Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Be honest about DC screentime

58 replies

springhassprung22 · 08/06/2022 16:06

I have two DC, 7 and 3. The youngest doesn't sit and watch TV for long so isn't a problem.

My eldest, lately, seems to be developing an addiction to TV. He doesn't have it in the morning before school, and our mornings are definitely easier as a result. After school he is allowed to watch it to unwind, especially as I WFH so if I collect him, I am then working for an hour or so (younger DC is in nursery). He does after school activities on two weekdays so it's limited to about 45 minutes maximum on those days but on the other days he can have up to 1.5 hours, maybe even 2 at a push.

His listening has gone really downhill recently so I've implemented a TV reward chart, a basic amount of 30 minutes TV a day, and the opportunity to win or lose some depending on listening. Yesterday he had won extra so had 50 minutes, but on Monday he'd lost it all so had none.

On Monday he whined and whined without it but after a while went off to play happily with his sibling. He managed to win 10 minutes which he watched before bed.

Yesterday after the 50 minutes, he turns it off with little fuss, but then asks to watch more and more later: "just a little bit pleeeeeeasseee". It's like an addiction at the moment in a way it didn't used to be!

I think it might be the stuff he watches (strictly no Youtube but has free reign of Kids' Netflix/Prime etc so watches rubbish cartoons a lot) so I'm torn whether to try an all out ban, or maybe limit to less trashy stuff eg CBBC.

In reality how much do your kids have? And does it impact behaviour? The only other screen my DS has is a Kindle Fire tablet which he's allowed to play on the weekends, it's only ever about 30-40 minutes a day though. He mostly plays Sonic on that.

OP posts:
ChewOnAPickle · 08/06/2022 17:10

I think I wouldn't do the increase or decrease in time, that way it is consistent that he gets 30 minutes and you address the not listening issue another way. You are framing the tv as a reward and so he sees it that way.

Any more asking for the tv once it is switched off just results in a flat no and a reminder that you will not change your mind and stick to it.

There are lots of other activities he could be doing, make a list together so that he can refer to it rather than thinking it up for himself. It can be difficult to play alone as his sibling gets older this will become easier hopefully, mine have a 3 year gap and are the best of friends (now 19 and 16 years old.)

We had 2 no tech days in our house but that was when both children were on the same schedule and both at school. We did Tuesdays and Thursdays. On the other days we did allow a lot more tv that you are allowing but we controlled what they watched, so lots of fun educational stuff but I am a SAHM so was able to monitor everything they watched. But we had set times for tech so they knew once that time was over it was done for the day.

Pawtucketbrew · 08/06/2022 17:10

No restrictions on DD 9 except YouTube as there is so much inappropriate content. YouTube kids ok. She has enough activities in the week and weekends that I feel she has a good balance. We both use devices to unwind. I can't see that it is detrimental to her behaviour or academic learning. If I did I would consider settings limits.

Kanaloa · 08/06/2022 17:04

My 11 & 10 & 6year olds don’t game at all/don’t have any video game type things but they can watch TV when they want. We have a lot of activities (especially the older two who do quite intensive hobbies/sports) so basically we rarely have time in the week. At the weekend they watch as much telly as they like outside of matches and classes and things, but again they do tend to be going with friends/playing with friends/doing other things too so it’s just when they have time. My 8yo watches a little bit more TV especially superhero films and TV and documentaries about certain topics.

It doesn’t seem to affect their behaviour. They watch telly and do other things. We don’t make a big thing of ‘winning’ or ‘losing’ TV time. I watch programmes with them too and we chat about them. It’s nice. In my opinion parenting, environment, and personality are what determines behaviour really.

Metalandtea · 08/06/2022 16:58

Apart from restricting the use of kids YouTube and the awful toy unboxing videos we don’t restrict screens and never have. My children will look up educational content often without pushing from me- I think in part because they know they aren’t limited. They have tvs in their rooms and switches etc yet are well rounded, with good social skills and vocabulary. They will also just do non-screen things out of choice, probably because we don’t make a big thing out of it.

CatDogMonkeyPOW · 08/06/2022 16:54

DD6 isn't ever bothered by it and would rather draw.

DS9 has it in the mornings before school providing he is up, dressed, bed made, curtains opened, eaten breakfast etc. Basically ready for school.

After school he has clubs three times a week and on those nights he's not home until 5pm He has screen time after school / clubs providing he has done his homework until dinner which is about 6pm. So about an hour on club nights and 2 hours on non club nights.

No screen time after dinner, except ok Fridays when we have family movie night all together.

Weekends: Saturday morning from when he gets up until he goes to a club at 10am. And then none until 4pm. Again no screens after dinner.

Sunday: iPad free day but he can watch TV. Normally in the morning till we all get up and have breakfast around 9. Then again at 4pm until dinner time.

I'm more lax in the holidays though, it has to be said. We definitely struggle with him consistently wanting more, but he's an avid reader, well above his reading age and has read 100s of novels so I'm not too worried. I do think it impacts his behaviour though, he's more irritable etc with screen time. I flipping hate YouTube so we limit how much of that he can watch and he can only watch it on the family TV so we know what he's watching.

I don't know what the right answer is. You will get a wide range of responses here and probably very few from parents who let their kids have free reign because they know they will get slated on here.

I think all you can do is tweak the rules you have until you find a nice balance that works for your family.

Findahouse21 · 08/06/2022 16:53

7 year old dd watches YouTube (mostly drawing videos) and Disney plus. She has no lmset limits but we will tell her to get up and shift if it's been too long. Most weekdays she won't watch any - it does really help to have screen free areas for her and her younger sister to play in but I know we are very privileged to have the option of additional space downstairs to do so.

Cherryblossom42 · 08/06/2022 16:50

My 7YO and 9YO have their own television in their bedroom. They also have an Nintendo switch each.

They're both currently outside on the trampoline through their own choice. (I know it's very common to have a trampoline!). They are generally mild mannered children.

KingofLoss · 08/06/2022 16:42

Until he was two he had none. Well, technically some, twice he watched TV for a couple hours when I was really poorly and had no help, but other than those two days it was none.

Once he was 2 and a few months we introduced a bit, maybe 20m a couple times per week.

If he's showing signs of addiction that's even more reason to reduce how much he's watching. When you say his 'listening' though, what do you mean? Listening to you?

Swipe left for the next trending thread