Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unschooling - thoughts?

202 replies

Snickerdoodle1 · 09/06/2022 17:02

Recently got back in touch with an old school friend via Facebook, have mostly shared messages but last week we met properly for coffee and was good to see her again.

I'd never heard of it before but apparently she is 'unschooling' her DS - not the same as home ed as they never sit down and dedicate time to work, they just visit the occasional museum and forest school class but mostly just focus on being happy. They go on a lot of holidays and spend time will their fellow unschooling friends.

Her DS seems cheerful and positive so clearly she's doing something right but when I was discussing with DH later at home he said he thinks it's 'not fair' on someone not to equip them for life and work and adulthood.

Just wondering what other people's thoughts/opinions are on it?

OP posts:
FilamentB · 09/06/2022 18:52

The older I get, the more amazing it is to me how people can have such strong opinions about things they know little or nothing about.

We home educate. We don't unschool but know many families who do and without exception their children are bright, motivated and enthusiastic with numerous talents and interests, many of which they've persued to a high level. I know several who are now adults and have had no problem going onto further education or employment.

The law says you must provide a 'suitable' education and defines that as 'that which equips the learner for life in the community of which they are a member'. How you achieve that is largely upto you. Home educators don't have to teach in a formal way, follow the national curriculum or take exams if they don't wish to, but It's worth noting that most families DO take GCSEs and/or go into further education, and that includes many unschoolers. If an unschooled child wants to follow a career path which requires certain qualifications, why wouldn't they be motivated to study for those exams? Unschooling isn't about avoiding anything which looks like traditional schooling.

Unschooling isn't about doing nothing or just letting the child decide what they want to learn and expecting them to magically come up with a schoolish answer like the romans or trigonometry. A HUGE part of unschooling is creating a rich life (in terms of education and experiences, not money), about introducing children to new information, ideas, topics, concepts, opportunities, but with the focus on helping the child finding their talents and their passions.

The unschooled children I know have a range of interests, some which look nothing like school and many which do. One is about to take GCSE history at age 10, another is passionate about languages and is fluent in several, both from following their interests and passions. Persuing an interest may well involve hiring tutors or seeking out mentors, again it is NOT about avoiding anything which looks like formal schooling.

As for reading, it's common for home educated children, even when not being unschooled, to learn to read at a later age, often around 8 or 9. Schoolchildren would too, except everything in school requires being able to read, so we teach children intensively to get them reading as soon as possible. Home educated children, taught one to one and able to go at their own pace, don't have that urgency. Of the research I have seen and going also by personal experience, home educated children who learn to read at 8 or 9 have caught up and often overtaken their schooled peers within a year or two. Unschoolers DO help their children learn to read if that child wishes to be helped, but yes, some children do learn without formal teaching. We live in a literate world where almost everything requires being able to read and write, so children are naturally motivated to want to be able to read and parents are on hand to facilitate that. The idea that left to their own devices a child will choose not to learn to read is nonsense. Barring one with severe SEN and one with dyslexia (who is receiving help) I dont know any home educated children above age 10 who can't read.

Sirzy · 09/06/2022 18:51

Thatswhyimacat · 09/06/2022 18:46

It doesn't sound very conducive to stretching bright kids?

I was extremely good at maths for example. I could do quadratic equations by the time I was 10. That wouldn't have happened if I'd been doing cake baking maths.

Most schools aren’t exactly fantastic at stretching talent children are they. They are as limited by the curriculum in a lot of schools as the children who struggle.

infact having the support to develop your skills without pressure of school can be a massive help in stretching children.

TheKeatingFive · 09/06/2022 18:47

It’s amazing how much children pick up when they’re not in an environment that’s hostile towards them

well I'm sure that's true, but the point is that it's not a good option for most people to forgo basic skills.

It’s not easy to make a living in general though - minimum wage jobs and cost of living crisis means even basic normal jobs don’t support you anymore. Anyway, and this is a personal thing, I think it’s more important to encourage children to follow their passions than to fit in, conform and do a dead end job because “that’s what you do”.

Which is why it's important to have a variety of options. Anyone I know who has made it in following their passions has been dependent on supporting themselves in more mundane jobs while they establish themselves

Thatswhyimacat · 09/06/2022 18:46

It doesn't sound very conducive to stretching bright kids?

I was extremely good at maths for example. I could do quadratic equations by the time I was 10. That wouldn't have happened if I'd been doing cake baking maths.

Snickerdoodle1 · 09/06/2022 18:39

@Blueyandbingosmum I have been on MN many years but recently changed username and account because of the data breach issue last week.

And @carefullycourageous I'm not being goady - had genuinely no experience of unschooling before. Shouldn't have posted in AIBU I suppose, would have been better in Chat!

OP posts:
AntlerRose · 09/06/2022 18:39

Its increasingly difficult to access anything without at least level 1 functional skills in english and maths - most apprenticeships and jobs. But this is relevant to school children, homeschooled and unschooled.

LoonyLurcher · 09/06/2022 18:37

TheKeatingFive · 09/06/2022 18:29

but say she didn’t pick up much maths for arguments sake - maybe she old be an author, an artist or a musician? Maybe she would compose, maybe she’d write novels

The issue is that it isn't easy to make a living with any of these things, great as they might be, particularly when starting off.

Meanwhile basic qualifications in maths are a requirement for many jobs, including those that you might have to do to support yourself while trying to make it as a writer/musician.

Unless you're from a very rich background, or aren't going to support yourself for whatever reason, basic skills are important.

Many of my son’s peers who went to school didn’t achieve maths GCSE. Those who have gone on to apprenticeships have the opportunity to take them again, my son has the same opportunity.

My younger son was recently assessed for his English and maths ability before starting college. He was slightly below average for maths (they estimated he’d need a couple of months of tuition to catch up) but way above for English (comprehension, vocabulary etc), following 5 years out of school. It’s amazing how much children pick up when they’re not in an environment that’s hostile towards them.

carefullycourageous · 09/06/2022 18:36

Blueyandbingosmum · 09/06/2022 18:29

I can't find any other threads started by OP. Perhaps she name changes regularly.

There have been a few anti home ed threads on MN recently. At the same time, there is a new education bill proposed that will significantly restrict homeschooling.

I agree this is likely - this topic is designed to goad and make people take an anti-HE position.

Tumbleweed101 · 09/06/2022 18:35

I did this with my two eldest until junior school age (around 7). They weren't impacted educationally but they are a lot more grown up and independent than my younger children who went through the school system from nursery.

Done properly it can be very positive but as parents you need to be committed to providing experiences and opportunities.

ForestFae · 09/06/2022 18:34

Blueyandbingosmum · 09/06/2022 18:29

I can't find any other threads started by OP. Perhaps she name changes regularly.

There have been a few anti home ed threads on MN recently. At the same time, there is a new education bill proposed that will significantly restrict homeschooling.

Yes, it’s very interesting isn’t it. There’s also been loads of news articles with an anti home ed stance.

ForestFae · 09/06/2022 18:33

TheKeatingFive · 09/06/2022 18:29

but say she didn’t pick up much maths for arguments sake - maybe she old be an author, an artist or a musician? Maybe she would compose, maybe she’d write novels

The issue is that it isn't easy to make a living with any of these things, great as they might be, particularly when starting off.

Meanwhile basic qualifications in maths are a requirement for many jobs, including those that you might have to do to support yourself while trying to make it as a writer/musician.

Unless you're from a very rich background, or aren't going to support yourself for whatever reason, basic skills are important.

It’s not easy to make a living in general though - minimum wage jobs and cost of living crisis means even basic normal jobs don’t support you anymore. Anyway, and this is a personal thing, I think it’s more important to encourage children to follow their passions than to fit in, conform and do a dead end job because “that’s what you do”.
.
I have also worked in standard normal job in the past and I’ve never been asked to prove my maths qualification. Plus you can sit GCSE maths as an adult anyway - which if you need it for a job, you’re probably more likely to do it well as you have a motivation rather than a kid who hates it and doesn’t want to do it. Learning doesn’t have to only be 5-16 in conventional school

ForestFae · 09/06/2022 18:31

LoonyLurcher · 09/06/2022 18:28

@PurpleDaisies HE usually follows a plan, rather like a curriculum, so topics that might run for a few weeks or so, like a school would, which includes many areas of learning.

Unschooling is letting the child lead what is happening, so following their interests and fitting in relevant learning within that. So a “topic” may last for weeks and weeks if the child finds it interesting.

To give an example, one of my kids is really interested in gardening. Loves it. Outside in all weathers, adores plants, loves growing things. A lot of his education centres on that. We use gardening to teach him pretty much everything. All his “lessons” are done outside if possible, and we relate everything back to it. We will do this for as long as he shows an interest.

And yes, he can count and read to a similar level of his peers. He doesn’t only know how to grow plants, before someone says that.

Blueyandbingosmum · 09/06/2022 18:29

I can't find any other threads started by OP. Perhaps she name changes regularly.

There have been a few anti home ed threads on MN recently. At the same time, there is a new education bill proposed that will significantly restrict homeschooling.

TheKeatingFive · 09/06/2022 18:29

but say she didn’t pick up much maths for arguments sake - maybe she old be an author, an artist or a musician? Maybe she would compose, maybe she’d write novels

The issue is that it isn't easy to make a living with any of these things, great as they might be, particularly when starting off.

Meanwhile basic qualifications in maths are a requirement for many jobs, including those that you might have to do to support yourself while trying to make it as a writer/musician.

Unless you're from a very rich background, or aren't going to support yourself for whatever reason, basic skills are important.

ForestFae · 09/06/2022 18:28

carefullycourageous · 09/06/2022 18:27

Because people talk as if not putting a child into the school system is 'worse' but statistically it is not worse. Some parents prefer to take control and give their kids a hgher standard of education and an education focused on their child's talents.

The assumption is often that kids who are home educated (whether with a curriculum or unschooled) are somehow impoverished and deprived of opportunities. They are not. They often have greater opportunities and more tailored opportunities. Schools are really very limited in what they can offer.

I have experience of teaching, of home educating and of school educating.

I also find it amazing that if a child isn’t doing very well at school, people accept maybe the child isn’t talented in that particular area - whereas if a home ed child struggles, it must be because they’re home ed

LoonyLurcher · 09/06/2022 18:28

@PurpleDaisies HE usually follows a plan, rather like a curriculum, so topics that might run for a few weeks or so, like a school would, which includes many areas of learning.

Unschooling is letting the child lead what is happening, so following their interests and fitting in relevant learning within that. So a “topic” may last for weeks and weeks if the child finds it interesting.

carefullycourageous · 09/06/2022 18:27

PurpleDaisies · 09/06/2022 18:21

A very large number leave school functionally illiterate and unable to do basic maths.

Which is a failure of schools. I’m not sure what it’s got to do with this discussion.

Because people talk as if not putting a child into the school system is 'worse' but statistically it is not worse. Some parents prefer to take control and give their kids a hgher standard of education and an education focused on their child's talents.

The assumption is often that kids who are home educated (whether with a curriculum or unschooled) are somehow impoverished and deprived of opportunities. They are not. They often have greater opportunities and more tailored opportunities. Schools are really very limited in what they can offer.

I have experience of teaching, of home educating and of school educating.

ForestFae · 09/06/2022 18:25

PurpleDaisies · 09/06/2022 18:22

This is using too much that’s outside my sphere of knowledge.

I’ll simplify it - there’s different types of home ed, it’s an umbrella term. Unschooling is what’s used to refer to a child led, loose approach. Most home edders will use a mixture of methods rather than purely one type.

ForestFae · 09/06/2022 18:24

LoonyLurcher · 09/06/2022 18:22

Unschooled children (having met many of them) seem to be more curious and keen to learn, possibly because they follow their interests often to a very great level.

It hasn’t seemed to hold any back from accessing university or 6th form college, or vocational courses, or apprenticeships, so I’m not sure it’s accurate to say that this will hold them back.

In fact I would go so far as to say that compared to the local secondary school, the unschoolers have a higher rate of success when it comes to moving into higher education and beyond. Obviously this is a relatively small local group who met up and supported each other, and may not be representative of the whole UK population of unschoolers, but it really does seem to work. Not one of us decided to take this path so we could be lazy or neglectful though.

It makes me laugh when they say home educators of any kind are lazy - if I was lazy, surely I’d be glad to palm my kids off for 9-3 and possibly an after school club later? No/very little food to cook, only a couple of hours until bedtime, wouldn’t have to look after the kids for most of the day and week…

I’m not for a minute saying all parents of schooled kids are lazy, just that if someone IS lazy, I’m not sure home education is what they’d choose.

PurpleDaisies · 09/06/2022 18:24

ForestFae · 09/06/2022 18:22

Because people are holding conventional schooling up as some sort of intellectual panacea when that’s often far from the case.

I’m not coming from that position.
I’m trying to understand how this is different from the sorts of home education I’ve seen before.

SickKid · 09/06/2022 18:24

Spikeyball · 09/06/2022 18:06

When I have seen the term unschooling used it has been used when the child has been through trauma, sometimes trauma caused by being in school.

This

LoonyLurcher · 09/06/2022 18:22

Unschooled children (having met many of them) seem to be more curious and keen to learn, possibly because they follow their interests often to a very great level.

It hasn’t seemed to hold any back from accessing university or 6th form college, or vocational courses, or apprenticeships, so I’m not sure it’s accurate to say that this will hold them back.

In fact I would go so far as to say that compared to the local secondary school, the unschoolers have a higher rate of success when it comes to moving into higher education and beyond. Obviously this is a relatively small local group who met up and supported each other, and may not be representative of the whole UK population of unschoolers, but it really does seem to work. Not one of us decided to take this path so we could be lazy or neglectful though.

PurpleDaisies · 09/06/2022 18:22

ForestFae · 09/06/2022 18:21

Home educating (not home schooling) encompasses a wide variety of philosophies and approaches to education, including school at home, the classical approach (heavy classical literature focus), Charlotte Mason style, to list a few off the top of my head. A lot of home educators use a mixture of methods, unschooling is typically following the child’s interests rather than having a rigid plan of what to do when.

This is using too much that’s outside my sphere of knowledge.

ForestFae · 09/06/2022 18:22

PurpleDaisies · 09/06/2022 18:21

A very large number leave school functionally illiterate and unable to do basic maths.

Which is a failure of schools. I’m not sure what it’s got to do with this discussion.

Because people are holding conventional schooling up as some sort of intellectual panacea when that’s often far from the case.

ForestFae · 09/06/2022 18:21

PurpleDaisies · 09/06/2022 18:20

Can anyone explain in terms that a four year old can understand how unschooling is different to conventional home schooling?

Home educating (not home schooling) encompasses a wide variety of philosophies and approaches to education, including school at home, the classical approach (heavy classical literature focus), Charlotte Mason style, to list a few off the top of my head. A lot of home educators use a mixture of methods, unschooling is typically following the child’s interests rather than having a rigid plan of what to do when.