Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asked to cosign

167 replies

Boxowine · 08/06/2022 23:50

My DS's girlfriend has been accepted into a very prestigious (and very expensive) post graduate program in New York City. Housing costs there are astronomical. My DS plans to spend the year there with her. He asked me today if I would cosign for their accommodation. I'm not sure yet what that would be but it is separate from the University as they have limited school housing. I would normally tell someone to say no but she may not be able to go if she can't find a place to live.

AIBU to say no?

OP posts:
Valeriekat · 10/06/2022 08:15

Where are you and your family living now.
We assumed you live and work in the UK because this is a UK based site. Don't get upset with people because you didn't make that clear.
If you are all US citizens living in the US it changes everything.

Valeriekat · 10/06/2022 08:03

If you are all US citizens and living and studying in the US it rather changes the situation doesn't it.

Valeriekat · 10/06/2022 07:56

Boxowine · 09/06/2022 01:09

And I remember what it was like to be young and in love and to have a dream. This is her dream.

A dream that you pay for.

Valeriekat · 10/06/2022 07:51

Will she get student loans for an overseas course?
Her tuition fees are likely to be $60 000 and accommodation another 10 000 at least.
I am assuming she doesn't have a scholarship.

IDreamOfTheMoors · 10/06/2022 05:22

I’m in California, btw.

nannynick · 10/06/2022 05:20

No. I would offer the landlord 9 months of rent paid upfront. If you cannot afford to do that, or the landlord does not accept that, then walk away.

IDreamOfTheMoors · 10/06/2022 05:20

I had some friends, once, with a brand-new baby.
They asked me to co-sign on some furniture.
I felt bad for them, because of that baby, so I did.
Three months later, I heard from the finance company that they were three months behind on their payments.
I had no choice but to take back the furniture (that I didn’t want & didn’t need) and take over the payments, all to save my credit from going down the toilet.
I don’t think my “friends” ever had any intention of paying, ever. And I think they thought they’d just get free furniture.
It might be different because it’s your son, but unless you can afford to pay their entire rent, etc., I’d think twice.
I might be jaded. I’m probably jaded.

DatingIsDifficult · 10/06/2022 05:05

OP I’m not sure why everyone is being so mean to you. You’re American, living in the US and your American son wants to live with his American girlfriend in an American city, and personally I can’t imagine where you’ll get better advice than on a British parenting website.

Everyone else - this thread has kept me thoroughly entertained. Thank you.

expat101 · 10/06/2022 04:21

I'm with Aussiegirl123456 too. Don't sign, let her figure it out and go for the single accommodation.

I have avoided reading most of the other replies, so I will add what I think is my own reply, and ask how you would feel about the cosigning if the couple separated?

Would you still feel strongly about supporting (possibly financially) your DS's GF's education esp. if she moved on relationship wise too? I think that is the red flag here. I'm mindful of our new young neighbours, 10 months in and they have called it quits. It does happen.

And slightly OTT, and I'm not in the UK or USA, but when DD went into private studio student accommodation, we found out that type of tenancy isn't covered by our Govt's tenancy laws. This came about as another resident stole a number of items from the property and the management attempted to charge all residents for the replacement cost. Fortunately for us, DD had flown home that weekend and I had her boarding pass, so went head to head with them on the issue. But it surprised me nevertheless.

I raise that as an example of something to watch out for in your scenerio too. Hopefully your Country has better tenancy protection for students than where I live.

Boxowine · 10/06/2022 03:49

Aussiegirl123456 thanks. I rather think the same. I put myself through college and I've paid for his schooling so far so he should be able to pull it off. I just always assumed I would encourage him to do a year abroad but that wasn't possible during Covid so I'm not really resistant to this idea.

OP posts:
Aussiegirl123456 · 10/06/2022 03:25

BadLad · 10/06/2022 03:06

Bloody nora, CanaryWharf2 had fun on this thread.

To be honest, I’ve seen a few threads now where he/she has done the same. Getting rather tedious now.

OP, don’t co sign. Where there is a will there’s a way. For what it’s worth, I went to New York for a year doing law as a uk/us citizen. My uk citizen boyfriend followed me, and we actually ended up staying longer than planned as he managed to get onto a architect course. That was 20 years ago now and even though it was pretty hard going at the time, it was the beginning of something fabulous. Sometimes all reason and sensibility has to be chucked out the window for wonderful things to happen. Both sets of parents were all “what if it doesn’t work” but you know, sometimes it does and sometimes it’s amazing. Sometimes you just have to be crazy and accept that life can be beautifully unpredictable.

But you…. Don’t sign. They’ll make it work. And if it doesn’t work out, then so what, what’s the worse that can happen? They’ll just have to come home and explore different avenues, together or apart.

Boxowine · 10/06/2022 03:24

@TheTeenageYears I would never openly call someone a troll much less blatantly insult their child no matter what pertinent facts may or may possibly be misconstrued.
Women who engage in relational aggression towards other women do so because they are under the belief that it is their prerogative to do so. Even when it is against the rules of the site.

My particular dilemma is relatively common and not exactly all that complicated. Hardly worthy of the level of scrutinization and cross examination I was subjected to.

And as I have also said OVER and fucking OVER again, this was a question that was broached to me by my son, who is exploring his options and not a concrete lease or contract that has been placed before me to sign. There aren't any details for me to keep straight. It's a hypothetical right now but I'm ambivalent to what degree I want to support this desire of his. Whatever he ends up doing will be determined to some degree by how much I am willing to support him because as a young person who is not independently wealthy he has to rely on my financial support. I thought this was also a common situation for young people but apparently on mumsnet that means that CanaryWharf2 is allowed to call him a drop out with issues who needs to get a job.

OP posts:
BadLad · 10/06/2022 03:06

Bloody nora, CanaryWharf2 had fun on this thread.

TheTeenageYears · 10/06/2022 02:56

Boxowine · 10/06/2022 01:35

@TheTeenageYears I wasn't aware I had to post my name, address, and all of my other personal information in order to avoid being accused of lying and openly insulted. Maybe mumsnet can leak my email so CanaryWharf2 can dox me when she's done insulting my family. Over a fairly routine situation. If I wanted to make up a story I would have come up with something a lot more interesting than should I cosign for an apartment.

Stating your country of residence and nationality are hardly akin to divulging personal information, you are one of many, many millions of people. The world does not revolve around the US or their educational/real estate systems and the vast majority of people on Mumsnet have no understanding or experience of the US system so don't get antsy at people because they've misunderstood/raised a question etc because you omitted to give fairly pertinent information in order to seek help.

Boxowine · 10/06/2022 01:35

@TheTeenageYears I wasn't aware I had to post my name, address, and all of my other personal information in order to avoid being accused of lying and openly insulted. Maybe mumsnet can leak my email so CanaryWharf2 can dox me when she's done insulting my family. Over a fairly routine situation. If I wanted to make up a story I would have come up with something a lot more interesting than should I cosign for an apartment.

OP posts:
Boxowine · 10/06/2022 01:08

@SonicHg what contract? There isn't a contract. As I've said before, she hasn't asked to sign anything. My son brought it up yesterday to see if it would be something I'd consider.

I didn't realize that posting on this site meant that I'm supposed to allow myself to be called a troll ( at least one response had to be removed) and personally insulted. All over a relatively common issue people deal with all the time.

OP posts:
TheTeenageYears · 10/06/2022 01:03

*MN

TheTeenageYears · 10/06/2022 01:02

@Boxowine MM is a predominately British group and your OP doesn't state that you are either American or living in the US. You mentioned being American once I think quite a few per people had misunderstood the situation and I identified that. You didn't state you actually livdd in the US for ages afterwards and being an American doesn't automatically mean you live in the US. I think there has been a huge amount of misunderstanding on this thread and lots of aspects that someone without a good understanding of the US system just wouldn't understand. If you read the whole thread again you'll see that's the problem. This could have all gone very differently if you had said American in the US in your OP.

SonicHg · 10/06/2022 00:11

OP since you’re so rude how about co-sign the contract 😂.

Boxowine · 09/06/2022 23:22

@CanaryWharf2 you supposedly lived there temporarily for something that wasn't an internship. Doesn't make you a New Yorker. How sad to go to any great city and avoid its major landmarks.

OP posts:
CanaryWharf2 · 09/06/2022 23:19

Boxowine · 09/06/2022 23:10

@CanaryWharf2 it's free. Which you would know if you ever actually lived in NYC. But the national park service does have internship programs that anyone can apply to. They are not even limited to US citizens. Which you can Google for yourself. Instead of calling people liars who who claim that their children are exploring intern opportunities in the city. Because you're the only person who can go there. Anyone else who even considers it is really a troll. Who sets up a bait and switch in order to start a fight.

I lived there petal, I wasn’t a tourist.

Boxowine · 09/06/2022 23:10

CanaryWharf2 · 09/06/2022 22:58

Do you think he’ll be able to get me a discount to see the statue?

@CanaryWharf2 it's free. Which you would know if you ever actually lived in NYC. But the national park service does have internship programs that anyone can apply to. They are not even limited to US citizens. Which you can Google for yourself. Instead of calling people liars who who claim that their children are exploring intern opportunities in the city. Because you're the only person who can go there. Anyone else who even considers it is really a troll. Who sets up a bait and switch in order to start a fight.

OP posts:
CanaryWharf2 · 09/06/2022 22:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted as it refers to a deleted post.

Do you think he’ll be able to get me a discount to see the statue?

Boxowine · 09/06/2022 22:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted as it refers to a deleted post.

CanaryWharf2 · 09/06/2022 22:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.