Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can our wedding venue do this??? Any lawyers?!

508 replies

RedWineRage · 09/06/2022 18:17

Posting here for traffic....and also some perspective/help/ideas!

Getting married this summer. Reception venue is stately home-type place which is open to the public but also does weddings, has done successfully for years. Top listed wedding venue in various magazines etc and very good reviews. So - not some shady outfit.

Email out of the blue this week - all rather breezy - due to several incidents at recent events, just to let you know we will no longer be serving red wine at all, with immediate effect.

But don't worry, we'll just swap that out for rosé in your drinks package.

What???

My mum only drinks red wine. Several family members prefer red wine. We planned to have beef as a main.

Totally unacceptable, right? They appear to be relying on some woolly clause in the contract around "it's a historic building, changes may need to be made to your wedding plan that are out of our control due to operational reasons" etc.

We're genuinely considering trying at short notice to get another venue, and trying to claim money back through small claims. Has anyone done this? Any ideas on how likely we are to be successful?

My mum can't not have an alcoholic drink at my wedding. Sorry I'm ranting and probably not being very rational.

Perspective and advice welcome!!

OP posts:
HogInAManger · 09/06/2022 21:37

Hmm. Enjoyment is a major feature of a contact to deliver a wedding. Introducing a new contractual term after you booked proscribing the serving of red wine at your wedding is an onerous restriction potentially limiting the ability of the contact to deliver enjoyment.
On this basis, if you cannot persuade the venue to serve red wine, you should be able to cancel your booking without a financial penalty, provided you make it clear to the venue in advance that serving red wine is integral to the overall enjoyment of your wedding day.

LuaDipa · 09/06/2022 21:37

I was once a guest at a wedding where another pissed guest managed to spill red wine all over one of the bridesmaids in her beautiful dress. She ended up crying. So did the bride. This may not be the worst thing.

MrsEthelMorningtonCrescent · 09/06/2022 21:36

Btw I don't personally think beef or lamb (or venison...) have to be served with red wine (or indeed any wine) for myself, but the point is whether this is a reasonable expectation given the type and cost of meal and drinks package, menu, nature of the event (wedding), and the original agreement. I'd say it is a reasonable expectation.

(Disclaimer: Not a lawyer; good a writing letters-before-legal-action though and getting a result, including for non-trivial matters involving 4-figure sums.)😉

My advice is (still) to grumble in a legalish sounding way (IMO put Without Prejudice at the top of the letter, and do it in writing not by email sent by recorded or whatever it's called now - they will realise you mean business) and try to get a not-insignificant discount (and advise everyone in advance that there is no red wine due to the historic and delicate nature venue with their alternative options, it's not as though you are likely to have already explicitly told them there is).

StepAwayFromGoogling · 09/06/2022 21:31

You are getting married in this venue presumably because it is a beautiful historic building that people have worked hard to preserve. Clearly red wine has at some point, and no doubt repeatedly, been spilt at events and is ruining said building's carpets/soft furnishings/paintings/woodwork. In order to continue preserving it for future generations they are no longer allowing red wine to be served at events. I used to work in the wine industry - there are most definitely white and rose wines that will pair with beef. Or serve something other than beef. But FFS, this is so far into the world of first world problems.

MrsEthelMorningtonCrescent · 09/06/2022 21:29

Disagree somewhat about it not being a "material change", IF the formal sit-down menu has wine matched to courses (and those include beef or lamb) it's a material change to the menu chosen (if chosen already or highly anticipated given many people want a beef course/option), and makes a difference to that menu. There is definitely haggle room here (even if cancelling the whole contract/getting the deposit back and moving venue would be trickier given the contract get-out clauses). Remember, the booked food and wine is often the most expensive part of the booking, by a country mile.

Nocutenamesleft · 09/06/2022 21:28

Can they do it? Probably. I would imagine so. If it’s historical it is likely to be listed and being listed comes with tons of contractual clauses.

TeaKlaxon · 09/06/2022 21:13

NewYorkLassie · 09/06/2022 20:59

We had roast beef and white win. Nobody complained or asked for red

I think what you meant to say was no one complained to our faces. I would find it very odd not to be offered a choice of red or white wine regardless of what the food was.

Yep. I don’t actually like red. I’d find it really odd to only have a choice of red (or rosé) at a meal.

Mummyoflittledragon · 09/06/2022 21:13

That would frustrate me too. I think you just need to adjust from perfect to really amazing. There are white wines, which ‘go’ with beef. I’d say something full bodied.

TeaKlaxon · 09/06/2022 21:12

luckylavender · 09/06/2022 20:55

I absolutely hate the dependence on alcohol we have in this country. It's obscene. No one needs to be so reliant on alcohol to have a good time. But you know if you don't like it, find another venue.

Nonsense. Celebrations and booze go together in many many countries.

What matters for someone’s wedding is personal and it’s ridiculous to pretend valuing the ability of people to have a celebratory drink (of their choice) at your wedding is a ‘dependence’ on alcohol.

Houseplantmad · 09/06/2022 21:08

I can't believe the number of people who are saying it's not a big deal. I think it is! You've planned a wedding meal with wine and now they're withdrawing part of that agreement however, if they won't back down then I think you need to get them to come up with an alternative menu and paired wines.

Fleur405 · 09/06/2022 21:05

You have a contract for a whole package wedding - venue, catering, wedding planner etc, presumably costing thousands. Unless you made it clear that you would only book if they provided red wine then I doubt you’d be able to successfully argue that they are in breach of contact (at least not sufficiently material a breach to justify you terminating). Wrongfully terminating a contract is itself breach of contract…..

Annoying as it is, in the context of the whole day it’s surely a minor thing really? I agree that beef and rose isn’t really a winning combo - ask if you can have red wine for the seated meal only (the rule is presumably to avoid spillages which I expect has damaged some old piece of furniture or original wallpaper or something) otherwise change the main to chicken!

minipie · 09/06/2022 21:04

In your shoes I would not be thinking legally. You would get nothing from a legal claim except legal bills and a pissed off wedding venue.

Instead I would be seeking to understand the reasons behind the change, what has gone wrong in the past, and then ask (nicely) she for exceptions based on that.

So if there are some particularly delicate rooms that have got damaged in the past then ask for red wine in the dining room only. If the dining room is very delicate maybe you can use a different room for dinner? Or if neither is an option then at least ask for an exemption for your mum.

Try to work with them, understand their perspective and reach a middle ground rather than going nuclear.

WimpoleHat · 09/06/2022 21:00

The chief responsibility is preserving the condition of the building and its contents.

Then running a hospitality business from there is not a good idea….

I don’t think you’re unreasonable at all; red and white wine is absolutely standard with a sit down dinner. To tell you after the event that you can’t have it is dreadful.

TolkiensFallow · 09/06/2022 21:00

Keep calm and give your mother a hip flask.

luckylavender · 09/06/2022 20:59

nomistake · 09/06/2022 18:32

Just BYO

Which obviously will be against the rules too

NewYorkLassie · 09/06/2022 20:59

We had roast beef and white win. Nobody complained or asked for red

I think what you meant to say was no one complained to our faces. I would find it very odd not to be offered a choice of red or white wine regardless of what the food was.

TeaKlaxon · 09/06/2022 20:59

GrinAndVomit · 09/06/2022 20:54

They appear to be relying on some woolly clause in the contract around "it's a historic building, changes may need to be made to your wedding plan that are out of our control due to operational reasons" etc.

Yeah but this change isn’t outside the venue’s control.

luckylavender · 09/06/2022 20:57

KyaClark · 09/06/2022 18:28

Red wine in gift bags.

Be discreet.

Stupid stupid idea. Honestly.

Queenoftheashes · 09/06/2022 20:57

I’d be furious personally.

luckylavender · 09/06/2022 20:56

Shinytaps · 09/06/2022 18:28

I would start by contacting them and explaining this is important to you and can you work together to come up with a solution? Acknowledge their concerns and give reassurance that there won’t be an incident?Perhaps you could compromise and say you’ll have it outside for the drinks reception? I wouldn’t steam in making threats. I totally get why you’re upset though. It would upset me too!

How on earth can you guarantee there won't be an incident?

luckylavender · 09/06/2022 20:55

RedWineRage · 09/06/2022 18:17

Posting here for traffic....and also some perspective/help/ideas!

Getting married this summer. Reception venue is stately home-type place which is open to the public but also does weddings, has done successfully for years. Top listed wedding venue in various magazines etc and very good reviews. So - not some shady outfit.

Email out of the blue this week - all rather breezy - due to several incidents at recent events, just to let you know we will no longer be serving red wine at all, with immediate effect.

But don't worry, we'll just swap that out for rosé in your drinks package.

What???

My mum only drinks red wine. Several family members prefer red wine. We planned to have beef as a main.

Totally unacceptable, right? They appear to be relying on some woolly clause in the contract around "it's a historic building, changes may need to be made to your wedding plan that are out of our control due to operational reasons" etc.

We're genuinely considering trying at short notice to get another venue, and trying to claim money back through small claims. Has anyone done this? Any ideas on how likely we are to be successful?

My mum can't not have an alcoholic drink at my wedding. Sorry I'm ranting and probably not being very rational.

Perspective and advice welcome!!

I absolutely hate the dependence on alcohol we have in this country. It's obscene. No one needs to be so reliant on alcohol to have a good time. But you know if you don't like it, find another venue.

GrinAndVomit · 09/06/2022 20:54

TeaKlaxon · 09/06/2022 20:50

Not unless their contract specifies that and the OP hasn’t posted anything from the contract that says they do.

They appear to be relying on some woolly clause in the contract around "it's a historic building, changes may need to be made to your wedding plan that are out of our control due to operational reasons" etc.

Daenerys77 · 09/06/2022 20:53

Is it only red wine that is forbidden or all dark coloured drinks? No Kir Royale, no port, no Ribena for the kids?

SpideySensesIsALoadOfShit · 09/06/2022 20:52

Because stains and damage has obviously become an issue between the time of booking and now.

The venue has a responsibility to maintain the property to the highest standard.

I would think brides would be more upset with paying thousands for a venue covered in red wine stains or losing their deposit because a guest spilt a drink

If that's true, and stains have become an issue, then it's fine for the venue to veto red wine (or anything else they like) for future bookings. But they can't apply it retrospectively.

As I say, I have no dog in this fight as I loathe big weddings and would be happy if they were all banned. However, I would say that the venue is wrong in this case.

Abbaloverandmum · 09/06/2022 20:50

We had roast beef and white win. Nobody complained or asked for red.