Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave A&E…

62 replies

rainyskylight · 08/06/2022 19:45

Sorry to add to all the A&E threads.

On Saturday I hit my head badly and I’ve had headaches ever since. I didn’t black out, but I did get knocked to the ground. No nausea, no vision changes. But have had general sense of not right, headaches, and deep desire to lie in a dark room in silence. Sharp pain has gone but the dull pain remains and isn’t going away.

Called the GP. She said it was borderline but ultimately I should probably go to A&E so a doctor there could make a call on whether I need a CT or not.

Got here at 3pm. Have had my obs done 2 hours ago but nothing since. At this time I’m thinking they won’t do CTs until the morning anyway.

Fully charged phone but I can’t really do sustained phone reading due to the headache. Mainly sitting here with my eyes closed and sunglasses on, looking v hungover.

Thinking I should just sack this and take my chances at home. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
stripesorspotsorwhat · 09/06/2022 17:18

I hope you have been able to rest now, and are feeling a bit better today.

Palavah · 08/06/2022 23:34

Glad you got seen, OP.

I had a serious bash to the head 3 years ago and went to A&E, more for the stitches than anything else, but when i git home i was glad to have been checked out. I went into work the next day mainly because i was nervous about being by myself.

It took a couple of weeks for me to feel normal again - i had to really avoid screens/reading, exercise beyond walking, and general exertion for a couple of weeks.

Be gentle with yourself.

ObjectionHearsay · 08/06/2022 23:16

Welcome to the currently sporting a concussion club!

I didn't go to a and e or a Dr, I knew I had one, got nearly knocked out by a punch I didn't see coming in a venue when a fight broke out next to me.

I was gifted a black eye and a deep blue fist shaped bruise on my temple and cheek bone, plus swelling.

The punch was hard enough to daze me and knock me to the ground.

I have however had mild nausea, a headache, tiredness, and "foggy brain" for about a week now.

Googled NHS head injury, read the little write up. Shone the phone torch in to my eyes to make sure my pupils were reacting and my symptoms didn't match what was written in the "red box" for go to a and e.

I am however very lax about my own personal health. I can't stand A and E, have given up on ever seeing a GP again. I will only ever attend a and e if someone calls an ambulance for me, a broken major limb, if have like chronic unimaginable pain that I'm screaming about (such as the mass kidney infection I once had) or should I ever have severe chest pains. Other than that I operate a "It will clear up" attitude 😳

Glad your feeling reassured though OP, tea and toast sounds like a great plan.

ShowOfHands · 08/06/2022 23:13

AmaryIlis · 08/06/2022 23:01

I just think there should be a better way than a GP giving wishywashy advice and then sending me along to A&E… where I waited 7 hours to pick up a freely available leaflet. There has to be a middle road, surely?

In some areas there is a middle way in the form of a Minor Injuries unit. We have one near us and I must say on the few occasions we've used them they've been excellent. They really need to be rolled out all over the country.

We used to have minor injuries but 4 or 5yrs ago, they decided it wasn't financially sustainable and closed it. We now have the GP or A&E, including signs in the GP's surgery reminding us that all cuts, sprains, bumps, bashes, burns etc are a matter for A&E. An A&E that's in special measures and one of the worst in the UK. In part due to the closure of minor injuries. It's frustrating and obviously nothing to do with the people who are, ime, brilliant but they're in a sinking ship where I live.

I hope you feel better soon op!

meowzeer · 08/06/2022 23:06

I guess the main thing is that your ok and nothing serious and I'm sure you feel better knowing that than having left it and wonder. Take care op.

AmaryIlis · 08/06/2022 23:01

I just think there should be a better way than a GP giving wishywashy advice and then sending me along to A&E… where I waited 7 hours to pick up a freely available leaflet. There has to be a middle road, surely?

In some areas there is a middle way in the form of a Minor Injuries unit. We have one near us and I must say on the few occasions we've used them they've been excellent. They really need to be rolled out all over the country.

rainyskylight · 08/06/2022 22:59

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow genuinely though, I take that on board, thank you.

OP posts:
rainyskylight · 08/06/2022 22:58

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow thank you for that, some fair points, although the word slagging is a bit much.

I think perhaps the whole NHS subject has just become so so emotional, with everyone having different stories. I am in general normally very happy with my GP, and I try not to bother the surgery unless absolutely necessary. I think perhaps my opinion is currently coloured not just by the general commentary and political debate, but also their refusal to see a really bizarre rash my 18mo daughter has had on her back for 4 months. They just keep prescribing a different cream - currently on our fourth strength hydrocortisone without an examination.

OP posts:
rainyskylight · 08/06/2022 22:53

@LibrariesGiveUsPower I was accurate and did not embellish in my check in form, making quite clear I’d been stable and had had no vomiting etc. They streamlined me to emergency not minor injuries. Would have quite liked minor injuries! But that’s a very good point!!

OP posts:
rainyskylight · 08/06/2022 22:51

@meowzeer yes I see, but I didn’t need a CT - the doctor shone a light in my eyes and then sent me home with a leaflet. I don’t know. I don’t really see how I was impatient. I sat there for a long time, very quietly and uncomplaining. I never once asked how much longer, although many around me did. And then about half way through I wrote a MN thread because I was tired and losing perspective.

I just think there should be a better way than a GP giving wishywashy advice and then sending me along to A&E… where I waited 7 hours to pick up a freely available leaflet. There has to be a middle road, surely?

Well aware that I was seen in order of priority and that’s why it took them so long to see me - and also why I sort of knew more and more that it really was so unlikely to be serious.

Sorry I don’t really know why I’m responding so specifically here, as these back-and-forths online can be a bit much. Anyway, thank you for taking the time respond, appreciated.

OP posts:
MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 08/06/2022 22:48

BlanketsBanned · 08/06/2022 20:02

An xray would show a fracture, what did they do in the days before ct. And in my day working in a&e a suspected head injury would warrant 15 minute neuro obs

Were you a porter in A&E, or did you make the tea? You’re clearly not a clinician, or you’d know that most brain injuries have no associated skull fracture, and that x-rays haven’t been the recommended investigation for head injury for a good 25 years.

And not much point doing 15 minute obs on someone who has been stable for > 72 hours.

There’s nothing wrong with being non-clinical, but best not to give medical advice when you don’t know what you’re talking about. One day, someone might follow it and be seriously harmed.

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 08/06/2022 22:42

rainyskylight · 08/06/2022 22:10

@stripesorspotsorwhat yes they said it’s mild concussion or contusion (either a brain shake or a brain bruise, impossible to say) and that there’s nothing really I can do. Also said that even if it is bleeding a bit they wouldn’t do anything to treat it. But to come back if I suddenly start having new and alarming symptoms.

Seven hours wait and so much NHS admin wasted - to squeeze a doctor’s finger and be given a leaflet. There has to be something inbetween A&E and a GP.

Something between would be minor injuries, which is not appropriate for head injuries.

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 08/06/2022 22:40

rainyskylight · 08/06/2022 22:02

Hello - I have just been seen, in a taxi home. Doctor saw me, asked some questions, did some extremely simple tests (follow my finger, touch your nose, squeeze my thumb etc). Then gave me a leaflet and sent me on my way. I think it was a ten minute consultation after a 7 hour wait.

I guess I just don’t really understand why my GP couldn’t have done that, if she seen me face to face. A bit baffling really. (I wonder whether GPs might be deskilling themselves or getting less confident, so much easier to send someone to A&E than make the wrong call?)

Many thanks to everyone who told me to stay. The conversation was useful and reassuring.

Looking forward to some tea and toast when I get home.

GP’s are, as ever, General Practitioners not experts in many specific fields, and certainly not in trauma. A&E was the right place for you to be assessed when erring on the side of caution.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 08/06/2022 22:40

rainyskylight · 08/06/2022 22:10

@stripesorspotsorwhat yes they said it’s mild concussion or contusion (either a brain shake or a brain bruise, impossible to say) and that there’s nothing really I can do. Also said that even if it is bleeding a bit they wouldn’t do anything to treat it. But to come back if I suddenly start having new and alarming symptoms.

Seven hours wait and so much NHS admin wasted - to squeeze a doctor’s finger and be given a leaflet. There has to be something inbetween A&E and a GP.

Depressing to see you slagging off your GP, who gave you good and prompt advice, correctly saying this was borderline for needing investigation, but clearly taking your ongoing symptoms into account.

I’m both an A&E doctor and a GP. A GP has 10 minutes to assess you. In A&E, you are observed over time, and that is immensely valuable in making a diagnosis. A diagnosis isn’t just about the tests that are done; it’s also about observation. A&E has the luxury (even if it doesn’t feel like a luxury!) of time. Also, A&E doctors see dozens of head injuries a week, whereas your GP probably sees a few a year. But your GP will know about many conditions that an A&E doctor hasn’t a clue about.

onlythreenow · 08/06/2022 22:35

I'm glad you waited it out OP and hope you feel better soon. Flowers

meowzeer · 08/06/2022 22:35

Imo gp done the right thing. They are not the same as a and e Dr's and whilst she could have checked your reflexes she couldn't have done a ct scan meaning you'd have had a telephone call, gp appointment and then to a and e, taking much longer. I think you need to understand that in a and e people come in with emergencies such as heart attack, stroke and therefore you were triaged in order of priority. You come across as very impatient.

rainyskylight · 08/06/2022 22:10

@stripesorspotsorwhat yes they said it’s mild concussion or contusion (either a brain shake or a brain bruise, impossible to say) and that there’s nothing really I can do. Also said that even if it is bleeding a bit they wouldn’t do anything to treat it. But to come back if I suddenly start having new and alarming symptoms.

Seven hours wait and so much NHS admin wasted - to squeeze a doctor’s finger and be given a leaflet. There has to be something inbetween A&E and a GP.

OP posts:
stripesorspotsorwhat · 08/06/2022 22:05

I'm glad you've been seen and you're now on your way home.

By the way, has anyone mentioned concussion?

rainyskylight · 08/06/2022 22:03

@NamelessNancy yes you are quite right there! Should have expected it 🤣

OP posts:
rainyskylight · 08/06/2022 22:02

Hello - I have just been seen, in a taxi home. Doctor saw me, asked some questions, did some extremely simple tests (follow my finger, touch your nose, squeeze my thumb etc). Then gave me a leaflet and sent me on my way. I think it was a ten minute consultation after a 7 hour wait.

I guess I just don’t really understand why my GP couldn’t have done that, if she seen me face to face. A bit baffling really. (I wonder whether GPs might be deskilling themselves or getting less confident, so much easier to send someone to A&E than make the wrong call?)

Many thanks to everyone who told me to stay. The conversation was useful and reassuring.

Looking forward to some tea and toast when I get home.

OP posts:
NamelessNancy · 08/06/2022 22:02

YANBU to have gone to A&E on the advice of the GP.

YANBU to be fed up of waiting whilst feeling unwell although I think if you leave now YABU.

YABVVVVU to post an A&E thread here and not expect a horrible pile on!

All the best. Hope they see you soon.

SunnyShiner · 08/06/2022 21:46

Ignore the rude ones. You're in the best place, just sit tight and I hope you're seen soon x

chris8888 · 08/06/2022 21:43

Stay its boring and when your in pain seems endless but you went to get checked out properly so just stay for your health.

Basilbrushgotfat · 08/06/2022 21:38

Hope you're seen soon, op. It sounds like a concussion at the very least, but definitely needs to be medically cleared - wouldn't take a chance with head injuries.

Fridgemagnetto · 08/06/2022 21:36

Burgoo · 08/06/2022 19:49

If you want to be medically cleared then stay. If you don't then don't.

Either way its not like A&E are going to be overly upset. What do you actually want? You do realise they do CT scans out of hours right? It doesn't stop at 5pm.

I think this depends on area. My DP was taken to hospital on a Friday morning with severe abdominal pain and a fever. By the time he had been seen by someone who decided he needed a scan it was evening. He had to wait in absolute agony on a ward all weekend for a CT scan as nothing seemed to happen at the weekend. No scans, no consultants, just monitoring by nurses. On the Monday he was rushed into surgery immediately after the scan which detected a perforated ulcer.