Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you use a childminder with a dog?

279 replies

PashunFroot · 08/06/2022 22:02

Just that really. We want to use a childminder rather than a nursery, purely for logistical reasons as they can collect older child from school. However all the childminders locally have dogs. I’m not a dog person, and I’m quite wary of them. I know they will be kept shut away from the children but would I always be worrying about it while I’m at work?

aibu for even being worried about it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 13/04/2023 23:48

Absolutely 100% not.

PashunFroot · 12/04/2023 12:50

Gosh this is old! We went with a nursery in the end :)

The childminder I visited assured me the dogs were always kept separate however as I left I saw 2 children napping in the living room where the dogs were! Accepted his nursery place that day.

OP posts:
Scroobydoo · 12/04/2023 11:48

Yes if I viewed the set up and met the dog

But I'm a 'dog person'

zingally · 12/04/2023 11:33

Completely depends on the dog, and the set-up the childminder has.

For example, I'd be much more content with dopey old labrador who "lives" in the conservatory and comes out on walks on a lead, than I would be over 3yo german shepherd who has free roam of the house.

LavenderOlive21 · 12/04/2023 08:58

No.

Wickywickyyow · 12/04/2023 08:55

Bagsundermyeyestoday · 12/04/2023 07:54

I agree. I would think a childminder isn't that serious/ it's not a priority if they had a dog. More that it's just a sideline to make some extra money, would completely put me off

Newsflash- most people work for the money, even childminders! We wouldn't do it for free just because we love working with children.

I've been a for 14 years, we have a 2 Yr old dog who is amazing with the children. Of course I am safety conscious and he isn't left alone with them etc, but families choose a cm for the homely experience and having a dog can be part of that.

I'm also ofsted outstanding and constantly have a waiting list so many parents agree, despite the scaremongering on mumsnet.

SaySomethingMan · 12/04/2023 08:41

Sarah13xx · 08/06/2022 22:56

I’ve always been brought up around dogs so it depends on your own background I think what your views on dogs are. Personally I don’t think a house is a home without a dog and if your child minder is trustworthy she will have a sensible dog and won’t allow it near your child where it could cause any harm. There are these extremely rare cases where dogs attack children but unfortunately many of these dogs have been mistreated for years and then possibly even been backed into a corner by so many children over the years having ears pulled etc and not doing anything about it. There’s obviously no excuse for a dog attacking a young child but the blame is on the owner for causing that situation to come about in my view. I have two big dogs and a baby. I could trust them with my life but will still not allow them near my baby unless I have a hold of them as he’s still new to them.

Theres nothing worse though than a child who haven’t been raised around dogs making a big song and dance about a dog being near them 🤦🏼‍♀️ We were at my friends house and she had to lead her dog into the other room while we were in the living room. My little boy was buzzing at seeing her dog, while my friends little girl (who doesn’t have a dog) screamed the second the dog walked in the room. She had a massive over reaction to a dog just walking past and her mum sort of encouraged it in a way I would say. I was just so glad my little boy will never be that child 🙈

you sound pleasant

Cherryonthetop2019 · 12/04/2023 08:37

Nicecow · 12/04/2023 07:52

Gosh I feel sorry for your dog, how cruel

Oh for gods sake! The dog didn’t live in tbe crate and was out of the kitchen with us during the day. The point was I had an adequate steps in place to know the children and dog didn’t mix without me being present.

The children loved tbe dog and she was amazing with them.

I only worked term time 8.30-5 and the dog had completely free reign of the house outside those times.

I really do wish people would think outside the box before coming back with stupid and ignorant comments like yours.

Bagsundermyeyestoday · 12/04/2023 07:54

Mumuser124 · 12/04/2023 06:24

I wouldn’t personally use a childminder who had a dog at home. Any dog , even well trained dogs are an additional risk to an environment that is supposed to be as safe as humanly possible when looking after other peoples children. Whether rightly or wrongly, it would make me question how responsible the childminder was. I understand that a lot of child minders risk assess but it is an added responsibility when you are promoting yourself as a safe person whose primary focus is on the children in your care.

I think if my childminder got a puppy now, depending on the breed, I’d probably keep my child there for a while but would be thinking of other arrangements when the dog became bigger.

I agree. I would think a childminder isn't that serious/ it's not a priority if they had a dog. More that it's just a sideline to make some extra money, would completely put me off

Nicecow · 12/04/2023 07:52

Cherryonthetop2019 · 12/04/2023 05:06

I used to childmind and had a dog. Dog had a crate in the kitchen and a gate across kitchen door.I also had a gated section in the garden so the dog was never in same area as the kids.

I had a written policy for the dog and a full risk assessment. I am a qualified teacher so knew how to ensure it was done safely.

My parents loved the fact I had a dog as the kids got the all the joys of dog ownership with non of the responsibility! it was very positively connected in in my OFSTED inspection too. I was given an an outstanding so I’m 100% confident it was not an issue. I was always full with a waiting list.

Gosh I feel sorry for your dog, how cruel

Mumuser124 · 12/04/2023 06:24

I wouldn’t personally use a childminder who had a dog at home. Any dog , even well trained dogs are an additional risk to an environment that is supposed to be as safe as humanly possible when looking after other peoples children. Whether rightly or wrongly, it would make me question how responsible the childminder was. I understand that a lot of child minders risk assess but it is an added responsibility when you are promoting yourself as a safe person whose primary focus is on the children in your care.

I think if my childminder got a puppy now, depending on the breed, I’d probably keep my child there for a while but would be thinking of other arrangements when the dog became bigger.

Cherryonthetop2019 · 12/04/2023 05:06

I used to childmind and had a dog. Dog had a crate in the kitchen and a gate across kitchen door.I also had a gated section in the garden so the dog was never in same area as the kids.

I had a written policy for the dog and a full risk assessment. I am a qualified teacher so knew how to ensure it was done safely.

My parents loved the fact I had a dog as the kids got the all the joys of dog ownership with non of the responsibility! it was very positively connected in in my OFSTED inspection too. I was given an an outstanding so I’m 100% confident it was not an issue. I was always full with a waiting list.

SorePaw · 12/04/2023 02:45

ZOMBIE

@DaSilvaP why would you revive this old thread? Not quite enough dog hating on MN today?

Nurseries & childminders are two different things.

of course it's the childminders home. Do you think they live elsewhere?

You should take up jogging!

Phoebo · 12/04/2023 02:33

Never

DaSilvaP · 12/04/2023 02:13

Chickychoccyegg · 08/06/2022 22:27

I'm a childminder, I have 2 dogs, thinking about it now, all the other childminders I know also have dogs.
It's a great way for children to learn how to behave around dogs and how to care for them.
You'll know when you've found the right childminder for you and your family, and part of that will be how they reassure you with their pet policy.
For the person who mentioned it upthread, there's no obligation to tell minded families you're going to get a dog or any pet, it's the childminders home at the end of the day, and the only thing minded families can do is leave if their not happy with that.

there's no obligation to tell minded families you're going to get a dog or any pet, it's the childminders home at the end of the day

No IT'S NOT "your home" - it's a place where you run a business.

Any nursery "forgetting" to mention to parents they keep dogs on site would find itself on very thin legal ice, any accidents happening or not.

You better pray you never have to test that in courts ...

Wannabegreenfingers · 14/06/2022 21:51

Yes, I do and I'm not a dog person.

Changednamesorry · 14/06/2022 21:50

No chance.

tilder · 14/06/2022 21:46

Chickychoccyegg · 08/06/2022 22:27

I'm a childminder, I have 2 dogs, thinking about it now, all the other childminders I know also have dogs.
It's a great way for children to learn how to behave around dogs and how to care for them.
You'll know when you've found the right childminder for you and your family, and part of that will be how they reassure you with their pet policy.
For the person who mentioned it upthread, there's no obligation to tell minded families you're going to get a dog or any pet, it's the childminders home at the end of the day, and the only thing minded families can do is leave if their not happy with that.

There may be no obligation but surely it's common courtesy?

Bunnycat101 · 14/06/2022 21:31

“Must say I'm quite amazed by some of the replies and curious whether those with a firm no would also not send their child to a school if they have a school dog ?”

I was a flat no but am very chilled about the reading dog who comes to my daughter’s school. The dog has undergone temperament assessments, has breaks, is incredibly well trained and children have the option of not interacting. That is a completely different situation to an unpredictable toddler being cared for in a home with a dog where there could be multiple distractions.

Ohthatsexciting · 14/06/2022 06:11

I always say..... No one ever left a kid with a dog that they knew was dangerous

although the 10 year old boy mauled to death this year by his parents pit bull called “the beast” would say otherwise

Ohthatsexciting · 14/06/2022 06:09

DancyNancy · 14/06/2022 00:16

I'm a major dog lover and recently bereaved owner and worked with dogs in some capacity and I'd say no unless ABSOLUTE assurance that dog and child are separated by gate etc.

It's not about bad dog/bad kid. It's about the miscommunication that can happen.

Someone outside the family can be perceived as a threat by the most 'placid' of dogs....even people within the family.
It's not about not 'trusting' a dog. It's just being aware that humans and dogs don't speak the same language. Sometimes things get lost in translation.

Size matters too....Someone gave a good point.... baby with a large dog absolutely no. Older kid with a tiny dog maybe. They could still end up with bite but unlikely to be fatal.

When people say to me 'My dog would never'
I always say..... No one ever left a kid with a dog that they knew was dangerous

That is a really sensible and balanced post.

LicoricePizza · 14/06/2022 05:17

Dog lover here but no. I might trust the childminder to stick to the arrangements for where the dog is kept etc but so many of stories where children been sadly attacked seem to involve other family members or individuals supervising (or failing to supervise) dogs properly. Wouldn’t be able to trust that others’ responsible for taking them to random vet visits or taking them out would follow the rules and not inadvertently slip up, forget to lock the gate, let them off without realising kids in the garden type thing. Also wldn’t be comfortable with dogs plural for obvious reasons. Sound like a dog hater - am not! prob just too paranoid!

DancyNancy · 14/06/2022 00:16

I'm a major dog lover and recently bereaved owner and worked with dogs in some capacity and I'd say no unless ABSOLUTE assurance that dog and child are separated by gate etc.

It's not about bad dog/bad kid. It's about the miscommunication that can happen.

Someone outside the family can be perceived as a threat by the most 'placid' of dogs....even people within the family.
It's not about not 'trusting' a dog. It's just being aware that humans and dogs don't speak the same language. Sometimes things get lost in translation.

Size matters too....Someone gave a good point.... baby with a large dog absolutely no. Older kid with a tiny dog maybe. They could still end up with bite but unlikely to be fatal.

When people say to me 'My dog would never'
I always say..... No one ever left a kid with a dog that they knew was dangerous

InChocolateWeTrust · 13/06/2022 23:50

Not only due to the risks, but also because at the moment my children arent fussed about dogs. I don't like them , and wouldnt want my kids ending up enjoying the dog a lot at a childminders and wanting to own dogs themselves as adults. This is because I don't like visiting homes with dogs and I don't like people bringing their dogs to my home so it would limit my visits with my children if they own dogs as adults.

InChocolateWeTrust · 13/06/2022 23:47

Nope. Not in a million years.

Swipe left for the next trending thread