes, use gay slurs in jest etc.

SurfBox · 10/06/2022 09:17

In my experience Africans are much more inclined to make comments or jokes that directly reference race in a way we wouldn't. So you might want to consider that it is pretty easy for any one of us to make a faux pas in a culture different from our own

I used to work with alot of black people and many would make black racist remarks and jokes against black people. One woman used to say that she'd tell her daughter ''I'm the big black bitch in this hose, don't forget it.''

The others,all male, would jokingly and sometimes seriously use the n word.

30mph · 10/06/2022 09:11

Well done you. Ignorance needs educating. Stupidity is not a get-out of consequences clause (though it has perhaps served him well previously).

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 10/06/2022 09:09

I don't think anything further will be gained from challenging him. You have already had the argument with him and it doesnt sound like he is going to change his mind. I think pointing it out infront of colleagues is probably going to have more of an effect on him than further training etc but it is probably the right thing to do to tell his employer

loislovesstewie · 10/06/2022 09:02

As it's too late for boundaries to be established at the beginning, spelling it out at any point might be better, might it not? BTW , I agree that what he said was racist, and he should be reported , but he should also be included in a general discussion about appropriate behaviours in respect of other issues. I mean dealing with people with disabilities etc, because he probably has no idea about that either, does he?

WhatsInAMolatovMocktail · 10/06/2022 08:26

Yes you should report it to your manager or HR. The comment is clearly indefensible and the fact he tried to defend it worsens the crime.

Where and when I grew up, racist jokes were common. I am now an adult, and feel quite sickened by some of the memories I have from childhood. I certainly don't think back fondly and enjoy the same "jokes" I did as a child, much less repeat them to colleagues assuming they are funny today.

Unquestionably you would not be unreasonable to report it up. If we tolerate this crap it never goes away.

22N · 10/06/2022 08:26

Cma1988 · 10/06/2022 08:20

Morning all, thank you for all your responses, much appreciated. I have decided that Inman going to take it further and talk to one of the leaders or programme coordinators this morning after breakfast, and ask about making a formal incident. I am guessing they have a anti-racism, or equality and diversity policy as most places do. Thank you for the reassurance that I did not overreact, I’m still stemming about it even now! And I don’t really want to even see him today.

Good luck. I hope they respond appropriately.

Brefugee · 10/06/2022 08:22

oh come on all the "he didn't realise it's racist" because he's South African.
Racist is racist and he knows it.

OP well done on the challenge. I'd take it further because it is obviously a difficult conversation for you to have with someone.

Cma1988 · 10/06/2022 08:22

LaurieFairyCake · 10/06/2022 04:34

Yes, you need to let your organisation know formally - he needs to have training on this to work here, what he said is a disciplinary offence (and would be viewed by my organisation as very serious, possibly fireable)

If you're in an old Manor House it's an organisation you work for (like a church?) rather than a uni course?

Yeah it’s a church-leadership type training, I don’t want to give any more details as it will be very outing, but that’s what makes it worse in a way.

OP posts:
Cma1988 · 10/06/2022 08:20

Morning all, thank you for all your responses, much appreciated. I have decided that Inman going to take it further and talk to one of the leaders or programme coordinators this morning after breakfast, and ask about making a formal incident. I am guessing they have a anti-racism, or equality and diversity policy as most places do. Thank you for the reassurance that I did not overreact, I’m still stemming about it even now! And I don’t really want to even see him today.

OP posts:
MarinoRoyale · 10/06/2022 08:12

Aquamarine1029 · 10/06/2022 00:55

Do not confront him again, at all, but make a formal complaint. What a absolute shitbag of a person.

I agree with this, I hope you’re ok. You did so well to confront him.

Phlewf · 10/06/2022 07:56

I think him being from SA is relevant here, because he was not in SA. If he wants to benefit of the learning here (and work? And lifestyle if he’s planing to stay after the course) then he has to live a way that is acceptable here. There’s places I won’t go because I won’t conform to the way they live.

I’ve heard this bullshit ‘joke’ often enough and im
white so it’s not some localised in joke. It’s great that the other student asked for an explanation because there can be zero doubt about exactly what he meant. He made a racist statement and then explained why it was racist in front of a group of people.

22N · 10/06/2022 07:55

loislovesstewie · 10/06/2022 05:17

Don't know if this helps but, I used to work in local government (retired now), there was always a bit at the end of every course about equal opportunities. If yours has that , could you have a quiet word with the speaker/facilitator /what have you, and ask them to bring in 'casual racism'? That way everyone can contribute , he can listen and understand why his comment was totally unacceptable.

I know you mean well but “a bit at the end of the course” as a means of educating a participant who has been grossly offensive is so inadequate.

Boundaries should be established before the course begins, what is expected, a code of conduct.

And addressing the whole group as an afterthought to minimise discomfort of the perpetrator is not fair to the other participants and let’s face it, why should he be shielded from the discomfort of facing the consequences of his behaviour?

His comments were dreadful, there is no place for attitudes or “jokes” like that in a civilised society. Yes he’s a white South African but
he is now in the UK and needs to observe UK professional standards.

OP I don’t think you need to justify why you are thinking of taking it further. I’m glad you got angry. Stay angry until he’s put it right or has been put right.

Anothernamechangeplease · 10/06/2022 07:45

hattie43 · 10/06/2022 07:40

You'll get a lot of truck with this on MN but not in the wider community .

WTF does that mean?

Anothernamechangeplease · 10/06/2022 07:45

1000yellowdaisies · 10/06/2022 01:28

You challenged him. He apologied. Taking it further would be overkill. What would you be wanting to achieve from a more formal complaint? Him kicked off the course?
It sounds like the guy is stupid rather than viciously racist.

So casual racism is OK, it's just the "vicious" type that isn't?

hattie43 · 10/06/2022 07:40

You'll get a lot of truck with this on MN but not in the wider community .

NCed2Help · 10/06/2022 06:38

Formal complaint. No doubt.

Merryclaire · 10/06/2022 06:31

I’ve heard someone make this joke about her own husband before, when looking through holiday photos! He seemed to think it was funny but it’s a strange casual racism.

We all come across people who are just ignorant or out of touch, and don’t mean to be nasty, but really they should know better by now. If you are called out on ‘innocently’ making an offensive comment, then the natural reaction is to feel ashamed, make a sincere apology and learn from it.

If the man had genuinely taken it on board and offered a believable apology then you could probably leave it at that. But as he didn’t seem to get it, you should report it to the supervisors - perhaps explain that you’re not looking to get him kicked off the course but feel they should model an anti racist policy. They could then give him a warning - explain this behaviour won’t be tolerated, and if it does happen again, he’ll be out.

loislovesstewie · 10/06/2022 05:17

Don't know if this helps but, I used to work in local government (retired now), there was always a bit at the end of every course about equal opportunities. If yours has that , could you have a quiet word with the speaker/facilitator /what have you, and ask them to bring in 'casual racism'? That way everyone can contribute , he can listen and understand why his comment was totally unacceptable.