Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Examples of Wrongly Being Told There Was Nothing Wrong By The NHS

307 replies

Westover · 08/06/2022 18:10

Interested in examples of this, as it appears to be a growing trend to be fobbed off, sometimes repeatedly by a GP, and told there is nothing seriously wrong when there is an issue requiring treatment. I'm also wondering if it is bad in other countries. In my case:

  • Developed what turned out to be pneumonia. 2 initial visits to the GP, first visit told there was nothing wrong and it was just a virus and couldn't be treated, second visit a few days later and was diagnosed with a kidney infection and given antibiotics appropriate to that. Ended up collapsing at home that weekend, ambulance called, taken to hospital, chest x ray and diagnosed with pneumonia. Was given penicillin. Unfortunately, it turned out to be a penicillin-resistant strain and so felt increasingly terrible over the next week. Managed to persuade my GP to give me an emergency appointment (this was pre-Covid), during which he barely looked at me and took a lengthy phone call before dismissing me, telling me that the antibiotics took time to work. Phoned 111 the next day and was given an appointment at a local health clinic who sent me back to hospital, where I was admitted for 4 days and put on intravenous antibiotics.
  • Fell while out running and slightly dislocated my kneecap (as diagnosed by my GP). A week later, felt a sharp pain and was unable to bear weight after that. After being phone triaged, eventually got an appointment with NHS physio some weeks later where I was x- rayed, told there was nothing wrong with it and told I was being lazy and there was no reason I couldn't exercise and I should be walking properly and not using crutches (I have never been lazy in my life!). Went back 2 months later as it was worse and was told the same again by a clearly even less interested physio. Refused an MRI scan. Paid for a private MRI scan, which showed a stress fracture. My knee is now severely damaged as a result of not resting it for 5 months after it occurred.
  • Fell off my bike and got a bad cut which caused scarring to develop on my face. At A&E where it was initially treated, I was told by the consultant that I should refer for possibly laser treatment or to have the scar revised once a year had passed. GP happily did this and in the consultation, I was told that "the best option" was to have psychiatric counselling to help me "get used to the change in my appearance". I wrote a stinker of a letter back saying that I would not be taking up that option as I wasn't that bothered by it but I had been advised to get further revision surgery by a consultant. I then moved house, got another consultation elsewhere and was given laser treatment to revise it which was successful.
OP posts:
Lickerz · 09/06/2022 13:22

maddening · 09/06/2022 00:24

These are reasons that gps will be automated, there is AI that is already much more accurate at diagnosis.

Yes! My husband was telling me about a study that found an AI system (where the patient inputs their symptoms into a computer) was much more accurate than a GP diagnosis. It was even more accurate than the AI plus GP input (i.e. patient inputting their symptoms into the computer with the GP adding their thoughts in too). The GP adding their input made the computer system less accurate, not more!

Oligodendrocyte · 09/06/2022 13:14

@Odessafile accountability for a start. The people who failed to diagnose niece 1 with her tumour, berated my sister for being PFB. That niece almost died, because of their dismissal.

The people who accused my BIL of beating niece 2, because he's got a shaved head and tattoos, refusing to do her blood tests because even though she had every single symptom of leukemia - thought they knew better.

Well, how many more people have they dismissed? I could not speak to my patients the way medics do. I could not fuck up so royally, that killed people, and blythly carry on doing my job with no repercussion and certainly no apology.

People need to take accountability for their health too, and stop wasting time for things they could get at the pharmacy. They could pay, if affordable, for private osteotherapy and physiotherapy for their MSK pain, when all they'd get from the Dr is pain relief. The systems in the NHS are not fit for purpose.

Most of all, it's attitude in my experience, and that costs nothing to change.

thesunwillout · 09/06/2022 13:06

Ruptured brain aneurysm.

Very dangerous.
Lucky to be here at all.
😬

JasmineFlowering · 09/06/2022 13:04

Both hospital births I had I got raging thrush immediately after the babes were born.
With dd2 they refused to give me any medication until the swab results came back in two days. I was writhing in agony before the two days was up. I tried another mw who grudgingly agreed to check me out. She recoiled with a shocked look on her face after seeing what my poor vulva looked like. She speed walked off to get me the pessary and cream. Took days before I could pee without sobbing because I'd made such a mess whilst scratching in my sleep.
I also ended up with sore hands because I was so paranoid about passing it to my baby that I was obsessively hand washing.
I know it's nowhere near as bad as some of the other posts though.

BorisJohnsonsvomitbucket · 09/06/2022 12:59

I agree with the point made about arrogance and misogyny. My mum discovered she had fibroids, but at that stage hadn't gone through the menopause. (This was about 15 years ago, mum was in her late 40s) After the male gynae in his older years told her the diagnosis he said without any discussion that he'd set up a hysterectomy. My mum said, now hang on, what other options are there? He said there wasn't any. Mum wasn't having it. She knew he wasn't telling her something. Had a feeling. She asked if she could be referred to another specialist. He was horrible to her. Telling her he'd been in the field for many years and he knew what he was talking about. My mother gave as good as she got, saying, you haven't even discussed how I feel about surgery, what would happen if I refused, what the long term consequences of that would be. You just flat-out without discussion want to whip it out. He was testy, like the "little woman" was challenging him. My mum said, no, she'll go and look into other treatment options.

She went back to the GP and he did some research on the subject. He discovered that if she could put up with the symptoms they would probably disappear after menopause. And they did! But the man was so arrogant, and so dismissive of my mum, she has been wary of asking to be referred to anyone since.

I have had various experiences of specialist care and I have to say misogyny and arrogance has in every case impeded my treatment. I know this has been written about and some research has been done but that is the culture of the NHS. My daughter had to attend an assessment at a children's centre at about 12 months old because she was developmentally delayed as a premature baby. The doctor assessing her was horrible, making assumptions about her, her dad and I because of the occupations were were in (manual workers). He basically said DD wouldn't amount to much and would continue to be delayed because we were working-class. There was a follow-up appointment due and I flat-out refused to go. My HV got involved and asked why. I said because the doctor had been rude and dismissive and prejudiced. She put in the notes that I was a first-time mum and that I was being difficult, basically. Anyway DD had just started a private nursery by this point. Guess what? She caught up, then she thrived. But that doctor will live on in my memory as an absolute arrogant w*er. I wonder how many other kids he's written off because of his prejudices.

Wrongkindofovercoat · 09/06/2022 12:55

@Ozgirl75 isn't healthcare in Australia free, as in the same way it is free here , in that you pay for it via taxes ? Out of interest how much does your private health insurance cost you ?

IWishTheBishopWell · 09/06/2022 12:42

I first saw a doctor about suspected asthma in 1999, aged 11. Was told I didn't have asthma as a test of my lung function after some inhalers was 'just below' 12 and 12 or above indicated asthma.

I went to many GPs in my 20s saying I kept having shortness of breath and a tight chest and thought it might be asthma. I was told it wasn't as I 'don't wheeze' and 'it's not asthma without a wheeze'.

Diagnosed with asthma in 2018, aged 29 after my asthma was so bad on holiday I had to google how to say 'asthma attack' in Italian, just in case. I finally found a GP willing to refer me to an asthma nurse for an assessment.

I am now under an asthma consultant as my asthma is difficult to control. I have recently been declared CEV after needing several courses of steroids recently and am now eligible for Covid treatments.

I still don't wheeze.

AchatAVendre · 09/06/2022 10:13

These tragic stories read like something out of the third world.

I'm not originally from the UK and it absolutely blows my mind why a gp is the gatekeeper to all further treatment.

Because its a state-run system and therefore encourages collectivist, nanny-state led thinking and the patient is assumed to meet the lowest common denominator because thats what is most convenient for the state.

Everyone knows that the NHS is simply a healthcare system, amongst many in the world. There are many, many examples of better run European systems, but NHS defenders will shriek shrilly that the only alternative is the American system.

Everyone also knows that the NHS is woefully inefficient, prone to medical misogyny and writing off women in particular as having nothing wrong with them, mainly because theres very little accountability for getting things wrong.

The NHS also seems to produce an extremely large proportion of arrogant consultants, doctors, GPs and nurses who get things wrong but insist they are right. It seems to be characterised by brutality and a near pride in its insistence on "doing nothing" as some kind of magical panacea.

That is not to say there are not great examples of competent, dedicated, skilled workers within the NHS. But that isn't due to the NHS and its an outdated, inefficient system now.

I'm one of those people who looks very healthy no matter what hits them, and on at least 3 occasions when I have desperately needed antibiotics, I've been refused them because I "look too well to be [insert condition}. I've ended up going to a private GP or A&E to resolve what the GP shouldn't have fobbed off. I really don't have any faith in the NHS, its far too inconsistent depending on what day of the week you fall ill, the mood of the doctor, their caseload that day, their pre-conceptions, etc. A lot of mistakes occur due to lack of time.

Thinkingblonde · 09/06/2022 09:50

Not me but a woman I knew was having surgery on her back, she had a cannula in her wrist for fluids etc, during the operation a nurse noticed her hand was changing colour, it seemed swollen too, she alerted the anaesthetist and the surgeon, who asked the anaesthetist to check her cannula, reported back all was fine. The hand became even more discoloured. by this time nurse was getting increasingly concerned and checked the woman’s hand and pulse, the hand was cold and she couldn’t find a pulse in that wrist, the nurse told the surgeon who stopped the operation and checked for himself, he then went ballistic at the anaesthetist. The cannula hadn’t been inserted properly and the fluids had been going into the tissue stopping blood supply. A vascular surgeon was called for to try and repair the damage but it was too late to save her fingers, she lost all four fingers on that hand. The woman sued and the anaesthetist was struck off after investigations showed he’d cocked up other operations.
She was compensated but no amount could give her back what she’d lost.

LicoricePizza · 09/06/2022 09:50

My heart goes out to those who have been failed by a system (& some horrible individuals within it) that is supposed to protect us 💐. I have & continue to have my own struggles with disbelief, gaslighting & misdiagnosis. It’s institutional abuse. I agree with a pp - the nhs heroes rhetoric just helps the government justify gross underfunding & for negligent, abusive practise to continue to go under the radar.

loislovesstewie · 09/06/2022 09:49

Just to add, my family has also had exemplary service from all parts of the NHS. The problem, as others have said, is that when something goes wrong there is no apology forthcoming . Admitting a mistake is unlikely to cause a patient to take legal as most understand that errors happen, if they learnt and moved on we would be better, but some just won't do that.

IncompleteSenten · 09/06/2022 09:39

Staffy1 · 08/06/2022 22:03

I don’t understand attitudes like this. Have you read all these posts? They are horrifying. I don’t think the answer is to keep quiet or go on about how wonderful the health system is and how lucky we are to have it. It’s dire for many reasons, probably a lot to do with far too many patients per GP and pressure by the government not to spend too much, but whatever the reasons, it’s awful and it needs saying.

That is exactly what I was talking about.
This attitude that the NHS is perfect and any attempt to say otherwise is propaganda. Aka lies.

Pages and pages of awful experiences and it's 'propaganda' designed to pull down Saint NHS.

I suppose we're all russian bots or some such shit.

Odessafile · 09/06/2022 09:33

@Oligodendrocyte without minimising all these stories what's your solution ? Please don't just say it needs an overhaul. It's had numerous reorganisations over the years.
And if you use MN you can be reassured that nurses are not viewed as angels on here. Far from it.
Much of this is to do with poor training and communication skills, arrogance and cultural issues. Not to mention all the other problems like inadequate funding and lack of staff.

IncompleteSenten · 09/06/2022 09:23

The misdiagnosis is human error. It happens.
I could forgive that if it wasn't for the arrogance and the lying.

If they would hold up their hands and say I got it wrong. I am sorry. Then you could forgive human error.

But that rarely happens.
What mostly happens is you get treated like shit and lied to . They double down on their wrong DX and are offended that you dare to not be meek and grateful. Yes doctor thank you doctor whatever you say doctor I'll just go away and quietly die doctor so sorry to be a bother doctor.

I sued over what the Dr did to my son (pulled his head and caused nerve damage instead of performing the mcroberts manoeuvre) and the hospital lied, altered notes and were just awful.

Thankfully they were as incompetent at their cover up as they were at his birth and I won and my son was awarded £300,000 for what they did to him.

I could have sued for myself too but I didn't. I didn't want money for me . I wanted an apology. My lawyer laughed in my face.

My younger son was very unwell. I tried for 3 years to get help. I was fobbed off at every turn. Eventually the Dr snapped at me and my husband that she'd organise blood tests but it would be a waste of time and distress him etc (he has add and ADHD).

He had the tests.

Severely, severely anaemic.

Here's the part that makes me particularly angry. The doctor who was so foul to us - never saw her again. She was still at the surgery but she clearly told reception to not book appointments with her for us.
Because she did not want to have to face us.

nolongersurprised · 09/06/2022 09:10

You don’t get rheumatoid arthritis after Scarlett fever, it’s rheumatic heart disease

It’s not just Scarlett fever, it’s any strep A infection so can get after pharyngitis and tonsillitis. But - most of these are viral, especially in pre schoolers and the damage to hearts, kidneys etc isn’t from the toxin itself but from immune complex deposition.

So - in practice - if a child has a sore throat AND that is die to step A a doctor has 7-10 days to treat it to prevent kidney/heart complications.

best practice in a pre schooler is to swab and treat only if culture grows group A strep (it usually doesn’t)

ChocolateAndT · 09/06/2022 08:41

We also had issues with ASD diagnosis- 4 referrals just rejected even though I already had 2 dc diagnosed with ASD.

We had to go privately in the end as nobody would help. The speech therapist was even fed up as she kept referring and they got rejected

loislovesstewie · 09/06/2022 08:41

Oh, and with my first successful pregnancy ,( after 3 miscarriages) I bled constantly. Back and forth to GP's and constantly being told that there was nothing wrong, getting through several pads per day, eventually I presented myself at hospital after bleeding horrendously and still being told I was OK by the GP. The consultant arrived and admitted me, when I could eventually be examined properly it was found I had a cervical erosion. The consultant asked me about how many times I had been to the GP, and who was my GP? When I told him, he actually said ' Oh her, she's useless'.

WiseRobin · 09/06/2022 08:23

Some of these stories are shocking!

Mine seems relatively tame compared to many of yours.

I was passing many loose stools containing blood and mucus, throughout the day. GP examined me and told me I had piles and sent me away with a prescription for suppositories.

Two weeks later and still as bad, back to GP who referred me for a colonoscopy, she told me they would probably be able to ‘tie’ or whatever they do to piles while examining me.

Imagine my shock when after the colonoscopy I was given a diagnosis of Crohn’s disease, absolutely no sign of piles, none whatsoever!

The GP did apologise!

I’m just thankful that this happened in a short space of time and that at least I was referred for a colonoscopy, I know many people have suffered for years before being diagnosed.

Oligodendrocyte · 09/06/2022 08:11

FangsForTheMemory · 08/06/2022 20:40

Misdiagnosis by medical people isn't specific to the NHS though. There are many dreadful cases on here - but I take issue with the blame being placed on the NHS as an organisation.

For the majority of people, they use the NHS, so anyone wrongly diagnosing them, will likely be an NHS worker.

I take offence to people claiming the NHS is great, and it's workers are heroes. It's not, and nor are a lot of its staff.

Not in my case they aren't. My long list is just a fraction of the incompetence experienced from a plethora of GPs, doctors and consultants.

Humans are not infallible, and mistakes happen. However in my case, most of the medics, had superior attitudes that they knew best. Except they didn't, and it's killed people, rendered me infertile, and ruined 2 kids lives, who are still having chemotherapy.

StickyFingeredWeeNed · 09/06/2022 08:02

My fasting blood glucose is regularly over 8 and I struggle to get it below 6. My GP recently asked the nurse to take blood “to put my mind at ease”. Apparently glucose levels of 8 aren’t anything to worry about.

every single piece of literature I can come across suggests pre-diabetes.

my mum lived for nearly 50 years with type I so I’m reasonably clued up about diabetes.

sooner or later I’ll collapse (again) - had a hypo IN hospital and hit the deck when I took DD in for something else.

Thinkingblonde · 09/06/2022 07:15

P.S re: Scarlet fever, other possible long term complications include kidney damage, rheumatoid arthritis and two others that I can’t recall.
Im not sure if I’ve had it, I was quite ill once with an ear infection, I was hospitalised for two weeks on IV antibiotics, the first time I’d ever had AB’s, I developed a rash on my face and upper body, after a couple of days the rash faded but my hands a feet felt like they were on fire if I put them into water, the skin peeled of my hands and feet like a glove, leaving the skin red. I was about ten. The doctor said I was a allergic to penicillin but reading about the symptoms of Scarlet fever am I allergic to it? Or did I have SF? I’ve never had penicillin since, which can be a pain at times as in certain infections it works more effectively than other AB’s. I am not going to risk it though, to test my theory.

PrivateHall · 09/06/2022 07:14

mummabear18 · 08/06/2022 20:59

It’s not a lack of funding, it’s mismanagement of funding and pure waste.
I found out recently that every pair of stainless steel scissors they cut the umbilical cord with is just thrown straight in the bin. Back in the day these things would have been sterilised and reused, now they’re just thrown out and new ones are bought.

It is actually cheaper to buy new. The sterilising departments cost a fortune to run - paying staff to work day and night, scrub the instruments with special solutions, maintain the sterilising unit, package the instruments up in sterile wrap, deliver to wards. This costs more than a huge factory mass-producing new items.

loislovesstewie · 09/06/2022 07:08

I was told I wasn't in labour. I was told I could go home; I said no chance . I was allowed to stay, but if I hadn't given birth by the morning, they were going to be cross. I gave birth that evening, no-one checked me until I advised that I needed to push. Apparently no-one had heard of a pregnant woman giving birth having only had a bit of a backache. Odd because I knew several women who had done just that.

QuebecBagnet · 09/06/2022 07:06

I had an ongoing leg problem and after months had an mri. Had an appt where they were like oh your mri looks quite normal. Asked for a print off of my mri report and sat in the car park reading it and it said my fibula was broken! I went to another hospital who put me in a plaster cast. When I had surgery to fix the leg my tendon was torn in two as well, which I’d told them it felt like it was, the initial mri interpreter had said it was torn but the hospItal consultant had disagreed. It’s still not properly fixed as the tendon dislocates but the consultant doesn’t believe me.

Phillipa12 · 09/06/2022 07:04

Not quite a wrong diagnosis but an abrupt a and e Dr who just thought I was an anxious mum. Took dc3, age 3 to a and e one night as he was very unwell, Dr examined him and said viral infection. Whilst I was explaining all his symptoms and that they were identical to dc2's he just quipped that her illness was incredibly rare, she had strep A bacterial pneumonia. He did a more thorough examination when I said that even though dc2's illness was rare she was still dead because of the illness and the resulting sepsis. Turned out dc3 had a nasty urine infection.....