Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why we can't train more doctors?

136 replies

Turmerictolly · 08/06/2022 08:55

The NHS is desperately short of GP's and other doctors and the system is at breaking point. I look on the regular threads on here about not being able to physically see a GP any longer and my own experience of having cancelled hospital appts which are leading to worsening health. I then look at the Medicine threads where there seem to be so many bright and promising young people willing to train but not enough spaces on the courses.

It seems like some sort of dystopian catch 22. How on earth is this going to be fixed?

OP posts:
QuebecBagnet · 08/06/2022 11:31

Health education England have increased the number of medical school places so they are trying.

Im sure I read somewhere that last year not all graduates got a job, there were too many qualifying 🤷🏻‍♀️ Seems a bit bonkers if true.

Babdoc · 08/06/2022 11:25

OP, delaying starting training until 21 would hugely disadvantage female medical students, who would then be 3 years older before qualifying, ie at 26, then facing their FY years and a further seven years of specialist training - they would be heading for their late 30’s before having a fixed home or being able to even contemplate children.
When I was a medical student, in the 1970s in Dundee, they took applicants at 16, straight from school, who qualified as doctors at 21. I was a little surprised to be dissecting human cadavers as a teenager, but we all got on with it, and only 3% of my year failed to complete the course and qualify. Being young and resilient was a big help in coping with the 100 hour weeks on duty.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 08/06/2022 11:12

Doctors don't want to be GPs. Even if we trained more, they would leave.

We need to change the whole system and get rid of GPs altogether.

We need to look at what works in other countries as our system does not work anymore.

Carrotten · 08/06/2022 11:09

I also think in my experience being a junior doctor isn't always very rewarding. I've seen very poor treatment towards me and colleagues from nursing staff, ED staff, other specialities, seniors within my own speciality and management. Some hospitals are really toxic places for junior staff and its no wonder that many say fuck this. You can often get poor treatment from all angles.

Artwodeetoo · 08/06/2022 11:05

expertbyordeal · 08/06/2022 10:55

There are also too few graduate entry places. I might be talking out of my arse here but standard entry (5 year course, mostly 18/19yos with no prior degree) is about 8 applicants per place, whereas graduate entry (accelerated 4-year course, mid-20s and older with a previous degree) is about 100 applicants per place.
I really, really wanted to do medicine. But having just finished my first degree as a mature student I can't spend years of my life trying to get into another, 4-year, degree, in order to graduate into dreadful working conditions on shit pay, or possibly even no job at all.
Another issue with medicine is that no matter how much of a hard worker you are, you can't really work alongside a medical degree. It's not advisable. But the loans and bursaries are not enough. So medicine is very difficult to access for those without financial support from parents/spouses.

The grad PA route because although a PA isn't a doctor there are similarities will help a bit but it also causes many of its own issues..

Carrotten · 08/06/2022 11:04

It's not just as as simple as train more doctors

To train more doctors you need facilities, you need experienced doctors to train them. You need FY1 places. You need to make sure that the people you are training a)want to go in the right specialities where there are gaps and b) live in the right areas

You need the facilities for those doctors to practice, the rooms to see patients, the theatres to operate (alongside the additional theatre staff to run the theatres), the extra beds for your post operative patients and extra nursing staff this comes with. The extra admin staff to facilitate extra doctors. Extra office space for the extra doctors to carry out their admi

You need to improve working conditions for doctors, which admittedly would improve if there were more doctors, pay to improve to retain doctors. Better computer systems so that more time can be spent on clinical work

You then need more CT scanners, MRI machines, pathology facilities and staff to run these. All of these also result in delays to patient care.

The training is long. It's not as simple as pass a medicine degree get more doctors. The NHS is well over capacity in all areas

Turmerictolly · 08/06/2022 11:01

I'm shocked by the level of obstacles needed to fix this. It just seems insurmountable for any government.

I think I agree with looking at who is picked for med school in the first place - at Ds school it seems to be something that people aspire to rather than a vocational choice. I also think they're too young to cope with the pressures (and obviously from this thread, not very well supported for all sorts of reasons). Hence the high drop out rates and poor retention.

Perhaps training should start later, at 21 say, and trainees should be required to have had some kind of health care role beforehand so they know what they're letting themselves in for. I also think there should be some stipulation or incentives for newly trained workers to commit to a few years in nhs practice.

OP posts:
expertbyordeal · 08/06/2022 10:55

There are also too few graduate entry places. I might be talking out of my arse here but standard entry (5 year course, mostly 18/19yos with no prior degree) is about 8 applicants per place, whereas graduate entry (accelerated 4-year course, mid-20s and older with a previous degree) is about 100 applicants per place.
I really, really wanted to do medicine. But having just finished my first degree as a mature student I can't spend years of my life trying to get into another, 4-year, degree, in order to graduate into dreadful working conditions on shit pay, or possibly even no job at all.
Another issue with medicine is that no matter how much of a hard worker you are, you can't really work alongside a medical degree. It's not advisable. But the loans and bursaries are not enough. So medicine is very difficult to access for those without financial support from parents/spouses.

WigglyWombat · 08/06/2022 10:53

@HistoricMoment - So, if you tie doctors into working for a certain amount of time in the NHS - or, paying back a percentage of their tuition costs if not - that isn’t really “forced labour” is it?

I’ve been offered expensive training paid for by employers in the past, where part of the contract was that if I left within a year then I had to pay the cost of the qualification back, with a sliding scale reduction after that.. that is because companies don’t want pay out huge amounts tor qualifications for staff who then leave. That seems fair enough really and it isn’t forced labour it’s a contractual agreement.

Stompythedinosaur · 08/06/2022 10:51

There is a lack of suitable placements and mentors.

The biggest problem is retention. Junior medics are often treated very badly, in my experience.

PenguinWings · 08/06/2022 10:49

These are my ideas to improve retention-

Have a working IT system that lets me quickly do what I need to do without the computer repeatedly crashing or spending 5 minutes staring at the spinning blue circle.

Make mandatory training easy to access- run it for the convenience of the staff, not the trainers.

Have reception staff for the wards so I'm not "first on" for answering the phone.

Have more phlebotomy staff so that we don't start the day spending half an hour taking blood.

Have enough chairs that everyone in the office can sit down at once, and a system that doesn't make us feel like we're being entitled for asking for this.

Some kind of clerical help so that I'm not one managing appointments to see relatives.

I'd like to spend more time seeing patients and less time dealing with keeping the creaking support system going.

PurassicJark · 08/06/2022 10:49

Give them better pay and stop people from treating them like trash. Would you work in a highly skilled job saving lives when you're going to be also screamed at, threatened, abused, spat on etc and then reported on so you can't keep working while being investigated just because some jumped up twat didn't agree with their diagnosis? All for a low pay for all of that shit? No you would not.

expertbyordeal · 08/06/2022 10:48

This year 800 med school graduates were placed on the reserve list for foundation places. There are few medical school places, but an even greater shortage of jobs for those medics to go to.

AmaryIlis · 08/06/2022 10:47

They desperately need to do something about working conditions so as to retain those who have trained. The situation depicted in "This is going to hurt" is really not an exaggeration.

853ax · 08/06/2022 10:45

Any female Dr or nurse I know in 30s works 2 days a week.
Presume for NHS to be able to offer this flexibility they also need to have x2 or x3 staff to fill a position.
So training 100 doctors won't necessarily fill 100 roles.
Pay is sufficient to achieve part time job without limiting life style too much.

passport123 · 08/06/2022 10:44

Around a fifth of doctors leave the NHS after the first 2-3 years, many more within the first 10 years. Training more drs to sort the workforce crisis is like turning the tap on to fill the bath without noticing that the plug is out. The NHS needs to become a less hideous place to work force.

nolongersurprised · 08/06/2022 10:39

Start treating young doctors decently and they will want to stay. As it is, they are voting with their feet and leaving in droves

It’s this.

Im an Australian doctor and UK doctors come here because the NHS treats them like shit. Massively overworked, often covering more wards and patients than can ever be safe and then doesn’t support them when adverse outcomes happen. It’s impossible to keep track of all of the subtly deteriorating patients in hospital when you are literally responsible for 100 plus patients and being bleeped constantly for fluids, paracetamol, new drug charts, discharge summaries, talk to families about patients you don’t know and deal with new admissions.

All hospital training jobs are challenging but the NHS is untenable.

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 08/06/2022 10:35

The BMA has a lot to answer for.

we are also sending the wrong people to become doctors - I see too many medical students who have been steered towards medicine at all costs, and hate it, so retention is poor. I’d rather have slightly less brilliant academics and more commitment/understanding of what a doctor is.

interestingly, all my best colleagues did postgraduate medicine. I think that is a far better way to train medics.

Libertybear80 · 08/06/2022 10:33

It's always todo with placement capacity. It's not just a theoretical programme. You need supervision in the workplace! It's the same problem with nurses.

lunar1 · 08/06/2022 10:33

As a consultant, DH has been offered jobs abroad at 4/5 times his salary here. He could earn three times his wage here if he switched to private practice only.

His working conditions are awful, his department is constantly short staffed.

He loves his job and speciality and won't leave until he retires. But you can't blame people for doing what's right for themselves, people in other professions aren't condemned for following better pay.

NHS staff across the board are not paid what they are worth.

Mushroo · 08/06/2022 10:33

I think it’s just not that attractive as an option. I very much contemplated doing medicine at uni (I had the grades) but decided against it at the last minute. One of my close friends did do medicine.

Now, in our early 30s, i work in accountancy and whilst I earn a little less than her (we’re both on about £70k but she gets extra for additional shifts sometimes) our lives are incomparable. I work pretty much 9-5, get 30 days holiday and lots of ‘fun’ at work - conferences, business travel, free drinks, pub lunches. I feel respected and well looked after. My exams were done after 3 years and they were all paid for and I got generous study leave and time out to go to college.

Her on the other hand has been working shifts though out, and still can’t plan her life at all. She’s missed weddings, birthdays, holidays. She can’t commit to a single event because she might be working, but doesn’t know in advance. She’s had to move between hospitals meaning excessive commutes and has the pressure of saving lives. She has also only just finished her exams at the age of 30 all whilst working and she had to pay for all the exams herself.

long term, she will undoubtably be better off when she makes consultant, but at what cost to just living a normal life. This is all before she has kids to think about as well.

spanishsummers · 08/06/2022 10:32

And frankly the medical education at some establishments could be better.

spanishsummers · 08/06/2022 10:30

It's training infrastructure at the placements. And retention is a huge issue.

HistoricMoment · 08/06/2022 10:29

NewMN · 08/06/2022 10:23

@HistoricMoment I might prefer to be treated by a ‘demotivated’ doctor as you put it - than one who hasn’t slept… or one who can’t actually access the correct records because the IT systems don’t work, etc…

And if the Doctor isn’t motivated - then maybe the selection process isn’t sufficiently thorough? There are far too many Drs who are completely arrogant; who don’t listen, who won’t admit they don’t know, who dismiss awful health issue as anxiety. (I’m thinking here of a recent thread). Clearly we also have some brilliant doctors, but the ‘attitude to patients’ module isn’t necessarily well taught or assessed. Clearly something is going wrong…

Ask any big company to improve staff motivation. It is possible!

I meant a demotivated doctor who is being forced to do his job, not a doctor who is demotivated because he doesn't want to do his job but is still doing it voluntarily.
It is very concerning that some posters seem to think forced labour is ok. Just because other countries do this doesn't mean we should.

NewMN · 08/06/2022 10:23

@HistoricMoment I might prefer to be treated by a ‘demotivated’ doctor as you put it - than one who hasn’t slept… or one who can’t actually access the correct records because the IT systems don’t work, etc…

And if the Doctor isn’t motivated - then maybe the selection process isn’t sufficiently thorough? There are far too many Drs who are completely arrogant; who don’t listen, who won’t admit they don’t know, who dismiss awful health issue as anxiety. (I’m thinking here of a recent thread). Clearly we also have some brilliant doctors, but the ‘attitude to patients’ module isn’t necessarily well taught or assessed. Clearly something is going wrong…

Ask any big company to improve staff motivation. It is possible!

Swipe left for the next trending thread