Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Challenging racism - did I do enough? AIBU to take it further?

82 replies

Cma1988 · 10/06/2022 00:40

Im mixed-race (black-white) (relevant to the story) and I’m currently away at a residential course.

This morning one lady on the course left suddenly, we don’t know the reason, I guess something personal, and this lady is black (again, only mentioning as it’s relevant.

This evening few of us were playing cards in the lounge this evening, and I don’t even know how it even came about in conversation as I was only half-listening at this point, but one guy, (who is white South African) made a comment about the basement (we are staying in an old manor type house) and then he said “maybe that’s where Jane went,, mind you she’ll have to smile so you could see her”. There was a awkward silence and then another lady who doesn’t have English as her first language asked him what he meant, and he then explained his “joke” saying you know, you can’t see black people in the dark, only their teeth and then laughed again. I was in total shock that he could say something so horrendously racist - and worse - in front of me - as if he was saying a completely normal comment.
I challenged him saying “that’s not funny and it’s actually really racist and I can’t believe you just said that. He then went in to defend himself and justify himself saying that it was a joke, that he grew up in South Africa where he had black friends and they made that joke all the time and apparently his black friends used to make the joke too and he just brushed it off and carried on shuffling the cards. I then told him again that I was very upset by his joke and that He had shown his true colours because if he had made that joke in front of me, what would he be saying behind my (or any other person of colours) back. He then gave a poor excuse for an apology, he said sorry, but backed his sorry with more defending himself and I left and went to bed.

I’m now stewing with anger in bed, thinking I didn’t challenge him enough and feeling really hurt by his casual racism. I’m wondering if I should just leave it now, or if I should take it up again tomorrow either with him or with the course leaders? We are here together until Saturday but we will be joining together again in a few weeks for part 2 of the course and I feel that maybe he should be formally spoken to? Or am I overreacting? I really want to make a formal complaint about him. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ChagSameachDoreen · 11/06/2022 08:13

He doesn't see racism in the same way as we do in the UK.

Well he needs to learn then, doesn't he?

Valeriekat · 11/06/2022 07:55

Ferrarilover · 10/06/2022 02:07

I am mixed race. I think the fact that he is south African is pertinent here. He doesn't see racism in the same way as we do in the UK. It's awful but it's widely accepted to be true.

Hopefully you have made him aware of how racist he was being and he might think twice before making offensive comments like this again.

You did well to challenge him but I wouldn't take it further, on the basis that unfortunately he is probably doesn't know any better, and you have made him think about his attitude.

As a South African he should be hypersensitive to issues of race given the history of that country.

22N · 10/06/2022 23:12

Cma1988 · 10/06/2022 22:03

Thanks all; just to update, I did report it this morning and he was taken into the office when they had a meeting with him. This afternoon he came over to me and apologised. It felt a bit like a forced apology if I’m honest, I guess they must have told him to do it. He is still here so they haven’t sent him home but he has been very quiet and said very very little at meals and this evening. Apparently another one of the group who was also there last night had a strong word with him after I left last night, (which I found strange as she said nothing while I was there) We go home tomorrow morning and I’m hoping I won’t see him in a couple months for the next stage, but if I do, maybe he may have been forced to address his ugly views by then.

just to clarify, he is South African born but has lived here for 10 years, so he really should know that such jokes are not acceptable over here (not that they should be accepted anywhere!).

Thanks for updating. You did what you could. Personally I think the course people could have handled it better.

Sbqprules · 10/06/2022 22:09

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Cma1988 · 10/06/2022 22:03

Thanks all; just to update, I did report it this morning and he was taken into the office when they had a meeting with him. This afternoon he came over to me and apologised. It felt a bit like a forced apology if I’m honest, I guess they must have told him to do it. He is still here so they haven’t sent him home but he has been very quiet and said very very little at meals and this evening. Apparently another one of the group who was also there last night had a strong word with him after I left last night, (which I found strange as she said nothing while I was there) We go home tomorrow morning and I’m hoping I won’t see him in a couple months for the next stage, but if I do, maybe he may have been forced to address his ugly views by then.

just to clarify, he is South African born but has lived here for 10 years, so he really should know that such jokes are not acceptable over here (not that they should be accepted anywhere!).

OP posts:
5foot5 · 10/06/2022 15:28

rocksonrocks · 10/06/2022 01:32

@1000yellowdaisies remove yourself from this thread. Completely worthless input.

I do not agree with what 1000yellowdaisies said and I think the OP is justified in making a complaint.

However, I dislike very much your response here with its implication that anyone who holds an opinion different to yours, or to the majority, is not welcome to take part in the discussion or that their viewpoint is worthless just because you disagree with it.

SurfBox · 10/06/2022 14:51

*hmm..so I suppose, 'You can't see blacks in the dark, only their teeth' (laugh), or 'Jane went in the basement, mind you, she'll have to smile so you can see her'.

Is that the simply factual part? and would this be joke/statement*

i assumed it's derives from the racist joke -how do you hide a black man in a coal shed? Knock his teeth out.

BTW I am not telling that out of mirth or because I'm racist but I assume that's where his comment came from.

SurfBox · 10/06/2022 14:46

*I (white) was talking to my neighbour (white) when another neighbour (black) drove past and my neighbour said that he has a big, shiny face

My white neighbour is in his seventies and thinks it's totally okay to say that*

I am Irish and often have seen memes and comments about how white we are. It's really no different.

Mally100 · 10/06/2022 14:08

Nahnanananahna · 10/06/2022 03:52

I also agree with taking it further. I know a lot of white (Afrikaans) South Africans and the casual racism you're talking about is very common. He may not have been meaning to offend, and he may not have realized his comment was racist, but he absolutely should be educated to know that what goes in SA (hardly a country to model what is acceptable on!) does not go in the UK.

I'm from SA and I can tell you it's just as much racist there as it is here. The difference is that if it's challenged there, there are no repercussions. He most likely has friends and family who makes these types of jokes. He so openly said it in front of the op because he still has the mentality that non white people can be abused in this way, just as it is back in SA. Makes me livid, as a non white SA I can place his racist type quite confidently. Please make a complaint op, this racist needs a wake up. The fact that he tried to even justify it, just proves how much he believes he has a right to his joke. The most racist people you will ever come across are his type.

Agrudge · 10/06/2022 13:43

mout · 10/06/2022 13:25

not sure why posters are saying ‘well I know black people who joke about their blackness’ or ‘I have gay friends that use gay slurs’. What’s that got to do with it? Confused. This ‘joke’ was made by a white person referencing a black person

Agreed.

Just because you can joke around like that with your friends doesnt mean it will go down well colleagues/people you dont know well

Context is alway it big part of these sort of comments

mout · 10/06/2022 13:25

not sure why posters are saying ‘well I know black people who joke about their blackness’ or ‘I have gay friends that use gay slurs’. What’s that got to do with it? Confused. This ‘joke’ was made by a white person referencing a black person

MadeForThis · 10/06/2022 12:55

I would definitely complain. That type of "joke" isn't acceptable and I struggle to believe that he didn't know how racist it was.

roarfeckingroarr · 10/06/2022 12:55

1000yellowdaisies · 10/06/2022 01:28

You challenged him. He apologied. Taking it further would be overkill. What would you be wanting to achieve from a more formal complaint? Him kicked off the course?
It sounds like the guy is stupid rather than viciously racist.

I agree with this

Blaze1886 · 10/06/2022 12:51

I (white) was talking to my neighbour (white) when another neighbour (black) drove past and my neighbour said that he has a big, shiny face

My white neighbour is in his seventies and thinks it's totally okay to say that

Phlewf · 10/06/2022 12:49

HeadOnShoulders · 10/06/2022 12:34

There possibly was an element of mockery, but I'm not sure that qualifies as racism. Certainly it would fall on the lower end of the spectrum.

It's a joke based on a fact rather than a stereotype. Like joking about gingers getting sunburnt easily.

im not sure it is based on a fact. Black people are 3 dimensional sentient beings, I’ve never not notice a black person in a dark room, you know what with them actually being there breathing, moving, wearing clothes and you know not being the exact same colour as a dark room (which can also be varying levels of dark). It would be like saying you wouldn’t notice me if it was snowing unless I opened my mouth.

Brefugee · 10/06/2022 12:41

I used to have alot of gay friends and many would openly make gay jokes, use gay slurs in jest etc.

But this chap is a white South African so presumably he has heard about the issues of racism there? And has noticed he's not now in South Africa and racism isn't acceptable here even if it is there? (and i can't believe that in a mixed race group, a white South African - a white any nationality - making a racist comment like that wouldn't be pulled up on it, unless he's the boss and everyone needs to suck up to hm)

Same with gay people telling gay jokes - that's up to them.

2bazookas · 10/06/2022 12:38

He needs to know that when in UK, he's subject to UK race laws and needs to know what they are so he doesn't lose his job.

Your employer should give him a heads up.

Bravo.

HeadOnShoulders · 10/06/2022 12:34

Tonty · 10/06/2022 12:08

hmm..so I suppose, 'You can't see blacks in the dark, only their teeth' (laugh), or 'Jane went in the basement, mind you, she'll have to smile so you can see her'.

Is that the simply factual part? and would this be joke/statement?

Tough one.

There possibly was an element of mockery, but I'm not sure that qualifies as racism. Certainly it would fall on the lower end of the spectrum.

It's a joke based on a fact rather than a stereotype. Like joking about gingers getting sunburnt easily.

purpleboy · 10/06/2022 12:26

Sorry you had to go through that op, I hope you managed to get a good nights sleep and it didn't play on your mind too much.

Your doing the right thing by reporting him, just because it's what he grew up with doesn't mean it's acceptable, it should be challenged each and every time, that's the only way we will ever start to see a change.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 10/06/2022 12:12

@AlternativePerspective - most South Africans (and I've known a few) should be aware then when moving to a country without apartheid that certain comments are racist and shouldn't be said.

about 25 years ago I worked with a SA man who was constantly making comments about having to live in a gated community because of the danger from blacks. I told him off and said he shouldn't say that here (in London) as it's racist. Luckily he didn't really go any further into it apart from 'they were dangerous'.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 10/06/2022 12:09

I'd definitely challenge him.

For what it's worth, not saying all South Africans are like this, but I went to a hairdresser in London over lockdown and the stylist was SA and he made several racist comments about blacks (explained away because he was from SA) - totally unprompted by me, he was asking me where I was from in London.

Turned out from google reviews he's made the same comments before (the hair salon is a well known chain).

I was disgusted at his comments and didn't engage/answer after the first one but didn't feel able to say he shouldn't say that, as I felt awkward. Now, I'd like to think I'd complain about him to the owners/reception.

Tonty · 10/06/2022 12:08

hmm..so I suppose, 'You can't see blacks in the dark, only their teeth' (laugh), or 'Jane went in the basement, mind you, she'll have to smile so you can see her'.

Is that the simply factual part? and would this be joke/statement?

Tough one.

Moithered · 10/06/2022 12:05

AlternativePerspective · 10/06/2022 09:40

He absolutely needs to realise that the comments he makes in SA aren’t seen the same as here.

However he’s right that comments are seen differently over there. And the reality is that for people growing up in apartheid it is different. They never knew any better because it was how they grew up, and nobody didn’t live that way iyswim.

And there definitely are terminologies that are used in other countries which aren’t here etc. e.g. people who are mixed race are called coloured. It’s not offensive over there, it’s a term used by everyone, even those who are mixed race themselves, and no, they don’t just use it because they feel they have to, it’s an accepted term there. But we don’t use it here, and so when a South African refers to someone who is mixed race as coloured over here we assume he must be racist when actually he’s just using the terms he’s grown up with and which have always been used, iyswim. So we educate rather than condemn. It’s the only way to change mindsets.

Apartheid ended in 1991. 32 years is enough to know that racism/ apartheid is unacceptable.
No excuse

HeadOnShoulders · 10/06/2022 11:58

Not to sure about this. I think there's a difference between a joke/statement that relies on a stereotype and one that is simply factual. So saying all Blacks are... is clearly racist, but just stating they have dark skin isn't.

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 10/06/2022 11:27

Dont go making a formal complaint. He'll have learned nothing and you didnt achieve anything either

What is silly statement. He will learn that he can't use language like this in a public forum and that it is racist. If it is ignored, he will carry on, thinking OP was making a mountain out of a molehill.

Well done OP for taking this further. All the racist apologisers here are why he gets away with saying shit like that and thinking it's funny.