Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Right to buy

37 replies

Forestgate · 09/06/2022 09:47

What a ridiculous foolhardy scheme

Just what we don't need !

YABU - Great idea

YANBU - terrible idea.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PermanentlyTired03 · 09/06/2022 17:58

@carefullycourageous I think most people feel the same as you. Take your overpriced wallpaper and piss off 😂

carefullycourageous · 09/06/2022 13:22

More drivel from a washed up PM.

Wish Johnson would just fuck off. Sorry to be unconstructive but I hate him.

This policy will make things worse not better according to Shelter.

Trinity65 · 09/06/2022 12:33

JustTheOneSwan · 09/06/2022 09:53

A social housing build scheme would be a better idea.
Wonder why they won't do that.

Absolutely

JustTheOneSwan · 09/06/2022 12:28

None of the political parties are offering any solutions and that's worrying.
As @Kerrangutan said the fix is a multi level approach but it's a hot potato because the only solutions involve spending and investment.
If things continue like this we'll end up with US style homeless villages of worse South African style communist rioting.
Not something I want my DC or GC to struggle through.
Grasping the nettle on housing would get my vote.

adlitem · 09/06/2022 11:49

@Kerrangutan overall I agree. But of course the government subsidises lots of things for the good of society. They pay people for not working (for whatever reasons), and for access to lots of free services that would of course not be expected of private providers/ employers etc (beyond certain limits). So I guess it depends on whether you agree that giving people the ability to buy their own homes is a good thing (and the best use of funds). I think not for the reasons I've already mentioned, which is why I think it's a bad idea (not least due to the consequences). But if you accept it as a valid benefit to society that trumps the negative consequences then I don't see an issue with goverment footing the bill.

Beamish22 · 09/06/2022 11:42

Sugarplumfairy65 · 09/06/2022 10:44

100% mortgages? That worked well last time didnt it?

It did for a lot of people. It followed the high interest rates when a lot of people lost the equity in their homes, as I did. However I was well able to pay the cost of a 100% mortgage on the house I wanted to move to. I brought on a 100% mortgage and so did the bloke who purchased my flat. The decision to lend was based on income etc, in other words the ability to pay.

The mortgage companies were gambling on property values going up again, which they did. So they were reasonably assured that if they had to repossess they would get the value of their loan back.

whenwillthemadnessend · 09/06/2022 11:41

I'd be for it if ALL money made was put into building new social
Housing for younger generations

Beamish22 · 09/06/2022 11:37

Kerrangutan · 09/06/2022 10:38

What about Universal Right To Buy 😂!!

So if you private rent you have a minimum 5 year tenancy (which only you can end early) and then after if the landlord tries to evict you, you get an automatic discount and a right to buy?

Something tells me our government pull of part-time property investors would not be keen AT ALL on their assets being sold off at discounted rates...

That kind of thing is only okay when it's our assets, of course.

I think this would just negatively affect the amount of rental properties available. Whatever we think about landlords why would anyone make an investment knowing that it could be taken from them without consent and sold at a discount? The result would be current landlords would get their tenants out and sell before the legislation came in. Potential landlords would invest differently.

PermanentlyTired03 · 09/06/2022 11:31

100000s on the housing list, councils can't afford to build many new homes, letting people buy their homes is a terrible idea unless they are selling at a proper market rate so the council can buy more homes to increase social housing.

FreddyVoorhees · 09/06/2022 11:24

Going to have to be some building programme to cope with the c.700,000 per year birth rate plus net immigration.

That aside, allowing benefit payments to be used against mortgages is partially a good idea for some tenants as they can see they're getting something for their efforts.

There are potentially a lot of problems.

Obviously, if you're reliant on benefits you probably don't have much wriggle room financially and if there's an interest rate rise, fairly good odds you're stuffed and the social housing system really isn't and can't be set up to accommodate a higher number of evictions.

I'm also thinking that this is going to be absolutely slaughtered fraud wise especially in areas like London where house prices move so quickly. Use other peoples money to buy an asset you can later sell for a potentially whacking profit? No incentive for shenanigans there.

Also are you going to ensure low income/no benefit families are given the same opportunity to buy? I'd be well hacked off if I'm stuck renting whilst Billy and Betty Benefit down the road are happily buying their own house.

It's been a while so I'm not 100% on the current regulations but is it still possible to get Guaranteed pension credit then sell your house without falling foul of the capital rules?

caringcarer · 09/06/2022 11:12

Anything that reduces social housing stock is only a bad thing in my view. They never replace these homes, so in the long run it means less social houses for those families in need of a house. Where I live in Midlands for every private rental there is are 7 or 8 people who want to rent it precisely because there are not enough social houses for rent.

JustTheOneSwan · 09/06/2022 10:49

Part of the rent structure for SH is toward the RTB discounts. That's why certain HA properties have the RTA, because some of their rent goes into the discount pot.
Crudely the rent is expenditure/upkeep/maintenance/area and tenants facilities/housing services.
social housing is just capped at 8% profit like most public services.
it pays for itself no one pays towards it unless they are a tenant.
They just aren't allowed to make big profits and don't need to pay bank interest rates.

Kerrangutan · 09/06/2022 10:48

@adlitem you're totally correct of course, which is why I can't understand why anyone supports it for publicly owned assets?!

Why would anyone (including councils) invest in assets knowing they'll be forced to sell them at discounted prices in future.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 09/06/2022 10:44

100% mortgages? That worked well last time didnt it?

fairgame84 · 09/06/2022 10:42

Its the working families in private rents that need help.
We both work full time and earn £50k per year between us but can't save for a 10% deposit because of the rent and bills that we are paying. This scheme does nothing for us because we don't qualify for a council house.
We're at the mercy of our landlord while at least council tenants have a secure lifetime tenancy.
Boris is just picking an easy way to try and look like he's helping the working class without actually putting in any effort to help renters.

adlitem · 09/06/2022 10:41

Kerrangutan · 09/06/2022 10:38

What about Universal Right To Buy 😂!!

So if you private rent you have a minimum 5 year tenancy (which only you can end early) and then after if the landlord tries to evict you, you get an automatic discount and a right to buy?

Something tells me our government pull of part-time property investors would not be keen AT ALL on their assets being sold off at discounted rates...

That kind of thing is only okay when it's our assets, of course.

Why would anyone then become a land lord in the first place? Why would you invest in an asset only to have it forcefully removed years later. What you would then see is a decrease in private rental stock (so more competition of what there is) and higher rents (to maximise profit before losing the assest) = both bad for the tenant.

Of course private rental stock is not the same as social at all. RTB is of course subsidised by the government for social purposes.

LillianGish · 09/06/2022 10:40

Selling off affordable housing (ie council houses) is exactly how we got into this situation of there being no affordable housing in the first place. I can't believe anyone is seriously proposing selling off the remaining affordable housing and thinking this is going to solve anything. Bonkers.

Kerrangutan · 09/06/2022 10:38

What about Universal Right To Buy 😂!!

So if you private rent you have a minimum 5 year tenancy (which only you can end early) and then after if the landlord tries to evict you, you get an automatic discount and a right to buy?

Something tells me our government pull of part-time property investors would not be keen AT ALL on their assets being sold off at discounted rates...

That kind of thing is only okay when it's our assets, of course.

bluelavender · 09/06/2022 10:34

The big change that is needed is with mortgage lenders. If someone has been paying a £1,300 rent for 2-3 years with a good credit history then they should be able to get a mortgage where the repayments are £1,200

lonelyapple · 09/06/2022 10:34

Completely unfair. Tenants who already have heavily subsidised and secure housing offered a huge discount to buy the homes they live in. Meanwhile, private renters pay much higher rent, have insecure housing get no help. The Tories are sending out a very clear message - don't bother making an effort as we will punish you and tax you more and we will use the tax you pay to give to people in secure, subsidised housing to purchase a property cheaply. Everyone should just give up work, claim benefits and get a free house.

JustTheOneSwan · 09/06/2022 10:33

I hated RTB when Thatcher implemented it, I can't say that now because the social mobility it provides speaks for itself.
What they never tell you is the money raised by it doesn't go to buy or build replacement homes.
that'd be an easy start.

JustTheOneSwan · 09/06/2022 10:30

This was floated by David Cameron years ago and the banks wouldn't get on board (rightly so imo) the number of people this would actually make a difference to is tiny.
Its just shit stirring and distraction.
We need affordable rentals with tenancies that don't leave people at constant risk.
Most other European countries manage but you only need to count the landlords in the Tory party to understand why we won't do anything.

Kerrangutan · 09/06/2022 10:26

I just want to clarify I have nothing against people lucky enough to get a CH or people who use RTB (or any of the other home ownership schemes that ultimately inflate the property market). They're just doing what most people would do.

It's governments and homebuilders primarily at fault.

Beamish22 · 09/06/2022 10:24

My first thought that here is another idea that assumes that those on a low income will be receiving benefits. We all know that there are low income people who aren't entitled to any benefits because their income is low, but not low enough. We have posters here from time to time explaining why they are better off on benefits than working. I'm not criticising anyone, I just think this needs to be recognised by government when they consider support of any kind.
It's the same with the ULEZ consultation, talk of assistance for those on low incomes - in receipt of benefits.

Kerrangutan · 09/06/2022 10:22

Terrible idea.

We need to get far more creative with housing options in this country, and RTB sounds like just more of the same. You'll have people buying what are essentially public assets for discounted prices only to sell at large profits, and "create" hundreds of thousands of pounds to outbid other buyers who have not been so lucky and would literally give their left arms for a council house.

Council houses are essentially a lottery anyway, and RTB is a lottery scheme for people who have already bloody won!!

What I mean by more creative is things like "Tiny Houses" for example. I'd have lived in one in a HEARTBEAT when I was a single mother to a young DD to have the opportunity to save. I've tried to look into this, I have about £40k, maybe I could buy some land? Everything I've read says it'll be likely impossible to get planning permission. (Not to mention the cost of land has gone up 90% - 300% in the last year because of another government scheme - the "rewilding" thing which is essentially a GIANT BACKHANDER for rich people).

Park homes not just for retirees. Why isn't this more of a thing? I live in a tiny poky flat that's hard to heat - at least if I was in a park home I'd have a garden and a sense of community! And I wouldn't be paying eye watering amounts for the pleasure.

Communities built around different demographics - they do this really well in Canada. I spent a summer with my grandparents siblings and they lived in an "Over 50s Village" where the homes were all built around a communal pool, woodworking shop, and rec room for stuff like bingo or movie nights. They were not rich either, a housewife and a baker in a supermarket. Their single mother daughter lived in a complex where you had to be a parent and when I visited you could literally FEEL the sense of community in the air. The other siblings were living in a development of multi-generation homes, so the 60-something couple lived in the basement type apartment with no stairs and direct access to part of the garden while their adult daughter and spouse + two grandchildren lived upstairs in a nice 3 bedroom home. It sounded ideal as they could literally come upstairs for datenight childcare and the younger couple could come downstairs to help them with cleaning the skirtings etc. Both families seemed really happy.

What do we have in this country? The area I grew up in where my whole family lives had the gift of "regeneration" bequeathed on them. Gentrified. So now if you want to start a family near your support network you basically have to hope you win the council house lottery (which they're trying to make harder) or you pull off buying a 2 bedroom shoebox that is TEN times the salary of a nurse of police officer etc.

We need an entirely new strategy IMO, not more of the same sticking plasters that are the equivalent of removing a splinter from one persons eye only to stick a plank in someone else's. Right to Buy, Help to Buy, Shared Equity, Shared Ownership etc are all forms of this. If homebuilders think they can get £150k for a house, but the government is handing people £30k, they don't charge £120k. They charge £180k. It's so fucking obvious they and the gov must think we are buttoned up the back.

Or too downtrodden to rise up and demand better.