Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you use a childminder with a dog?

279 replies

PashunFroot · 08/06/2022 22:02

Just that really. We want to use a childminder rather than a nursery, purely for logistical reasons as they can collect older child from school. However all the childminders locally have dogs. I’m not a dog person, and I’m quite wary of them. I know they will be kept shut away from the children but would I always be worrying about it while I’m at work?

aibu for even being worried about it?

OP posts:
ChanceNorman · 09/06/2022 07:09

No. Dog owners prove time and time again that they cannot be objective about their pet - they're defensive and frequently don’t control them well. They regard them as one of their family so your child’s safeguarding would always be at the mercy of their loyalty to an unpredictable animal with animal reflexes and instincts

This with bells on.

There are posts on this thread proving this. One aong the lines of 'well I wouldn't leave dc unsupervised with them but I'd trust my dog with my life' 🙄

Anyone stupid enough to trust any dog 100% in this way - I would never believe their lip service to the not leaving dc alone with them.

Cakeandslippers · 09/06/2022 07:07

Yes we do. I'm scared of dogs and saw it as a positive because I've always been desperate not to pass my fear on. Our cm is wonderful, the dog is very small and very placid, and the cm teaches dog safety to all the kids such as what to do if an unknown dog approaches you. This all paid off greatly when my eldest was only 2 and we were at the park. A dog ran up to her took a mouthful of her hair and refused to let go - she was incredible, calm, stood very still, hands by her side and repeated "mummy the dog is hurting me" a few times in the calmest voice I'd known, while I was a complete wreck!

Strugglingtodomybest · 09/06/2022 07:04

I would see the childminder having a dog as a bonus. I would not pick a childminder I did not trust. So, if I trust them with my child, I trust that they are responsible dog owners too.

Palmtree9 · 09/06/2022 07:00

I went to a childminder with a dog when I was younger. No issues. The dog had its own space, we had ours, and it was a lovely GSD.

I'd send my kids to a childminder with dogs now, but only if I had met the dog/played with it/my kids could cope with it/the childminder had a written policy of when and how it would interact with the children.

Any decent childminder who is Ofsted registered would (should?!) have these plans in place, so I would be more than comfortable with that

RedWingBoots · 09/06/2022 06:59

Darbs76 · 09/06/2022 06:43

It would depend on the dog. I’m a big dog lover, we have a dog, but I didn’t get him until my children were age 9 plus. I am not sure I’d be comfortable having a small child around a dog to be honest. Would depend on the set up, I’m sure she will have gates etc, but if it was a breed that I view to be those always responsible for attacks then no. I always used a nursery, I wasn’t comfortable having 1 person looking after my child, for a few reasons.

You must have missed the post in the thread where the poster has a CM with dogs and then used a nursery where the owner had a dog.

The nursery owner expected every staff member to deal with their dog so allowed the dog to cause havoc, there as the CM knew she was responsible for them.

RedWingBoots · 09/06/2022 06:55

I know they will be kept shut away from the children but would I always be worrying about it while I’m at work?

The CM will have friends and neighbours with dogs. She and they will teach your children how to greet dogs anyway

If she has dogs herself your child may actually be more wary around them.

My own DD doesn't like strange dogs, and I don't like small dogs from childhood.

My DP thinks it's funny that I freak out if a small dog approaches there as I completely ignore a rottweiler.

Giraffesandbottoms · 09/06/2022 06:54

No!! I have a dog but I am the person in charge of the interaction my children and my dog have. I would not trust a stranger to implement correct and safe measures all the time with several children to look after.

Kangaruby · 09/06/2022 06:50

Cm I used had a dog, she got the dog two years after dc started, the only time dc and the dog mixed was when they all went on walks together, cm home set up meant there were 2 back doors to her garden so was v easy to separate the children and dog. Dc stayed with that cm for 10 years and enjoyed walking the dog so positive experience here

RedWingBoots · 09/06/2022 06:48

CandleSchtick · 09/06/2022 00:07

For the person who mentioned it upthread, there's no obligation to tell minded families you're going to get a dog or any pet

I'd think it's courteous to give them enough warning to find alternative childcare, surely.

My DD's CM keeps ending up with more pets in her household.

There is now a dog as well. Luckily the CM ensured my DD learnt how to meet dogs from when she could walk.

The household dog is kept away from my DD 95% of the time and the 5% is heavily supervised.

My own CM had a much larger dog. Poor thing spent his time locked behind a baby gate in another room. Looking up the breed as a teen I found he was more likely to knock small children over than anything else.

Darbs76 · 09/06/2022 06:43

It would depend on the dog. I’m a big dog lover, we have a dog, but I didn’t get him until my children were age 9 plus. I am not sure I’d be comfortable having a small child around a dog to be honest. Would depend on the set up, I’m sure she will have gates etc, but if it was a breed that I view to be those always responsible for attacks then no. I always used a nursery, I wasn’t comfortable having 1 person looking after my child, for a few reasons.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 09/06/2022 06:35

CandleSchtick · 08/06/2022 23:22

disaster....and it will be the dog who pays with its life

And as a pp reported, a child could be scarred for life. Dogs should not be in any childcare setting.

I find this interesting as when I was in school, we had several "school dogs" including a Scottie dog who spent its days in the classroom with it's owner - he slept under the desk and went everywhere with her.

Lots of schools have dogs and use therapy dogs.

Galaxyrippleforever · 09/06/2022 06:06

Sarah13xx · 08/06/2022 22:56

I’ve always been brought up around dogs so it depends on your own background I think what your views on dogs are. Personally I don’t think a house is a home without a dog and if your child minder is trustworthy she will have a sensible dog and won’t allow it near your child where it could cause any harm. There are these extremely rare cases where dogs attack children but unfortunately many of these dogs have been mistreated for years and then possibly even been backed into a corner by so many children over the years having ears pulled etc and not doing anything about it. There’s obviously no excuse for a dog attacking a young child but the blame is on the owner for causing that situation to come about in my view. I have two big dogs and a baby. I could trust them with my life but will still not allow them near my baby unless I have a hold of them as he’s still new to them.

Theres nothing worse though than a child who haven’t been raised around dogs making a big song and dance about a dog being near them 🤦🏼‍♀️ We were at my friends house and she had to lead her dog into the other room while we were in the living room. My little boy was buzzing at seeing her dog, while my friends little girl (who doesn’t have a dog) screamed the second the dog walked in the room. She had a massive over reaction to a dog just walking past and her mum sort of encouraged it in a way I would say. I was just so glad my little boy will never be that child 🙈

My daughter is 'that child'. It's not my doing, she's just scared of dogs. We do a lot to help her get used to them.

You sound like a dick to be honest. Children are allowed to be afraid of things. Imagine judging a frightened child!

stuntbubbles · 09/06/2022 06:06

Not a chance in hell.

Thissucksmonkeynuts · 09/06/2022 06:04

I used a childminder with 2 terriers, there was never an issue with them (a whole host of other reasons why we stopped using her...)
I've also used a nursery where the owner bought her dog in, it was left to run into area where babies who pram napped were parked and was very noisy, I saw it wake babies with it's barking and the exasperation of the room staff who had to deal with prematurely woken babies.

tiggergoesbounce · 09/06/2022 06:03

Definately not, and thats from a household with a dog.

3amAndImStillAwake · 09/06/2022 05:58

Absolutely not

Leonberger · 09/06/2022 05:55

I would and did providing the correct procedures are put in place.

My DC school has a resident dog that wanders around, the children love it and it hasn’t really crossed my mind to worry about it.

Notaneffingcockerspaniel · 09/06/2022 00:54

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

PrinnyPree · 09/06/2022 00:39

I'm a dog lover and most of my family have dogs however I was also badly bitten by the family dog when I was 6 and needed stitches.

For me I would probably err on the side of no mostly because I think alot of dog owners are slightly love blinded by their dogs and it lets their safeguarding and caution slip.

Recently there was an article where a child was mauled by a dog and so many people defending the dog and saying it was probably a reflexive defence to a loud child or sudden movement and thinking Christ, these people still think that sort of dog will make a good pet, one you have to walk on eggshells around.

I also was out in a park and a large bull terrier dog approached my toddler, face to face height, and the owner got super defensive when I scooped my baby up, protesting "he wouldn't hurt a fly" and just thinking I'm not leaving my toddler in a vulnerable position with a potentially dangerous dog I do not know to save a strangers feelings.

I do really worry about some dog owners attitudes around their pets.

nokidshere · 09/06/2022 00:17

I'm a childminder and I would never use a childminder with a dog, but that's largely due to my own animal phobia rather than anything else.

CandleSchtick · 09/06/2022 00:07

For the person who mentioned it upthread, there's no obligation to tell minded families you're going to get a dog or any pet

I'd think it's courteous to give them enough warning to find alternative childcare, surely.

Neveranynamesleft · 09/06/2022 00:00

Its a no from me. A definite no in fact.

KenAdams · 08/06/2022 23:50

I have a dog and I wouldn't. I don't know their dogs temperament or training like I do my own so I wouldn't be comfortable with that, particularly when they were trying to watch several children and the dog all at the same time. I also wouldn't want someone who thinks its OK to shut a dog away for 8 hours at a time.

Footbelle · 08/06/2022 23:47

My cm got a dog and I never gave it a thought. I think he was only in the house in his cage though.

Depends on the cm and the dog, I think. We have dogs who are so patient and protective with our dc but may treat other dc as strangers.

OppsUpsSide · 08/06/2022 23:45

No

Swipe left for the next trending thread