Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Be honest about DC screentime

58 replies

springhassprung22 · 08/06/2022 16:06

I have two DC, 7 and 3. The youngest doesn't sit and watch TV for long so isn't a problem.

My eldest, lately, seems to be developing an addiction to TV. He doesn't have it in the morning before school, and our mornings are definitely easier as a result. After school he is allowed to watch it to unwind, especially as I WFH so if I collect him, I am then working for an hour or so (younger DC is in nursery). He does after school activities on two weekdays so it's limited to about 45 minutes maximum on those days but on the other days he can have up to 1.5 hours, maybe even 2 at a push.

His listening has gone really downhill recently so I've implemented a TV reward chart, a basic amount of 30 minutes TV a day, and the opportunity to win or lose some depending on listening. Yesterday he had won extra so had 50 minutes, but on Monday he'd lost it all so had none.

On Monday he whined and whined without it but after a while went off to play happily with his sibling. He managed to win 10 minutes which he watched before bed.

Yesterday after the 50 minutes, he turns it off with little fuss, but then asks to watch more and more later: "just a little bit pleeeeeeasseee". It's like an addiction at the moment in a way it didn't used to be!

I think it might be the stuff he watches (strictly no Youtube but has free reign of Kids' Netflix/Prime etc so watches rubbish cartoons a lot) so I'm torn whether to try an all out ban, or maybe limit to less trashy stuff eg CBBC.

In reality how much do your kids have? And does it impact behaviour? The only other screen my DS has is a Kindle Fire tablet which he's allowed to play on the weekends, it's only ever about 30-40 minutes a day though. He mostly plays Sonic on that.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ChiefWiggumsBoy · 13/06/2022 10:16

I’ve never really put timescales on leisure activities. I will make them stop playing games if they’re getting frustrated - as I always say to them, games are meant to be fun! If we’re away from home they’re quite happy playing board games and stuff like that together (I have three, older than yours). It was only ever tablets that seemed to change their behaviour so I took them away.

Mine are much better at doing other stuff since we moved to a house with a garden and they can go out there.

Kanaloa · 13/06/2022 10:09

That’s what you seem to be missing - that I don’t understand the need for the announcement. If someone said ‘oh I’m just off for a glass of che’ and I’d never heard of it I wouldn’t feel the need to announce ‘I’ve never heard of that.’ I’d be able to use my reading comprehension to think ‘well they’re having a glass. It must be a drink.’

Kanaloa · 13/06/2022 10:07

I’m not saying everyone has to be interested in TV. I’m saying a dismissive comment like ‘I don’t know what that is,’ is pointless when the context of my post told you exactly what it is. It’s a TV show. That’s my point. Not that you have to have heard of Stranger Things - that you’re clearly trying to make some sort of big point of ‘oh I don’t even know what that is, I never watch TV.’ But if you had read my post you should have easily been able to comprehend that it was a TV programme. So what do you get out of announcing you don’t know what it is?

HistoricMoment · 13/06/2022 06:37

Kanaloa · 10/06/2022 17:20

You’ve never heard of the television show stranger things, the most streamed show in the world at the moment? Nobody has ever mentioned it to you and you’ve never heard of it before? You couldn’t understand contextually from my post saying ‘an episode of stranger things’ that it was a television programme? Then, when you had never heard of it and couldn’t comprehend from my post that it was a TV programme, you were incapable of Googling it to discover what it was?

Or you’re just desperate show how little you watch TV in the same smug vein as ‘my kids have never heard of Coca Cola!’

I have never heard of stranger things either and couldn't be arsed to Google it. You do realise not everyone is interested in TV?

oblada · 13/06/2022 06:32

TV massively impacts on behaviour in my experience. Negatively so.
I have 4 kids from 2 to 10. No TV during the week with the exception of an hour on Friday afternoon possibly watching a series they like (different series for my older girls and my younger 2. Usually the 2 yrs doesn't really stick around for it). At the weekend it's family movie time if we can fit it in. It can be once (one day) or both days (rarer) or none if no time. More common is once.
No other TV and I've found their behaviour much better for it (used to allow some TV before school, Sunday morning etc).
No other screen as they don't care for tablets etc. 5yrs old can play Osmo occasionally on the tablet but that's once a fortnight/once a month sort of thing.
Our tablets are otherwise used for movies during long drives (over 2hours).

YukoandHiro · 13/06/2022 06:26

My almost 5yo watches a bit more than your 7yo. None before school, like you it makes mornings easier.
I also use it for work time after school while younger DC is still at nursery. We have a play date or activity a couple o days a week.
On other days and on weekends if we're at home she's allowed to watch or play on the iPad. I have stopped using it as a reward or taking it away as a punishment as both have made her obsession with it worse, so that may be worth trying

smileyworld · 13/06/2022 06:21

Jeez @Kanaloa , you must be tons of fun at a party!

I don't know what to tell you beyond, before you mentioned Stranger Things, I had never, ever heard of it. My friends, family and colleagues have never mentioned it to me, I have never seen (or noticed, if you prefer) an advert relating to it... nothing, nada, zilch.

So, when you point out that it would take my DC a considerable amount of time to watch one episode of a show which I never ever heard of, and I reply 'I don't know what that is', I genuinely cannot understand why you find this so incredulous. Despite you saying it's the most streamed program, despite you saying almost everyone has heard of it... I still have no knowledge of it.

I am not virtue signaling, I am not being smug. I simply have never heard of it in any context before and so no, I didn't know what it was. (I have now googled and have seen that it is a Netflix show but I didn't read any additional information because I am simply not interested).

The thread asked for honesty. I gave it, without judgement.

You, however, are being unkind and pedantic.

Kanaloa · 12/06/2022 18:44

But presumably you did understand it was a television programme from the context, as the sentence mentioned episodes? So why did you feel the need to announce you didn’t know what it was when it was clear it was a TV show? Why did you need people to know you didn’t have a clue what it was?

violetindigopurple · 12/06/2022 18:09

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Kanaloa · 12/06/2022 09:39

Although thank you for being the mumsnet kindness police.

Kanaloa · 12/06/2022 09:39

I’m not being unkind 😂 just used to the weird smugness on mumsnet over never having heard of things almost everyone in the world has heard of. It’s silly. Either way most adults wouldn’t need to say ‘I’ve never heard of that’ because they could either understand contextually what it was or could look it up. There’s a weird snobbery on this site about not watching TV.

BlackandBlueBird · 12/06/2022 09:23

No need to be so unkind Kanaloa!

Kanaloa · 11/06/2022 23:55

smileyworld · 11/06/2022 21:48

@Kanaloa
Given that a) I don't live in the UK and b) as previously stated we are not interested....

But you carry on with your narrative. I'm off to read my book.

Of course you are. Presumably even not living in the UK if you have any level of reading comprehension you could have worked out from the context that if I’m mentioning ‘an episode’ of something it’s probably a TV show?

smileyworld · 11/06/2022 21:48

@Kanaloa
Given that a) I don't live in the UK and b) as previously stated we are not interested....

But you carry on with your narrative. I'm off to read my book.

ThatPosterIsSoRight · 10/06/2022 17:28

DC aged 11 had covid a couple of weeks ago. After 2 days spent puking he was better but still at home and rather tired, while DH and I worked (at home!). DH showed me his screen time report, and he’d spent 12 to14 hours a day on his PC for 3 days running…oops

Do I win?

Kanaloa · 10/06/2022 17:20

smileyworld · 10/06/2022 16:31

Don't know what Stranger things is? I also don't want much TV. We just aren't bothered about it.

You’ve never heard of the television show stranger things, the most streamed show in the world at the moment? Nobody has ever mentioned it to you and you’ve never heard of it before? You couldn’t understand contextually from my post saying ‘an episode of stranger things’ that it was a television programme? Then, when you had never heard of it and couldn’t comprehend from my post that it was a TV programme, you were incapable of Googling it to discover what it was?

Or you’re just desperate show how little you watch TV in the same smug vein as ‘my kids have never heard of Coca Cola!’

smileyworld · 10/06/2022 16:31

Kanaloa · 08/06/2022 18:45

What’s the point of 30 minutes TV time three times a week for a thirteen year old? It would take them a week to watch an episode of Stranger Things.

Don't know what Stranger things is? I also don't want much TV. We just aren't bothered about it.

Boomboompowpow · 08/06/2022 19:59

No devices in the morning, we watch tv together instead.devices allowed from 6.30-8pm and they usually max that out unless they can be persuaded outside. Ds 11 plays games online with his schoolfriends (they talk on zoom whilst playing) and dd 7 mostly watches YouTube kids. I have to say her vocab is excellent and she learns a lot from YouTube although she also watches a lot of crap. Not dissimilar to the 1980s when I watched kids tv.

My view with kids, for what it's worth, is that you put some rules around things and stick to them, but also teach them that they can make choices around how they apply those rules (eg just because you can have your device at 6.30pm doesn't mean you have to choose to do so).

No rules at weekends although they both have lost of sports, drama etc activities so plenty of device free time.

Kanaloa · 08/06/2022 19:56

My son is obsessed with the ocean/under the sea too. His idea of a good conversation is naming types of sharks and telling people killer whales aren’t whales. There are tons of kids documentaries if you have sky? Even many of the adult ones are okay for kids too.

Greenginghamdress · 08/06/2022 19:52

No real limits here. Sometimes she has hours and other days absolutely no ipad at all.
DD (4) is very very active and given the choice she'd rather be at the park playing with friends than any screen time.

springhassprung22 · 08/06/2022 19:44

Just to add academically my DS is doing fine - as mentioned his listening in school isn’t always the best but he isn’t naughty and is ahead on reading, writing and maths are fine. He reads well, enjoys reading, will sit and flip through books, comics etc. He also loves playgrounds, swimming, bikes, trampoline,
lots of outdoor activities.

But he loves TV. If he was given the straight out choice of something versus Tv, he would choose tv. I think part of it is the fact that he gets free reign over the remote, on the kids apps.

OP posts:
springhassprung22 · 08/06/2022 19:40

Thanks for all the replies.

Thanks to the posters who said using it as a reward might not be a good idea - never would’ve noticed that on my own but you’re right, he’s put it on a pedestal more since. Although I chose tv as the reward/punishment as he was so into it lately.

In terms of not listening, yes I mean not listening to me and DH (although he’s not a 100% listener in school either) - we always have to ask him so many times to do anything. Get dressed, shoes on etc. His attitude is up and down and at the moment it can be really cheeky, saying “no way” when asked to do something and occasionally “I don’t care” when told off so bringing in a reward chart was quite a big deal - haven’t used one for this DC in about 3 years!

I do want to be careful about being too strict as my own DM was VERY strict about TV, and none of my friends’ parents were so I felt the odd one out. I think we might start to limit content rather than amount on his non club nights. Weekends we also have it on more, in the morning especially. Both my DC will play nicely, it’s more the asking for the TV to begin with.

Any suggestions on content? DS likes educational stuff, under the sea/nature etc. I think we might try DH’s suggestion of a Netflix / Prime ban so his only options are the iPlayer app and Disney.

OP posts:
MarmiteOnToast · 08/06/2022 19:40

No restrictions here. Teen occasionally moans when told to come off gaming.
4yr old comes off when asked. I do normally say 5 minutes then off. That's for switch or tablet
2yr old if we're home and finished playing together and im getting on with choresor wfh (in same room lots can be done on mobile) has the tv on and flits between watching 5.min then play. To maybe an hr tv then play.
They never have an issue with turning it off or not having it on in the first place

pinkhipposgoswimming · 08/06/2022 19:36

One episode of something when getting dressed so maybe 10-15 mins in morning. Then 2 hours ipad / gaming after school. On Tuesday it's swimming night so only 1 hour.

The younger one sometimes has 30 mins to 1 hour in the morning, but I'm finding she doesn't need it now she's older. There was a period where she gave up napping, but was hysterical with tiredness and even reading books didn't help. So I'd put on one of the Julia Donaldson 30 minute movies like The Gruffalo.

At the weekend no morning Tv, as I insist on playing or audiobooks ( Tonies) !!! Then we do clubs, but probably 2 sessions of iPad so total 3 hours unless out for the day. But then if it's a long car drive to family I may have songs on or iPad one direction.

But so many friends have what appear strict rules and when you unpick they aren't. Things like no gaming before 9am but they at watching YouTube for 3 hours before that then gaming from 9am.

Or a friend saying her now teenager never has had a games console. But I remember her buying him a gaming computer ( like that's different !) I said I thought he played Robolux a bit and she oh yes he still does he loves it even now Hmm

CheapFoodShits · 08/06/2022 19:33

We have a "no games before school" rule but other than that I don't set limits for DS10. Now that he doesn't go on Fortnite with his friends he can self-regulate better and will often just have YouTube on for background noise while he plays. I have parental restrictions set up on YouTube and on his Switch, though. He's happy to spend time away from tech and go out to the park or anywhere really and he certainly doesn't struggle academically because of our lack of time limits.