Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think many schools forget that lots of mums work?

269 replies

malificent7 · 09/06/2022 07:36

In primary school it was almost a given that they scheduled things in the school day which is understandable but a bit sad that when i was teaching myself, i couldn't get time off for sports day etc.

In secondary school I was chatying to a mum friend who was asked to go to a meeting during school time. She can't...she works! Not a huge issue i guess and not sure how it can be solved. As an ex teacher I wouldn't have wanted to meet parents outside school hours.

OP posts:
savehannah · 09/06/2022 14:36

FriendlyPineapple · 09/06/2022 07:58

I got two texts from school yesterday within ten minutes, saying that 1) the class walk cannot go ahead tomorrow without parent volunteers and 2) neither can Sports Day on Friday, so please call the office and put yourself forward.

Right, I'll just take two days off work shall I, to walk a bunch of 11 year olds around the town?! Who, by the way, go around our small town on their own all the time 😆

Obviously not. But there may well be non-working parents, or parents who are off on these days who can help. If you can't help you can't help. They are not saying every parent must help, they only need a couple.

You don't need to make any excuse if you can't help. It's like people answering Amazon questions with "sorry, I don't know" Just don't answer!

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 09/06/2022 14:35

Momicrone · 09/06/2022 13:56

It's amazing how many busy working mums have time for mumsnet during the day

I can mumsnet from my phone at my desk in my office. So unless the school does sports day under my desk then it's quite different.

Sherrystrull · 09/06/2022 14:34

Blurp · 09/06/2022 14:02

"Teachers presumably can't attend their own children's assemblies, sports day, tea parties etc.....because they don't have any flexibility in their work days/schedule..... "

In my experience (DH is a teacher) they can attend a certain amount - he can go to the nativity every Christmas, and a sports day, but probably couldn't get out of work for every assembly.

I do think it's sometimes obvious when a teacher has gone from school to uni to teaching without any experience of any other work environment. DH did this, and he has absolutely no idea how office jobs work (both his sisters are also teachers, his mum was a SAHM and his dad self-employed, so he's just never come across it). He was surprised to hear that I have to book holidays off, for instance, and that I need to take into account when other people are off. He'd no idea that you could get a holiday request rejected. Also didn't really get that I can't just take a morning off and go in for the afternoon, or that I can't always rearrange client meetings to suit myself. So sometimes I do wonder whether some teachers just have never really had to think about stuff like that and therefore don't understand that office jobs aren't all super-flexible, and that they do require a bit of forward planning for time off.

(DH was also delighted when I brought my work laptop home at the start of lockdown, because he thought it would be way better than his school one and he could use it instead... turned out his school one is better, and anyway I can't let him use it because it has confidential stuff on it. But he was convinced that people who work in offices all have amazing up-to-date tech, while teachers have to make do with ancient stuff).

I honestly think there can't be many teachers like that. Most teachers I know have worked in different industries before teaching or had jobs when training.

Borisblondboufant · 09/06/2022 14:30

My issue was the lack of notice. One year we got a full schedule at the start of the year and it was amazing. I was able to plan and move things around and meant I wasn’t using so much holiday. Never happened again.

The worst thing they did was hold an ‘open classroom’ one Friday at 1.30pm which meant looking at schoolbooks for 5 minutes and then taking your child home early. Not a problem for me as not a day I worked but definitely felt like a trick to get rid of the kids.
On Monday they tell us there is a performance on that Friday. One of the mums was so upset as she couldn’t ask for another Friday off and her daughter had a staring part AND the teacher had a veiled go at her for not coming. It was a shitty thing to do.
They had form for doing this kind of thing. 2 days notice for school shows etc. It’s ignorant not to recognise others have jobs too.

TheTurn0fTheScrew · 09/06/2022 14:26

It's the short notice that gets me. For example, two days' notice for volunteers to drive to a football match where the astro turf pitch requires pre-booking well ahead.

I have a reasonable degree of flexibility in my diary, and can make pretty much anything with 6 weeks' notice. However with less that two weeks' notice my diary is full. If school even sent a lust of possible/tentative dates half-termly that would help, as I could protect that time in advance.

slippysept · 09/06/2022 14:22

'Most teachers do a lot of things for your children for free, they organise plan and practice in their own time - the least you could do is make a bit of effort'

The problem lies in that parents are working FT and often have other commitments in the evenings (or work during those hours).

Ha! being asked to make a tray of cupcakes for the following day is getting off lightly. 14 years ago, all the parents mothers of our female final year primary school pupils were sent a red pillowcase to make a Bugsy Malone dress for their child for the leaving show! I kid you not! A red pillowcase! That 'request' did make me laugh.

caoraich · 09/06/2022 14:15

Momicrone · 09/06/2022 13:56

It's amazing how many busy working mums have time for mumsnet during the day

Some full time working mums work shifts. Hope that helps. gentle pat on the head

Mangogogogo · 09/06/2022 14:15

I’m fine with taking time off here and there for stuff but when they tell me the week before I get irritated.

alphons · 09/06/2022 14:11

I’m really surprised to hear of the prevalence of schools not being organised. How can it get to be like this? Even if these are brand new schools, the people
working in them aren’t in their first year of work post-graduation. How can they just forget??

Each August my DCs’ school sends out a calendar for the following school year. On it is marked all the bank holidays; all the parents’ evenings; all the sports days; all the music recitals; all school holidays; all curriculum nights; all weekend meets. For those doing pro sports, obviously that calendar changes as the year progresses, but parents of those children know what to expect and plan accordingly. At the beginning of the school year we are given the first day of the next school year +/- 2 days, so people can book flights and make travel arrangements.

During the school year, we are told by our teachers or admin or the PTA what’s coming up in the next two weeks, whether it’s things already in the calendar or new things that crop up. Teachers plan the class plan well advance. It just doesn’t happen that a teacher decides on a Monday that oh we’re going to do something on Wednesday that requires a home made bonnet. How can it?

Around 30% of children have one SAHP. On the whole, these parents aren’t stingy about “I didn’t stop working to facilitate your career” towards other parents and help other parents out with drop offs and pick ups, and working parents are still replying to emails/on WhatsApp late into the evening to get around to everything they’ve got going on in their lives.

It works. It just takes some organisation. It’s not about being able to afford things, or a lack of resource. It’s just planning ahead, having a REAL community spirit between staff, faculty and parents, and everybody giving just a little bit to ensure that every child is included. That’s what it comes down to, really: it’s every parent realising that the other kids are in their kid’s class, could be their friend, that they study and play together and that for the children this is the main thing they have going on in their lives. School is IT, up to 18yo and certainly in the primary years that means a lot of facilitating by the adults in their lives.

TheSummerPalace · 09/06/2022 14:08

It's amazing how many busy working mums have time for mumsnet during the day

Yes, while the PC decides to install numerous updates to Windows, after being switched on; or waiting in a telephone queue to a government department or even to clear your head, because you are so confused by the mess the client has made, you can’t see the wood for the trees! I charge by the minute, so I just put on my timesheet, the minutes worked! If I choose to work 10 - 6.15 pm, rather than 10 - 6 pm, due to spending 15 minutes on my phone in the day, that is up to me!

Blurp · 09/06/2022 14:02

"Teachers presumably can't attend their own children's assemblies, sports day, tea parties etc.....because they don't have any flexibility in their work days/schedule..... "

In my experience (DH is a teacher) they can attend a certain amount - he can go to the nativity every Christmas, and a sports day, but probably couldn't get out of work for every assembly.

I do think it's sometimes obvious when a teacher has gone from school to uni to teaching without any experience of any other work environment. DH did this, and he has absolutely no idea how office jobs work (both his sisters are also teachers, his mum was a SAHM and his dad self-employed, so he's just never come across it). He was surprised to hear that I have to book holidays off, for instance, and that I need to take into account when other people are off. He'd no idea that you could get a holiday request rejected. Also didn't really get that I can't just take a morning off and go in for the afternoon, or that I can't always rearrange client meetings to suit myself. So sometimes I do wonder whether some teachers just have never really had to think about stuff like that and therefore don't understand that office jobs aren't all super-flexible, and that they do require a bit of forward planning for time off.

(DH was also delighted when I brought my work laptop home at the start of lockdown, because he thought it would be way better than his school one and he could use it instead... turned out his school one is better, and anyway I can't let him use it because it has confidential stuff on it. But he was convinced that people who work in offices all have amazing up-to-date tech, while teachers have to make do with ancient stuff).

TheSummerPalace · 09/06/2022 14:00

Teachers do not get paid for their lunch break.

Who does get paid for their lunch break? The problem is teachers say “we schedule meetings within our working hours”, while putting unpaid work on parents at very little notice! DD2 came home from primary school on a Friday afternoon, saying she had to make an Easter bonnet over the weekend - when we had a hotel, a 3 hours drive away, booked for the weekend for a family Silver Wedding Anniversary! What did the teachers think we could do, in a hotel, in a town we didn’t know, while expected to attend family get togethers?

Likewise, DD1 came home one day, saying she had to have a red, white and blue jumper for school the next day (for the Queen’s jubilee). I had no idea where to get a red, white and blue jumper! Other parents were told, they had to get a red jumper, or a white jumper. The parents had to ring each other up to work out, the children had to wear a red or blue or white jumper! (And this school was in a deprived area, so tough luck if the parents couldn’t afford it!)

My DC never saw all these dressing up days as “fun”, they got sick of them!

BiasedBinding · 09/06/2022 14:00

Momicrone · 09/06/2022 13:56

It's amazing how many busy working mums have time for mumsnet during the day

Oh stop it. You can do better than that.

Momicrone · 09/06/2022 13:56

It's amazing how many busy working mums have time for mumsnet during the day

BiasedBinding · 09/06/2022 13:53

riesenrad · 09/06/2022 08:22

It's the same with baby groups- always during the week and hardly anything at weekends

and only in term time. Babies don't go to school but the assumption seems to be that everyone has older school age kids.

Often the people who run them have school aged children. I get that it’s annoying, but this is often why.

Villagewaspbyke · 09/06/2022 13:52

echt · 09/06/2022 11:15

Teachers do not get paid for their lunch break.

Yes they do. They get paid a salary and are given a lunch break. And please don’t start with the “teachers don’t get paid holidays” rubbish.

Villagewaspbyke · 09/06/2022 13:50

ClocksGoingBackwards · 09/06/2022 07:56

It’s not that they forget, its that if they need to have a meeting with parents then they should be able to do that within their working day.

The school/teachers shouldn’t have to work into the evening to accommodate working parents, it’s for the the parents to make the sacrifices and awkward arrangements because it’s about their children.

Schools exist for the benefit of children, not their parents.

It’s for the benefit of children that their parents are able to attend meetings about their children though. Most professional jobs would expect some accommodation for the “clients”. I think some give and take on both sides is reasonable.

TempsPerdu · 09/06/2022 13:48

Dixiechickonhols

And mine (state sector in the ‘80s and ‘90s) was of loads of clubs, themed days and trips, and it was absolutely the making of me, especially all the ‘extras’ that I experienced at secondary level. Massively broadened my horizons, embedded me in a community while making me realised there was a much wider world out there, and provided opportunities that my own (supportive but relatively uneducated) parents just couldn’t.

I’m now on the privileged position of being highly educated, with plenty of cultural capital, and able to provide these sorts of opportunities for my own DD outside of school if necessary. But I’m also very aware that, for many other DC, school is the only place they’ll ever be able to access them.

It’s horses for courses isn’t it? When it comes to education one size certainly doesn’t fit all.

CaptainMyCaptain · 09/06/2022 13:41

anniegun · 09/06/2022 07:44

You have answered your own point. "As an ex teacher I wouldn't have wanted to meet parents outside school hours."

Exactly what I was going to say. Many teachers are, themselves, Mums that work. Although some directed time has to be done in the evening the rest of the time they want to fit meetings etc. into their working day.

Dixiechickonhols · 09/06/2022 13:36

Tempsperdu
My school experience was fewer trips and things like a trip to panto would be with Brownies not school.
Like I said DD went to a small private primary and there was much less in terms of themed days and trips. But all the children had working parents who would take them to panto or activities etc so less need for school to do it.

Trainbear · 09/06/2022 13:30

You are right when you say "it's always the mother" but where there is another parent or guardian why should the mother always be the one attending? Why not dad? Why should the female always be the point of contact, why the female always being the one taking time off to look after the child when sick?

Fizbosshoes · 09/06/2022 13:19

Threetulips · 09/06/2022 12:22

School have very quickly lost my goodwill as they just don’t help themselves sometimes

Why not blame your inflexible work place? Why not blame the government for not giving extra family days off for parents of young children?

Schools can’t do right for doing wrong can they?

Scrap all activities sports day plays Christmas concerts charity work - and just go back to basics.

Then parents can be responsible for all the extras in there own time.

The poster you've quoted was talking about 3 mornings in one week instead of a full day, not that they never wanted to attend a school event. I think that would be more difficult to schedule than simply saying I'm not in on Wednesday for example.

Teachers presumably can't attend their own children's assemblies, sports day, tea parties etc.....because they don't have any flexibility in their work days/schedule.....
Other jobs might also have constraints, even those that are fairly flexible might not be able to permit 3 mornings or 3 half days in a week.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 09/06/2022 13:17

I mean, my child is in reception and I do try to avoid formal wrap around care in favour of friends and family. It does work quite well and we are very fortunate to have that support network around us.
HOWEVER, wrap around care is an absolute god send and I would kick off massively if my school dropped it. Though I use it infrequently, I do still use it and have excellent peace of mind knowing it's there and that my son loves going and the staff are wonderful.

I wouldn't choose to use a school that didn't offer wrap around care as I would feel like they looked down on me as a working parent.

TempsPerdu · 09/06/2022 12:46

Attitude to wraparound care tells you quite a lot about the school and the demographic they want. One we looked at had nothing for reception, another only had a breakfast class. Not hard to guess their attitude to working parents. Our school serves a deprived area where probably quite a few parents don't work, but they have always given lots of notice for events etc for those that do

Hmm… it’s certainly an interesting one. Our local area is very mixed - probably the majority of women work, but also a fair few SAHMs and some non-working families. Real range of attitudes to wraparound care taken by schools.

There does seem to be a bit of a tension between how schools view themselves and how parents view what school is for. Often it seems to be the school’s attempts to champion (what they see as) the child’s best interests coming up against the reality of modern working families’ lives. One slightly old fashioned school we visited came in for a lot of flak for suggesting that some very young children don’t do well in after-school club, and to avoid wraparound care where possible in Reception. Some parents were hugely offended by this, and you can see why, but in my primary teaching days I’d regularly see Reception-aged kids crying, or acting up, or sitting exhausted in a corner, or even fast asleep in the hall after school. What works best for the parent isn’t always the ideal option for the child.

Our ‘best’ option locally for wraparound care is the new free school - they see themselves as very ‘modern’ and their big selling point is that you can drop your child off at 7.45am, nursery style, and pick them up at 6. There’s no PTA, no big school events, and parents never need to attend for parents’ evenings, assemblies etc. The ethos is that ‘We take your child, educate them and present you with the finished article’ (they actually said that at the information session we attended).

We avoided this school because personally I wanted more input in my child’s education, and more of a relationship with the school community. But I can see that it would absolutely be the ideal option for others.

Miyazaker · 09/06/2022 12:26

TempsPerdu · 09/06/2022 11:01

There seems to be little interest in the kids or the welfare/needs of the people who are trying so hard to educate and provide a lovely environment for the kids, it's all about what's easiest for them

Really struck me, when we were recently looking at primary schools for DD, that at every school we visited the first (and in some cases only) question asked by the prospective parents was what the wraparound care offer was and how early DC could be dropped off in the morning/how late they could be collected.

It’s important, of course it is, and parents need to know this stuff - but the relative lack of curiously about the actual education provided, curriculum content, pupil wellbeing, safeguarding, opportunities on offer etc really surprised me.

Attitude to wraparound care tells you quite a lot about the school and the demographic they want. One we looked at had nothing for reception, another only had a breakfast class. Not hard to guess their attitude to working parents. Our school serves a deprived area where probably quite a few parents don't work, but they have always given lots of notice for events etc for those that do.