Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think many schools forget that lots of mums work?

269 replies

malificent7 · 09/06/2022 07:36

In primary school it was almost a given that they scheduled things in the school day which is understandable but a bit sad that when i was teaching myself, i couldn't get time off for sports day etc.

In secondary school I was chatying to a mum friend who was asked to go to a meeting during school time. She can't...she works! Not a huge issue i guess and not sure how it can be solved. As an ex teacher I wouldn't have wanted to meet parents outside school hours.

OP posts:
CoralPaperweight · 09/06/2022 10:55

@rainbowmilk - I am public sector too. I take 30 minutes for my lunch. It is law that you must take 30 minutes break after 6 hours work.

At DS school the children have 1 hour lunch break where they are in the care of TAs and playground supervisors not teachers. i don't think it unreasonable to suggest 15-20 minutes of this time could be used for phone calls should no other time available providing that the teacher gets a full 30 minutes break.

MercurialMonday · 09/06/2022 10:51

Is it really normal that a school would have weekly assemblies for parents to attend?

It was brought in at DC first primary - some parents spoke to the head - school was good at listening and it became once a term with notice.

TempsPerdu · 09/06/2022 10:51

Is it really normal that a school would have weekly assemblies for parents to attend? Or would invite parents to an assembly of their child was going to get a certificate? That seems like way too much

But there is no obligation to attend, and no one will think any less of you if you don’t. The child will still get the certificate in front of all their teachers and peers. The school is probably only asking because some parents actively want to come, and would complain if they weren’t invited.

And weekly class assemblies have been a thing since I was a kid in the 1980s and throughout my entire primary teaching career to the present day. It’s not every class every week; it’s once or twice a year on a rota basis, and again not compulsory for parents to attend (mine often didn’t).

Triffid1 · 09/06/2022 10:50

BordoisAgain · 09/06/2022 07:47

Our school is pretty bad for notifying parents of things at really short notice and it does grate when you are just expected to be available to pick up because school is closing early next Friday because of Y

Yes, this! I can cope with pre-requested meetings taking place during hours as I can accommodate those in a similar way to a doctor's appointment or getting my boiler fixed. But the complete lack of understanding that changing times at short notice is infuriating. Our school's favourite is to offer some kind of activity or club or whatever but not to let you know if you have got a place until the day before and/or to not provide details until the day before. So if you're working/have other kids etc, it lands up getting ridiculously complex as you try to work out how you juggle it all with almost no notice.

They're always banging on about how they get 98% attendance for parents "evening" (it's afternoon/early evening) and I always feel like I should point out that they announce parents evening dates about 6 weeks ahead and then open the booking 4 weeks ahead... so miraculously, people can sort their lives out.

They gave us the extra jubilee holiday day last October.... announced it a month before. Was a complete nightmare.

cadburyegg · 09/06/2022 10:48

Also I don't attend all the non compulsory stuff.
My youngest had a jubilee party at preschool a couple of weeks ago which I couldn't go to. I'm not offended or annoyed that I couldn't go plus i do think it's good for children to learn that their parents can't come to everything. It's not expected that all parents can go to these things, it's an invitation not a summons

Artwodeetoo · 09/06/2022 10:47

InvisibleDragon · 09/06/2022 10:40

Is it really normal that a school would have weekly assemblies for parents to attend? Or would invite parents to an assembly of their child was going to get a certificate? That seems like way too much!

DS school did this before covid, thankfully it hasn't reared its head since! It just created more work for teachers and lots of upset children who didn't fully understand why x's parent was there and there's wasn't.

MercurialMonday · 09/06/2022 10:46

I’m not entirely sure what some people on this thread are asking for

Plenty of notice and clearly stated requirments - and possibly depending on the school fewer overall number of events.

I know my Dmum went to thinks in the 80s - as school we went to didn't want younger siblings at events - which was frequnetly very akward. I've not had that with my DC schools they have been understanding about younger siblings and often welcoming.

It is school dependent the DC secondary is dire with communication - but there is less overall. I do wish they'd phone in order listed - it's always my mobile first despiet kids saying DH may be easier to contact.

The school always going to do most things in school hours - but there are ways of making that easier for parents to accomodate - but I think many schools have other prioritises.

One school my DC went to massive improved with a new receptiomn staff member - she put all the known dates on a caladener and did a months news letter with them on - massively improved parental attendance. Prior to that it was often last minute text messages which frequnetly raised more questions as there was an assumption of knowlege that hadn't been given to parental body.

TempsPerdu · 09/06/2022 10:45

It drives me mad. Ours has easter egg hunts, picnics, sports days, weekly assemblies open to parents - which luckily havent reopened since covid and because enough parents said er no, we work, church services, performances, car boot sales, all either in school day or just before normal school pick up which is bloody early enough at 3. Some is great for the kids but if you cant go to lots of them, you feel its the kids that have working parents that must feel a bit different. plus 189 emails since september last year.

Again, what is the alternative model? If it is to be that none of this stuff happens - fine in theory and obviously more convenient for working parents - then how is the school (which like most state schools is probably severely underfunded) going to raise the money it needs? And how are the children going to be given meaningful opportunities to become part of the wider community in which they are growing up?

If we do indeed want a low-parental engagement, ‘back to basics’ model, with school becoming a place that only offers basic childcare and education (which would also probably be much less stressful for the teachers), then we need to accept that all the ‘nice to haves’ like trips and author/theatre visits and clubs and music groups will fall by the wayside, and the gap will either need to be made up for by parents, or (in less advantaged families) not accessed by the children at all.

In this light of this and the also currently active ‘What’s happened to volunteering?’ thread, it sounds like a proper debate on this is long overdue.

cadburyegg · 09/06/2022 10:44

I'm a single working mum and actually i find evening appointments much more difficult because I'm negotiating two small children on my own. I wfh and find appointments in the middle of the day much easier to get to because my children are in school/preschool and my work is flexible enough that I can take an hour or so out of the day and make it up another time. I've got a meeting this evening at school and have had to arrange a babysitter. I'm not complaining at all, just saying that it's different for everyone.

Babyboomtastic · 09/06/2022 10:42

anddis · 09/06/2022 09:59

Schools don't forget that you work. They expect you to arrange time off work to attend important meetings, as you would for a medical appointment. If its not important enough for you to arrange time off, then don't attend.

My child getting an award is clearly something that's important enough for me to want to attend. It doesn't mean all parents can usually arrange this with 24hr notice.

LouisCatorze · 09/06/2022 10:42

Maybe schools put too much emphasis on all these extras that never were a thing in times gone by? Does it enrich the curriculum as much as they like to think?

One of the 'wins' of the pandemic was going 'online' for parents' evenings. So much less stressful and more flexible really.

InvisibleDragon · 09/06/2022 10:40

Is it really normal that a school would have weekly assemblies for parents to attend? Or would invite parents to an assembly of their child was going to get a certificate? That seems like way too much!

rainbowmilk · 09/06/2022 10:38

I do feel that teachers and schools are considered by some parents as indentured servants. I work with a few people who - despite having the most generous family friendly policies ever, and attending everything such some weeks it feels that they're barely in the office - are constantly complaining that the teachers don't arrange everything to be completely convenient for working parents. Yet they expect teachers to work through their lunch breaks and hold events during times in which they're unpaid. There seems to be little interest in the kids or the welfare/needs of the people who are trying so hard to educate and provide a lovely environment for the kids, it's all about what's easiest for them.

Artwodeetoo · 09/06/2022 10:35

I wouldn't mind volunteering for specific things in school if needed (I work shifts so have some weekdays off or would be happy to even use leave occasionally) but as others have said, the late notice makes it tricky. I can see why logistically it isn't always possible to give a tonne of notice, but even save the dates or making it clear it could change would help people plan. Between me and DH we have managed to go to most of the 'big' events so far like sports days.

rainbowmilk · 09/06/2022 10:31

CoralPaperweight · 09/06/2022 09:57

It's the short notice that gets me. It is not easy to rustle up x,y and z when you aren't a SAHP. I also dislike the tendency to call back / have parent consultations immediately when teaching finishes ie 3.30 when DS is home and I cannot discuss things properly.

I don't really understand why it isn't an option to call at lunchtime of on one of the teachers non-teaching days/times.. There are also teachers who don't routinely teach/ have dedicated classes so are there to cover should it be needed.

I do think there is a tendency to think that one parent will be SAHP or v part time. There are a surprising number of mums who don't work at DS primary or work 10 hours a week or similiar

I don't really understand why it isn't an option to call at lunchtime

You really don't understand why that's not an option? Really?

TempsPerdu · 09/06/2022 10:31

Notice. Notice is what we are asking for.

I do completely get this; I said in my pp upthread that I agreed that schools should publish key dates well in advance and stick to an agreed schedule as far as possible.

The trouble is that quite often a fixed schedule isn’t possible. A fixed date is fairly doable for the ‘big’ events like Sports’ Day (although even that is highly dependent on favourable weather), but schools are operating under such fluid conditions, with so many different variables, that it’s inevitable that events are often subject to last minute change or cancellation. Will the school hall be available at that time (many schools are hugely cramped and accommodating all the kids is a logistical feat in itself)?; Will the visitor we’ve booked turn up? Will all the kids be there, or will half the class (or the teacher) be off due to norovirus/chicken pox/covid? Will we have enough parent volunteers to fulfil the required ratios? Will we have sufficient funding/parent engagement to go ahead?

It’s a total minefield, and as several PPs have said, there is no solution. @ArseInTheCoOpWindow is right - schools are mandated to engage with their local community (surely a good thing for the children?) but, with many people’s working and living conditions as they presently are, this can prove nigh on impossible. There were countless complaints on here during the pandemic (most of which I agreed with), saying that schools were offering a joyless ‘skeleton service’, with no clubs or trips or fun events. But parents are equally up in arms when asked to volunteer to chaperone these trips, or fundraise for the fun ‘extras’, or provide a costume for a dress-up day.

It can’t work both ways. Perhaps some of these ‘extras’ are unnecessary window dressing, but there needs to be an understanding that parents either inconvenience themselves to some extent to engage with this stuff, or it just doesn’t happen, parents lower their expectations and the ‘school offer’ becomes much more minimalist and limited in scope (as per the pandemic).

I had to prioritise the ones that were most important for my child that I attended but I did feel bad not going to some, as my DS class in particular had lots of SAHM and dad's that wfh and seemed able to come to lots of events.

This comment is a case in point. Does the school continue to hold these events, making the working parents who can’t attend feel bad, or does it stop doing them, meaning that nobody gets to go and the children miss that particular experience? Either way someone loses out.

Dixiechickonhols · 09/06/2022 10:26

DD went to a private primary for various reasons (deprived northern town fees £5000 a year) one massive perk I’d not appreciated was how working parent friendly they were as all parents worked. It had an old fashioned vibe. No random dress up days. Costumes for plays and nativity they provided - brown leotard with a paper mask would be a reindeer, rabbit etc. Lots of notice of events. Children not sent home at drop
of hat with tummy ache. One snowy day they were only school in town open. I had workmates with kids at local state schools and they were always faffing about.
Part was attitude and part was due to more generous staffing ratios so no need for volunteers.

Tista · 09/06/2022 10:23

It drives me mad. Ours has easter egg hunts, picnics, sports days, weekly assemblies open to parents - which luckily havent reopened since covid and because enough parents said er no, we work, church services, performances, car boot sales, all either in school day or just before normal school pick up which is bloody early enough at 3. Some is great for the kids but if you cant go to lots of them, you feel its the kids that have working parents that must feel a bit different. plus 189 emails since september last year. REallty??

CanaryWharf2 · 09/06/2022 10:21

malificent7 · 09/06/2022 07:36

In primary school it was almost a given that they scheduled things in the school day which is understandable but a bit sad that when i was teaching myself, i couldn't get time off for sports day etc.

In secondary school I was chatying to a mum friend who was asked to go to a meeting during school time. She can't...she works! Not a huge issue i guess and not sure how it can be solved. As an ex teacher I wouldn't have wanted to meet parents outside school hours.

It’d be considered pretty normal to take a day off or half day for things like sports days or an important meeting.

I’d hope that the school would try to schedule a meeting at the end of their working day, but definitely wouldn’t expect them to hold it at the weekend.

bringincrazyback · 09/06/2022 10:18

Momicrone · 09/06/2022 08:01

Obviously schools know parents work, and it's not just about mums, but all this moaning about not being able to fit things in, life is a juggling act,if you have chosen to have a family you gave to try and find ways to make it work

This.

oldwhyno · 09/06/2022 10:17

They don't forget, they're fully aware. But it's certainly so low on their list of priorities to the point it appears they don't care.

Seeingadistance · 09/06/2022 10:16

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 09/06/2022 07:47

But isn't it much like a dentist or doctors appointment? They are open between Xam and Ypm Monday to Friday, and if you work and need to attend, then you book time off work.

I don't see why there should be a "solution", and surely its not just a Mum thing but a parent thing?

Essential appointments (eg important meetings with teaching staff) - a parent books time off to attend, acknowledging that it's essential. Non essentials (eg sports days, parent helper on trips etc), attend if possible, if not don't worry

This.

tootiredtoocare · 09/06/2022 10:16

anddis · 09/06/2022 09:59

Schools don't forget that you work. They expect you to arrange time off work to attend important meetings, as you would for a medical appointment. If its not important enough for you to arrange time off, then don't attend.

Which is fine, when they give adequate notice, but they don't. I got a letter yesterday about a very important group meeting during working hours this coming Tuesday. I only work Mondays and Tuesdays, so I don't see my boss again until Monday (she's on holiday this week) when I'm supposed to ask for half of Tuesday off, which I can't see being possible as we're already short staffed. I've had to contact school to ask for comprehensive minutes, but not being there means I can't ask questions or express my opinion. It's a huge change that will radically affect our childrens' education that has been sprung on us without notice and the meeting to discuss it should have been outside of working hours.

Testina · 09/06/2022 10:16

YerAWizardHarry · 09/06/2022 09:53

I teach and there are only 2 children in my class of 29 that have both parents working within school hours. They’re P3 (8ish) but there is very little update in the after school club at school either

@YerAWizardHarry I’m interested in that!
Is that predominantly wealthier families who has chosen to have a SAHP? (SAHM..)
Or is it far less wealthy families where childcare is relatively much higher and that drives the SAHP decision?

At my child’s school - wealthy area - lots of mum are available during the day. There are a lot of higher earning professional woman who are now working part time, or have high flexibility and WFH options.

My sister’s school is in a deprived area and mum availability is also high. The typical profile driving that though, is not working as single parent (with younger children) or working part time to the minimum for UC and dad has fucked off or working in lower paid jobs with variable shifts - like Tesco - where they have some possibility to request or swap shifts.

To be absolutely clear: no judgment of single parents (I’m one) or working part time with UC. That’s fine. I’m just describing the profile.

Sirzy · 09/06/2022 10:15

I don't really understand why it isn't an option to call at lunchtime of on one of the teachers non-teaching days/times.. There are also teachers who don't routinely teach/ have dedicated classes so are there to cover should it be needed.

many teachers work through their lunch, including phone calls when needed. PPA is used for meetings and things of suitable. but along with the other things that need doing that is only a small part of the use of PPA.

schools don’t have staff floating arojnd doing nothing and using supply/cover is disruptive for pupils so will be a last resort. Certainly wouldn’t expect it to be used for a meeting that could be arranged at a different time.