Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think email isn't a secure way to share your passport etc

61 replies

nuvverfing · 08/06/2022 13:34

I have a virtual job interview next week, and the employer has asked me to email them my passport in advance, as well as showing it at the interview. They have referenced this Government guidance for identity checks: www.gov.uk/guidance/coronavirus-covid-19-right-to-work-checks#updated-advice-for-employers-carrying-out-right-to-work-checks-during-coronavirus-covid-19-adjusted-measures

Surely email isn't a secure way to share personal identity docs? I'm surprised the Government is encouraging it. I will do it, as I haven't been offered an alternative, but it feels uncomfortable. Just me?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EmmaH2022 · 15/06/2022 14:42

PerkingFaintly · 15/06/2022 13:25

Everything we were told not to do, we're suddenly being asked to do.

YES! This drives me potty.

I was recently dealing with a property maintenance company (part of a large estate agents, so not some one-man-band). Shortly afterwards, I received an email:
– from a company I'd never heard of <RED FLAG>
– instructing me to click on a link <RED FLAG>
– with the subject "Finance", so presumably asking me pay money or at least give my financial data on the link <RED FLAG>

It did mention my address and I was indeed expecting a bill from the maintenance co, so I phoned them to find out if it was connected. Oh yes, they said, we and the estate agent outsource all our payment stuff to this third-party accounting company.

So someone at a financial services company thinks it's smart to send out emails which look exactly like a scam email. If people within the financial field are behaving like this, and training the public to accept such emails as normal, we can hardly be surprised fraudsters are so successful.

I had similar with a text from my credit card company. I called them because I thought it was a scam and it was real!

i think it was total lack of professional standards. That seems rampant now.

EmmaH2022 · 15/06/2022 14:38

Wrong thread 🤦🏽‍♀️

EmmaH2022 · 15/06/2022 14:38

I increasingly wonder if the sellers believe it or just find it the easiest way for them to make money. Like many things online!

balalake · 15/06/2022 14:16

Have to agree OP, and I'd have second thoughts about whether or not I'd want to work for such a company. I'd propose calling into their offices and showing it to someone.

PerkingFaintly · 15/06/2022 13:25

Everything we were told not to do, we're suddenly being asked to do.

YES! This drives me potty.

I was recently dealing with a property maintenance company (part of a large estate agents, so not some one-man-band). Shortly afterwards, I received an email:
– from a company I'd never heard of <RED FLAG>
– instructing me to click on a link <RED FLAG>
– with the subject "Finance", so presumably asking me pay money or at least give my financial data on the link <RED FLAG>

It did mention my address and I was indeed expecting a bill from the maintenance co, so I phoned them to find out if it was connected. Oh yes, they said, we and the estate agent outsource all our payment stuff to this third-party accounting company.

So someone at a financial services company thinks it's smart to send out emails which look exactly like a scam email. If people within the financial field are behaving like this, and training the public to accept such emails as normal, we can hardly be surprised fraudsters are so successful.

SteggySawUs · 15/06/2022 13:00

There are apps specifically designed for sending personal information like this, our solicitor used one when we remortgaged last year and needed to verify our identity. I think it was called credas.

SerendipityJane · 15/06/2022 12:59

Unless you have 100% faith in the outfit you are sending the data to (which is impossible for me) then fretting over how you actually get the data to them in the first place seems a little ... illogical.

EmmaH2022 · 15/06/2022 12:57

PerkingFaintly · 15/06/2022 11:39

EmmaH2022 I don't use WhatsApp so I'm afraid can't comment on that.

I usually try to send photocopies of passport, etc, by post. I take the point by FarFarFarAndAway that something identifiable as a passport might be targeted by a thief within the Post Office, but an A4 photocopy is indistinguishable from any other letter. The exception might be when dealing with a large organisation where you don't know if the mail is opened by some random far from the recipient or even by an outsourced mail-processing service.

If I were ever forced to send a passport scan by email, I would send it as a password-protected document, as suggested by a PP, and then transmit the password separately NOT BY EMAIL. This will protect the document even at rest.

(I don't know how to set up password-protected docs: I'm still using dupes of the one set up by a friend to email me something sensitive. She works in IT in a secure environment, and this was her preferred method.)

Thank you
i'd just be worried they'd open it with the password and then save it on their system. The paper copy seems so much better.

DinoSphere · 15/06/2022 12:32

I find it maddening that apparently the passport is so vital a piece of identification that nothing can happen without it, but at the same time so little effort is made to keep this vital information secure!

You can verify a driving licence online with the DVLA, with the licence holder generating a check code, for when you hire a car. Seems we need something similar for passports.

PerkingFaintly · 15/06/2022 11:39

EmmaH2022 I don't use WhatsApp so I'm afraid can't comment on that.

I usually try to send photocopies of passport, etc, by post. I take the point by FarFarFarAndAway that something identifiable as a passport might be targeted by a thief within the Post Office, but an A4 photocopy is indistinguishable from any other letter. The exception might be when dealing with a large organisation where you don't know if the mail is opened by some random far from the recipient or even by an outsourced mail-processing service.

If I were ever forced to send a passport scan by email, I would send it as a password-protected document, as suggested by a PP, and then transmit the password separately NOT BY EMAIL. This will protect the document even at rest.

(I don't know how to set up password-protected docs: I'm still using dupes of the one set up by a friend to email me something sensitive. She works in IT in a secure environment, and this was her preferred method.)

PerkingFaintly · 15/06/2022 11:27

BTW, when a friend's email got hacked I had an actual conversation back and forth with the hacker who was pretending to be her. They really are that bold.

I got suspicious by the second or third short email as the tone wasn't her.

Couldn't raise her immediately on the phone, so asked the emailer to tell me a personal detail (obscure fact about obscure family member who wouldn't be on Facebook or otherwise known to someone with access to her accounts or devices).

The emailer immediately stopped replying to me.

Turned out her email really had been hacked. She had a bit of hassle sorting it out.

FarFarFarAndAway · 15/06/2022 11:21

Given the passport office send out passports by mail in very obviously passport shaped sizes, and ask you to send precious docs (including former and current passports from other countries) by post, the whole system is entirely hackable at all points! My docs were lost by the post office, even when tracked/signed for and no-one knows where they went!

EmmaH2022 · 15/06/2022 11:18

PerkingFaintly · 15/06/2022 11:16

Always PHONE the company you're dealing with to double-check the info before moving large amounts of money or sensitive data around.

And use the phone number from the company website/paper correspondence, not a phone number from the email!

Perking what are your thoughts on sending passport scans etc via email or WhatsApp, please?

PerkingFaintly · 15/06/2022 11:16

Always PHONE the company you're dealing with to double-check the info before moving large amounts of money or sensitive data around.

And use the phone number from the company website/paper correspondence, not a phone number from the email!

PerkingFaintly · 15/06/2022 11:14

BalloonsAndWhistles · 14/06/2022 22:23

How isn’t it secure?!! If you’re not 100% sure you’ve got the right email address then send a ‘test’ email first and wait for a response and then send the passport pic to the email thread. All good.

<headdesk>

So how do you think that email exchange with the email hacker will go?

Because the woman in the article linked above received email confirmation... from the fraudster:

When she received an email purporting to be from her solicitor asking for a transfer of funds, she sent the first instalment – £50,000 – and then emailed a member of staff at the firm’s office to check the money had been received. She received a reply confirming receipt, and the following day, as requested, she paid the balance of £45,750. This was deposited into another Lloyds account after she was told the bank details had been revised because of an ongoing audit.

Flood, who works in a Stockport secondary school, says her heart sank when her bank (not Lloyds) later rang to say that Lloyds had noticed a discrepancy in the payee name. “I phoned my solicitor immediately, only to have them confirm their system had been hacked. The first email asking for the funds transfer looked very authentic. When I received a second email in response to mine, confirming receipt of the first transfer from my solicitor, I felt reassured and made a further payment.
www.theguardian.com/money/2020/feb/29/bank-scam-solicitors-email-hacked

EmmaH2022 · 15/06/2022 10:19

I'm not the OP but I see her point.

in the past, When I've taken a copy of a passport, the copy went in a locked drawer which only two of us could access.

When you email a copy, it can be intercepted by anyone, as well as forwarded by anyone.

I wasn't happy with the client WhatsApp request, so went to their office. I didn't make a big deal, just said I was coming by. I don't know what's reasonably secure and what isn't.

Everything we were told not to do, we're suddenly being asked to do. Do others still shred documents with name and address on?

BalloonsAndWhistles · 14/06/2022 22:23

How isn’t it secure?!! If you’re not 100% sure you’ve got the right email address then send a ‘test’ email first and wait for a response and then send the passport pic to the email thread. All good.

EmmaH2022 · 14/06/2022 22:16

I had this on watch to see if there was an answer

i was asked to send a copy of my passport by Whatsapp. I presume that's no better? I'm so confused by all this.

PerkingFaintly · 09/06/2022 14:54

It's the data on the passport page that's the problem – inc date of birth and photo. Passport number used to matter as well, as it was used by eg Western Union money transfer service over the phone without having seen even a copy of the passport, but I think that's changed now.

Of course if you've given your correct date of birth to Facebook and uploaded photos of every moment of your life, it's pointless to worry about your passport. But some of us haven't.

TheTeenageYears · 09/06/2022 14:49

Have you tried to use a copy of a passport as ID? I've never come across an officialdom that doesn't need to see the actual passport or a certified physical copy.

PerkingFaintly · 09/06/2022 14:33

It's not a Yes/No situation when poor data security is so rampant. As with any widespread problem, you can't just avoid it by going next door – because they're probably just as bad.

Everyone has their own red lines which will cause them to actually walk, but for the most part it's a case of constant management and pushing back where one can, and can be bothered.

Emailing unsecured passport pics about the place is usually an unnecessary risk.

I've mitigated it by sending paper copies (which don't get duplicated left right and centre and can only be accessed by someone physically present). Others have suggested encrypted, password-protected documents which, even at rest, need the password (sent by a separate means, eg phone) to open.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 09/06/2022 13:08

PerkingFaintly · 09/06/2022 12:31

So don’t think any reputable business is going to not take steps to secure the data or to delete it after validating it.

Reputable businesses fail to delete or secure data all.the.time.

It's just something people and organisations are crap at.

Even when they've made a token gesture towards it, they frequently haven't deleted or secured all copies, which multiply unintentionally especially as emails get pinged hither and yon still carrying the attachment.

I've just had this with a hospital clinic which I hesitantly entrusted with an emailed medical form. I was replied to by a different person with my medical form still attached – dreadful practice. So that form is now in my sent box, my inbox, and at least two people in the clinic's email boxes, and possibly devices they're reading emails on if sometimes they do admin from home. I can trawl through manually finding and deleting it in my boxes... but not theirs.

And that's if they're even aware of GDPR requirements in the first place.

The number of times I've had to explain to my local council that they do not need my date of birth... They might want it, because they're all about Big Data and what uses they might come up with for data they've previously collected and combined across multiple databases... but THAT IN ITSELF is a breach of data protection legislation, which states that subjects must give informed consent for each purpose for which their data is processed, and that you can't just collect personal data speculatively in case it comes in handy later. I've had the call operators wail "But there's a space on my form for DoB!"

Yeah, no.

I was particularly annoyed by the council because mostly it's been an entirely unjustified collection of data – outright breach of GDPR – but on the one occasion my age had any relevance at all they could have proportionately met their aim by the trad method of asking my age group, 21-25, 26-30, etc. Not asking for my exact birthday which my bank uses as part of my security id.Angry

Honestly, the argument "It's important, so they can't possibly be doing it wrong," does not hold any water whatsoever.

Again, though…this is a company who the OP presumably wants to work for and if all goes according to plan will have access to much more personal data, including bank details, medical information, performance information, etc. Not a random entity that she is doing a piece of business with. If she doesn’t trust them to safeguard their passport data then what about everything else after she hired?

This all really makes no sense. Either this is a dealbreaker for the OP or she trusts them if they hire her.

PerkingFaintly · 09/06/2022 12:31

So don’t think any reputable business is going to not take steps to secure the data or to delete it after validating it.

Reputable businesses fail to delete or secure data all.the.time.

It's just something people and organisations are crap at.

Even when they've made a token gesture towards it, they frequently haven't deleted or secured all copies, which multiply unintentionally especially as emails get pinged hither and yon still carrying the attachment.

I've just had this with a hospital clinic which I hesitantly entrusted with an emailed medical form. I was replied to by a different person with my medical form still attached – dreadful practice. So that form is now in my sent box, my inbox, and at least two people in the clinic's email boxes, and possibly devices they're reading emails on if sometimes they do admin from home. I can trawl through manually finding and deleting it in my boxes... but not theirs.

And that's if they're even aware of GDPR requirements in the first place.

The number of times I've had to explain to my local council that they do not need my date of birth... They might want it, because they're all about Big Data and what uses they might come up with for data they've previously collected and combined across multiple databases... but THAT IN ITSELF is a breach of data protection legislation, which states that subjects must give informed consent for each purpose for which their data is processed, and that you can't just collect personal data speculatively in case it comes in handy later. I've had the call operators wail "But there's a space on my form for DoB!"

Yeah, no.

I was particularly annoyed by the council because mostly it's been an entirely unjustified collection of data – outright breach of GDPR – but on the one occasion my age had any relevance at all they could have proportionately met their aim by the trad method of asking my age group, 21-25, 26-30, etc. Not asking for my exact birthday which my bank uses as part of my security id.Angry

Honestly, the argument "It's important, so they can't possibly be doing it wrong," does not hold any water whatsoever.

cakeorwine · 09/06/2022 08:45

Exactly, most free email accounts are automatically encrypted with TLS so the advice to put text in an encrypted file attachment is, well, completely redundant and unnecessary

As far as I am aware - the text in an email would be automatically encrypted but an attachment in such an email wouldn't be - but I am not entirely sure about that.

So if you were to send bank details in an email, it would be encrypted in transit - but at rest, it would not be encrypted in the server. Some email providers could read it if they wanted to.

Something like Proton Mail automatically encrypts email at rest.

If I was sending a sensitive attachment, I would not just send it as an attachment - but then again, people send in CVs all the time - which probably contains lots of sensitive information

Alexandra2001 · 09/06/2022 08:36

Why are you bothered?

You are sending a photocopy of a passport to an organisation you may never actually work for, who could do anything with your 'copy, regardless of the method used to send it to them.

You know nothing of how secure their servers are, who will have access, how they will delete info you send them, if they even do so.

Good luck with the interview.