Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why we can't train more doctors?

136 replies

Turmerictolly · 08/06/2022 08:55

The NHS is desperately short of GP's and other doctors and the system is at breaking point. I look on the regular threads on here about not being able to physically see a GP any longer and my own experience of having cancelled hospital appts which are leading to worsening health. I then look at the Medicine threads where there seem to be so many bright and promising young people willing to train but not enough spaces on the courses.

It seems like some sort of dystopian catch 22. How on earth is this going to be fixed?

OP posts:
Didiplanthis · 08/06/2022 14:19

I am 47 and a very experienced GP ... I am burnt out beyond belief and am not sure how to make it through the next 3 months let alone the next 13 -18 years. Yesterday i got in to work and started my admin at 7.15. I spoke to my first patient at 8.30 , I had so many extra patients added on to my morning surgery that I was still going when my afternoon surgery started and I had to slot them in alternately. I finished speaking with patients about 7.30 pm and started on my admin again. I left work at 9 45 pm having left my desk for 2 wees and to microwave my lunch to eat at my desk. Today I have a day off and I am doing the rest of yesterday's admin. I cant do this anymore..every single one of the patients yesterday deserved more time, thought and head space than I had to give. I'm scared of what might happen and I can no longer just work harder and longer to make it all OK as there is no more to give.... and everyone hates us and thinks we are lazy and work shy.... why the HELL would ANYONE go into the job it is now ?????

NoNotHimTheOtherOne · 08/06/2022 13:52

Having worked in A&E, I would argue that a black belt in Karate and a job working behind a bar in a rough part of town are far more useful attributes than Grade 8 piano, but we still insist on choosing students with the latter 🤦🏻

Who are "we"? I have been a medicine admissions tutor for a very long time and we have always favoured the former over the latter. I am only aware of one UK medical school where grade 8 piano will contribute to your chances of getting a place. (I know that's one too many.)

DodoDino · 08/06/2022 13:52

Again, lots of professions have women in them who want to work LTFT due to raising children - they have managed to overcome this issue (mostly!)

GrandmaWillow · 08/06/2022 13:49

There are many female GPs now who want to bring up there families and opt for shorter working hours. However it still takes the same amount of time to train them and much of their work time involved keeping up with Continuous Professional Development. The number of hours worked means they often lack experience. Just one of those changes that we haven't managed to accommodate.

NoNotHimTheOtherOne · 08/06/2022 13:43

It wasn't so long ago that the BMA voted to restrict places because they didn't want an oversupply of doctors!

They didn't want a large surplus of medical graduates competing for a restricted number of foundation training posts. This is fair enough. It is unethical to expect students to undertake 5 or 6 years of degree-level education/training and then say some of them aren't allowed to become doctors despite having completed their degrees successfully, meaning they only have the same to show for 5 years of study as others have for 3 years.

There are numerous pinch-points - including lack of capacity for clinical placements - in addition to the lack of political will to fund more undergraduate or postgraduate training posts. To its credit, Health Education England (the part of the NHS that funds training of healthcare professionals) is currently trying to force medical schools and their partner hospital trusts make more efficient use of placements. However, there is always the issue that a doctor who is teaching students will take longer to get through a list of patients than one without students. (Added to which, some patients refuse to have students in the room with them: this is one of the reasons why it has so far proved impossible to place students in private hospitals.)

There are some efforts going on to develop alternative pathways for training doctors. Some of these, such as the part-time programme run by the University of Edinburgh, might provide a quicker route, but this programme is for other healthcare professionals, so this approach just replaces a shortage of doctors with a shortage of nurses and allied health professionals.

It is fairly obvious that just increasing the supply of medical graduates would not achieve much unless the loss of early-career doctors to other countries or other careers can be controlled. This is already urgent, as this morning's news story shows: www.theguardian.com/society/2022/jun/08/nhs-hiring-more-doctors-from-outside-uk-and-eea-than-inside-for-first-time

DoctorSock · 08/06/2022 13:38

Yes - AndSoFinally - your second paragraph sums up the person we know so well.

DoctorSock · 08/06/2022 13:37

We have a friend who is on their third training programme now - failed one, changed and then quit the second one. They are now back doing the first (or similar to the first) one. Post foundation years she has also worked abroad to supplement the income for all the funded here training - it seem completely insane given how much money is being wasted.

Doctors always mention the "horrific" shift work - but it isn't the only profession that has shift work - it also isn't the only profession where you pay for your own exams, professional registration, external training, CPD in your own time etc.

luciatrope · 08/06/2022 13:01

Doctors have essentially had around a 30% pay cut over the last decade.

Our government also spends some of the smallest percentage on healthcare compared to those in Europe.

Coupled with the constant exams (which you have to pay for), horrific shift work, competition for placements, media smear campaigns, being treated by the NHS as nothing more than a number, dealing with anti-social behaviour from patients and their families... it just isn't as appealing a career as it used to be.

Doctors have been banging on about the decline of the profession for years. The public might only just be waking up a bit to these issues now that trying to see a doctor can be a challenge. But they deserve to be paid better, as do all NHS clinical staff, so no wonder they're leaving in droves.

AndSoFinally · 08/06/2022 12:54

It is also a job that very few people are capable of doing

I also don't believe this. It's a job that very few people are capable of getting on to the training course for. The majority of the consultants I work with are excellent^^ and have been in the job 30 or 40-odd years. They got a mixture of A-Level results, but most were in the BBC, BCC, CCC range. They freely admit they'd never get in to do medicine these days.

The retention crisis is partly because we're now choosing the wrong people for the course. Academically brilliant, but little in the way of life experience or (often) common sense. They have no 'street smarts' because they're often from very privileged backgrounds, and have been spoon fed at private schools from an early age. Often they come from wealthy backgrounds and this gives them choices. If they qualify and find that they hate it or can't cope with the pressure, their backgrounds mean they can just up sticks and leave, and retrain as something else. I don't blame them. A fair few do this now, Many more so than when I trained.

I came from a working class background. I happen to love my job, but if I'd have hated it, I'd still have stuck it out as I'd got so much debt I'd have had no choice!

We need to be selecting Med students differently these days. We need to forget attracting triple A* students, and focus more on those with the right personal characteristics and a heavy dose of resilience. Having worked in A&E, I would argue that a black belt in Karate and a job working behind a bar in a rough part of town are far more useful attributes than Grade 8 piano, but we still insist on choosing students with the latter 🤦🏻

Morred · 08/06/2022 12:50

PenguinWings · 08/06/2022 10:49

These are my ideas to improve retention-

Have a working IT system that lets me quickly do what I need to do without the computer repeatedly crashing or spending 5 minutes staring at the spinning blue circle.

Make mandatory training easy to access- run it for the convenience of the staff, not the trainers.

Have reception staff for the wards so I'm not "first on" for answering the phone.

Have more phlebotomy staff so that we don't start the day spending half an hour taking blood.

Have enough chairs that everyone in the office can sit down at once, and a system that doesn't make us feel like we're being entitled for asking for this.

Some kind of clerical help so that I'm not one managing appointments to see relatives.

I'd like to spend more time seeing patients and less time dealing with keeping the creaking support system going.

These are great ideas, but the result of implementing is the tabloids stirring up fury about how much the NHS pays on 'administrators' and 'managers' not 'frontline medical staff'. The problem with cutting the administrators is that other people end up having to do the administration.

(If they had a working IT system their administrators could actually do more than just stare at spinning wheel of death as well - much more efficient.)

MarshaBradyo · 08/06/2022 12:40

Enb76 · 08/06/2022 10:17

In 2008, BMA voted to put a cap on the amount of doctors that could be trained as more places 'would devalue' the role.

"Delegates at the annual BMA conference voted by a narrow majority to restrict the number of places at medical schools to avoid “overproduction of doctors with limited career opportunities.” They also agreed on a complete ban on opening new medical schools.9 Jul 2008"
www.bmj.com/content/337/bmj.a748

I believe that is biting us on the bum

Interesting, this lag is an issue

I assume it’s been upped but will take time

As a degree it does strike me as competitive

AndSoFinally · 08/06/2022 12:40

A friend who's a doctor is part of a group looking at this. The issues are cost (he reckons it costs about £250,000 to train a doctor in the UK, mostly funded by the government) and a lack of training places - you need people, hospitals etc. to train that many doctors.

I hear this figure a lot, but have no idea where it comes from. I am a doctor and I teach at the medical school. I lead one weeks teaching a year and help out for the odd lecture on other peoples weeks, as they help out on mine. For this, I get £10k a year. There are around 80 students on my course. £250k to train a doctor would be £50k a year, so £4 million per year for the 80 on my course. The teaching at £10k a week would be roughly £400k a year. The students are paying £720k per year in tuition fees between them. Obviously there are staff expenses other than teaching, as well as exam entry/costs, and other costs, but I doubt these amount to £4.3 million pounds a year. The clinical placements are all provided by hospital consultants, and we don't get paid any money for providing these. We also don't miss any clinical time as the students basically tag along to whatever we're doing and learn as they go.

I genuinely cannot see how training 80 students costs £4.72 million pounds a year?! If anyone knows I'd be very interested

XenoBitch · 08/06/2022 12:37

Libertybear80 · 08/06/2022 10:33

It's always todo with placement capacity. It's not just a theoretical programme. You need supervision in the workplace! It's the same problem with nurses.

This.

During an operation, you could have 2 medical students in there, along with 2 student ODPs, and possibly a student nurse too. If X-rays are needed, then a student radiographer could also be tagging along too.
All need supervising and mentoring.

Fluffycloudland77 · 08/06/2022 12:34

Why would you choose medicine with its long hours and poor pay when you can choose dentistry and earn more working 9-5?

Theres better careers out there than medicine.

Artwodeetoo · 08/06/2022 12:33

BigWoollyJumpers · 08/06/2022 12:30

So GP's specifically and locally. My practice used to have 5 full time GP's. They now have many (I loose count) part time GP's. Great, work/life balance, most of the part timers are women. However, many of those women also have private clinics going. Fantastic if you can afford it. I have switched from seeing my one day a week menopause NHS GP, to her private practice. Same lady, same knowledge and prescriptions, just more available. I don't blame her, but it does highlight issues at practices. NHS consultants, same. All the local ones fulfill their NHS roles, and then have private practices as well.

Without those opportunities though many would go abroad to practice. No countries are utopias for doctors, but many pay much much better and with better working conditions. Of course many don't go in just for the money, but it is a job on the other hand like any other and so of course money plays a part. If the NHS sorted out its issues I'm sure many more would be inclined to not subsidise their NHS careers with private work. You'd also lose some if there weren't part time opportunities. The issue is its just not an appealing route for many, can't blame them. The public are getting more and more entitled as well which isn't pleasant to have to deal with.I

Droopinloopin · 08/06/2022 12:32

It's a question of retaining the doctors the NHS already has.

The job is incredibly stressful, with long hours, sometimes little sleep and being on call during the night.

If these issues were fixed then maybe fewer doctors would leave and more young people would be keen to train.

BigWoollyJumpers · 08/06/2022 12:30

So GP's specifically and locally. My practice used to have 5 full time GP's. They now have many (I loose count) part time GP's. Great, work/life balance, most of the part timers are women. However, many of those women also have private clinics going. Fantastic if you can afford it. I have switched from seeing my one day a week menopause NHS GP, to her private practice. Same lady, same knowledge and prescriptions, just more available. I don't blame her, but it does highlight issues at practices. NHS consultants, same. All the local ones fulfill their NHS roles, and then have private practices as well.

Jaxhog · 08/06/2022 12:28

We need more (some!) and better forward planning. Although I think the NHS is in danger of being too big to fix. We throw more and more money at it, yet the impact seems to be minute. Paying staff more, while seemingly a good idea, isn't the answer either. The problem is that a vast amount of money is going towards supporting an increasingly complex and byzantine system that no one completely understands. This is pretty typical of any very large organisation.

Maybe we need to break it up into smaller independent units, where the emphasis is on people facing care?

Confusedofbritain · 08/06/2022 12:20

All doctors need clinical supervision, so this is another barrier.

However we do need to increase the pipeline being trained as Drs are retiring at a faster rate than entering the workforce. We are now recruiting more Drs from abroad than inside the U.K.

All trusts have vacancies- but they might not be the jobs individuals want to do. So there will be a mismatch there. The areas which require large numbers of Drs (GPs, A&E, elderly medicine) not necessarily the areas people find attractive to work in.

cadburyegg · 08/06/2022 12:17

One of my best friends is a GP and I've known her since school.

Issues are, it's hugely expensive to train doctors, the training is very hard work (my friend was always very bright and academic, she has about 6 As at A level, and even she found it very difficult). Places in med school are hugely competitive because of staffing issues, universities often struggle to retain good staff.

After graduating, there are better paid careers for those qualifying in medicine than becoming a doctor. After finishing med school lots of people choose to pick a specialism in a hospital rather than go into GP training. Trained doctors might find that living in certain areas too expensive so because of demand they can choose to go live in cheaper areas.

Then there's all the issues that come with being a GP itself

Theluggage15 · 08/06/2022 12:16

The BMA voted against increasing the number of medical school placements. They want the supply restricted. Ok when you can import docs but not now.

shrodingersvaccine · 08/06/2022 12:11

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ.

Darkstar4855 · 08/06/2022 12:07

It’s pointless training more doctors when the job is so unrewarding that nobody wants to do it.

When I qualified 16 years ago three quarters of my class wanted to go into GP. It was seen as rewarding but also family friendly. These days none of our juniors want to be GPs: the workload is overwhelming, the abuse from patients and social/mainstream media is constant and the pay isn’t that great, considering how stressful it is.

I wouldn’t do it in a million years.

TeacupDrama · 08/06/2022 11:51

to target medical and dental school places they upped requirements to all A's at A level and stopped interviewing in 1980's you need 3 B's to do medicine and BCC to do dentistry, just getting 4 A's does not make you temperantly suited to being a doctor, there are loads of good doctors in their 50's that never got A grades maybe grade inflation means and 1980's B is a current A I don't know,
lack of training is one thing mountains of paperwork is another
I worked in NHS dentistry for year mostly in rural scotland then 4 years in a deprived area near Glasgow before I left dentistry for good
reasons earning deflation earning the same in 2014 as I was in 1998 costs increased expontentially fees did not ,
pressure and stress, form filling undervalued I left before Covid but dentists are leaving NHS in droves, it is not just money but work life balance time with patients etc aggressive patients it is not my fault you have holes in your teeth when you drink 2 litres of irn bru a day, any more than it's GP's fault your blood sugar is through the roof for the same reason, then they complain to the health board you were rude because you advised cutting down on sugary drinks it is no longer worth the aggro, left before I was shattered by burnout and stress have told my DD 13 not to consider health care as a profession or teaching for similar reasons

NewMN · 08/06/2022 11:41

@PenguinWings a really interesting view from the inside…

IT and organisation problems seem to crop up again and again don’t they? The NHS needs ‘Undercover Boss’ - so when the junior doc gets treated like shit, for ex, someone at the top finally ‘gets’ it…

Swipe left for the next trending thread