Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can our wedding venue do this??? Any lawyers?!

508 replies

RedWineRage · 09/06/2022 18:17

Posting here for traffic....and also some perspective/help/ideas!

Getting married this summer. Reception venue is stately home-type place which is open to the public but also does weddings, has done successfully for years. Top listed wedding venue in various magazines etc and very good reviews. So - not some shady outfit.

Email out of the blue this week - all rather breezy - due to several incidents at recent events, just to let you know we will no longer be serving red wine at all, with immediate effect.

But don't worry, we'll just swap that out for rosé in your drinks package.

What???

My mum only drinks red wine. Several family members prefer red wine. We planned to have beef as a main.

Totally unacceptable, right? They appear to be relying on some woolly clause in the contract around "it's a historic building, changes may need to be made to your wedding plan that are out of our control due to operational reasons" etc.

We're genuinely considering trying at short notice to get another venue, and trying to claim money back through small claims. Has anyone done this? Any ideas on how likely we are to be successful?

My mum can't not have an alcoholic drink at my wedding. Sorry I'm ranting and probably not being very rational.

Perspective and advice welcome!!

OP posts:
PlanningTowns · 09/06/2022 19:10

Sadly I imagine some guests at a previous wedding have a had a spillage and I assume they have marble floors or white carpets and the damage has been substantial.

we looked at a couple of historic venues where high heels couldn’t be worn nor red wine drunk. Didn’t put me off them and I understood the reason (I work with historic buildings so maybe I’m more sympathetic).

if they have marble floors the cost to clean a red wine stain would be huge. I guess you could ask that you put a cleaning deposit down (££) and have red wine but don’t get weary if a guest spills and you have to pay, or go with it or change venues.

20 years down the line and I can remember we had wine at our wedding and ate lamb but not the specifics!

adlitem · 09/06/2022 19:08

They don't even need that clause to get out of it. Supplying a different wine would not be considered material breach. And, again, what is the loss you have incurred?

Look, people who try "go legal" over this sort of thing will cause nothing more than eye roles (and maybe some laughs) from the venue's lawyers. Appeal to their better nature (as others have suggested) or their reputation.

Chances are though that all they will offer you is a fee free cancellation "as a gesture of goodwill"

mam0918 · 09/06/2022 19:08

This is boardering on Bridezilla territory honestly.

Take a deep breath, its really not that big a deal and with hindsight you'll laugh about how unhinged your irrational response of binning a whole venue due to the rant of 'My mum can't not have an alcoholic drink at my wedding' is when there is indead alcohol on offer.

DWofMN · 09/06/2022 19:08

Legally speaking, this is a matter of contract law. There's a legally binding agreement that they will supply a service and some products, and you're legally bound to pay them and follow other terms set-out. They want to change "red" in your contract to "rosé" the agreement there is between you.

The clause they're relying on is pretty vague so, if it came down to it, a judge would really have to decide three things:


  1. Whether this is "out of their control"

  2. Whether this change is for "operational reasons".

If the judge thinks "yes" to both of those then the venue can continue you and you're bound by the contract (i.e. will lose your deposit if you pull out and are liable to pay for the wedding).
If the judge decides no to either 1 or 2, then it goes onto question 3:
  • Is this change (from red to rose) a significant enough change in the contract to be considered altering the terms of the contract and, therefore, a breach of contract.
I think the likelihood is that it's not a big enough change to be enough change to be considered a breach of contract - if they were saying they're switching your beef main for coco pops then that would probably be a big enough change. I could be wrong here though, it depends on the entire interaction between you and the venue - if you chose this venue specifically for their selection of wines (i.e. it's a vineyard) then you could probably win in court.

So, legally, I think the venue would win this if it came down to an actual dispute - although I understand it's frustrating.

Things you can do:


  • Ask them to make an exception for your mother

  • Ask them why they've made this change and, if it's due to damage caused by spills, offer to pay a damage deposit

  • Ask to switch your beef dish to one that works better with rose

  • Try to get a reduction in the price you've paid.


I know it's frustrating, I'm sorry. Unfortunately, there's not much you can do.

veggiesupreme · 09/06/2022 19:08

Red wine is a total dealbreaker for a winter wedding, but a summer wedding I am sure it would be fine without, but I have never ever heard of anywhere not serving both, but I think you can get around it (if you want to)

FixTheBone · 09/06/2022 19:08

Could you offer to take out an insurance policy to cover any damage caused by red wine?

Watapalava · 09/06/2022 19:08

I’d be 100% pissed off as I only drink red wine as do all my social group

i can’t stand white or rose

LadyPenelope68 · 09/06/2022 19:07

You’d change your whole wedding just because of the colour of wine that can be served? Talk about Bridezilla. If your Mum can’t manage a day without red wine, then I suggest you’ve got a bigger problem than what wine can be served.

FlipFlopShopInHawaii · 09/06/2022 19:05

It absolutely IS a big deal! I only drink red wine, and wanting to have a drink at my daughter's wedding does not make me an alcoholic.
I can't believe majority vote YABU 😟

Mumdiva99 · 09/06/2022 19:05

This is also good advice
What I would do is consult a good sommelier or wine merchant around what suitable wine to choose as an alternative that will go with your, rather than be fobbed off with the red wine being swapped for a rose as if the choice is unimportant. See if you can negotiate on corkage if you want a wine that is not on their list. Your guests will then remember a delicious wine rather than the absence of red wine.

Your mum would probably rather a big gutsy bold white than the dry rose which is popular at the moment.(personally I love the fizzy rose - we had pink fizzy cava at our wedding, only around £15 bottle - we did our own bar so was the off licence price. Not a hotel price.) But we tried some great whites around a similar price point which were delicious. We went to majestic wine for our tasting and purchasing. They were really helpful.

purplecorkheart · 09/06/2022 19:05

There are some full bodied rose wine types out there. Not many admittedly but a few grape varieties are out there. That might be well worth researching.

Aop · 09/06/2022 19:04

saltinesandcoffeecups · 09/06/2022 18:30

Yeah OP they can do this based on that clause. Yes you are overreacting a bit. Yes, it sucks to have last minute wrench thrown into plans. No, don’t change your venue.

Step back, serve the Rose’ , this is a big deal to you right now, but you will honestly not give it a second thought down the road.

This. Very shortly after the wedding, no one will give two fucks about what wine was drunk.

SausageAndCash · 09/06/2022 19:04

OP, I would also be very disappointed in the venue over this. And let them know it.

No way would I serve beef as a main without the option to drink red wine with it. I wouldn't be bloody paying for my guests to eat beef with white or rose the only wine options.

I wonder if they would relent for red wine to be drunk seated at tables during the meal?

Otherwise at the very least I would demand that I can change the menu.

Have guests already been asked for menu choices?

Obviously don't take the suggestions for smuggling red wine in etc, as they would probably sue you for any stains.

Discuss the possibility of insurance with them?

Ask if it would be OK to discreetly explain to guests that as a historically sensitive venue they need to be extra careful with red wine and it will only be available for sit down drinking?

GrumpyPanda · 09/06/2022 19:02

The reverse snobbery on here is bizarre and frankly obnoxious. Of course it matters if the venue is swapping out your booked drinks for something totally unsuitable to your meal package - and their proposing rose would make me worry about getting served some godawful swill, since there's so little halfway decent rose around.

I'd go with what a pp said and see if you can't negotiate something around a raised security deposit. Failing that, make them upgrade to a different, white wine-compatible main dish free of charge. Maybe some nice veal? I definitely wouldn't accept their proposed changes without a massive discount at the very least.

LauraNicolaides · 09/06/2022 19:02

TargusEasting · 09/06/2022 18:54

Here we go. ^

Another poster just firing from the hip with 'thoughts and feelings', never even considering that something might exist in society such as the law of contract.

It's likely though that under the contract @RedWineRage is liable to pay for damage caused. The venue has probably had trouble recovering the large bills for this sort of thing in the past. So I think "their gaff they rules" is not unreasonable in this case. Hence my suggestion of allaying their concerns with a deposit. If they still won't let it go ahead then yes, they are being unreasonable.

DobbyTheHouseElk · 09/06/2022 19:01

You will look back in this and laugh. You are over reacting.

Rose is horrible, but I’m sure your guests will be fine drinking white wine.
Suggest hip flasks for those who can’t cope.

I would definitely ask the venue what they can offer instead and ask for a reduction in the white wine costs.

CotswoldWoolly · 09/06/2022 19:01

@LauraNicolaides I doubt it’s to protect the carpets! Given the venue the OP has described, any damage may run into tens of thousands. Items in stately homes are often irreplaceable, and so the offer of money may not be enough even if the OP can offer a sizeable deposit .

Vapeyvapevape · 09/06/2022 19:01

They probably do have insurance but would maybe have to close rooms off and cancel other bookings while repairs to stained floors are made , meaning they lose income.

KrisAkabusi · 09/06/2022 19:01

Your guests will then remember a delicious wine rather than the absence of red wine.

I've been to dozens of weddings. I don't remember the wine from any of them it's really not that important a detail of the day.

adlitem · 09/06/2022 19:00

I'm a lawyer. You will get nowhere with this contractually. Even if you could show they were in breach (which I doubt) what foreseeble and direct damages have you incurred?

veggiesupreme · 09/06/2022 18:59

Change the main dish and don't worry about it. Most red wine drinkers I know are happy to drink rose instead.

If it is a dealbreaker then switch venues. YABU a little anyway!

erinaceus · 09/06/2022 18:59

In terms of perspective, this was a rule at our wedding venue due to the value of the artworks on the walls (! -- no idea what they thought our guests were going to get up to). We had beef as a main. I do not think that the wedding was affected in any way.

What I would do is consult a good sommelier or wine merchant around what suitable wine to choose as an alternative that will go with your, rather than be fobbed off with the red wine being swapped for a rose as if the choice is unimportant. See if you can negotiate on corkage if you want a wine that is not on their list. Your guests will then remember a delicious wine rather than the absence of red wine.

ScottishBeeswax · 09/06/2022 18:58

Beef needs red wine! I'd ask to change your menu if they'll only serve rose

LauraNicolaides · 09/06/2022 18:58

Offer to provide a deposit to pay for any red-wine-related damage. I'm guessing they're worried about carpets. (Although any damage you do cause could well be extremely expensive for you to fix - I'm guessing that's why they've changed their policy.)

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 09/06/2022 18:57

See if you can find a specific liability insurance for wine damage?