Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu that you should say thank you when someone cooks you dinner?

158 replies

MarmaRell78 · 08/06/2022 19:29

Maybe I'm in the minority, but I always say thank you when someone cooks for me. I'm on maternity leave, so basically doing all of the cooking / cleaning/ washing / clearing up. DH can't even be arsed to put his stuff in the dishwasher, a classic pile it up the side of leave all over the house.

But the very least, surely, is when I've cooked him dinner he could at least look up from his phone and say thanks? I get that he's been at work, but am I asking too much?! Silently fuming and wondering whether to pick this fight.

YABU - You don't need to say thank you every single time someone cooks for you when you're off work anyway

YANBU - Doesn't take much to make me feel a little more appreciated and it's definitely good manners

OP posts:
Bookworm20 · 10/06/2022 12:49

Exactly, this is lovely and how it should be. Most people care more about manners within the house than the love or conditions they are setting on their kids just so they feel appreciated or validated.

Teaching your kids to say please and thankyou does not mean you love them less than parents who don't teach their dc this. what weird logic.

My dc saying thank you for a meal is not a condition I set in order to love them ffs. We teach manners in our house because we want to do the best for our dc in hoping we've raised them well enough that they turn out to be decent human beings. BECAUSE we love them.

We've had friends of the dc over on many an occasion and yes some of them have zero manners. No pleases or thankyous anywhere. And yes, I do judge the parents of those dc because at the end of the day this is basic parenting that should be taught at home. And yes also most if not all of those mannerless dc who visited as younger children are now incredibly entitled teenagers.

If one of my dc turned out like OP's partner, sitting there like an entitled arse, not thanking her for the meal she prepared because he was 'entitled' to it, sat on his phone while eating it. Well, I'd think i'd failed them somewhat in my job as a parent.

Only on mumsnet do parents argue that teaching your dc manners is a bad thing.

Rosebel · 10/06/2022 12:36

IFeelItInMyFingersIFeelItInMy · 10/06/2022 10:25

Of course it does - you're basically teaching your children to show gratitude for something they are automatically entitled to. You are teaching them that politeness and manners are required for your obligation to feed them. If they don't say thanks, you're forcing them to say thanks because of social etiquette which shouldn't apply because you are required as a parent to feed them.

Don't be daft - buying a gift is not the same because you don't have to buy a gift for your child. Whilst I'm sure every parent will try to for the sake of their child, are social services going to come knocking on the door because you didn't buy your child a gift? Maybe you couldn't afford to?

Children should grow up entitled to expect they will be fed by their parents. It's a real travesty that so many parents think, in the name of 'good manners', that they should be thanked for this - what unconditional love.

Expecting to be thanked doesn't mean that I don't love my children unconditionally. What a ridiculous statement make.
If you don't want to teach your child good manners that's up to you but don't think it means your love for your children is any more unconditional than parents who do teach good manners.
The point about presents was would you expect your child to open it and not say anything?

Vivi0 · 10/06/2022 11:43

NightmareSituation · 10/06/2022 11:05

@Vivi0 you have a very odd perception of how families work. Why the hell should your kids not say thanks just because you are their mum?

We all say thank you to each other frequently. If my husband has beaten me to taking the clothes out of the dryer, I would say thanks. If I say I’ve ironed your shirts but left them in the airing cupboard, he would say thanks. When one the kids clear the table after dinner, we say thanks.

Chores always feel a little less of a burden when someone appreciates it and of all the people in the world I appreciate my family the most.

Of course my children say thanks, but we are talking specifically about cooking and whether you should expect a thank you each time you prepare food for your family.

Cooking is part of my responsibility towards the family, working is part of my husband’s responsibility towards the family. My role isn’t any more worthy than his is. The effort I put into cooking shouldn’t be ranked as greater than the effort he puts into work. I’m not deserving of thanks any more than he is. I wouldn’t expect my kids to thank their dad for going to work each day. That is our responsibility as adults and my children are absolutely entitled to expect to be supported financially and fed. That’s the bare minimum as far as I’m concerned.

Nor do I expect my children to thank me for doing something for them which they cannot do for themselves. They will learn, in time.

10HailMarys · 10/06/2022 11:32

@IFeelItInMyFingersIFeelItInMy

I think you're making a whole lot of really extreme judgements and generalisations here.

Just because a family puts value on expressing gratitude, that doesn't mean they aren't just as happy, loving, thoughtful or nurtured as any other family. The two things aren't mutually exclusive. I really can't understand why you'd be so vitriolic and vicious about it, really, calling people wet blankets, implying that their families can't possibly be as nice as yours... what on earth is going on?! I don't know whether you had some issues in your own childhood with overly strict/formal/cold parents or something, but it certainly feels like there's some crazy projection going on here.

I grew up in a really loud, raucous, warm, loving, opinionated, affectionate working class family where everyone was talking and laughing and arguing and eating and hugging each other all the time. Not remotely formal or needy or cold or anything like that. But we also said 'Thanks Mum, that was really nice' or whatever when she cooked us dinner, just as my parents said 'Ooh, thanks sweetheart' to me and my siblings when we made them a cup of tea or something (which seemed to be about 12 times every evening but anyway). I also remember that when we went on days out and stuff, my mum used to say to us 'Aren't we all lucky that Dad works so hard and takes us out to all these places, eh?' and there'd be a big chorus of 'Yeah, thanks Dad, love you' from the back of the car.

It's absolutely fine that you don't feel saying 'Thanks Mum/Dad - that was really nice' after a plate of spag bol is necessary - no problem at all! If you're happy and your family's happy, and that's your general vibe, that's brilliant and that's all that matters. I'd never dream of thinking there was weird or wrong about that. But I don't understand why you're so angry that some people's families have different norms to yours, or why you think they must be
cold/dysfunctional/needy/unloving/formal/slaves to the patriarchy just because they're verbally appreciative of the things they do for each other. People are allowed to express themselves in different ways.

IFeelItInMyFingersIFeelItInMy · 10/06/2022 11:19

NightmareSituation · 10/06/2022 11:05

@Vivi0 you have a very odd perception of how families work. Why the hell should your kids not say thanks just because you are their mum?

We all say thank you to each other frequently. If my husband has beaten me to taking the clothes out of the dryer, I would say thanks. If I say I’ve ironed your shirts but left them in the airing cupboard, he would say thanks. When one the kids clear the table after dinner, we say thanks.

Chores always feel a little less of a burden when someone appreciates it and of all the people in the world I appreciate my family the most.

you have a very odd perception of how families work. Why the hell should your kids not say thanks just because you are their mum?

No one is saying you shouldn't be thanked at all by your family - it's all the people on here who are saying they should/must be thanked and seem to have illogical far-fetched reasons as to why cooking stands out.

That just sounds like a family dynamic that is based on validation through reward and gratitude rather than love. You see tasks as individual things and when someone does it, they should be thanked. It's all part of running a family and a household.

NightmareSituation · 10/06/2022 11:05

@Vivi0 you have a very odd perception of how families work. Why the hell should your kids not say thanks just because you are their mum?

We all say thank you to each other frequently. If my husband has beaten me to taking the clothes out of the dryer, I would say thanks. If I say I’ve ironed your shirts but left them in the airing cupboard, he would say thanks. When one the kids clear the table after dinner, we say thanks.

Chores always feel a little less of a burden when someone appreciates it and of all the people in the world I appreciate my family the most.

IFeelItInMyFingersIFeelItInMy · 10/06/2022 11:03

NightmareSituation · 10/06/2022 10:56

YANBU.

This is one thing I will give my DH and both children credit for. They always say thank you and very often that it was lovely and they enjoyed it. There is no excuse for poor manners or neglecting to appreciate some else’s efforts.

Oh isn't that nice - giving gratitude to your husband and kids for giving gratitude to you.

IFeelItInMyFingersIFeelItInMy · 10/06/2022 11:01

Knowing my children are well fed, enjoying their meals and going to bed on a full stomach is enough gratitude for me. For that, I am grateful.

Exactly, this is lovely and how it should be. Most people care more about manners within the house than the love or conditions they are setting on their kids just so they feel appreciated or validated.

The best justifications are 'I don't want them growing up entitled'....oh, you mean like their mums who feel entitled to gratitude for feeding the kids they chose to have and raise? 😂

vitahelp · 10/06/2022 10:56

We don't really say thank you to each other for meals. But him leaving dirty stuff lying around the house would annoy me, he sounds like an unruly teenager!

NightmareSituation · 10/06/2022 10:56

YANBU.

This is one thing I will give my DH and both children credit for. They always say thank you and very often that it was lovely and they enjoyed it. There is no excuse for poor manners or neglecting to appreciate some else’s efforts.

jadeyxox · 10/06/2022 10:40

YANBU - manners cost nothing!!

Vivi0 · 10/06/2022 10:38

Bookworm20 · 10/06/2022 10:13

Anyway, is there anything more entitled than expecting recognition and thanks for doing something that is expected of you as an adult and in your role as a parent?

Well I've raised 5 dc, 4 now in mid/late teens and none of them are entitled arseholes. They are polite, independent and decent human beings who any parent would proud of. So you do you, and I'll do me. I simply believe that teaching manners in the home carries forward to other situations they will find themselves in.

The irony in your use of the word entitled. You see, i'd consider someone who ate food someone else had prepared and cooked and didn't say thank you (and were sat on their phone no less) as entitled. But there you go. Different views.

I’m not talking about a vague “someone” preparing food though, I’m specifically talking about a parent.

Of course I teach my children manners, but they are absolutely entitled to have an expectation that I will feed them, and feed them not “any old crap” as someone else suggested, but a “nice meal”.

I simply do not have this formal type relationship with my children. I’m their mummy, not some Victorian schoolmaster. Doesn’t mean my children are going to grow up to be entitled arseholes, not by a long shot.

Knowing my children are well fed, enjoying their meals and going to bed on a full stomach is enough gratitude for me. For that, I am grateful.

IFeelItInMyFingersIFeelItInMy · 10/06/2022 10:25

Rosebel · 10/06/2022 10:00

Saying thanks creates a barrier of formality??!! That's the most weird thing I've ever read on here.
So because we should buy a gift for a child's birthday they don't have to say thanks, even if it's something they really like? And yes it is similar to saying thanks if someone has cooked something you enjoy because both are things as a parent you should do
No wonder some children grow up so entitled.

Of course it does - you're basically teaching your children to show gratitude for something they are automatically entitled to. You are teaching them that politeness and manners are required for your obligation to feed them. If they don't say thanks, you're forcing them to say thanks because of social etiquette which shouldn't apply because you are required as a parent to feed them.

Don't be daft - buying a gift is not the same because you don't have to buy a gift for your child. Whilst I'm sure every parent will try to for the sake of their child, are social services going to come knocking on the door because you didn't buy your child a gift? Maybe you couldn't afford to?

Children should grow up entitled to expect they will be fed by their parents. It's a real travesty that so many parents think, in the name of 'good manners', that they should be thanked for this - what unconditional love.

Bookworm20 · 10/06/2022 10:13

Anyway, is there anything more entitled than expecting recognition and thanks for doing something that is expected of you as an adult and in your role as a parent?

Well I've raised 5 dc, 4 now in mid/late teens and none of them are entitled arseholes. They are polite, independent and decent human beings who any parent would proud of. So you do you, and I'll do me. I simply believe that teaching manners in the home carries forward to other situations they will find themselves in.

The irony in your use of the word entitled. You see, i'd consider someone who ate food someone else had prepared and cooked and didn't say thank you (and were sat on their phone no less) as entitled. But there you go. Different views.

Rosebel · 10/06/2022 10:00

IFeelItInMyFingersIFeelItInMy · 10/06/2022 09:49

Saying thanks doesn't mean they won't be entitled arseholes. Just because they don't say thanks to you doesn't mean they aren't incredibly polite and well-mannered to everyone else they meet.

It basically sounds like there is no genuine love or gratitude in most of the posters' families on this thread. They value this bizarre notion/gesture of saying 'thanks' to apparently 'teach' manners within the family which creates a barrier of formality. Even then, if they don't say thanks, it has to be drawn out so it's contrived.

Saying thanks creates a barrier of formality??!! That's the most weird thing I've ever read on here.
So because we should buy a gift for a child's birthday they don't have to say thanks, even if it's something they really like? And yes it is similar to saying thanks if someone has cooked something you enjoy because both are things as a parent you should do
No wonder some children grow up so entitled.

Vivi0 · 10/06/2022 09:57

Of course we have to feed our kids. And yes I do cook for my dc enjoyment. I make things they like, and other days things we like. And then theres feeding a child any old crap (to keep them alive as you put it) and actually taking time to cook a nice meal. When the dc cook, I say thank you. I don't expect them to be grateful for every single thing I do for them, or even every meal if its not their favourite things, but I do expect them to have manners.

I’m not “feeding a child any old crap” I’m “taking time to cook a nice meal” - cooking martyr!

Its called not raising entitled arseholes.

It’s entirely reasonable for a child to have an expectation that mummy will do for them the things they cannot do for themselves. It’s not the lack of eternal gratitude that makes them entitled, it’s when mummy (or daddy) don’t show them how to do these things for themselves at the appropriate age.

Anyway, is there anything more entitled than expecting recognition and thanks for doing something that is expected of you as an adult and in your role as a parent?

IFeelItInMyFingersIFeelItInMy · 10/06/2022 09:49

Bookworm20 · 10/06/2022 09:40

But cooking for your children isn’t optional. You don’t cook for your children’s enjoyment, you cook to keep them alive. And anyone who is caring for a child, should be feeding them.

Of course we have to feed our kids. And yes I do cook for my dc enjoyment. I make things they like, and other days things we like. And then theres feeding a child any old crap (to keep them alive as you put it) and actually taking time to cook a nice meal. When the dc cook, I say thank you. I don't expect them to be grateful for every single thing I do for them, or even every meal if its not their favourite things, but I do expect them to have manners.

Why should kids be thanking adults for doing something they’re supposed to do?

Its called not raising entitled arseholes.

Saying thanks doesn't mean they won't be entitled arseholes. Just because they don't say thanks to you doesn't mean they aren't incredibly polite and well-mannered to everyone else they meet.

It basically sounds like there is no genuine love or gratitude in most of the posters' families on this thread. They value this bizarre notion/gesture of saying 'thanks' to apparently 'teach' manners within the family which creates a barrier of formality. Even then, if they don't say thanks, it has to be drawn out so it's contrived.

IFeelItInMyFingersIFeelItInMy · 10/06/2022 09:41

builds goodwill.

You shouldn't need to build goodwill with your family.

My dad and my older siblings turned it into a game to see who could say thank you first for the rest of my childhood.

So basically it was meaningless/seen as a game.

I’m not apologising for teaching my children to say thankyou when someone has taken time from their day to do something for them to enjoy, no matter who that is or what the meal is.

'Someone' - you're their bloody parent. It's your job.

in fact the other day dd (15) had a friend over and while we were eating she said ‘thankyou for dinner, this is lovely’. I didn’t think ‘oh yay, go me’ and I wouldn’t have been offended if she’d said nothing. But I simply thought, what a lovely well mannered girl.

I mean clearly in this situation it is fair to consider her ill mannered had she not said 'thank you'. You're not her mum, you're not responsible for her and you have cooked her dinner - it would be polite to say 'thanks'.

Bookworm20 · 10/06/2022 09:40

But cooking for your children isn’t optional. You don’t cook for your children’s enjoyment, you cook to keep them alive. And anyone who is caring for a child, should be feeding them.

Of course we have to feed our kids. And yes I do cook for my dc enjoyment. I make things they like, and other days things we like. And then theres feeding a child any old crap (to keep them alive as you put it) and actually taking time to cook a nice meal. When the dc cook, I say thank you. I don't expect them to be grateful for every single thing I do for them, or even every meal if its not their favourite things, but I do expect them to have manners.

Why should kids be thanking adults for doing something they’re supposed to do?

Its called not raising entitled arseholes.

Vivi0 · 10/06/2022 09:05

I’m not apologising for teaching my children to say thankyou when someone has taken time from their day to do something for them to enjoy, no matter who that is or what the meal is.

But cooking for your children isn’t optional. You don’t cook for your children’s enjoyment, you cook to keep them alive. And anyone who is caring for a child, should be feeding them. Why should kids be thanking adults for doing something they’re supposed to do?

Thanking a woman for cooking a meal for the family seems like a relic of past days when the “man of the house”, who knew he had free rein to do whatever he wanted, would do his bit for the day to keep his wife happy by thanking her for preparing the meal, in a tone which instructed the children to do the same.

It seems really rigid and outdated. If the adults in the house are sharing the load and doing their bit, then there should be no need for it. I get that a bad day can cause us to feel under appreciated, but appreciation needs to be mutual and you can’t expect it without giving it back.

Cooking really turns people into martyrs. “Look at what I’m doing for you, you better thank me” as if no one else’s contribution to the household is as important.

Bookworm20 · 10/06/2022 08:50

I don’t get those saying it’s just a normal household task so why say thank you. Cooking a nice meal takes planning, prep, effort and thought has to go into it.
it takes no thought or prep to clean a toilet, dust the lounge, hoover a floor. It’s the same thing over and over.
cooking is different everyday and requires thought and mental effort.
maybe we’re weird then, but I’m not apologising for teaching my children to say thankyou when someone has taken time from their day to do something for them to enjoy, no matter who that is or what the meal is.
in fact the other day dd (15) had a friend over and while we were eating she said ‘thankyou for dinner, this is lovely’. I didn’t think ‘oh yay, go me’ and I wouldn’t have been offended if she’d said nothing. But I simply thought, what a lovely well mannered girl.

MarmaRell78 · 10/06/2022 08:39

@Rosebel yes I wouldn't expect thanks for each washing because it's really not any hassle, but quite a lot of thought goes into meal planning, shopping and cooking meals that the whole family will eat

OP posts:
IDreamOfTheMoors · 10/06/2022 07:30

ABSOLUTELY YANBU.

When I was little, I told my mum her dinner was very good and thank you.
She said “well, at least someone in her family appreciated it.”
My dad and my older siblings turned it into a game to see who could say thank you first for the rest of my childhood.

bloodyunicorns · 10/06/2022 07:25

We always thank each other for cooking. Or for doing other household chores. It's polite and builds goodwill.

Rosebel · 10/06/2022 07:20

How can someone who teaches manners and for others to be grateful be rude?
It's nice to thank someone when they do something for you, whatever it is.
IMIO cooking is more effort than lots of other things though. Chucking washing on for example is a 2 second job, cooking is every day for at least 30 minutes at least once a day.

Swipe left for the next trending thread