Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking 16 yr old for ‘rent’

112 replies

Scaredypup · 08/06/2022 21:47

My dd is 16, 17 in September and finishes school this month. Well, I say finishing school, but she has only attended twice through the whole of year 11.
She suffers with mental health quite badly but the last 12-18 months she has given me hell. She stopped coming home, I never knew where she was, she was doing drugs and disrespecting me and the home in every way possible. I had heavy social services and police involvement. She’s extremely rude to me at times. We don’t really have a relationship anymore.

Shes settled a little now, has a weekend job, ‘only’ smokes weed now. Barely comes home still but I know where she is. But she treats home like a drop in centre and I find it so disrespectful.

She’s not going to college, she has no plans. She’s going to go full time at her weekend job and will be earning more money than me as a single Mum with a another young child. Is it fair that I charge her maybe £30 a week ‘rent?’ The way I see it is if she doesn’t want to stay at school and wants to be an adult then she needs to get used to the real world. She has no outgoings, all her money goes on takeaways and weed. Her answer is she’s barely here. But she comes here sometimes at midnight to sleep, or in the day to use the bath and do some washing. It’s basically a base or somewhere to go when she can’t stay at her boyfriends.

OP posts:
newfriend05 · 09/06/2022 10:08

I had my children, take on one of the household bills .. one did the sky bill and the other took over the mobile phones .. worked well

Discovereads · 09/06/2022 10:06

Swayingpalmtrees · 09/06/2022 09:12

We don’t really have a relationship anymore

Rather than thinking about charging her rent - surely you should be building your relationship with her op? She is still a child and in your care until she is eighteen years old, and although I appreciate you haven't had an easy time of it lately it does sound like she has turned a corner.

I would be supporting her 100% to get back into education, failing that a well paid apprenticeship so she can train and have a proper career. In lieu of rent I would open a savings account instead.

Recognising her achievement of kicking drugs and getting herself together - I would be moving heaven and earth now to try and keep her safe, at home, into a steady job with lots of love and support. It is not easy being a teenager and it doesn't sound like it has been fun for her either. She is still incredibly young and needs your support, whether she will admit or not.

Very sensible advice.

veggiesupreme · 09/06/2022 10:04

I always feel so sad for the poor teens with so little support at such a difficult age with the world as it is. Parents completely giving up on them without any awareness of their own contribution to the child's problems.

Discovereads · 09/06/2022 10:00

@woody87
Discovereads is an idiot with zero life experience judging by the comments made to you.

No need to be so rude. I have two adult DC and two teenage DC. One of which has poor mental health & diagnosed PTSD and GAD due to having been raped as a teen. What makes you so much more qualified than I to know the OPs DD is “treating her like a mug”? Have you ever had a teen DD under care of CAMHS due to poor mental health?

CharSiu · 09/06/2022 09:46

Do you know why your DD has MH issues?

AchatAVendre · 09/06/2022 09:43

Her answer is she’s barely here. But she comes here sometimes at midnight to sleep, or in the day to use the bath and do some washing. It’s basically a base or somewhere to go when she can’t stay at her boyfriends.

Sounds like you'd be charging her for B&B, rather than rent.

I think by charging her "rent" you risk driving her away. She clearly needs to return home for some security now and then, not to pay rent for somewhere she doesn't actually live. She's very young, she seems to need support, frustrating though she can be.

Swayingpalmtrees · 09/06/2022 09:38

If she wants to live like an adult and do adult things then she pays her way like an adult

But the key point is that she is NOT an adult, and nowhere near the point of adult maturity, as parents it is our responsibility to care for our children until they are old enough and responsible enough to navigate the world themselves with a degree of competence.

There is no way I would be allowing her to keep all her wages to blow it on drugs

Did you miss the part where op said she has actually stopped taking drugs

Sarah3587 · 09/06/2022 09:38

I think you need to put your big girl pants on and be tougher with her.
for a start she’s still legally a child and has to be in full time education/training until she’s 18.
the only job she can do is an apprenticeship based one.
that is the law in 2022 and a Breach of it could see YOU in court.
i have a 16 year old who is tough but I would sooner get beaten to a pulp by her trying to keep her in line then allow her to swan about like your daughter is.
I know it’s tough but you need to take more control of her life, because she sounds like she needs it!.

MrsSkylerWhite · 09/06/2022 09:38

Can’t advise on the rent as ours left home at 16. Otherwise, you could be me, several years ago.

fast forward, ten years on she is the most wonderful young woman and we couldn’t be more proud. She did most of it herself and I hope yours does, too. Working full time in itself will change her outlook. X

Pennyhill22 · 09/06/2022 09:35

You should definitely charge her. If she wants to live like an adult and do adult things then she pays her way like an adult. There is no way I would be allowing her to keep all her wages to blow it on drugs.

FoiledByTheInsect · 09/06/2022 09:34

YANBU at all but sounds like what you want (and deserve) OP is respect, not rent.

She's using weed as escapism, all it'll do is damage her MH and completely destroy her relationship with you and also her ability to hold down a job. Nothing wrong with ft work at 16 but because she's so busy escaping and not dealing with her issues, she probably hasn't considered her options properly. Because she's still a rebellious teen she won't listen to you either. But she's crossing boundaries and has to be reined in, I think you're right to be worried about what she'd spend a ft wage on.

Iiwu I'd lay it on the line: tell her you're concerned for her and upset, she's affecting other family members etc. Ask her if she'll come to counselling or therapy with you to address her weed habit and communication issues, or at least talk about things and address the problem. If she refuses and carries on trashing your boundaries, then rent it is.

woody87 · 09/06/2022 09:31

Scaredypup · 09/06/2022 08:14

@Discovereads Being abusive to your family, dropping out of school and doing drugs every day is not normal teenage behaviour.

Of course it's not normal teenage behaviour. @Discovereads is an idiot with zero life experience judging by the comments made to you.

Teenagers can be utterly appalling and yours is treating you like an absolute mug, zero respect for you or your house and it's time to get serious.

Charge her the rent. Tell her that unless the rent is paid on time each week then she doesn't get to use the facilities.

Swayingpalmtrees · 09/06/2022 09:12

We don’t really have a relationship anymore

Rather than thinking about charging her rent - surely you should be building your relationship with her op? She is still a child and in your care until she is eighteen years old, and although I appreciate you haven't had an easy time of it lately it does sound like she has turned a corner.

I would be supporting her 100% to get back into education, failing that a well paid apprenticeship so she can train and have a proper career. In lieu of rent I would open a savings account instead.

Recognising her achievement of kicking drugs and getting herself together - I would be moving heaven and earth now to try and keep her safe, at home, into a steady job with lots of love and support. It is not easy being a teenager and it doesn't sound like it has been fun for her either. She is still incredibly young and needs your support, whether she will admit or not.

Reallyreallyborednow · 09/06/2022 08:46

Whilst I can understand that you would like the money, I think if you try to charge her rent, she just won't come home. She's obviously got somewhere else to stay

this. I suspect you ask for rent she’ll simply stop coming back.

ConfessionsOfAShopper · 09/06/2022 08:46

My mum charged me rent at 16 (when I was still in full time education and working weekends). I was the only person I knew who was paying rent at 16 and it really used to upset me.

I would say though that since she will be working only and no further education that it would be ok to charge a little rent. Ot maybe you could ask her to contribute to the food shop weekly?

dianthus101 · 09/06/2022 08:42

queenMab99 · 09/06/2022 08:28

I think that some posters have no idea what it is like, to watch your teenager ruin their lives, by missing their education and getting involved with drug culture, even if it is 'only pot', it sounds like OP has done everything she can, but it is like trying to save them from drowning, while they are not only being pulled by the tide, but are actively swimming in the wrong direction. I don't know what the answer is, asking for rent is not the OP being avaricious, she is trying to get her daughter to take some sort of adult responsibility for her own life, and showing her that you cannot hold down a job without keeping yourself and your clothes clean, and feed yourself, and that she will need to pay for that in some way.
If OP was not struggling financially herself, she could set her daughter up in a flat, then let her daughter keep herself and pay rent to a landlord, and be there to help when it all falls apart, or her daughter learns to budget and lives happily ever after. However those who say she should save the £30 and use it to pay for counselling, as well as pay for the electricity and washing powder etc her daughter uses, are living in a dreamworld.
It is not just the financial pressure either, the stress is almost unbearable, just reading about this has brought me to tears
Q

I don't think you have to know what it is like “to watch your teenager ruin their lives, by missing their education and getting involved with drug culture” and if you do it doesn't mean you are best person to advise OP on what will improve things. It's pretty obvious charging rent to someone who's hardly ever there is not going to teach responsibility. She will either never go home or if she does her behaviour will probably be even worse if she thinks she's paying to treat the house like a hotel.

cheninblanc · 09/06/2022 08:41

I'd charge her rent if she wasn't in full time education. My 18 year old wanted to leave her a levels this time last year, and it was made very clear I expected her to work full time and pay rent. She decided to stay and has pushed through and is expected good grades. But the reality once I laid it out to her wasn't as attractive when she realised her free life was coming to an end

Bednobsbroomsticks · 09/06/2022 08:39

Sounds a bit like the rent will push her away and that's kind of what you want. Do you want her to live with you? Tbh the rent sounds like least of your worries.

Discovereads · 09/06/2022 08:36

Scaredypup · 09/06/2022 08:14

@Discovereads Being abusive to your family, dropping out of school and doing drugs every day is not normal teenage behaviour.

You said she has very bad mental health. That causes the above and she needs support not condemnation. I never said those aspects were normal behaviour.

In my post I said that “normal teenage behaviour” is the coming and going between home and where they live as an interim phase on the path to independence. The sleeping over, showering, washing clothes one night/morning and then gone for several days- that’s perfectly normal but you are calling it disrespectful and taking the piss.

Rafferty10 · 09/06/2022 08:32

In your circumstances op, l would charge her more and lay out the costs of her portion of home bills and explain that if she is not in full time education she must pay a proportion of the running costs of her home (however she treats it)

Lay it out calmly and let her decide, she has decided she knows better than you and wants to work so let her see the real working world including responsibilities

carefullycourageous · 09/06/2022 08:32

Comedycook · 09/06/2022 08:02

@carefullycourageous yes I'm aware of that...I was just wondering if it means the op will end up facing some sort of penalty?

In theory CB could be stopped. LA would have to engage.

queenMab99 · 09/06/2022 08:28

I think that some posters have no idea what it is like, to watch your teenager ruin their lives, by missing their education and getting involved with drug culture, even if it is 'only pot', it sounds like OP has done everything she can, but it is like trying to save them from drowning, while they are not only being pulled by the tide, but are actively swimming in the wrong direction. I don't know what the answer is, asking for rent is not the OP being avaricious, she is trying to get her daughter to take some sort of adult responsibility for her own life, and showing her that you cannot hold down a job without keeping yourself and your clothes clean, and feed yourself, and that she will need to pay for that in some way.
If OP was not struggling financially herself, she could set her daughter up in a flat, then let her daughter keep herself and pay rent to a landlord, and be there to help when it all falls apart, or her daughter learns to budget and lives happily ever after. However those who say she should save the £30 and use it to pay for counselling, as well as pay for the electricity and washing powder etc her daughter uses, are living in a dreamworld.
It is not just the financial pressure either, the stress is almost unbearable, just reading about this has brought me to tears
Q

Scaredypup · 09/06/2022 08:27

Thanks for all the responses. It seems I am not being unreasonable to ask for a small contribution so I will do so whilst hoping things one day get better.

OP posts:
Scaredypup · 09/06/2022 08:14

@Discovereads Being abusive to your family, dropping out of school and doing drugs every day is not normal teenage behaviour.

OP posts:
itsgettingweird · 09/06/2022 08:14

If she's working full time and living at home she pays rent.

She's going into the adult world of working so she pays her way like an adult.

I'd be charging more than £30 a week.

I've heard people put money in savings from rent (so use what is needed to pay he way and save some) before so that could always be an option so when she's moved on from her current difficulties she has a bigger to help her financially move on too.