Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Be honest about DC screentime

58 replies

springhassprung22 · 08/06/2022 16:06

I have two DC, 7 and 3. The youngest doesn't sit and watch TV for long so isn't a problem.

My eldest, lately, seems to be developing an addiction to TV. He doesn't have it in the morning before school, and our mornings are definitely easier as a result. After school he is allowed to watch it to unwind, especially as I WFH so if I collect him, I am then working for an hour or so (younger DC is in nursery). He does after school activities on two weekdays so it's limited to about 45 minutes maximum on those days but on the other days he can have up to 1.5 hours, maybe even 2 at a push.

His listening has gone really downhill recently so I've implemented a TV reward chart, a basic amount of 30 minutes TV a day, and the opportunity to win or lose some depending on listening. Yesterday he had won extra so had 50 minutes, but on Monday he'd lost it all so had none.

On Monday he whined and whined without it but after a while went off to play happily with his sibling. He managed to win 10 minutes which he watched before bed.

Yesterday after the 50 minutes, he turns it off with little fuss, but then asks to watch more and more later: "just a little bit pleeeeeeasseee". It's like an addiction at the moment in a way it didn't used to be!

I think it might be the stuff he watches (strictly no Youtube but has free reign of Kids' Netflix/Prime etc so watches rubbish cartoons a lot) so I'm torn whether to try an all out ban, or maybe limit to less trashy stuff eg CBBC.

In reality how much do your kids have? And does it impact behaviour? The only other screen my DS has is a Kindle Fire tablet which he's allowed to play on the weekends, it's only ever about 30-40 minutes a day though. He mostly plays Sonic on that.

OP posts:
towelsa · 08/06/2022 19:22

No limits here. They watch a lot of tv and a little tablet. They often play with lego or something while the tv is on.
They do however often spend hours playing together with no screens in sight so it varies. I have decided not to limit screens other than at bedtime. For some children limiting it means they watch all they can because they know it will get taken away. If they know they can have it whenever they want (within reason) then they may be more happy to put it down and walk away. We do watch more than other families but some of it is educational and my children sometimes use it as a way to regulate (as do I each evening!). It's not an argument I want to have if I can't see real harm.

Simonjt · 08/06/2022 19:04

The rule is 30 minutes a day in the week, in reality screw the rules I need to maintain my sanity.

frogswimming · 08/06/2022 18:58

One hour Nintendo per day. Less if naughty, more if they earn it or eg in an airport.

Tv as much as they want. There's only one by in playroom they share. They play together, watch tv, play in garden, go to their rooms to play etc. so they watch it on and off. I just turn it off if they're not listening. If I think they've watched too much I turn it off and send them off to play.

They don't have phones or iPads.

They are 11 and 9.

I don't think it affects their behaviour at all.

Kanaloa · 08/06/2022 18:45

What’s the point of 30 minutes TV time three times a week for a thirteen year old? It would take them a week to watch an episode of Stranger Things.

smileyworld · 08/06/2022 18:40

Also, just wanted to say so that I don't sound saintly... they are all book worms and we are outdoors a lot. Plus as there are four of them, there is a lot of socializing.
They also don't have screens at school, as the school is a non screen school. (I work in the school).
The DC are just not used to it.

smileyworld · 08/06/2022 18:37

My 4DC are allowed 30 mins screen time in a Wednesday, Saturday and a Sunday. This includes switch time, they decide if it is tv or games.

However, we are often out on a weekend and don't have time on a Wednesday, (not in the UK, no school on Wednesday afternoons) so it's actually rare that they have it.

We do sometimes have a family film night on a Saturday, maybe once every 4/6 weeks?

They definitely have their maximum screen time on rainy weekends, but thankfully we don't have many of those except November.
I am trying to think the last time the tv was on, and it's been over two weeks?

My DC are 13, 12, 9 & 7.

BlackandBlueBird · 08/06/2022 18:15

Like a pp we instigated tech free days. I find it way easier to say ‘we don’t watch Tv on Monday or Tuesday’ and they accept it better. It’s actually my 3yo who’s the worst! DD8 will barely ever watch, the DS6 loves it but is also fine with being told no but DS3 asks and asks unless it’s very clear cut.

As for timing on the other days - the boys watch about an hour on a Weds & Thurs, we usually watch a film together on a Friday night, and then they rarely have it at the weekend but I don’t mind them watching another film on one of the weekend days. No tablets or any other devices.

Generally I’d say having certain no TV days work well if you are worried. The amount he gets doesn’t sound at all extreme though!

GlisteningGoldGrasses · 08/06/2022 17:59

Unlimited except it goes off an hour before bedtime. We make a point of it being the boring option, it's never used as a reward. DC10 watches art techniques, baking shows, horrible histories etc. My younger one watches more imaginative story series and then spends hours acting them out and playing imaginary games, sometimes with the video playing in the background, sometimes off. Most of the time they're out of the house so I'm not at all bothered about them watching their favourite things when they get home. They regularly get bored with it and choose to do other things.

PizzaPatel · 08/06/2022 17:57

We have no tv in the morning, no iPads or phones but after he’s home from childcare he can watch til dinner. That’s sometimes 15 minutes and sometimes 1.5 hours.

on weekends I try not to let him watch in the morning because it makes him so grumpy but DP isn’t really on board so we’re not consistent with that. We have nicer weekends when he doesn’t watch tv in the morning.

id say he watches 1-2 hours (sometimes more) at the weekend. I find after about 1hr he starts to play and stops watching so I don’t mind.

ChocolateHippo · 08/06/2022 17:56

I don't really monitor screen-time for my DC. I take the approach of adding things into his day - getting out of the house, activities, crafts, building things or just more playing with toys or in the garden - if I think he's getting too much screen time or he's becoming fixated on it. But he doesn't find it particularly addictive, he prefers doing active things and socialising and it doesn't seem to affect his behaviour. If I had a child who made a fuss when screens were turned off or who preferred it to other things, I would take a different approach.

Oblomov22 · 08/06/2022 17:55

Both ds's a lot. They liked tv, it suited me when they were toddlers for them to watch it as I was prepping dinner etc. Then they've had x box. Hours and hours of fun. All day sometimes. They also play sports and meet with friends. None of it has ever been an issue.

EsmeeMerlin · 08/06/2022 17:52

DS1 is 8 and tbh I don't keep track of how much TV he watches. He is at school all day, does 5 after school clubs and on nice days like today he plays in the playground that is literally outside ours with his friends. He is a very active child who does his guitar practice and homework so if he then wants to relax in front on the TV then he is welcome to do so.

DS2 is 4 and is a little more for the TV but again he goes to nursery every afternoon, will often play in the playground after nursery and attends 3 morning playgroups a week so it all balances out I figure.

Paddingtonthebear · 08/06/2022 17:48

9yr old has restrictions on tablet time but less so on tv. We are not popular for the tablet restrictions and parental control but it’s for their own good really and we try to encourage balance.

gracelessladyhottramp · 08/06/2022 17:47

My oldest is able to self regulate and is fine. My youngest can't self regulate at all ... I think he was addicted. First thing he asked for in the mornings etc. We stopped screens altogether earlier this year and his behaviour has been so much better. Family life in general has been more peaceful. I think it only takes a week or so and then they stop asking and find other ways to entertain themselves.

Walesscales · 08/06/2022 17:44

Our 7 year old has no limits on screen time because he's a hard worker at school, doing well in all his subjects and is a lovely kind happy boy so we don't see anything wrong with him choosing how he wants to spend his down time.

MassiveSalad22 · 08/06/2022 17:44

I’ve had success with adding things into his life rather than using screen time as a punishment or reward. So basically a lot of what I’m adding in involves me giving my attention too. I am definitely pro screen time - I use a shit ton of it to unwind myself - but it’s definitely detrimental sometimes to their mindset and listening and it can be a bit lonely.

So sometimes even watching something together yields as a happier child. Adding in things like - reading (DS is allowed pretty much unlimited books from Amazon), board games, playing in garden, more play dates, cooking etc. It’s exhausting though, but then at least you’ve done stuff together and then screen time isn’t so guilt-inducing so don’t feel so bad popping the TV on AFTER another activity. We have 100% banned YouTube (watching gamers) because that was horrific for his attitude. At least with consoles he’s actually using his brain (minecraft, animal crossing etc).

He has to be dressed and fed before he can have screens in the morning. He’s 7.

Little bro who’s 4 is a bit more of an addict with it (YouTube kids, absolute cesspool but I have a newborn and am mentally weak at the mo!). Really need to tackle that next! His attitude is not a problem yet though.

howoriginal · 08/06/2022 17:35

We aren't too strict about it, but do have limits. DS7 watches tv in the morning while having his breakfast - we have to get him to the school bus by 7:10 so we don't have much time in the mornings and he seems to eat quicker when watching tv. Don't know why! He has football 2 afternoons after school and a Spanish lesson on a Monday evening so I'm happy for him to watch TV/Youtube in the living room while I cook dinner after his activities. On the days he doesn't have after school activities he usually does some painting/reading/playing in his room and then his homework. He will have half an hour of TV before or after dinner, but most of the time he will turn off the TV and get on with whatever I've asked him to do without any strops - not always though. Sometimes he is on the iPad doing Duo Lingo or Reading Eggs which I don't mind as it's educational. At the weekend we are a lot more relaxed - he is usually out on playdates, at the park, on his bike or on a day out with us for a lot of the weekend, so when we're at home we're not all that restrictive about TV or the Switch. He's a bright boy, loves reading to himself in bed, gets plenty of exercise and is sociable, so I'm not at all concerned about his screen time.

Tigofigo · 08/06/2022 17:34

DC 6 and 9

No TV weekday mornings

They often watch an hour ish at weekends in morning, and we may watch a movie in the evening

They usually watch it 2/3 times a week after school for an hour

Then a couple of hours on tablet at weekend playing games.

We have 1 TV in our house, no consoles, 1 shared tablet.

In winter it may be more, in summer less, but I'd say 7-8 hours a week on average. It's more than I'd like, but I don't think it's excessive.

ILiveInSalemsLot · 08/06/2022 17:28

Mine watched quite a bit of tv. There are lots of really good educational programmes for that age as well as entertaining. As long as they're doing other things too, I think down time with the tv is ok.
Don't make it an issue as they will be more focused on this tv = reward thing.
Mine are teenagers now so I was more concerned about gaming and time on their phone. Getting them to sit with us to watch things together is a bonus these days! Thank goodness for Stranger Things and Marvel Grin

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 08/06/2022 17:22

She doesn't have it in the morning

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 08/06/2022 17:21

DD 9 has her own tv and switch in her room. She watches it after school (goes to after school club) but does come downstairs to lay the table feed the cat etc. she prob does have too much screen time but she does read later in the evenings and we're knackered in the evenings too or going to the gym, band practice etc so I don't think it's a major issue

Greaterthanthesumoftheparts · 08/06/2022 17:21

For us it’s all about balance. Usually DS4 is allowed 20 mins of TV before bed. He gets 2 episodes of Grizzy and the Lemmings (which is absolutely rediculous) followed by two episodes of number blocks which he’s really learnt a lot from.

this evening he’s having a bit more because he’s been in nursery all day (so I know he’s had a long walk, structured learning, crafts and unstructured play) and had a play date. He’s exhausted but I don’t want him in bed too early, so he’s having some extra TV time tonight.

Lolly86 · 08/06/2022 17:19

We don't really limit screen time for DD8. She has a tablet and plays on that or her switch (animal crossing) before school but also has her maths home work apps on her tablet which she also can do before school for maybe 30 mins or longer if she is up early. She does a lot of afterschool activities (dancing, swimming) and also plays a lot with barbies, sylvanian families etc, reads books, bikes, trampolines, dances around, watches films, YouTube or general TV. She has enough of a mix so I rarely set a limit. If I think she's been on it too long and she's getting a bit fixated at all I'll.nudge her off to do something else and she happily will.

ChuckBerrysBoots · 08/06/2022 17:16

Hours and hours. They’re fine.

mizzo · 08/06/2022 17:12

Metalandtea · 08/06/2022 16:58

Apart from restricting the use of kids YouTube and the awful toy unboxing videos we don’t restrict screens and never have. My children will look up educational content often without pushing from me- I think in part because they know they aren’t limited. They have tvs in their rooms and switches etc yet are well rounded, with good social skills and vocabulary. They will also just do non-screen things out of choice, probably because we don’t make a big thing out of it.

I think it's very much child dependent.
Two of my four will dip in and out of screen time, will almost always come off straight away when asked to, occasionally ask very politely can I just watch the last two mins or finish this bit, screens are just one of many things that they enjoy.
The other two would happily sit there all day, have to be asked repeatedly to turn off, will bargain and moan for more time, often get angry at being asked to come off whether they've been on for minutes or hours.
Our attitude to screens has been the same for all of them. Two just need tight restrictions.

Swipe left for the next trending thread