Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset at the reason for not being asked to be Godmother?

130 replies

wildchild88 · 09/06/2022 14:35

My best friend of 14 years is the godson to my eldest. She would've been bridesmaid at my wedding etc. She had a baby last year and hasn't asked me to be godmother. At that I could've been a bit hurt but got over it.
I had a baby myself a few months before her.
She said the reason she didn't ask me was because "her partners parents take it seriously and I've got enough on my plate"
I left my abusive ex 6 months ago and took our children with me. She's chosen someone who has no children but is married. I mean I'm sure she's a lovely woman and has done a lot for her little boy since he was born but it just feels like a kick in the teeth of "we would've chose you but your life is too chaotic to think you're responsible enough to leave our son to"
I haven't said anything and I won't cos I don't want to cause any arguments or not worth it, but.. AIBU to be upset? Had a little cry to myself about it.

OP posts:
Sweepingeyelashes · 09/06/2022 15:48

My son's godmother has no children of her own and isn't married. She has always remembered events and taken an interest in his progress. She stumped up with a cash sum when he was at university saying that she knew all sorts of expenses cropped up. She has the time and space to take an interest because she isn't weighed down with all sorts of other responsibilities. She has taken it on the chin that her godson turned out to be an atheist! I have to say the married godparents have their own children to see to and I'm sure hardly remember they were godparents.

To be a godmother in my faith you must be christened in a Christian church - we don't require it to be our particular faith - but it must be Christian. Taking it seriously might meant that they require somebody who is christened and ideally a practising Christian to be a godmother.

SpideySensesIsALoadOfShit · 09/06/2022 15:46

I think it's to do with different understandings of what a godparent's role is, OP, not anything personal.

My understanding has always been that it's to do with religion, hence my DC have no godparents. However, we do have lovely friends who have always been involved with them, and who are valuable sources of advice and support. If XH and I had both died, my sister would have had our children. I wouldn't even have wanted them to go to his family, never mind an 'outsider'.

Leypt1 · 09/06/2022 15:45

Your feelings are valid and I understand why you're upset! It must be tough to feel like someone is saying you're not strong enough when I'm sure you've demonstrated massive strength in your life recently!

Hopefully though you can see that your friend was speaking from a place of care, and that it's not her decision alone but her whole family's to make! Maybe have a conversation with her about how her comment made you feel, but bear in mind that her decision will probably stay the same

GCRich · 09/06/2022 15:43

SweatyChamoisPad · Today 14:38

That’s not the meaning of a godparent - to look after someone’s kids if they die. You have godparents to take responsibility for the child’s spiritual education if something happens to their parents. It’s why catholic children must have a catholic godparent. Either she or you are defining “godparent” incorrectly really.

There is no such thing as a catholic child. Only a child who is being indoctrinated by catholics.

pinkyredrose · 09/06/2022 15:42

You're confusing 'godparent' and 'guardian'. Anyway if she died wouldn't her husband have her child?

3luckystars · 09/06/2022 15:41

If you want to leave your child to someone if you die, then you make a will, this has nothing to do with being a godparent.

if it was, a person would pick the same godparent for all of their children, why would they want them to be split up?

godparent means taking them to church, and usually buying better gifts for them. Sorry you are upset.

PicklePastry · 09/06/2022 15:39

I do think some people do use the term "godparent" and "guardian if I should die" interchangeably. It seems as of OP and her friend are not religious so to them the term means "guardian should I die".

I agree with the above poster who says that people sometimes see the godparents as being like your maid of honor or bridesmaid. Friendship should not be the first and foremost reason you would give someone guardianship of you child. I would not make MY best friend my daughter's guardian. She is single, on a low wage, in rented accommodation, and doesn't like children. I do hope that someday she can take on a fun aunt role and teach my daughter about her many cool interests and be a great moral example for her. Although she loves my daughter, she would not be a good fit. My daughter's guardians in the event of my death are her grandparents, and when she (and they) get older, we will change it to some friends of ours who have kids her age, a stable marriage, a safe and loving home, and similar values to us. They are already "godparents" for several other people as well, they're a good choice!

It sounds like you DO have a lot on your plate right now, if you friend passed tomorrow would you find it easy to suddenly take on the responsibility of another child? She doesn't owe you this, even though you chose her for that role, and yes, as others have said, her husband also gets a say. Being a godparent/guardian is not a prize for being a good friend. I'm sorry her comment (which was certainly tactless) hurt your feelings, your difficult separation will certainly be contributing to your low mood and I hope things get better for you soon.

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 09/06/2022 15:37

She chose someone with no DCs so it may be that even if you were married, she wouldn't have picked you because her and her DP (it will have been a joint decision so not just up) wanted someone with no dependents.

Neolara · 09/06/2022 15:34

I was rejected as my nephew and neices' godparent as I didn't have an illustrious enough career and I wouldn't be able to help the kids network when I was older. (SIL's view,). I was quite put out.

Ironically, most of them have had fairly significant mental health issues and I'm a psychologist.so I my vested interest might have genuinely been quite helpful. Probably more helpful than the bunch of bankers I think they ended up with.

But I'm also a total atheist so have no interest in doing godly godparent duties.

Bettethebuilder · 09/06/2022 15:34

ElenaSt · 09/06/2022 15:31

Sounds to me that the grandparents want someone well off as god parent and think rightly or wrongly that your being a single parent meant a you might not be as generous financially to your god child as a wealthier person might be.

Eh? How on earth did you get to that thought?

ElenaSt · 09/06/2022 15:31

Sounds to me that the grandparents want someone well off as god parent and think rightly or wrongly that your being a single parent meant a you might not be as generous financially to your god child as a wealthier person might be.

Triffid1 · 09/06/2022 15:29

Yes, agree with PPs - you are not understanding this correctly.

If they are religious (or his parents are), a godparent is someone who will support the child in the way they grow in their religion and their relationship with God. Ideally, this person would also act as a sort of parental figure to the child, as a support and sounding board etc.

If they are not religious but are choosing to do a traditional godparent (DH's family are not religious but they take godparents very seriously, so we are in this category), a godparent is someone you would like to play an active role in your child's life, to support them and love them.

Neither scenario assumes the god parent would become the child's guardian. I and not particularly religious. My sister is. I am not a godparent to her children. I AM however, their legal guardian should anything happen to her and her DH.

I do understand why you might be upset. But not being godmother does not preclude you having a relationship with her children. And if his family have quite set roles for godparents, then I can understand that they might not feel you're in a position to have that type of relationship with this child. Certainly, in DH's family, this relationship is so important and now, years later, I appreciate it a lot - both of my DC get such a lot from their respective godparents (mostly).

Yodaisawally · 09/06/2022 15:27

Godparent does not mean taking a child after the parents die, that is old fashioned shit advice.

You have Wills for that.

God parents either support the child's religious growth if you are that way inclined, or they are a named person on the day that means nothing once the kid get about 2.

Anonymous48 · 09/06/2022 15:25

wildchild88 · 09/06/2022 14:39

No, neither of them are religious at all. I think they're understanding is it's who would have the child should they die.

That's not what a godparent is!

If they aren't religious at all, why are they even having their child baptised? None of it makes sense.

Are you religious and would you want to have the responsibility of guiding this child in their spirituality?

thecatsthecats · 09/06/2022 15:25

Confusion101 · 09/06/2022 14:56

I think you are over reacting a little. There comes an added expense with being a godparent, more pressure to buy gifts, to treat them, etc. Maybe that's the added pressure she didn't want to put on u! I understand u might feel hurt, but on the flip side I hate that because u asked her u feel it is expected that she asks u.

Yes, there's three options really:

  • the whole shebang of taking a child after they die
  • religious guidance
  • the sort of "bonus aunt" appropriation atheists use

"Tit for tat" godparent choices adds a whole other dimension. I think that you're looking for her to judge you when just as equally she could be being supportive.

I'm a bridesmaid at the moment for a friend who has occasionally messaged me to give me the heads up when one or more of the others is too preoccupied to deal with hen party stuff and no doubt she's done the same to the others about me.

Friendship isn't just about sharing the honours, it's about appreciating that we don't always have the same amount to give, and that's fine.

Sunshinebug · 09/06/2022 15:20

I can totally see why you’re hurt and disappointed by this decision. They can select who they wish, and parental views if a traditional or religious family may factor heavily, but they could have been kinder in their explanation perhaps.

AlternativePerspective · 09/06/2022 15:19

IMO the role of godparent has been confused and people see it almost like. Being asked to be a bridesmaid at someone’s wedding. Like a statement that you’re a mate so suitable as a godparent.

As said above, a Godparet is someone who has an input into the child’s spiritual upbringing, it’s not something to be done just because you’re her friend.

And tbh most people who aren’t religious and have a christening do so for the party afterwards. After all if you don’t believe in God then you don’t actually intend to bring up your child in the eyes of God so what’s the point really?

Sepiarose · 09/06/2022 15:19

I have a Godchild. When she was born I bought her a Bible. When she made her Sacraments (in the RC church) I sent her age appropriate books about God. I pray for her regularly. I believe that I am fulfilling my role as her Godmother in helping to be an influence to gently steer her towards Christ.

That's what it is about and those are the promises I made at her Christening a decade ago. If you don't plan to be that person, and will be lying when you promise to nurture the child's love for Jesus and understanding of the Gospel, then what's the point? I get that it's a status thing these days, but that's not what it's really about.

However, I am sorry that you feel hurt by it and see that it would sting somewhat when you look at it as some kind of cultural rite of passage. It hurts to feel rejected and I'm not trying to be harsh. Nonetheless, the real reason for being a Godparent is very different to how society often perceives it.

scrivette · 09/06/2022 15:07

Is she having a religious ceremony? If you have your child Baptised in Church the Godparents (and Parents) have to stand up and declare their faith and belief in God.

Icansleep · 09/06/2022 15:06

wildchild88 · 09/06/2022 14:39

No, neither of them are religious at all. I think they're understanding is it's who would have the child should they die.

I'd be extremely surprised if that's what they mean

Bettethebuilder · 09/06/2022 15:06

You are way overreacting here. Your friend is being sensible. It sounds like you don’t know what a godparent actually is/does. And you have got a lot on your plate - your friend is being thoughtful.

marylou25 · 09/06/2022 15:05

Common misconception about godparents being same as guardians. OP if you died and there was no father on the scene it doesn't mean your friend gets your kids or even just the one she is godmother too. That's a whole different thing! Sure how would that work bearing in mind that children have different godparents usually so if someone had 3 kids and both parents died each kid went to a different person, not the way it works!

This is why everyone should have a will made and guardians appointed just in case and they don't have to be godparents which is an entirely religious role.

Chikapu · 09/06/2022 15:05

She's chosen someone who has no children but is married. I mean I'm sure she's a lovely woman

What does the fact she has no children have to do with anything 🤔

Outnumbered99 · 09/06/2022 15:05

As someone who is often left out of things because i "have so much on my plate" I agree with you, it hurts.

But as someone who has been to Christenings and often thought wow, I couldn't in all honesty promise to do the exact things you agree to do to be a godparent, I see your friends point too, if taken seriously (as it should be, otherwise whats the point) its quite a hefty commitment.

Its who you think can commit to the religious aspects, to supporting your child's religious life, not a popularity contest and nothing at all to do with who you would nominate as guardians for your children upon your death.

Testina · 09/06/2022 15:04

Total over reaction and twisting what she said.

What role did you want for her to perform, as godparent to your eldest? What does she actually do now?

What role does she want from her choice?

As others have said - a godparent is not a de facto legal guardian.

And presumably you don’t think that either, as you say she’s godparent to your eldest. So presumably not to your youngest. So your plan if you died was for them to be split up between friends?

Like bridesmaid, for those are not religious, it’s just a meaningless title used to say, “you’re my bestie!”. Kind of like Y4s and BFF necklaces.

Swipe left for the next trending thread