Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why we can't train more doctors?

136 replies

Turmerictolly · 08/06/2022 08:55

The NHS is desperately short of GP's and other doctors and the system is at breaking point. I look on the regular threads on here about not being able to physically see a GP any longer and my own experience of having cancelled hospital appts which are leading to worsening health. I then look at the Medicine threads where there seem to be so many bright and promising young people willing to train but not enough spaces on the courses.

It seems like some sort of dystopian catch 22. How on earth is this going to be fixed?

OP posts:
Topgub · 10/06/2022 09:18

Its not just doctors

The whole if the nhs is in crisis.

And yet going by a recent thread on nurses lots of people seem to think its an over paid easy job.

Weird how we cant recruit or retain staff then isn't it?

missingmiddle · 10/06/2022 09:08

I work in professional services. We hire a lot of associates who finished medical school and maybe worked 1-2 years and then came to us. I was actually surprised and asked why so many were transferring, because I think of my industry as less prestigious/top-tier etc than medicine, and these kids are all obviously brilliant...

Every single one said it was the pay. We pay ~£50k to new grads which rises to ~£100-120k after 3 years or so. Shit but predictable hours and no weekend work. Who wouldn't?? These kids can sleepwalk through our interviews, it's a no-brainer!

Alexandra2001 · 10/06/2022 08:28

But their members, i.e. the doctors themselves, can decide not to offer themselves up for training, offering training places, working in the medical schools, mentoring etc., i.e. a kind of "work to rule" or "strike" to support their trade union should the government of the day go ahead and increase medical schools/places against the BMA's wishes!

Is there any evidence whatsoever, they actually did this?

My understanding is that as there wasn't enough funding in primary care to pay for extra GPs, so the BMA said what it said on places.... it was also 14 years ago.

700 EU GPs have left the NHS, many of these were working in the areas, traditionally hard to recruit into.

Badbadbunny · 09/06/2022 20:34

Tagliatellme · 09/06/2022 15:36

But surely the BMA is a trade union. They might have an opinion, but they can't make these decisions.

But their members, i.e. the doctors themselves, can decide not to offer themselves up for training, offering training places, working in the medical schools, mentoring etc., i.e. a kind of "work to rule" or "strike" to support their trade union should the government of the day go ahead and increase medical schools/places against the BMA's wishes!

Tagliatellme · 09/06/2022 15:36

BigWoollyJumpers · 08/06/2022 09:45

It wasn't so long ago that the BMA voted to restrict places because they didn't want an oversupply of doctors! Since then and only recently, have places increased, but the time it takes to train a doctor means we are still suffering from the limit places on students 10 or so years ago.

But surely the BMA is a trade union. They might have an opinion, but they can't make these decisions.

undermilkjug · 08/06/2022 16:43

The treatment at work is a huge issue.

My brother is a registrar who was working over Christmas. He applied for a temporary staff parking permit because the buses wouldn't be running and was told that applications for permits were reviewed in strict order of receipt and his would be looked at in turn, but not to expect a response until February. The trust said they would pay for taxis on Christmas eve but the taxis had to be booked 24 hours in advance... his taxi had left by the time he was able to leave his shift 3 hours late because there was a medical emergency.

He was the last doctor to see a patient who discharged himself and killed himself (36 hours after DB had seen him). He had to give evidence at the inquest and was put through a disciplinary procedure. he was cleared but it was 18 months of waiting, during covid, with no support, no recognition that this was stressful, and very much the hospital looking for people to blame.

A system like the air travel system where all near misses are reported without blame would go a very long way to make the job better. As it is, the pay is not enough for the level of responsibility, the doctor's career is on the line every day, and any bits of bureaucracy which can make life more difficult for the staff seems to be put in place.

woody87 · 08/06/2022 16:35

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 08/06/2022 11:12

Doctors don't want to be GPs. Even if we trained more, they would leave.

We need to change the whole system and get rid of GPs altogether.

We need to look at what works in other countries as our system does not work anymore.

I know many doctors in their mid 20s who are currently working as locum whilst trying to get accepted to GP training so I'm not sure where your statement comes from?

GP training is still attractive, more reasonable hours at a consultant grade. Unfortunately the training places are very limited and this has led to a massive shortage of Gp's

woody87 · 08/06/2022 16:32

853ax · 08/06/2022 10:45

Any female Dr or nurse I know in 30s works 2 days a week.
Presume for NHS to be able to offer this flexibility they also need to have x2 or x3 staff to fill a position.
So training 100 doctors won't necessarily fill 100 roles.
Pay is sufficient to achieve part time job without limiting life style too much.

I am a female nurse in my 30s with two toddlers and I work full time, many other women do also, so not sure what the point of your input is.

SugarDatesandPistachios · 08/06/2022 16:20

Stop treating doctors like shit, that would be a start. I remember Jeremy Hunt actually saying ‘Doctors want war!’ Re: the junior doctor strike. Yes, according to the government and media, that’s what we wanted… WAR. 🤦🏽‍♀️

carefullycourageous · 08/06/2022 16:07

Alexandra2001 · 08/06/2022 16:05

Yes because they aren't being forced to work in the NHS for 5 years.... introduce your idea and see what happens?

I don't want to be treated by a doctor who is there under duress, thanks. They will be shit at their jobs.

Why not improve things so they want to stay instead of setting up a bonded labour system?

Alexandra2001 · 08/06/2022 16:05

BareGrylls · 08/06/2022 16:03

If you did that, they'd do something else and not even bother to train as Dr's.. so a bit of an own goal
There are way more applicants than places.

Yes because they aren't being forced to work in the NHS for 5 years.... introduce your idea and see what happens?

carefullycourageous · 08/06/2022 16:05

This Tory government is running the system into the ground in a whole host of ways.

Saw a nurse who got a £100 parking ticket from their hospital because they had stayed late at the end of their shift due to too few staff to care safely. I mean really - how is that sensible?

You have to make being a doctor or nurse a rewarding job. These days it is stress, overwork and political bullying.

BareGrylls · 08/06/2022 16:03

If you did that, they'd do something else and not even bother to train as Dr's.. so a bit of an own goal
There are way more applicants than places.

KvotheTheBloodless · 08/06/2022 16:02

Working in the NHS is shit - the pay and conditions are miserable given the hours required (LOTS of unpaid overtime) and huge number of years spent studying (and then coming out with £100k of debt).

I know quite a few ppl who studied medicine here, worked in the NHS for a few years and then left for New Zealand or Canada. Fewer hours, MUCH better pay.

anniegun · 08/06/2022 15:55

The government refuses to address the long term issues in the NHS , including providing enough training positions. They would prefer to poach already trained Doctors from overseas www.theguardian.com/society/2022/jun/08/nhs-hiring-more-doctors-from-outside-uk-and-eea-than-inside-for-first-time

Alexandra2001 · 08/06/2022 15:52

BareGrylls · 08/06/2022 15:41

The tuition fees to train as a doctor are only a fraction of the cost of the training and yet there is no obligation on new doctors to work in the NHS.
Many complete their training and go straight into working for pharmaceutical or med tech firms, or go part time.
There should be a period of 5 years at least in the NHS or pay back the full cost of training.

If you did that, they'd do something else and not even bother to train as Dr's.. so a bit of an own goal.

Even if they did, Pharma would pay the costs back for the brightest.

When are people going to realise that unless the NHS improves pay, conditions benefits etc, it will never train enough staff as so many leave, not least to work abroad.

BareGrylls · 08/06/2022 15:41

The tuition fees to train as a doctor are only a fraction of the cost of the training and yet there is no obligation on new doctors to work in the NHS.
Many complete their training and go straight into working for pharmaceutical or med tech firms, or go part time.
There should be a period of 5 years at least in the NHS or pay back the full cost of training.

MintJulia · 08/06/2022 15:27

Nurses, not muses

MintJulia · 08/06/2022 15:27

GPS are private businesses that provide services to the NHS.To be a go, you train for 7 years at a cost of £25k per year average.
Then you work for a gp practice for a year or two, then you can either buy yourself into a partnership (huge cost) or you can set up with another gp but you have to provide your own premises, muses, pharmacy, etc etc. All very high cost. The hours are very long, the govt wants gps to offer weekend & evening appointments.

It's hugely hard work, long hours, big investment, ungrateful British patients. Or go work in Aus for more money, fewer hours, less stress etc etc.

Badbadbunny · 08/06/2022 15:21

The BMA voted to restrict the number of medical students and voted for an outright ban on new medical schools.

www.bmj.com/content/337/bmj.a748

"to avoid “overproduction of doctors with limited career opportunities.”"

That was in 2008. If they'd allowed growth in medical schools and numbers of students, we'd have a much bigger "pool" of qualified doctors etc now, given that it typically takes 10 years or so to train a doctor up to a self-sufficient/unsupervised standard.

But no, the BMA wanted to keep numbers low to keep demand (and pay) high!

Newgirls · 08/06/2022 14:59

AndSoFinally · 08/06/2022 12:54

It is also a job that very few people are capable of doing

I also don't believe this. It's a job that very few people are capable of getting on to the training course for. The majority of the consultants I work with are excellent^^ and have been in the job 30 or 40-odd years. They got a mixture of A-Level results, but most were in the BBC, BCC, CCC range. They freely admit they'd never get in to do medicine these days.

The retention crisis is partly because we're now choosing the wrong people for the course. Academically brilliant, but little in the way of life experience or (often) common sense. They have no 'street smarts' because they're often from very privileged backgrounds, and have been spoon fed at private schools from an early age. Often they come from wealthy backgrounds and this gives them choices. If they qualify and find that they hate it or can't cope with the pressure, their backgrounds mean they can just up sticks and leave, and retrain as something else. I don't blame them. A fair few do this now, Many more so than when I trained.

I came from a working class background. I happen to love my job, but if I'd have hated it, I'd still have stuck it out as I'd got so much debt I'd have had no choice!

We need to be selecting Med students differently these days. We need to forget attracting triple A* students, and focus more on those with the right personal characteristics and a heavy dose of resilience. Having worked in A&E, I would argue that a black belt in Karate and a job working behind a bar in a rough part of town are far more useful attributes than Grade 8 piano, but we still insist on choosing students with the latter 🤦🏻

Adam Kay being a case in point!

We have plenty of talent in the UK - we just don’t want to pay for the expensive training. There are new med schools opening but it’s a drop in the ocean. Too used to importing doctors who now don’t want to come. Can’t blame them. Or the doctors leaving the NHS.

Wifflywafflywoo · 08/06/2022 14:50

PurpleDaisies · 08/06/2022 09:01

The biggest issue is retention, not training enough.

This.

My job is in GP training. It's not the recruiting into training that's the issue. We recruit to capacity twice a year, but you can't control the outcome of if they pass training/change specialty/get a permanent job outside the NHS at the end etc. There's also lots of other factors that impact the number of trainees we can actually recruit onto the training programmes. The work that goes into it is absolutely mind blowing and the entire team work flat out behind the scenes to get as many as possible through training and into post.

SammyScrounge · 08/06/2022 14:44

Ghislainedefeligonde · 08/06/2022 09:04

That’s only part of the problem. NHS Drs are leaving the UK to work elsewhere as the work conditions are so bad here. Pay is also much better (like 2 or 3 times more!) in some places like Canada, and Drs are actually respected and listened to there.
We work in awful conditions, constantly attacked by the media and some of the public and are told we are lazy, hiding away etc.
Other more senior Drs are retiring early due to stress or due to punitive taxes related to pensions. Bear in mind we have to pay in a huge amount into pension each month (?14.5% I think depending on salary) so to then face being taxed heavily or having to give up part of our pension to pay this tax is an absolute joke.
The pension issue also disincentivises Drs from working extra as you would end up working for nothing effectively.
Fixing the pension problem would help a bit but the whole narrative of ‘lazy GPs’ has to change or the whole NHS is doomed. It’s possibly doomed anyway. GPs do more than 90% of all NHS contacts for around 8% of the budget, so if GP fails the rest of the NHS will also fail

That's true. Remember about 7 or8 years ago the fuss about young British doctors not being able to get posts here and then discovered Australia wanted them. They raved about their modern, fully equipped hospitals, their pay, lighter workload...
The NHS has fallen so far, or should I say, been let fall so far.

drspouse · 08/06/2022 14:28

HistoricMoment · 08/06/2022 10:09

Force people to work? Are you honestly suggesting this for a democratic country?

In any case, would you really want to be treated by a demotivated doctor who is being forced to do his job?

You can heavily subsidise training for those who do work in the NHS for a number of years, though.

I believe that GP training is particularly unpopular though.

And of course being a doctor has to be somewhat family friendly for people to stay (ditto other HCPs). A&E nurse friend retrained as a HV when she had DCs; so she's still a nurse but that's an A&E nurse down. GP mum at school works part time but still needs a babysitter to pick up her DC from after school club because her shift (at the nearest surgery to school) ends after the club finishes. So many therapists that have seen my DS, and adoption social workers, go off on maternity leave, and he needs consistency, I don't think we've ever had any kind of overlap or transition. For school-based therapy (e.g. SALT, OT, assessments) you are almost always looking at private so the HCPs train, work in the NHS for a very short time and then find they are not allowed to do what they think is best for the child so they set up in private practice instead.

PurassicJark · 08/06/2022 14:27

Morred · 08/06/2022 12:50

These are great ideas, but the result of implementing is the tabloids stirring up fury about how much the NHS pays on 'administrators' and 'managers' not 'frontline medical staff'. The problem with cutting the administrators is that other people end up having to do the administration.

(If they had a working IT system their administrators could actually do more than just stare at spinning wheel of death as well - much more efficient.)

The government won't pay for the it system required for the stress levels put on it by the nhs. That's why your system is shit, mediocre supplies. It would cost them millions, if not billions, to upgrade it properly, and take about a decade probably to be done right.

Swipe left for the next trending thread