Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why we can't train more doctors?

136 replies

Turmerictolly · 08/06/2022 08:55

The NHS is desperately short of GP's and other doctors and the system is at breaking point. I look on the regular threads on here about not being able to physically see a GP any longer and my own experience of having cancelled hospital appts which are leading to worsening health. I then look at the Medicine threads where there seem to be so many bright and promising young people willing to train but not enough spaces on the courses.

It seems like some sort of dystopian catch 22. How on earth is this going to be fixed?

OP posts:
Enb76 · 08/06/2022 10:17

In 2008, BMA voted to put a cap on the amount of doctors that could be trained as more places 'would devalue' the role.

"Delegates at the annual BMA conference voted by a narrow majority to restrict the number of places at medical schools to avoid “overproduction of doctors with limited career opportunities.” They also agreed on a complete ban on opening new medical schools.9 Jul 2008"
www.bmj.com/content/337/bmj.a748

I believe that is biting us on the bum

NewMN · 08/06/2022 10:16

Few working class people can afford to train as a doctor. Or a nurse, or as a midwife. Make it easier to train. Make those that train here - stay here for a set amount of time.

Too many young med grads burn out! They need support. Most big companies spend £ on wellbeing. The nhs - not so much…

Reduce the pension savings requirement - this has got to be the simplest tool? Then get the newly retired to train the trainees.

We need to appreciate this wonderful free at the point of access service that we have - and bloody nurture it.

Maybe some of those hospitals Boris promised to build could be teaching hospitals? Oh, wait….

If we voted for a party that wanted to look after the NHS instead of stripping it - then maybe it would stand a chance!

Artwodeetoo · 08/06/2022 10:13

HistoricMoment · 08/06/2022 10:09

Force people to work? Are you honestly suggesting this for a democratic country?

In any case, would you really want to be treated by a demotivated doctor who is being forced to do his job?

Meh it's the same as the armed forces, after phase 2 training you have a return of service before you can leave.

I think in this case though it shouldn't be that people can't leave, but perhaps a financial incentive for those who stay ie fees written off or something. Wales does this. If you train in certain HCP degrees you have to work there for x years otherwise you have to pay fees.

X6hfyib4ms · 08/06/2022 10:12

I think there should be fast track options for some specialities. Eg I would love to train as a psychiatrist but am too old to commit 11 years to it.

I have a psychology degree, an MSc in neuroscience. I don't feel like it should take 11 years to train someone like me, more like 3 or 4.

I also feel that should be a specific straining trajectory for GPs so you're training specifically for that role and you know that's what you're applying to up front.

We should also be locking people in to X number of years service to the NHS to pay back the investment we've made in them. If they want to work abroad, either they or that hospital has to pay the cost of training back.

Artwodeetoo · 08/06/2022 10:11

It's the same with midwifery- lots and lots of keen applicants but you need the mentors on the wards and placements where they can get the relevant experience needed to earn their pin. Even with such a competitive process lots of people drop out or leave the profession in the first year- this would be even worse if there was an abundance of places imo.

HistoricMoment · 08/06/2022 10:09

Wheretheskyisblue · 08/06/2022 09:52

Other countries tie doctors to work in their health service for x years after investing in their training. In the UK lots train and then move abroad for better pay and conditions. We need to improve pay and conditions and force those who have been trained in the UK to stay whilst they pay back some of this investment. We also have a huge issue with UK doctors taking early retirement because of the pension mess.

Force people to work? Are you honestly suggesting this for a democratic country?

In any case, would you really want to be treated by a demotivated doctor who is being forced to do his job?

HistoricMoment · 08/06/2022 10:07

Start treating young doctors decently and they will want to stay. As it is, they are voting with their feet and leaving in droves. Rightly so.

CreaToration · 08/06/2022 10:00

There is a HUGE retention crisis in the NHS. In all areas. In all disciplines. In our ambulance trust there’s been 60 resignations in the last two months from just one area node.

Senior managers, chief executives and DOH seniors need to realise that some serious work and investment is needed to keep the staff they’ve got. And it’s not just about pay either. It’s conditions, environment, culture, lack of ongoing development, education and training opportunities, lack of appreciation, completely ineffective leadership……..Treat your staff poorly and they will leave. It’s that simple.

Wheretheskyisblue · 08/06/2022 09:52

Other countries tie doctors to work in their health service for x years after investing in their training. In the UK lots train and then move abroad for better pay and conditions. We need to improve pay and conditions and force those who have been trained in the UK to stay whilst they pay back some of this investment. We also have a huge issue with UK doctors taking early retirement because of the pension mess.

MrsJorahMormont · 08/06/2022 09:49

BigWoollyJumpers · 08/06/2022 09:45

It wasn't so long ago that the BMA voted to restrict places because they didn't want an oversupply of doctors! Since then and only recently, have places increased, but the time it takes to train a doctor means we are still suffering from the limit places on students 10 or so years ago.

This.

PrawnToast5 · 08/06/2022 09:48

More people than ever are entering GP training but it's not translating to more GPs. Working conditions and pay are not attractive, some choose to end their studies early, some move abroad once qualified.

MoltenLasagne · 08/06/2022 09:47

There's also a limited political will to fix it as it takes 8 years to train a doctor and we have elections every 4 years. Not many politicians, especially the campaigning type we've got at the moment, will take the pain of the significant upfront cost knowing their opposition are likely to get the credit by the time the doctors are actually trained and making an impact.

Qwertyfudge · 08/06/2022 09:45

We have a cap on the number of students that can study medicine. A number of universities have called for this cap to be lifted. The government have increased the cap but not enough to have a significant impact in coming years. They also need to increase the funding for universities and the nhs to support additional placements.

BigWoollyJumpers · 08/06/2022 09:45

It wasn't so long ago that the BMA voted to restrict places because they didn't want an oversupply of doctors! Since then and only recently, have places increased, but the time it takes to train a doctor means we are still suffering from the limit places on students 10 or so years ago.

Getoff · 08/06/2022 09:43

I've wondered about this, as it annoys me when people claim we "have to" import doctors. (It may be a short-term solution, but there should not be a shortage in the first place.) Given how competitive medical school entry is, I doubt there's a shortage of UK people both able and willing to be doctors.

What I've read is that the main bottleneck is hospital training places. Hospitals apparently can't accommodate more on-the-job-training. I don't know if this is absolutely true, or if it is only true because it's assumed various other elements of the status quo can't be changed. (In the same way that people saying we "have to" import doctors are assuming training places and/or retention can't be improved.)

Hallyup89 · 08/06/2022 09:33

Not enough placements available, not enough mentors and people trained to assess them. It's as simple as supply and demand.

Brainwave89 · 08/06/2022 09:26

My son is a doctor. It is a long hard career path with a massive amount of responsibility. It is also a job that very few people are capable of doing. The NHS does and always has relied heavily on overseas doctors and nurses to keep itself going. Similarly most UK trained doctors are in demand in the US, Australia and elsewhere. Even three to four years into training a doctor can move to the US work less hours, enjoy much better conditions and double their pay. Given stress levels and working conditions a large number of more experienced doctors are exiting the profession in their mid to late 50s. Once a doctor reaches the pensions cap, there is limited incentive to remain at work. Little has been done to address this trend to date.

PurpleDaisies · 08/06/2022 09:20

CornishPorsche · 08/06/2022 09:10

There's also got to be a cost element for study. I wanted to retrain as a nurse a few years ago, but couldn't afford to.

£10k/year study fees, plus at the time, limited bursaries etc. How was I supposed to pay my rent, bills, run a car to get to placements etc?

I've already done one degree and that took me years to pay back. Doing it again in my 30s was a very intimidating idea.

Add that to the extra years of study for a Dr, and I dread to think the amount of debt people end up in.

Going into medicine is becoming the privilege of the wealthy. Again.

There isn’t a drop in people applying for medicine though. Yes, I’m sure there’s an issue with people from poorer backgrounds considering it as a career but a shortage of suitable applicants isn’t the problem.

What really needs to happen is investment in supporting early career doctors so they don’t emigrate or leave while the greater number of trainees works through. Having loads of very junior staff who haven’t really got a clue what they’re doing isn’t very helpful. You need to keep more of the ones with experience.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 08/06/2022 09:19

My parents both recently retired early from the NHS.

When they started, they said it was an incredible place to work and they both felt very privileged.

When they retired, they both said that if they were just starting their careers now c they'd never work for the NHS.

It's been ruined and it's such a shame.

HoppingPavlova · 08/06/2022 09:17

Find out what puts people off and fix those issues.

Main thing is lack of experienced staff who can train. There’s not the capacity to work/train/oversee with current experienced staff. Trainee’s need oversight and this takes time and when everything is already short staffed it’s not feasible. It’s also not a case where there is no difference in overseeing one or ten. So limited training places match existing experienced staff availability.

Also, the fact is not all medical degrees are equal. Qualifications in some countries are more than adequate and it’s just fine tuning to local systems that is required and easily achieved, but qualifications from some other countries are not worth the paper they are written on and I wouldn’t let them loose on a paper cut-out let alone a patient.

Auntieobem · 08/06/2022 09:13

It's not just that there aren't enough doctors! We need more social care, more physios, OTs, nurses, admin staff, paramedics, pharmacists, support staff, decent clinical accommodation, better IT and data systems.

FictionalCharacter · 08/06/2022 09:13

We train plenty of doctors every year. A lot of them decide not to practice medicine. Some go abroad. Some practice medicine for a few years then pack it in. Working for the NHS is not as popular as it used to be.

CornishPorsche · 08/06/2022 09:10

There's also got to be a cost element for study. I wanted to retrain as a nurse a few years ago, but couldn't afford to.

£10k/year study fees, plus at the time, limited bursaries etc. How was I supposed to pay my rent, bills, run a car to get to placements etc?

I've already done one degree and that took me years to pay back. Doing it again in my 30s was a very intimidating idea.

Add that to the extra years of study for a Dr, and I dread to think the amount of debt people end up in.

Going into medicine is becoming the privilege of the wealthy. Again.

Tagliatellme · 08/06/2022 09:10

The whole planning process is a mess and just getting more medical students to graduate won't solve it. This year there were medical graduates with no F1 posts to go into.

Years ago (John Reid was health sec so a very long time ago), a colleague and I went to a meeting with the BMA and the DH. My colleague, who was a consultant with a particular interest in workforce planning in Medicine, spoke about the complete lack of planning for service demand. He suggested a top down process, calculating how many GPs, consultants, service grades etc would be needed, then calculate backwards to work out the number of medical students needed. Obviously things like drop out rates would need to be included.

The so called experts said it was too difficult to do workforce planning in Medicine and actually shrugged their shoulders...

Nothing appears to have happened to solve it since. Planning needs to have started for late 2030s service needs bearing in mind how long it takes to put someone through medical school and onto the relevant register when they complete training.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 08/06/2022 09:05

Why would anyone want to work for the NHS given the state it's in?

Swipe left for the next trending thread