Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not give too much thought to what my toddler eats or am I just a terrible mum?

35 replies

PatOnTheBack · 09/06/2022 12:25

Inspired by a thread I read this morning, sort of, where poster's were referring to high salt in food when eating out not being suitable for young children ect..

And it got me thinking, am I just a really bad mum because I've never given much thought to what my young child eats beyond making sure he has a balance of healthy stuff.

He's 18 months, absolutely adores fruit of any kind and eats at least two types of fruit per day, not massively keen on veg but at least one type always offered with meals. But yeah, he drinks juice, sometimes he'll have water, sometimes he'll have juice, he has chocolate every now and then, might share a few of my crisps from a bag, have an ice-cream out at the park, he might have a dreaded high salt sandwich from a cafe (I wouldn't know because I don't check things like that Blush) and so on...

He eats good things and he also eats what some people on here would say are bad things or 'not recommended'. I've not really come across anything that I've felt should be totally off limits for him to try or have a small amount of (except fizzy drinks and the obvious things like alcohol obviously haha).

He's a normal looking 18 month old, not skinny, not fat.

Am I the only one who doesn't really 'care' what their young child eats? And by not care I mean I don't have specific off limit things like juice, chocolate or crisps or salt and so on? As long as he doesn't eat things things in massive amounts or daily I've never even thought anything of it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Sceptre86 · 10/06/2022 14:25

I think people are led by their own circumstances and the needs of their child. So when my eldest started weaning she was on the 2nd percentile and never drank much milk. I made all her food from scratch, I would only use pouches when put and often would take homemade food instead. When my son was at that stage he was a very chubby baby, a great milk drinker so food initially was more for exploration rather than me worrying about how much he ate. With my third, she is a big baby and a great milk drinker again, she has a good appetite for food but I'm easygoing and if she asks for a taste of what I am eating I will mostly give it unless it is spicy. I have used pouches this time around at home too but I still have a preference towards homemade food. By age 2 mine are eating curries that shock horror contain salt and a whole range of spices. Obviously it will be at a child appropriate level but I don't sweat it.

As long as you are happy with your parenting and not stuffing your 2 year old full of processed or takeaway food for two out of these meals a day, does it really matter? It's about balance.

Gr33ngr33ngr4ss · 09/06/2022 17:54

Had 2 children at 2 different nurseries and two different primary schools in a fairly "MN middle claaasss" area and I only met one parent who was as batshit as some of the folks on here about kids' food.

Annabel Karmelled them til they were about 8! I remember a birthday party where she called us all up by weaning stage to receive our appropriate puree or lumpy lunch! Ah, I'd forgotten that! Made me smile again. She still napped when the baby napped even when he was at nursery!

The rest of us are pretty normal. Kids eat what we eat and are all normal weights and active.

They eat sweet things. They eat chocolate. They eat fruit & veg. We've never obsessed over and they don't either.

DonnyBurrito · 09/06/2022 17:43

@Badgirlgonegood I wish I had the mindset for it, I love cooking for him, but if I've put in the time and effort (and done all the washing up that goes with cooking from scratch!) and my food gets rejected or smashed into the table, it is heartbreaking 😂 To be fair I get the low salt and sugar beans for him, beans are a good source of iron though so I kind of see it as a healthy food 🤷‍♀️

I keep forgetting to get fish fingers for him to try! Thanks for the reminder 😊

Badgirlgonegood · 09/06/2022 14:59

DonnyBurrito · 09/06/2022 14:41

I must be awful then! My PFB is 10 months and there's nothing I won't let him eat really 😆 Except stones... Or poop! Or poisonous plants.

Some 'naughty' things he eats regularly: Baked beans, buttered toast, garlic bread, pork pie, pizza, ice cream, home made chips and bisto gravy, cheese on toast, pancakes, muffins, cheese pastries, (baby) crisps, pasta/spaghetti bolognese (made with 😱 oxo cubes), cheese twists, crackers...

I do check the salt content of everything and try my best to keep it around the recommended 1g or less a day though. If I think he's had a bit of a salty day, I'll just give him more fruit and veg the next day. He eats basically anything though, so has plenty of healthy stuff alongside the 'naughty' stuff and I thinks it's relatively balanced.

I feel like @Badgirlgonegood would be aghast watching my kid wolfing down a pork pie! 😂 I commend your devotion to providing a salt/sugar free diet, genuinely!

Haha your attitude sounds great though 😀.

Our toddlers whole diet isn’t salt and sugar free, it’s just very low salt and we keep an eye on added salt.

I am getting more relaxed though, I think food prep was a big anxiety of mine and I have stressed about getting the practical things right but it’s ok not to be perfect.
Our little boy does have beans once a week he loves them!!! And he’s also partial to a fish finger.

I have let myself get really worked up about not having enough stuff prepped for him it’s madness really!! I think it’s cause I followed a couple of baby health food books and they made me worry.

OlympicProcrastinator · 09/06/2022 14:56

I think there’s a lot of judgement on here as if anything other than a typical western diet which is high in processed or sugary foods is ‘restrictive’ and parents who don’t buy kids sweets or biscuits are somehow neurotic. I have early onset osteoarthritis for which I am virtually symptom free now after years of eating a Mediterranean diet. I just don’t eat processed food so don’t have it in my house because I don’t buy it. My kids have plenty of high fat food such as cream and cheese so they are hardly deprived and no, they don’t go ‘mad at parties’, hoovering up sweets and cakes like I’ve been cruel to them not feeding them stuff like that daily. They enjoy party food at parties like other kids. I don’t think anyone should be looking at what others eat and make sneering judgements and ‘normal diet’ needs to be in context. What is a ‘normal’ diet for children in the US or UK would not be considered ’normal’ in many other places.

Hallyup89 · 09/06/2022 14:47

I don't really care. My 3 year old always drinks juice, milk or sometimes (shock horror) Diet Coke. For her lunch, she's had vegetable samosas, salt and vinegar crisps, fruit, yoghurt and little chocolate biscuits. She'll have similar every day, as will my other 4 kids.
None of them are overweight, nor have problems with their teeth.

The 'holier than thou' mothers on here that only feed their kids organic hummus, avocado and water do my head in.

DonnyBurrito · 09/06/2022 14:41

I must be awful then! My PFB is 10 months and there's nothing I won't let him eat really 😆 Except stones... Or poop! Or poisonous plants.

Some 'naughty' things he eats regularly: Baked beans, buttered toast, garlic bread, pork pie, pizza, ice cream, home made chips and bisto gravy, cheese on toast, pancakes, muffins, cheese pastries, (baby) crisps, pasta/spaghetti bolognese (made with 😱 oxo cubes), cheese twists, crackers...

I do check the salt content of everything and try my best to keep it around the recommended 1g or less a day though. If I think he's had a bit of a salty day, I'll just give him more fruit and veg the next day. He eats basically anything though, so has plenty of healthy stuff alongside the 'naughty' stuff and I thinks it's relatively balanced.

I feel like @Badgirlgonegood would be aghast watching my kid wolfing down a pork pie! 😂 I commend your devotion to providing a salt/sugar free diet, genuinely!

Kanaloa · 09/06/2022 14:38

My main problem with those pouches was the expense for something like mashed fruit. Fruit that I already had at home! I never bought them and just mashed up some fruit/veg/dinner. Much cheaper and I imagine just as tasty.

wherestheegg · 09/06/2022 14:33

By 18 months no, I find it weird when I go to a toddler group and a 3 year old is eating a baby weaning "fruit" rice cracker. I mean there's about 6 kcals in one, there's zero nutrition, why are you feeding that to a fully grown child? Just give them a variety of normal food.

So no I'm not bothered. When first weaning I did consider slay content and that some pouches are mainly just apple juice which just caused acid reflux in my DC.

MySerenity · 09/06/2022 14:16

I do think you should care...
We avoid ultra processed foods as much as possible- no "baby foods" like processed porridge/purees/snack things and avoid stuff like crisps/chocolate/cereals/nuggets/juice unless it's a one off sort of occasion. We do buy pre made breads/pittas etc, but try and get wholemeal and less processed ones where we can. Veggies offered with lunch and dinner.
I think if majority of foods are homemade then salt level is pretty easy to control? I wouldn't worry about a one off sandwich at a cafe!
I probably seem OTT but I genuinely believe added sugars and sweeteners are bad for health, and we do have an obesity epidemic in adults and now kids. So what's "normal" diet, clearly isn't good for us.
Processed foods aren't "banned" but aren't in our day-to-day diet, comparable to birthday cake not being an everyday thing here!

Rodneytrotterslovechild · 09/06/2022 14:09

My lot only ate organic veg-home grown
the only reason is their grandad is a gardener and used to grow so much he fed most of his street-the joke was ‘if grandad doesn’t grow it,you won’t get to eat it’
ive never grown so much as a weed
(believe me,their fruit wasn’t organic)
they ate chocolate,sweets and crisps-along with healthy meals
it really is about balance
my eldest will tell you how abused she was because she tasted her first McDonald’s aged 9-I don’t like the food (I bloody work there now!)
it didn’t dawn on me to take them!

Everything has its place-my son went though a stage where he refused sweets
i explained to him that no food is ‘bad’
even eating too much ‘good’ food is bad for you if you eat enough of it
hes a gym bunny now but does allow himself a treat or two once a week

Apollonia1 · 09/06/2022 14:08

I'm probably a bit on the batshit scale!

I've 2.4 year old twins. They eat everything (nothing I've done, they just have great appetites). I make all their food from scratch, so they fill up with fruit, vegs, meat, fish, eggs, dairy, pasta, potatoes etc. One of them was eating swede the other day, and said "yum yum" (weird kid!).

I don't have a sweet tooth, and don't like chocolate, biscuits, cake, etc, so I never think to buy it, so they never have it at home. At my dad's birthday party, they tried sponge-cake, and liked it. For their second birthday, my brother got them a chocolate cake, but they hated it.
I love crisps, but haven't given them any crisps yet. They don't know what they are, so I'll wait till they ask for them. I also love pizza, and took them out for a pizza recently - they loved it.

I'm not militant though - they had an ice-cream last weekend, they eat tonnes of salty olives, they had salami/chorizo the other day.

They only drink milk and water. They're not great on drinking water, so trying to encourage more of this.

My approach is to offer a range of healthy food, with some considered "unhealthy" food. I'm hoping as they grow-up and get more independent, they'll continue to eat everything, since now they like the taste of a broad range of food.

Lolly1987 · 09/06/2022 14:00

I'm similar with mine. As long as they're eating healthy stuff I'm not too concerned if they're eating " bad stuff". I think a balanced attitude to food is far healthier than keeping things off limits.

Kanaloa · 09/06/2022 14:00

It’s just normal. Most people don’t obsess like they do on mumsnet. Most people just eat most things in moderation and let their kids eat normal food.

Miriam101 · 09/06/2022 13:57

I- like many parents I think- have relaxed a lot with my second, but I'm still careful about the amount of salt he eats as if you look at the content in stuff it could be very easy for a small person to consume far more than they should if not monitored. That doesn't mean you have to be totally anal about it but just have a rough sense of what adds up to 2g a day.

fossilsmorefossils · 09/06/2022 13:57

I might be seen as batshit but my kid is allergic to all kinds of stuff. So she's never allowed any chocolate, or cookies, or pancakes, or pizza or whatever because it always contains one of her allergens. I'm stuck with fruit and veggies and a wholegrain sandwich with avocado, cucumber or a banana because that's what she can eat without vomiting and rashes. She eats healthily because she has no choice, it's so limited it gives me a headache trying to come up with stuff for her to eat. I now make my own "peanut butter" made from almonds and hazelnuts to put on a sandwich. Expensive but very tasty tbh...

Divebar2021 · 09/06/2022 13:56

Hmmm I can imagine the “no salt, no sugar” kids will go nuts at the sight of their first party ring biscuit given half a chance.
Everything in moderation I would say- reducing sugar is better for everyone but there’s a reason why some ingredients like sugar or salt appear in produce ( because the taste rank without it). I think the best attitude is to assume a child will eat what everyone else eats. It annoys me that so many restaurants offer such bland, beige food on the childrens menu. Since they are clearly not healthier options they are presumably driven by consumers.

Yodaisawally · 09/06/2022 13:45

You described me op. My kids are 11 now and eat pretty much anything and everything apart from fish in any form.

I'm basically lazy and they got a bit of whatever we were having with some cucumber and tomato on the side which they've always loved.

They can be funny with sauce and like gravy on the side for a roast dinner for example.

I didn't mainline them salt as babies but a bit of sense is required.

Some of my friends kids have sensory issues and one AFRID and that's a different story and really difficult.

SNAFU247 · 09/06/2022 13:42

I'm totally with you OP... I reckon my 1yr old probably eats far worse actually! I also have DS who is 6, so its hard to balance between them! To be honest, I know I should be more mindful of the food he eats as theres a lot of processed foods (e.g., babybel, baked beans, crisps).

However, I also find those people that control food and check all labels and have a panic attack about the salt content of a shop sandwich odd. A lady I used to work with once went into a blind panic at lunch because she calculated her kid had eaten over the recommended amount of vitamin A......I couldn't even tell you what is recommended. Everyone else I know with kids in real life is pretty laid back with this stuff though, so I think you're in the majority OP!

Badgirlgonegood · 09/06/2022 13:18

I am the batshit one but I’m learning to mellow out 😂😂.

Our toddler eats exactly what we eat and has his own portions in the freezer with no salt, like chilli, curry etc (no actual chillis but all the other spices).

He has a whole shelf of frozen home made snacks with no salt or sugar like oat bars and muffins and cookies.

He only drinks milk and water, don’t see the need for juice as he’s not the most amazing at having his teeth brushed so we are careful.

He is deffo partial to a cheeky icecream though but only a couple of times a month, he’s had chocolate about 3 times in 20 months, again don’t see the need at the moment until he knows what it is.

We use zero salt stock cubes and I make home made jam with no sugar in 10 mins.

LeeMucklowesCurtains · 09/06/2022 13:18

I’m on my third toddler now and I don’t care as long as she’s fed and happy.

shes 22 months, hates fruit of any kind, but will eat carrots, peas, broccoli, potato. likes meat. Eats lentil dahl, weetabix sometimes eggs if the mood takes her. Only drinks water or milk, she’s been given squash or fruit juice at playgroups and spits them out, she doesn’t like the taste. Thats good enough for me.

She has chocolate/crisps/ice cream etc because my 8 year old does sometimes. And I can’t lose sleep about the hatred of fruit because I haven’t eaten any for most of my life - I prefer vegetables too.

My eldest was worse than her. He basically lived off yogurt and toast until he was 3 and a half. I tied myself in knots over his diet, beat myself up no end.

He’s an extremely healthy 20 year old man now who will eat anything and has always chosen food on the healthier side, eats a ton of fruit, veg and fresh meat. When he was a toddler, I had visions of him growing into a fussy eater but he’s the opposite, there’s nothing he wouldn’t eat.

He suddenly changed at 3/4 and would eat anything. I’m sure his baby sister will be the same, so I don’t worry this time round.

GlitteryGreen · 09/06/2022 13:09

Tbh OP what you have written is what I recognise from parents I know in real life. Most of them make the effort that you do to give their children healthy and balanced diets, but also let them have the odd bits and pieces of chocolate, ice cream, McDonalds etc etc.

Some attitudes about food I've read on here just seem so extreme, even 'normal' dinners like sausage and mash or lasagne I've seen referred to as if they are the devil! Makes me wonder what some people on here eat, the amount of things that I've seen mentioned as crap.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 09/06/2022 13:08

The only thing that strikes me- and im not a puritan when it comes to food - is "sometimes he'll have water". I think water should be the main drink for children- the occasional should he heavily watered down juice.

The only other thing Im strict on is no sweets- i dont mind chocolate, i dont mind crisps- but no hard candy. I see toddlers with lollies and I dont get it. It makes children hyper, destroys their teeth, doesnt even fill them up.

CatSeany · 09/06/2022 13:06

I'm the same - he eats pretty much what he wants and what is on offer is generally balanced with fruit/veg/snacks in addition to meals. I have friends that won't use stock cubes because of salt, won't allow jam because of sugar, won't allow squash etc but in all honesty I really don't see how those things occasionally are bad.

Abouttimemum · 09/06/2022 13:04

Yep, everything in moderation is sensible!